Please log in or register. Registered visitors get fewer ads.
Forum index | Previous Thread | Next thread
Question for PinnerPaul 13:29 - Mar 14 with 829 viewsQPRSteve

Watching the Soton - Brighton game. Soton attack and a player is fouled on the edge of the area but the ref signals for advantage. Soton get a shot in which is brilliantly saved. Ref then signals for the free kick.

I understand pulling it back for the foul if no advantage ensues, but in this case they got a shot in. Surely the free kick is null and void.

Am I right?
0
Question for PinnerPaul on 15:51 - Mar 14 with 690 viewsPinnerPaul

Yep agree, haven't seen it yet but wrong to give attacking team two goes, which in effect he has done.

If attacker closed down or has to hurry the shot because of a defender, then maybe bring it back, but a 'clean' attempt at goal should mean no going back to the fk for me.
1
Question for PinnerPaul on 16:17 - Mar 14 with 660 viewsQPRSteve

Thanks Paul. What confused me was that the commentator and pundit didn't pick up on it.
0
Question for PinnerPaul on 16:18 - Mar 14 with 653 viewsPinnerPaul

Question for PinnerPaul on 16:17 - Mar 14 by QPRSteve

Thanks Paul. What confused me was that the commentator and pundit didn't pick up on it.


Never, ever ever ever look to commentators and pundits for guidance on the laws!
0
Question for PinnerPaul on 16:06 - Mar 15 with 503 viewsPinnerPaul

Just to add, for my own peace of mind, I have now got 'confirmation' on 'RefChat' that this was indeed wrong!
0
About Us Contact Us Terms & Conditions Privacy Cookies Advertising
© FansNetwork 2024