| Double Jeopardy Rule 21:39 - Aug 21 with 1075 views | BrianMcCarthy |
Robbie Fugging Savage (RFS) reckoned that Carlos should have been sent off in the first half tonight for his challenge in the area. The ref rightly gave a peno. Then he booked Carlos.
Isn't that correct under the Double Jeopardy Rule/Guideline?
You can't issue a red and award a peno for the same offence, I thought.
Pinner and others will know for sure, though. | |
| |  |
| Double Jeopardy Rule on 21:42 - Aug 21 with 1058 views | aston_hoop |
Not sure of the rules of that one, I'd be annoyed as a fan if that wasn't a red. Especially since he just made the potential Sevilla winner. Great game though, especially the first half.
Just to add without trying to hijack the referee stuff - Ashley Young..hahahahahha. have that you cheating prick. [Post edited 21 Aug 2020 21:56]
| |
| |
| Double Jeopardy Rule on 21:44 - Aug 21 with 1048 views | Match82 |
I have no facts on this. And I'm not watching the game.
But... I've always thought it was harsh to give a red for "preventing a clear goal scoring opportunity" if a pen was awarded (as that is obviously a clear goal scoring opportunity, therefore the player couldn't be preventing it)
I'd think a red + penalty is acceptable for a different offence such as violent conduct or intentional handball on the line (hello Suarez) [Post edited 21 Aug 2020 21:45]
| | | |
| Double Jeopardy Rule on 22:24 - Aug 21 with 944 views | loftboy |
The player has to be making a genuine effort to win the ball for it to be a yellow only, that was never an attempt to win the ball so should have walked. | |
| |
| Double Jeopardy Rule on 22:51 - Aug 21 with 884 views | BrianMcCarthy |
Yes, that does sound familiar, Loftboy. | |
| |
| Double Jeopardy Rule on 09:53 - Aug 22 with 593 views | terryb |
I'm certain that when he was playing, if hts team mate had been sent off for that, be would have gone ballistic at the referee!
The one thing I would say in favour of Savage, is that he doesn't change his mind just because another pundit has a contrary view. | | | |
| Double Jeopardy Rule on 13:10 - Aug 22 with 455 views | PinnerPaul |
Haven't seen it, but yes has to be a 'genuine attempt for the ball'
For a red, don't forget it has to be denying an obvious goalscoring opportunity.
Obviously, serious foul play in the penalty area is still a red whatever else is going on! | | | |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
