Please log in or register
Sunderland 1 v 1 Queens Park Rangers
SkyBet Championship
Saturday, 14th October 2017 Kick-off 15:00
McGeady leaves QPR ruing missed chances – Report
Sunday, 15th Oct 2017 17:59 by Lee McAlpine

QPR are still winless on the road this season, though quite how that’s the case after Saturday’s match against a dreadful Sunderland side has Lee McAlpine struggling to explain.


QPR left the Stadium of Light with only a point, after a combative, but not quite ruthless enough performance, against a bewildering poor Sunderland team.

How we didn’t take all three points, after dominating huge spells of the game, came down to familiar and frustrating reasons. A mixture of poor finishing, crap decision making or just an unlucky run of the ball in their box, meant we had to settle for the draw. But make no bones about it, and take zero notice of the ludicrous BBC match report, Rangers were the better side and deserved more.

The last time I volunteered to write one of these reports it was an evening game on a school night, which meant staring at a computer screen well into the early hours (picture Northern’s avatar!) This time I’ve gone one better, as I’ve written this while on a fifteth birthday weekend in Newcastle; my birthday bash!

It was a bit strange going into this game with the home town fans in such a miserable mood with their team. On every one of my previous visits to the Stadium of Light, QPR have been huge underdogs and usually come away empty handed, as the home side is roared on by a noisy crowd. Not this year. A horrible run of form following a gutless relegation (feel familiar?) and stuck with an overpaid squad that haven’t really looked up for the battle of the second tier, have left both attendances and spirits in a rapid decline on Wearside.

Normally a visiting QPR side would’ve been a perfect fodder to get their season back on track, but we are not watching a typical Rangers side this season and confidence amongst the visiting supporters was certainly evident. This despite a more unproductive run of results recently, which has left us winless in five and only three points from a possible 15.

It seems like months ago that Fulham stole the points from Loftus Rd before the international break (don’t you just hate those?). Most of the first team should’ve been fit and refreshed with only Luongo having to endure his mammoth quest of amassing the greatest number of airmiles in the history of football. Thankfully after appearing for only 20 minutes out of a possible 210, the only injury threat he has been at risk of has been deep vein thrombosis from hours in the air.

Unfortunately Jack Robinson managed to break his hand in training this week; I’m not sure that breaking bricks with punches is a suitable activity for an injury prone player, and something the squad should be doing in between games.

Rangers line up had a very similar and “thumbs up” feel about it. The best goalkeeper in the division, and probably most of the Premier League (anyone fancy a swap deal for Heurelho Gomes? Nah, me neither!), was protected by a trio of Bidwell, Lynch and the surprisingly reliable Baptiste. Manning and Wszolek occupied the wing back roles, with Scowen holding and Freeman and Luongo further forward. Mackie and Sylla were the front two, although the distance between the pair, meant they were more like two ones.

The initial exchanges led to a number of corners for the home side, which were all comfortably dealt with and we soon took charge of the game. The contest seemed to take place solely at the far end with spells of concerted Rangers’ pressure but without leading to any gilt-edge chances. Smithies was eventually called upon and pulled off a smart save after a corner was poorly cleared and McGeady was presented with an excellent opportunity mid-way through the half, when sent clear by Whatmore. Somehow he screwed his effort badly wide, when it looked easier to score.

Oviedo also had a long-range effort which went narrowly wide, but we were never put under any consistent pressure.

That was it for Sunderland as they began to make mistakes and consistently return possession to us. We had to score first. The grumpy home fans by now were expecting it and we didn’t disappoint them. Finally one of our many corners resulted in a goal. Freeman delivered a good ball into the danger area and Sylla headed home past the erratic looking Steele.

We needed to hold on until the break and did so easily. In fact only a mixture of good defending and poor finishing prevented Sylla from doubling our lead. A great cross by Freeman looked certain to be converted but somehow the ball ended up amongst the empty red seats behind the goal, rather than the net. The half time whistle was greeted with general unhappiness from the home sections, well those who were still in their places, as hoards had left for the concourse when we opened the scoring.

The second period brought a change for the home side, who replaced the anonymous Vaughan with Grabban. Bidwell had completely dominated Vaughan in his usual Bidwell manner, which left the former Everton striker bleating to the referee and his assistant, about our defender’s rather rough handling. I thought this was Bidwell’s best performance for Rangers as he looked both composed and strong throughout.

We started on the front foot in the second half and had the home side completely on the ropes. Gaps were appearing all over the place and good work by Wszolek presented Mackie with a wonderful opening to make it two nil. Mackie pointed exactly where he wanted the ball, our Pole delivered perfectly but one air kick later and the cross rolled harmlessly away. A frustrating miss but we weren’t worried as a second was surely coming.

Freeman, Wszolek and Luongo all had presentable openings but didn’t really stretch Steele, whose handling had become more assured. The home team’s passing had become even worse and the R’s fans enjoyed joining in with the regular boos that were echoing around the half empty stadium, as pass after pass failed to find a teammate. One particular un-pressurized, side foot effort from O’Shea was particularly funny, as it rolled out of play at least twenty yards from someone in red and white stripes.

This was the point we got it wrong. Regular and happy renditions of “You’re not really very good”, obviously that’s my polite translation, were ringing out from the away fans, as the game seemed to be in our total control. This singing was cut embarrassingly short on the hour mark, as McGeady showed his true ability with a cracking shot that left Smithies helpless. A goal from absolutely nowhere and obviously the mood in the stadium changed, as did the game.

The Sunderland team and their fans, were now up for it as gaps began to appear for them as they went in search of a winner. This was only temporary as Rangers took back control and drove forward in wave after wave of attacks. Washington replaced the isolated and frustrated Mackie, but he too proved to be a peripheral figure and hardly had any impact. Osayi-Samuel came on for Wszolek, who again had not really achieved his high earlier season standards. I would really like to see Wheeler be given a starting place ahead of the Pole as he seems to have lost his confidence in recent games. Osayi-Samuel’s first contribution was to ball watch and not track back and this lead to a half chance for the home side. Someone must have had a word at this stage, as for the rest of the game the youngster took his defensive duties far more seriously.

Late on, two almighty scrambles in the Sunderland box somehow didn’t result in a winner for us along with a couple of half-hearted penalty appeals that would’ve been unbelievably harsh. Another header from Sylla went well wide and the game drifted to a finish.

The overriding feeling in the away end was one of satisfied-disappointment. Satisfaction with a confident and enjoyable to watch display with so many positive. Disappointment that such an under-performing, former big-club were not put to the sword, when they so really should’ve been.

Unfortunately we are not picking up the points our performances are meriting. One disgruntled fan sat near, was particularly venomous with his criticism, claiming we are in a relegation battle. I disagreed and still do. It’s been said so many times what a tough league this is and we just need a bit more cutting edge and we can go on a bit of a run.

Match Gallery: 18 photos


The BBC claimed that Sunderland an earned “a deserved point”. Can I suggest to them that they actually send someone to watch the game in future, as anyone who was actually present today would not have come to that conclusion. In the pub after the game, home fans accepted they had “got away with it” and were relieved not to have been soundly beaten.


Links >>> Photo Gallery >>> Ratings and Reports >>> Message Board Match Thread

Sunderland: Steele 5; Matthews 5, Jones 5, O’Shea 5, Oviedo 5; Honeyman 5 (Williams 58, 6), Ndong 5, Cattermole 5, McGeady 7; Vaughan 5 (Grabban 45, 5), Watmore 8 (McManaman 79, 6)

Subs not used: Love, Gibson, Ruiter, Gooch

Goals: McGeady 61 (unassisted)

QPR: Smithies 7; Baptiste 7, Lynch 7, Bidwell 7; Luongo 7, Scowen 8, Manning 6, Freeman 7, Wszolek 6 (Osayi-Samuel 76, 5); Mackie 5 (Washington 67, 5), Sylla 7

Subs not used: Lumley, Furlong, Smith, Ngbakoto, Wheeler

Goals: Sylla 37 (assisted Freeman)

QPR Star Man - Josh Scowen 8 I bloody love the way this guy plays the game, does everything simply and effectively. Honourable mentions to Baptiste (again) and Bidwell

Referee – Steve Martin 9 Another fantastic display from a Championship ref. I thought he was virtually faultless, allowing the game to flow and keeping his cards in his pocket. The closest I’ve ever coming to awarding a ten! Cattermole might have been booked for simply being Cattermole, and only adding 1 minute added time at the end of the first half when three would have more appropriate, are my only frivolous complaints.

Attendance 26,066 (QPR 686)

The Twitter @LeeMcAlpine1


Get two free £10 bets on Queens Park Rangers v Brentford (or other matches) by opening a new account at William Hill. Place an initial bet of a minimum of £10 and William Hill will give you two £10 bets. You must enter the promotional code ''F20'' when signing up as a new customer.

Action Images



Please report offensive, libellous or inappropriate posts by using the links provided.



bob566 added 19:53 - Oct 15
Thanks Lee
0

RonisRs added 20:32 - Oct 15
thanks for the report.
I am feeling that it will come, injuries don't help.
as for the rubbish about KJ to take over, why bother, we need continuity and quite frankly I cant see the rationale........
0

derbyhoop added 20:48 - Oct 15
It wasn't just the BBC report. The C5 highlights gave the impression Sunderland were the better side.
0

Myke added 22:03 - Oct 15
Thanks Lee. Frustrating that we didn't get that killer second goal before they scored. Frustrating that for the secon






























































Cheers Lee. Frustrating that we didn't get that second killer goal before they scored. Frustrating too, that for the second year in a row McGeady has done us with a 'wonder' goal. (Thought Smithies could have done better) This is the same McGeady that can't get near a bang average Irish team.
I can't see why there should be any speculation over Holliway's position. Everyone who has watched us regularly this season agrees that we are enjoyable to watch and working hard for each other. Being mindful of Clive's excellent piece, we don't want to rewrite the same old story again. Fernandez must be unequivocal in his support for his manager. Meanwhile we just need to win a bloody match, starting with Bolton if Ophelia doesn't intervene




0

Myke added 22:58 - Oct 15
Major (and well documented) problem is our inability to score enough goals. I goal is rarely enough to win a game (especially as clean sheets are as rare as hens teeth) We scored two in most of our opening 6 games but have only managed 1 or less in our last 4. The goals have been nicely spread around as we knew they had to be , just not enough of them!
0

PunteR added 22:59 - Oct 15
Thanks Lee.
Regarding Wzsolek , i dont think replacing him with Wheeler is going to restore his confidence. It does seem that he's struggling a bit atm but i think he just needs games and he'll find his form. He's one of our best players , a Polish international.
0

timcocking added 02:23 - Oct 16
Pavel deciding not to shoot with the easiest chance of the whole match beggared belief. He's clearly struggling, must be removed immediately. My mum would have buried that one, to pass instead!? Mind blowingly bad.

Manning did well at wing back, it looks a good position for him. A little more attacking than Bidwell obviously.

And Sylla looked, surprise surpise, a better player than Mackie or Washington. Ollie needs to learn to understand how to get the most out of lazy foreigners, or don't sign them to begin with.
0

Melbourne_R added 06:53 - Oct 16
Have to be please with a point at the stadium of light but sounds like we should have had three. General consensus we are playing well but not getting the reward, then play badly and get beaten. have to get our confidence back with the strikers, maybe then we will see the hard work pay off.
0

Wren67 added 10:25 - Oct 16
This is an excellent report and perfectly represents the game I saw at the SOL. "Satisfied disappointment" also describes how I felt after the game too. My MOM was Bidwell for his aggression and determination. Wzolek's decision too cross to no one when a shot on goal when by far the better option leaves me thinking his confidence is shot. We should have, should have won. Onwards to Bolton
0

YorkRanger added 12:17 - Oct 16
Good report Lee, pretty much in line with how I saw it
0


You need to login in order to post your comments

Blogs 28 bloggers

Queens Park Rangers Polls

About Us Contact Us Terms & Conditions Privacy Cookies Advertising
© FansNetwork 2017 hosted by FastHosts