Please log in or register. Registered visitors get fewer ads.
Sylla’s late leveller can’t save Hasselbaink’s job – Report
Sunday, 6th Nov 2016 10:55 by Clive Whittingham

QPR tried and failed to register a first ever win at Nottingham Forest at the 33rd time of asking on Saturday. Manager Jimmy Floyd Hasselbaink paid with his job after the final whistle.

Mid-table sized club with a mid-table quality team sacks manager for having them in mid-table after drawing at a ground they’ve never won on in 33 attempts. On the face of it, it’s pure Queens Park Rangers.

Saturday’s draw at Nottingham Forest – which would have been a win on any other day, at any other ground, given Rangers’ total domination of the second half and abysmal quality of the opponent – left Jimmy Floyd Hasselbaink’s team seventeenth in the Championship.

Six points off the relegation zone, six points off the play-off places, this is not a disastrous position to be in 16 games into a 46 match season. In fact, given the drain of talented players away from Loftus Road over the past two years, a playing budget which has been hacked and then hacked again through FFP and parachute payment necessity, the number of European signing having to adjust to English football, the number of lower league signings being asked to step up, and a smattering of youth team players making their way in senior football for the first time, it could be argued it’s rather creditable. The perception of how QPR are doing – a team that never wins and never scores – is rather harsher than the reality – three away wins already this season, equal or more goals scored than nine other sides.

By all accounts the decision to ditch Hasslebaink was taken a week ago, after the pathetic capitulation to near neighbours Brentford. A 2-0 scoreline flattering the insipid Hoops, a London derby embarrassment too far for a club and a board that’s experienced quite a few in recent years. It would have taken an extraordinary performance at the City Ground to spare the Dutchman a trip to the gallows, and given QPR’s notorious record in this part of the world that was never likely.

What transpired instead was the perfect summation, an absolute microcosm, of Jimmy Floyd Hasselbaink’s time in Shepherd’s Bush.

First, the team news, which Hasselbaink largely keeps to himself, presumably for fear of tipping off the opposition. All well and good in theory, but QPR aren’t exactly blessed with a whole load of outstanding talent that any opponent would have to make a special plan for are we? Do we really think Nottingham Forest manager Philippe Montanier has been tossing and turning every night this week fretting over whether Conor Washington will play wide or upfront, whether QPR will go with three or five in midfield, whether Massimo Luongo will play? Has he fuck.

The effect of not telling anybody that, in this case, Luongo and Steven Caulker were injured and Ariel Borysiuk had a family emergency is only to make Hasselbaink’s ever-curious, ever-changing team selections look even more unfathomable than they already are. The same happened at MK Dons away last season where three players were left out after a decent performance and Rangers fell in a hole and lost 2-0 to a soon-to-be-relegated side. It transpired they’d all had flu, but by not telling us that it created a wave of confusion and anger when the team was announced at 14.00. He added pressure and criticism to himself that simply didn’t need to be there.

Second, said unfathomable team selection. The official website runs a guessing game encouraging fans to name the team in advance of the game and honestly if anybody ever gets it right they deserve a bloody OBE. Even once the 11 names are revealed it’s a case of picking out the four defenders and the lone striker and then wildly guessing at where the other five might be playing. Rangers have gone 4-1-4-1, 4-2-3-1, 4-3-3, 4-5-1 and yes even 4-4-2 at various points of various games recently. Pawel Wzsolek has played right, left and off the main striker – often in the same game. Tjaronn Chery has played ten, left wing and central midfield. Jordan Cousins has played centrally, wide right, and right full back. It’s little wonder there’s no flow to the team really is it? It’s hard to shake the idea that Hasselbaink and his coaching staff don’t just mix the five magnetic tags up in a bag and then throw them at the board and play whatever lands.

Third, a limp start to the game. Seb Polter was the man selected to lead the line here and once again, as we’ve seen so often this season, the poor bastard really did put the ‘lone’ in lone striker. Up top, with two centre backs for company, and no QPR player within the same post code, the German won far more than his fair share of the high balls QPR pumped up to him, flicking it on, nodding it down, holding it up and laying it – all to no avail, because there was nobody there with him. Exactly, word for word, point for point, the same problem Idrissa Sylla had against Brentford a week ago. Exactly the same problem Polter and Sylla have shared all season when starting games. Conor Washington, who his former chairman at Peterborough rightly said this week is being absolutely wasted by QPR who pick him either in that lone lone striker role or as a winger rather than an off-the-shoulder goal poacher, was asked to chase channel balls down the left wing.

Once more QPR’s sole attacking idea seemed to be based around getting the ball in the vague vicinity of where it might be dangerous and hoping it magically became so simply by being there. By the 30 minute point Nottingham Forest had hit four shots on target and seen a fifth blocked, QPR hadn’t registered a single effort either on or off target of their own. And this against a team with Vladimir Stojkovic in goal – as dodgy as they come at this level, get it on target he often does the rest of the work for you.

Fourth, the suicidally high defensive line. Hasselbaink made a very big deal of his love for the ‘full court press’ which has become trendy since Jurgen Klopp started conquering the world at Borussia Dortmund. Hasselbaink beasted his players all summer to make sure they were fit enough to do it and all that sounded like exactly what the team and the club needed, particularly after last year where mobility, energy, pace and goals were all entirely lacking from the centre of midfield. Two modern day club legends, Ale Faurlin and Clint Hill, were brutally cut loose in the summer because they apparently didn’t have the legs for this style.

But the only evidence we’ve seen of this on the pitch is the back four pushing so far up the field there’s actually little point them being there at all. With no pressing, harassing or energy from the constantly rotated midfield, Rangers have been inviting unpressured opposition playmakers to simply dink balls into the wide open spaces behind the defenders.

Brentford played it perfectly last week, running Scott Hogan in offside drawing the defenders still further up the field and then sending in Josh Clarke and Romain Sawyers clean through in the second phase. Forest, initially, didn’t look capable of doing the same – one ball after another kicked straight out of play down the left wing, like a golfer with a fault in his grip or a really great rugby union game. But they soon got their eye in and before long Britt Assombalonga was running through on goal so frequently it was almost like a one v one practise session for striker and goalkeeper. One was disallowed for offside then Alex Smithies, dressed in his flying banana costume, rushed from his line to block another brilliantly after Nedum Onuoha had got himself in a right mess and allowed a long punt to bounce right through.

The keeper was perhaps a little rash second time round though, charging out of his area and allowing Assombalonga to knock it round him and then slide home from an acute angle, despite the efforts of Grant Hall on the line, before beginning a ludicrous celebratory handshake routine with Hildeberto Pereira which, if the teams hadn’t had to go back to their own halves of the field for the kick off as dictated by the laws of the game, may well still be going on now.

Later Henri Lansbury, dressed as a homeless person for Halloween, took a turn to skip through the acres of peaceful meadow between Smithies and his back line – Ben Osborn shot just over after Hall got back to challenge the former Arsenal trainee at the last second.

To make matters worse, Rangers had also been reduced to ten men just before the goal. Now Keith Stroud has been on the refereeing circuit a long time, and at one point was something of a lucky official for QPR who avoided defeat in their first ten outings with him over several years. But he’s been a growing pain in the arse of late, starting a few years ago on this ground when a second Forest goal to seal the game was allowed despite the linesman flagging it offside. Last year at MK Dons he awarded two penalties to the hosts, and denied QPR a cast iron one of their own. He’s always had a touch of the short-man syndrome about him, but he’s started to referee games these days like somebody who doesn’t actually enjoy refereeing any more, or football at all in fact, and only keeps doing it because his wife can’t stand him fussing around the house all Saturday afternoon. If that is the case, somebody get this lunatic an allotment or something quick.

This was a game with one proper tackle in it. Midway through the second half James Perch channelled the evil side of Mark Dennis into a flying, airborne lunge over by the dugouts which took the ball clean as a whistle but, a quarter of a second earlier or later, would have clocked up a reasonable death toll. There wasn’t even a free kick awarded for that and yet through the rest of a fairly tame game physically Stroud contrived to show two red cards and ten yellows.

He’d lost control of the thing with time still in single figures. Karl Henry penalised for handball on halfway when a) it looked like the Forest guy had handled it and b) Henry had fairly obviously been pushed under the ball in the first place. Henry was then shown a yellow card for his dissent to the decision and QPR captain Nedum Onuoha was forced into three prolonged chats with the official in as many minutes as one curious decision after another went Forest’s way.

Henry is an experienced player though, and his behaviour over the following 20 minutes was utterly brain dead. Every stoppage, every break in play, every injury, Henry was back to the referee, in his face, arguing the toss, telling him how wrong he’d been. It was like Joey Barton all over again, burning with some sense of injustice and unable to concentrate on his game or think about anything else. At different points Seb Polter, Onuoha and even Alex Smithies took Henry by the arm and forcibly led him away from the official. It was a red card waiting to happen and that particularly time bomb went off just before the half hour when he tripped Lansbury as he accelerated into a dangerous area.

Should he have been booked in the first place? No. Could the referee have let him off with a final warning for the second one? Yes. But honestly, after Henry moaned and bitched his way through 20 minutes of football I suspect Stroud was just glad of the chance to get rid of him. Totally unprofessional, and no kind of reward to a manager whose faith in Henry has been unshakable through a catalogue of poor performances and supporter criticism. Again, it felt apt that Henry would let Hasselbaink and his team mates down to this extent on the Dutchman’s last day in the job. The idea that Henry should have been cut loose when his contract expired in the summer, as several better players were, carries more weight than Lisa Riley.

If Hasselbaink’s love of Henry is point five then point six came after half time. QPR, despite having ten men, completely took the game over by playing as they should do from the start every week – another regular occurrence under Hasselbaink.

Chery hit a free kick over the bar after great work by Jack Robinson, then he had a shot nervously parried away by Stojkovic. Grant Hall headed a corner wide at the back post. Conor Washington started to look dangerous wide left. It was difficult to know whether Forest were deliberately sitting back to protect their lead or being pushed there by QPR. Stojkovic’s yellow card for time wasting suggested the former but in actual fact, it could just be that they’re fucking rubbish.

Hasselbaink sent on Mide Shodipo to play down the right and, as he always does, the young winger made a massive difference. Nothing complicated, just getting at his man and getting a cross over. He also understood Stroud far more than his team mates, collapsing to the floor every time he felt a whiff of contact from his full back and being rewarded with a free kick every time. Now it was Forest’s turn to lose the plot with the official as Pereira was booked first for holding onto the ball and preventing a quick free kick, and then for a tiny flick on Conor Washington’s heels as he scooted past him in the left channel. Again, offences worthy of a red card? Certainly not, but having booked for literally everything else Stroud left himself with no choice. You could have done an oil painting of Pereira in the time it took him to leave the field, contributing to seven added minutes at the end of the game. It was getting light again by the time this one drew to a close.

Idrissa Sylla also stepped up off the bench to partner Polter in attack and Nasser El Khayati came on to do down the left what Shodipo was doing down the right. Lo and behold, wouldn’t you know it, knock me down with a feather, stone the crows, hold the fucking front page, getting the ball wide to wingers who can cross and putting somebody up alongside Polter to help actually worked. As it always has done before this season. Sylla scored almost immediately, powering in a header at the near post from El Khayati’s cross with Stojkovic’s efforts at saving it questionable. The Guinea international was, naturally, booked for over-celebrating. Of course he was.

There was a fantastic goal-saving header from under his own cross bar by Nedum Onuoha, and substitute Vellios appeared to be punished for diving in the penalty area in stoppage time with the award of a free kick the other way – but bizarrely no yellow card – but the play was almost exclusively at the QPR end of the ground and in the end only the clock saved Forest.

Two abysmal teams and a dreadful referee, pure Championship stuff, but it had been an uplifting final half hour from Rangers winning them a point they more than deserved. It felt like a corner had been turned, that Hasselbaink had finally seen the value of committing more men to the attack, of supporting the main striker, of using genuine wingers and giving them the ball in wide areas, of getting crosses into the box, of using Shodipo more. But we’ve been here before. The same thing happened at the end of the Fulham game, where Sylla scored a similar goal, and in the final quarter of an hour at Huddersfield, where Sylla scored an identical goal. It happens all the time but you just knew, deep down, that in a fortnight’s time against Norwich when Rangers take the field again it would have been back to one isolated man up top, fielding long hopeful punts down the field with no support, with no width, and no crosses, until it all went to shit and the wingers were finally sent on from the bench.

The team selection and the start of the Norwich game would have been like the final 30 minutes here never happened. The supporters lost patience with this long ago, and now the QPR board has too.

Links >>> Ratings and Reports >>> Message Board Match Thread

Forest: Stojkovic 4; Pereira 5, Mills 5, Perquis 6, Lichaj 6; Worrall 6, Kasami 6, Cohen 5 (Lam 82, -), Lansbury 6, Osborn 5; Asombalonga 7 (Vellios 90+3, -)

Subs not used: Dumitru, Fox, Lica, Henderson, Grant

Goals: Assombalonga 38 (assisted Kasami)

Red Cards: Pereira 71 (two bookings, see below)

Bookings: Deep breath… Worrall 50 (foul), Stojkovic 61 (time wasting), Pereira 66 (time wasting), Cohen 68 (foul), Pereira 71 (foul), Lichaj 90+3 (foul)

QPR: Smithies 7; Perch 6, Onouha 5, Hall 6, Robinson 6 (El Khayati 84, -); Henry 3, Cousins 6; Wzsolek 5 (Shodipo 55, 7), Chery 5, Washington 6 (Sylla 77, 7); Polter 6

Subs not used: Lynch, Gladwin, Ingram, Hamalainen

Goals: Sylla 85 (assisted El Khayati)

Red Cards: Henry 34 (two bookings, see below)

Bookings: Henry 11 (dissent), Henry 34 (foul), Robinson 67 (foul), Sylla 86 (over celebrating)

QPR Star Man – Mide Shodipo 7 Get ball, get at man, get cross into box. Shooting chance – have a shot. Contact from man – go down for free kick. Through all the over-complicated, over-elaborate, sport science-affected, constantly-rotating, lone striker, inverse winger infuriation of the Hasselbaink reign shines this beacon of basic football goodness. More of him, and this, and less of all that other stuff please.

Keith Stroud (Hampshire) 2 Just such utter, utter bullshit from the very first whistle to the last. Ten yellow cards and two reds in a game without a serious foul in it. Seven minutes of stoppage time. Long, drawn out conversations with players over every incident. Yellow cards flashed to players where, even with the benefit of watching it back on the video afterwards, you couldn’t possibly fathom why. Lost control of this with the time still in single figures and never regained it. A nonsense display, completely inept, maddening, farcical. Two poor teams and a shite referee, that’ll be £25 a ticket please – Championship.

Attendance – 20,043 (1,300 QPR approx) A sizeable, noisy following from West London which will be about a quarter as big as this for this fixture if we do happen to ever get a win here as the vast majority seem to travel ‘just in case it’s the one’. It wasn’t, though we’ll rarely face a Forest team as poor as this one. Still, 33 tries and still nothing.

The Twitter @loftforwords

Pictures – Action Images

Get two free £10 bets on Queens Park Rangers v Bristol City (or other matches) by opening a new account at William Hill. Place an initial bet of a minimum of £10 and William Hill will give you two £10 bets. You must enter the promotional code ''F20'' when signing up as a new customer.

Action Images



Please report offensive, libellous or inappropriate posts by using the links provided.



isawqpratwcity added 11:34 - Nov 6
Thanks, Clive.

Two weeks to decide between ending it all or turning up for the Norwich game. Choose wisely.
0

QPRski added 12:12 - Nov 6
A great analysis and report, plus an extremely entertaining, and amusing read.

You are correct that this match was a mini "case study" of the whole JFH era. It is just incredibly ironic that Henry played the role of "et tu Brute".

I am personally very dissapointed that the JFH era was not a sucess. I just hope that as a club, we are not over-expecting.
0

onlyrinmoray added 13:07 - Nov 6
Great report Listened to the game on Player with Andy Sinton co commentating. As a classic winger for us " head down get past the full back sling in a cross" he was saying the same thing as you in the report We seem to have plenty of wingers now which we didn't in the past (Routledge excluded ) yet we don't play in a way where we us them effectively
Glad to see the back of JFH some of the worst football Ive ever seen from QPR The Newcastle game was a disgrace Usually I'm willing to give anyone a chance but enough is enough Re a new manager Ive no idea ..Clement Hodgson and Warburton. I like Guidolin but possibly too much of a risk
0

18StoneOfHoop added 13:47 - Nov 6
?? Not seeing a full report,just three para intro at the mo. ??
0

Burnleyhoop added 14:52 - Nov 6
Ultimately........Jimmy simply didn't have a clue. Beggars belief really.

At least we have players in the squad we can get excited about. Just need Tony's "dream manager" to galvanise and sort the formation and I honestly we believe we can improve dramatically.
0

francisbowles added 15:26 - Nov 6
New manager needs to work out what to do with Chery. From your ratings, looks like he had another ineffective game yesterday. If we are to play with two wingers, of which we have plenty of right footed options but no left footed ones, then it is probably two strikers or one and Chery.

Whatever we have tried with him lately hasn't worked. He does try hard the vast majority of the time and is very skillful but I fear a bit too lightweight for this league. If we can't solve this conundrum by Christmas then I think we should sell in January and see if we can find a proper left winger.
0

062259 added 15:42 - Nov 6
Frank de Boer anyone?
0

Spiritof67 added 16:01 - Nov 6
Excellent report and mach summary. Especially the line - "It’s hard to shake the idea that Hasselbaink and his coaching staff don’t just mix the five magnetic tags up in a bag and then throw them at the board and play whatever lands."

Let's hope the powers that be don't use the same system for selecting the next manager, if so, who would be in the bag; Tim Sherwood, Sam Allardyce, Mick McCarthy, Gary Rowett, Nigel Pearson, David Warner, Roberto Martinez or even Ian Dowie who had the highest win percentage of any QPR manager - albeit he only managed for 15 games. Who ever it is, please let us get back to playing the type of football to excite and entertain the fans.
0

Myke added 20:11 - Nov 6
Bit lazy in places here Clive. You can't deliberately contradict points you yourself have made previously just to emphasise a point here. You agreed that Stroud was correct to overrule the linesman and allow Reid's second goal for Forest on Dec 26th 2013, so you can't really use that as your starting point for Stroud to 'become a pain in the arse' for QPR. Similarly, it was debated during the summer and generally agreed that Henry was an honest if limited pro and was worthy of a one year extension, so again you can't come along now and say he should have been cut loose this summer.
Finally, as I mentioned last week, it was clear from your text after the Brentford game that you believed Hasslebaink was not tactically up to the job and that is borne out again here with another totally inept first half performance and an admission it will be back to square one v Norwich. So to say our perception of QPR's current situation is 'rather harsher than the reality' is not actually true. It's not any part of the league table; games won or not won, the goals scored or conceded column, that has ultimately caused his demise. It's the performances and you have witnessed most of them and alluded to them again in this report.
Hasslebaink, after nearly a year, has no idea what is his best formation, never mind his best players Nobody in their right minds demanded or even expected promotion But what every supporter was entitled to was an indication that the club was steadily improving. Instead, we had a talented bunch of players by all accounts, being restricted by the limitations of the manager.
Whether, he will never be good enough to manage at this level or make a laughing stock of us by becoming a top European manager over the next 10 years, only time will tell. But for now - unfortunately - it was the right decision
So who next? If, as you rightly pointed out elsewhere, Les appoints Tim Sherwood and the project fails, then Les too will have to leave. Personally I like the idea of Karl Robinson, a progressive manager, who seemed to know what he was doing at MK Dons, not withstanding their relegation. Whoever it is must be instructed they have to work with the playing staff currently present at the club - if not we face an even more uncertain future.
0

TacticalR added 21:17 - Nov 6
Thanks for your report.

If we can't beat this Forest side, when are we ever going to beat them?

The pattern of the match sounds remarkably familiar. Whatever the shortcomings of the ref, it seems Henry really lost the plot. Perhaps if JFH had substituted him after the first yellow he might still be in the job. At least Shodipo proved a bright spark.

Like you I can see both sides on JFH. On paper he was fulfilling his brief, which appeared to be consolidation (although Fernandes' tweet on Saturday implied it was promotion). On the other hand there have been a lot of matches where we seemed both short of ideas and lacking in defensive nous, with Newcastle at home being the low point.
0

extratimeR added 23:12 - Nov 6
Thanks Clive

Great report as usual, totally agree, I never knew from one week to the next who he was going to pick, and what formation we would play.

I honestly can't decide whether he didn't know what he was doing, (unlikely I suppose), or he had lost confidence in his own decision making.

Before the sacking yesterday, a quick poll round the table in the boozer, was a firm 100% "enough is enough, time for him to go"

Worryingly no one had a clue as to who we should hire as a replacement.

My own view is that their are five decent players in the first team, Smithies, Luongo, Scylla, Borysuik, and Wzsolek plus (as mentioned) a very good prospect in Shodipo, (he even runs the clock down at the corner flag), Washington runs his heart out, and Poulter is effective when used properly, surely this is enough for someone to build on ?

I seem to remember Gary Neville saying something along the lines of "if you change your fullbacks every week its impossible to play centre half"

I've lost count of how many full backs we have used this season.
1

wrinklyhoop added 23:13 - Nov 6
Good report Clive, but surprised there was no mention of Cousins and Chery in centre mid. We looked better without Henry, despite being a man down, after half time. Cousins did a sterling job holding, and Chery had plenty of the ball with time to get moves started with telling passes. Forest seemed unable to counter this, even before Pereira went off. Finally a couple of important players in arguably their best positions, although largely by accident and needs must.
0

RonisRs added 09:24 - Nov 7
I think it's a shame JFH did not work out, but with all the chopping and changing and inept results it's is not a surprise. We do have some good players so I don't seee why we can't improve with a decent manager. I would be nice to get excited about QPR again.
0

probbo added 09:53 - Nov 7
Thanks for the report Clive.

The Club seems to be stuck in this virtuous (and highly destructive) wash, rinse, repeat cycle when it comes to appointing managers and the Director of Football needs to show some accountability here too. If the brief is 'a quick return to the Premier League please' its no wonder the cycle repeats so quickly - its just not realistic.

Managers just don't get the time these days but in the case of JHF, I can't disagree with any of the criticisms relating to team selection, tactics, playing guys out of position etc that have been levelled for quite some time now. The Brentford performance really was unforgivable.

As for his replacement, I can't help but feel if it is Sherwood the same thing will happen again in 12-18 months time - what would be the basis for appointing him - his highly successful tenure at Villa??. Maybe a West Country dream team of Holloway and Cottrell might be a better option, I just don't know. Regardless of who it is though they have to be given more time and more realistic objectives.
0

NayDaze added 11:35 - Nov 7
Brilliant balanced amusing analysis as ever x
0

CroydonCaptJack added 13:40 - Nov 7
Great report as usual. I think a six was harsh on Cousins who I felt had our best game.

Also, one other technicality I would like to pick you up on -
Have you not seen the weight Lisa Riley has lost recently?
0

romfordranger added 16:54 - Nov 7
relieved JFH has gone, he was out of his depth, either didn't have a proper game plan, couldn't communicate effectively or failed to motivate the players, or a mix of the three? The Brentford game was truly atrocious, easily second best to an average team. Can't believe Sherwood could be any worse, but my choice would have been Kenny Jackett and a shame he took the Rotherham job. It would be good to see a proven Championship manager take charge. I don't have high expectations supporting QPR, but what's wrong with a well organised team trying to play attractive football and being adventurous at times, the complete opposite to life under JFH.
0

WestonsuperR added 17:54 - Nov 7
Thanks for another amusing and extremely readable report.

I've never been one for changing Manager's, prefer stability and gibing time but did feel a change was necessary on this occasion. The performances have been dire and this so starting to affect attendances and general atmosphere at matches. whatever way you look at it 14 wins out of 47 is. not acceptable, plenty of time in the job and a significant amount of money spent.

0

pedrosqpr added 09:34 - Nov 8
Can't argue with your report Clive ,l have not been able to see the Rs since the Birmingham match. I think jfh almost tried to hard from my position l notice he was constantly referring to the clipboard. Felt exactly the same as you with Shodipo came on for me he is a Junior Hoilett with one big difference he can the ball in to the box .next manager hopefully keep the faith in this very talented yoyng man
0

delhisuperhoop added 13:42 - Nov 9
Please let it be Paul Clement
0

delhisuperhoop added 13:42 - Nov 9
Please let it be Paul Clement
0


You need to login in order to post your comments

Blogs 29 bloggers

Queens Park Rangers Polls

About Us Contact Us Terms & Conditions Privacy Cookies Advertising
© FansNetwork 2018