|Queens Park Rangers 1 v 0 Sheffield United|
Tuesday, 31st October 2017 Kick-off 19:45
Holloway brings up 300 not out with Sheff Utd visit - Preview
Tuesday, 31st Oct 2017 10:47 by Clive Whittingham
Fresh from a fine win against table topping Wolves on Saturday, QPR face new league-leaders Sheff Utd in Ian Holloway's 300th game in charge this evening.
QPR (4-6-4, DDLDDW, 14th) v Sheff Utd (10-0-4, WWLWWW, 1st)
Mercantile Credit Trophy >>> Tuesday October 31, 2017 >>> Kick Off 19.45 >>> Weather – Lazing on a sunny afternoon, cold and cloudy tonight >>> Loftus Road, London, W12
This evening’s game with Sheffield United is Ian Holloway’s three hundredth as QPR manager across two challenging spells. Saturday’s excellent performance and win against Wolves does at least spare him the ignominy of needing to win it to shore up his position.
Holloway can be infuriating. His team was often too direct towards the end of his first spell in charge, which lasted from 2001 to 2005, and his penchant for picking immobile defenders like Steve Palmer and Matthew Rose as central midfielders, or players like Georges Santos hopelessly out of position up front, would wear thin. His second stint has been marked by lengthy winless runs which have often, at least in part, been triggered by too much fiddling about with the team selection. There is a prevailing feeling, enhanced by how he reacted to failures at Palace and Millwall, that he’s constantly trying to show what a good manager he is, over-thinking and second guessing himself to the point of messing the team up completely.
For a man who was carving out a career in television prior to stepping back into the management game, he’s still incapable of articulating his point succinctly and in less than five minutes. Part of that is his shtick. Under pressure managers can distract from their own failures or actual issues by doing their own version of dead cat politics – Jose Mourinho is a master of cooking up some nonsense argument with an opposing manager, a referee, or a dispensable member of his own squad which the journalists all dutifully run after distracting them from the real story. Holloway’s version of that is just to burble a stream of consciousness out with a few jokes and metaphors until you’re not sure what the question was or whether he’s answered it or not. But when you hear Kaspars Gorkss talking about Neil Warnock’s ultra-basic method of team instruction you do wonder and worry whether Holloway can get a clear and concise message across to modern day footballers.
There are those that say he’s not up to the job now. There are even those that say his first spell was overrated, that he should have kept us in the First Division in the first place (despite looming administration and a terrible team), that he only achieved promotion by spending a relatively large amount of money for the division, that even when it did come it was second behind Plymouth and so on. That win ratios of 39% last time and 31% to date so far second time round are nothing to write home about.
But let’s have this right, QPR’s third longest serving manager of all time deserves respect. A good deal more respect than I feel he’s afforded at times.
Twice now he has come in to manage QPR in difficult circumstances. Yes, once administration had been exited in 2002 money was spent, and a couple of very good players provided for him by the Winton family that other clubs in the division wouldn’t have been able to get hold of, but prior to that he’d been trying to build a team from a starting point of six senior professionals fit and signed up while the club was in admin. To do it as well as he did, to bring the players in he did – the likes of Shittu, Ainsworth, Rowlands, Furlong, Day, Cook, Gallen, Bircham who are all still talked about today – was quite something. Not only that, but the way he changed the whole atmosphere and ethos around the place. And anybody who thinks the team he inherited could have survived doesn’t remember the 5-0s at Wimbledon and Preston and the 5-2 at Sheff Wed prior to his arrival very well. That team was shit.
You can look at how we’re doing currently and say, statistically, it’s really no better than what Jimmy Floyd Hasselbaink was doing results and league placing wise. But look at our team now, look how it played on Saturday, look how dynamic and mobile that midfield is, look how many shots on goal we’re sending in (only Brentford have more this season in the whole league), look at that Freeman-Luongo-Scowen combination… does anybody really remember anything like that under the previous manager? We are palpably a better team than we were 12 months ago.
Again, it’s being done in trying times. Holloway has once more arrived after his predecessors had spent all the money. He’s being required to cut his wage bill, and will surely be asked to shed at least half a dozen senior players from the current list at the end of this season, while remaining competitive on the pitch. He’s doing exactly that, QPR have only lost four times this season which is the same as league leading Sheffield United and one fewer than fifth-placed Leeds. To finish midtable, which is probably the aim while the squad and wage bill are trimmed, and is what almost everybody you spoke to said in August would count as a good season, you have to lose as many as you win. That’s exactly what QPR are doing, and yet defeats are treated like absolute calamities, and pressure is applied to the manager after each one.
You can make too much of his passion for the club. Neil Warnock had no previous connection to QPR but was absolutely fantastic here. Often Holloway can be overly emotional. All that badge kissing and what have you tends to appeal to the same sort of people who think Nedum Onuoha isn’t a “pwopah leadah” and worry themselves into a TalkSport-phoning frenzy over who the England captain is. But having people who do genuinely care about the club steering it through these difficult times is helping. Are you not reassured that there are people like Ollie, Bircham, Andy Sinton, Les Ferdinand and Gary Penrice working at QPR now? You should be. People who will go home after a defeat just as angry as we are. When you have people like that who care about what they’re doing you find the club making signings like Shittu, Cook, Bircham, Furlong… Josh Scowen. When the opposite is true, you find yourself infested with the likes of Jose Bosingwa.
Holloway is not perfect, and there are better managers out there. We’re certainly welcoming one of those to Loftus Road this evening. Lack of resources at Alfreton, a financial collapse at Northampton, a history of failure at Oxford and Sheffield United, none of it was enough to stop Chris Wilder winning, winning repeatedly, winning all the time. He’s been promoted in every job he’s had so far.
People talk about Sheff Utd being this year’s Huddersfield, and it’s starting to look like that might be the case. Critics of Holloway, and QPR, point to them, and Preston, and say there are clubs with smaller budgets, smaller wage bills, smaller ticket prices, doing better than us, going past us, and yes they’re certainly what we should be aiming for an aspiring to. But Sheff Utd, Huddersfield, Preston, all these clubs went through years of dark times to get their house in order so they could push on. Huddersfield went through four managers and several near misses with relegation in this league before they got to David Wagner. Four managers tried to get Sheff Utd out of League One before Wilder succeeded. The club has to be in a position to move forwards, and if it’s not then the influence of the manager, or the effect of changing him and getting somebody else, is overstated. Look at Simon Grayson, who was doing an excellent job at Preston but is now on the cusp of the sack at Sunderland while his old club has barely missed a beat under Alex Neill. Good managers can flourish at stable, well-run clubs. If the club’s a mess, then more often than not it doesn’t matter who the manager is.
Holloway’s 300 matches at a club as trigger happy as QPR is worthy of congratulation. The job he did before, the job he appears to be doing now, even more so.
Les Ferdinand there, making the extraordinary look routine as per.
Team News: Fairly typical of QPR’s luck at centre half this season that Joel Lynch crowned his first decent display for months with an injury time yellow card at the weekend – his fifth in just seven appearances this season, so he’s suspended for this one. He’s really up against it now if he’s planning his usual sabbatical over Christmas with games running out in which to accumulate another five. Whether he’s replaced by Steven Caulker tonight or not really rather depends on whether that 20 Stellas for a tenner offer is still on at the local Shell garage. Nedum Onuoha, Grant Hall and James Perch, all potential defensive options, remain on the long term injured list.
John Fleck is also on the naughty step for accumulation of yellow cards following his booking in the win at Leeds on Friday. Sheff Utd, however, have no other injury or suspension problems. Bastards.
Elsewhere: Ten tonight, two tomorrow, one on Friday, the Championship marches relentlessly on into the winter.
Birmingham’s decision to hand out a free cardboard missile with every ticket to their derby match with Big Racist John and the Boys at the weekend proved as shrewd as one would reasonably expect. The prolonged stoppages to clear the pitch only contributing to one of the most tedious football matches you could ever hope to sit through. They get an extra day off for it still, with Captain Bigot taking his troops up to Preston Knob End for a live Sky game tomorrow, and Birmingham welcoming Brentford in this week’s encounter between two teams beginning with B.
Something has to give at the bottom tonight when Sunderland, who haven’t won at home since December, host Relegated Bolton, who are yet to win away since their promotion in the summer. It’s a battle of the bottom two, and anything other than a home win is likely to see Simon Grayson chopped – because it’s definitely the manager that’s the problem at Sunderland, no question. Draw.
Further up the table the Champions of Europe against the Derby Sheep is a battle of two play-off contenders, and two clubs with weirdly unshakeable delusions about their size and place in it all. Sporting Wolverhampton face a tough task in bouncing back from the weekend defeat in their European fixture with Borussia Norwich. The Eighth Annual Neil Warnock Farewell Tour welcomes Ipswich Blue Sox, where manager Mick McCarthy continues to refuse to start with the club’s most talented player Bersant Celina and says fans complaining about that will only make him less likely to give him game time. One thing McCarthy does have is plenty of nose to hack off and spite his face.
What else do we have here… Allam Tigers, struggling, shock, against Middlesbrough; Tarquin and Rupert welcome Bristol City; Sheffield Owls are at home to the Millwall Scholars and Nigel Clough’s Burton Albion host Barnsley.
Referee: I thought things were going a little bit too well. Tony Harrington’s calm, composed handling of Saturday’s belter with Wolves continued a trend for excellent refereeing performances in QPR games this season, and tonight we must pay for that. Yes, that’s right, it’s Keith Stroud time again, so expect a veritable torrent of cards, random decisions and hot nonsense. He’s sent off three QPR players and awarded four penalties against us in his last seven Rangers appointments. Last season he red carded two and booked eight in our draw at Nottingham Forest, then showed another eight yellow cards while totally losing control of the home game with Fulham. He finished the season suspended from the list entirely after awarding an indirect free kick rather than a retake when Newcastle encroached on their own penalty kick against Burton Albion. He’s been on the list a long time, been a liability for several years, and it’s very surprising the league didn’t take that opportunity to shake his hand and send him on his way permanently. Instead, here he is to ruin your Tuesday. Extensive QPR case file and stats here.
QPR: Matt Smith’s winner on Saturday was the sixteenth goal scored for QPR by a substitute since the start of last season – easily the most in the Championship. It snapped a seven-game winless run, but five of those games were drawn and Rangers now only have one defeat in six games coming into tonight’s encounter. The R’s have only lost four times all season which is the same as league-leading Sheffield United and one fewer than fifth-placed Leeds. Only Fulham (1-2) have won here in the league this season, with Reading (2-0), Ipswich, Hull and Wolves (all 2-1) beaten and Millwall (2-2) and Burton (0-0) getting out with a point. Three of Smith’s four goals this season have been scored with his head, the joint most in the league with Middlesbrough’s Britt Assombalonga.
Sheff Utd: The Blades are yet to draw this season, with ten wins and four defeats so far propelling them to the top of the league thanks to a 2-1 win at Leeds on Friday night and Wolves’ subsequent loss to Rangers the day after. Three of those four defeats have come away from home at Middlesbrough (1-0), Cardiff (2-0) and Forest (2-1) but they’ve also won four times on their travels already compared to QPR’s none. Since taking over at Bramall Lane at the start of last season Chris Wilder has won 40 and drawn ten of his 60 matches in charge – only Antonio Conte and Mauricio Pochettino have a better record in this country over the same period of time.
Prediction: Our run of correct predictions came to an end at the weekend, but we’ll take that given the circumstances. It’s the last chance to win the October prize from the sponsor of this year’s Prediction League, The Art of Football tonight. We’ll be handing out prizes from their QPR Collection at the end of October, January and to the overall winner. Our reigning Prediction League champion Southend Rsss tells us…
“Well what a game that turned out to be against Wolves. Everything just seemed to click. A superb performance all round. It was just so typical QPR wasn’t it? Two draws against bottom sides and then we go and pull that result of the bag.. It would not surprise me in the slightest if we get the win against Sheffield United aswell.
“It seems we play better when teams attack us at home and I can’t see the Blades coming down and sitting back. Not after the way they went about their business against Leeds on Friday night. They seem up for it, playing with confidence and hopefully that’ll create an open game at HQ tonight. Heart says we could possibly get a win here. However, score draws seem to be all the rage these days so that’s what I’ll go with. An entertaining desmond under the lights..”
Craig’s Prediction: QPR 2-2 Sheff Utd. Scorer – Conor Washington
LFW’s Prediction: QPR 1-2 Sheff Utd. Scorer – Idrissa Sylla
The Twitter @loftforwords
Pictures – Action Images
Get two free £10 bets on Queens Park Rangers v Nottingham Forest (or other matches) by opening a new account at William Hill. Place an initial bet of a minimum of £10 and William Hill will give you two £10 bets. You must enter the promotional code ''F20'' when signing up as a new customer.
Please report offensive, libellous or inappropriate posts by using the links provided.
You need to login in order to post your comments
Blogs 28 bloggers
Gylfi Not Irreplaceable- But Not Trying To Directly Replace Him Is Smart by BarneyLW
So the dust has finally settled. In what seemed like the most painstaking saga in living memory, Gylfi Sigurdsson is an Everton player. A man the club were silently resigned to eventually losing has moved on and like so often in the past, the club must plan for life without their star player.
Too many things for a title, but stop with the xenophobia accusations! by waynekerr55
I had planned to write this in a different fashion, but Bob Bradley's departure from the club changes a section of this blog. The conclusion was as expected. A seemingly good man and a tryer who simply wasn't up to the job. In short he should never have been given the job.
A New Hope At the Liberty? by BarneyLW
A feeling of déjà vu rose with the sun over Swansea this morning. Another manager out the door, another few days of links, speculation, supposed sightings of candidates spotted outside Rossi’s sampling the scampi. But for the first time in recent memory, there is hope in the air.
Swans Fans Were Angry- In A Totally Positive Way How a Common Enemy Helped Guidolin’s side pull of by BarneyLW
A return from the international break, which in truth was needed to clear the air around the club. A frustrating transfer market compounded and exacerbated back-to-back defeats against Hull City and the champions, Leicester. Boardroom shake-ups and a tough run of games has given the Jack Army little to be optimistic about.
Guidolin and Conte- An Italian Managerial Head to Head by BarneyLW
A different league in a different country for two familiar foes; on Sunday Francesco Guidolin's Swansea host Antonio Conte's Chelsea side. So how does the head to head record look from their previous encounters in Italy?
Queens Park Rangers Polls