By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our terms and conditions
          The latest stories from across FansNetwork...          Football/Leeds United/Ex whites defender Greenhoff passes away aged 60 - Brian Greenhoff has passed away aged 60. The former Leeds defender joined us from hated rivals Manchester United for £350,000 in 1979 and made 78 appearances for us, scoring once.          Football/Rochdale/Brian Greenhoff dies aged 60 - Former Dale defender Brian Greenhoff has died aged sixty at his Norden home this morning.          Football/Leeds United/The big Georgian decides to stay in Turkey - The commentators on the Football League show heaved a big sigh of relief today, with the news that former Reading player Zurab Khizanishvili will not be coming to Leeds after all.          Football/Southampton/Andy Carroll Pulls Out Could Lambert Be Drafted For England ? - Andy Carroll has pulled out of the England squad due to injury, could this be Rickie Lamberts chance ?          Football/Southampton/McMenemy Honoured By The League Managers Association - Ex Saints manager Lawrie McMenemy has been rewarded for his service to football management by the League Managers Association.          Football/Queens Park Rangers/Still just a potato – full match report - QPR slipped quietly to a twenty first and final defeat of a dreadful 2012/13 season at Liverpool on Sunday with Michael Harriman putting his team mates to shame on a first Premier League start.          Football/Southampton/Vote For The Joiners As Britains Best Small Venue - Once again Southampton's very own Joiners Arms is featured in the national music press, this time it needs your help to win the title.          Football/Rochdale/Shall we take a trip? - It's going to be another season of long journeys with just two away games that are less than an hour's drive away from.          Football/Leeds United/Georgia on Brian's mind? - Brian McDermott is set to name a Reading old-boy to the ranks of Leeds United and it isn't Ian Harte (yet!) 31-year-old Georgian centre-back Zurab Khizanishvili is available on a free after his contract with Turkish club Kayserispor expired.          Football/Leeds United/Isn't it time we stopped dissin' Yeovil! - The official Leeds website could not resist trotting out the old "Where's Yeovil?" Line as the Somerset club booked their place in next seasons Championship, Hwever shouldn't we show the folks from Huish Park at bit more respect.          
Log In: Password: Password Help | Register

Tickle Tackle - Referee Man blues
Thu 23rd Oct 2008 21:46 by Steve Tickle

It seems like the back pages and sporting headlines are all too often talking about controversial refereeing decisions these days. Has it always been that way or have refereeing standards really worsened in recent years?


I suppose referees and linesmen have always borne the brunt of fans' ire since they were first introduced into the game but it seems that their errors and extravagances are even more in the spotlight these days than they ever were - few weekends pass without there seems to be some major discussion about referees' decisions and those of their linesmen.

Well let's get a few things straight first of all shall we? First of all, they have a difficult job not made any easier by the actions and reactions of far too many players who really should know better. Secondly, with most top games having at least half a dozen TV cameras dotted around the stadium, any errors they make tend to get seized upon by a media industry eager for sensation and controversy. Thirdly, most officials do a pretty decent job most of the time. However, it's the way of the world that the excellent decisions they make tend not to make the headlines whereas their mistakes do.

Nevertheless, I personally think that there are a number of referees who've risen to the top of their profession but who I wouldn't want to take charge of my daughters' games - let's not name names but I bet we could all agree on who they are. In my opinion, one of the things that links these refs is poor communications skills. The worst ones brandish their red and yellow cards at offending players like the cards themselves were a form of admonishment, rather than what they really are, simply a means of communicating that a player has been cautioned or sent off - all too often, the actual caution never actually takes place.

Some linesmen seem to struggle with offside decisions. I can think of several occasions over the last few days when goals have either been incorrectly given or disallowed purely because the linesmen haven't been in line with play and have made no allowance for the parallax error that results - I was certainly taught about at school. Are they not aware of this effect or are they told to disregard it by refereeing coaches? If it's the latter, how can they ever be sure they're giving a correct decision if they're not bang in line?

Personally, I put all of this down to bad coaching and bad selection and promotion by the refereeing authorities. An example of this was a radio interview I heard recently with one of their leading lights. He was celebrating the fact that there had been an increase in the numbers of teenagers taking up refereeing. This in itself is excellent news of course but he then went on to say that to many of those youngsters, the attraction was that of being in a position of authority.

Well I'm sorry but if that's a true example of the selection criteria then those responsible for it should resign their positions immediately. The last thing football needs is an influx of frustrated little dictators into the refereeing system. Anyone wanting to be a referee for that reason should be fitered out of the system at the earliest stage possible.

What football does need is good communicators who are given clear, consistent and responsible direction from those at the top.



You need to login in order to post your comments

Steve Tickle

Recent Stories


RSS Feed