| Greatest ever player. on 21:12 - May 25 with 2576 views | Darran |
Pound for pound he's not even in the top ten. |  |
|  |
| Greatest ever player. on 21:15 - May 25 with 2570 views | ItchySphincter |
From the PL era Leon needs to be considered. Gylfi not so much, Michu had as much of an impact. |  |
| |
| Greatest ever player. on 21:16 - May 25 with 2567 views | Neath_Jack |
| Greatest ever player. on 21:12 - May 25 by Darran |
Pound for pound he's not even in the top ten. |
The only player from my time watching the club, on that list, i'd put him above is Freestone. And i'm not even sure about that, by the time i hit send, i'd probably put him bottom of that list. |  |
| |
| Greatest ever player. on 21:16 - May 25 with 2556 views | Rancid |
I voted Robbie and hes currently tied at 6% with Allchurch. |  | | |
| Greatest ever player. on 21:17 - May 25 with 2555 views | Jackanapes |
Robbie James for me. Curt next. |  |
|
“The stupidest thing she knew was for people to act like they knew all about the things they knew absolutely nothing about.†|
| |
| Greatest ever player. on 21:18 - May 25 with 2538 views | Darran |
And on a side note if Trunds hadn't gone to Bristol he'd probably be our all time leading scorer now. | |
| |
| Greatest ever player. on 21:20 - May 25 with 2532 views | exiledclaseboy |
Britton. |  |
| |
| Greatest ever player. on 21:21 - May 25 with 2519 views | Darran |
For consistency it's got to be. | |
| |
Login to get fewer ads
| Greatest ever player. on 21:22 - May 25 with 2514 views | exiledclaseboy |
| Greatest ever player. on 21:21 - May 25 by Darran |
For consistency it's got to be. |
Agreed. Also never having played for Cardiff. | |
| |
| Greatest ever player. on 21:29 - May 25 with 2492 views | lifelong |
I know it's been said on here before,but,in the 1958 World Cup Ivor was described by the then Italian manager as being one of the top inside forwards in the World.... enough said. |  | | |
| Greatest ever player. on 21:35 - May 25 with 2465 views | ItchySphincter |
| Greatest ever player. on 21:21 - May 25 by Darran |
For consistency it's got to be. |
Except for the time when he went to Sheffield United.
That aside, Leon. | |
| |
| Greatest ever player. on 21:35 - May 25 with 2459 views | vetchonian |
| Greatest ever player. on 21:18 - May 25 by Darran |
And on a side note if Trunds hadn't gone to Bristol he'd probably be our all time leading scorer now. |
Doubt it Dar check the stats his goals dried up as he climbed through the leagues also somethings not right as according to Wikedpeidia he didn't score 100 goals for us in his two spells.
For me an overrated player and I know he is a hero due to his self promotion and showboating but to be compared to Curt,Ivor,Robbie or Gylfi who have proven themselves at the top level is not right.
I will be shot down I know but if he really had it he wouldn't have gone to Bristol City but a PL club or a club in the championship competing for promotion...for £1M he would have have been worth a punt but the scouts obviously saw him for what he is a one footed showboater....lower league player but not good enough for the top flight...yes a Swans Legend and icon for some ...but then so is Whyndham Evans who actually played in the top flight ! [Post edited 25 May 2017 21:39]
|  |
| |
| Greatest ever player. on 21:36 - May 25 with 2450 views | Darran |
| Greatest ever player. on 21:35 - May 25 by ItchySphincter |
Except for the time when he went to Sheffield United.
That aside, Leon. |
I thought it was about when they were playing for us Johnny?  | |
| |
| Greatest ever player. on 21:36 - May 25 with 2451 views | Kilkennyjack |
I think its Ivor, Curt, and Leon in that order.
All 4 letter jack legends. |  |
| Beware of the Risen People
|
| |
| Greatest ever player. on 21:39 - May 25 with 2435 views | ItchySphincter |
| Greatest ever player. on 21:36 - May 25 by Darran |
I thought it was about when they were playing for us Johnny? |
Well he didn't consistently play for us Dazzler. | |
| |
| Greatest ever player. on 21:39 - May 25 with 2427 views | ItchySphincter |
But LEON!! FFS.
In my lifetime anyway. | |
| |
| Greatest ever player. on 21:42 - May 25 with 2409 views | Rancid |
Michu was as good as any of them but just the 1 season takes him out of the equation
Ferrie Bodde was great for us too and could have been a club great.. | | | |
| Greatest ever player. on 21:42 - May 25 with 2406 views | aberhugh |
I've watched for over 50 years. Unfortunately, when I saw Allchurch I was very small and he was in his twilight years.
In my time our two best eras were the late 70's early 80's and the years in the Premier League. Trunds was probably the player I was most entertained by but his lack of any pace would have made it difficult for him in those two time slots.
For me the players I would choose are Leon, Robbie, Curt, Ash and Siggy, in that order but happy to swap around the first three.
Probably better to ask for your all time best team, but I would still leave out players before my time as I did not see them and the available footage is poor quality.
I have an elderly relative who loves Allchurch and waxes lyrical about him. He is annoyed at the voting. He describes his silky skills and says his only weakness was in the air. I wouldn't have rushed to head the balls they used then!! | | | |
| Greatest ever player. on 21:49 - May 25 with 2365 views | Rancid |
Leon wouldn't have been mentioned as much had he not done what he's the last few weeks.Hes knowhere near been one of our best players but as a servant and clubman hes been second to none. | | | |
| Greatest ever player. on 21:53 - May 25 with 2352 views | Gowerjack |
| Greatest ever player. on 21:49 - May 25 by Rancid |
Leon wouldn't have been mentioned as much had he not done what he's the last few weeks.Hes knowhere near been one of our best players but as a servant and clubman hes been second to none. |
Arrant nonsense. |  |
| |
| Greatest ever player. on 21:56 - May 25 with 2344 views | NeathJack |
From players I've seen on the basis of talent, longevity and consistency, it has to be Leon.
1 Leon
2= Curt/Robbie |  | | |
| Greatest ever player. on 21:58 - May 25 with 2330 views | Gowerjack |
Alan Curtis.
Obviously. | |
| |
| Greatest ever player. on 22:00 - May 25 with 2326 views | Darran |
| Greatest ever player. on 21:35 - May 25 by vetchonian |
Doubt it Dar check the stats his goals dried up as he climbed through the leagues also somethings not right as according to Wikedpeidia he didn't score 100 goals for us in his two spells.
For me an overrated player and I know he is a hero due to his self promotion and showboating but to be compared to Curt,Ivor,Robbie or Gylfi who have proven themselves at the top level is not right.
I will be shot down I know but if he really had it he wouldn't have gone to Bristol City but a PL club or a club in the championship competing for promotion...for £1M he would have have been worth a punt but the scouts obviously saw him for what he is a one footed showboater....lower league player but not good enough for the top flight...yes a Swans Legend and icon for some ...but then so is Whyndham Evans who actually played in the top flight ! [Post edited 25 May 2017 21:39]
|
I reckon he'd have been pretty close. | |
| |
| Greatest ever player. on 22:08 - May 25 with 2285 views | Rancid |
Maybe they're friends but he's never been one of our best players by a long way.He's never had a mention of an Engand cap, ever.And he's only ever been a real regular in the side when we were lower leagues or in the shit now.Hes a tremendous Swansea City man but never one of our best players.Sentiment would have ruled Curts heart including Leon. | | | |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
