Please log in or register. Registered visitors get fewer ads.
Queens Park Rangers 0 v 1 Norwich City
SkyBet Championship
Saturday, 22nd September 2018 Kick-off 17:30
QPR recovery grinds to a halt with Norwich defeat - Report
Sunday, 23rd Sep 2018 19:53 by Clive Whittingham

A run of four unbeaten, three wins and three clean sheets for QPR ended in a looooooooooong drawn out affair against Norwich City on Saturday night. Not my words Carol...

Well what a veritable treat for the discerning Saturday night television viewer this was.

Queens Park Rangers made the worst start to a season in the history of the football club this year with four defeats in the first four matches and 13 conceded, but they had been threatening to build a bit of momentum in their recovery from that with an impressive performance and comfortable 2-0 win against hapless Millwall during the week. From the bottom of the form table to the top, three wins and a draw in four matches with three clean sheets into the bargain.

That all ground to a halt at a sodden Loftus Road on Saturday night, Rangers stopped in their tracks by a deliberate and purposeful Norwich City side which has now won two and drawn two of its five away matches in the Championship so far this term. There was a real method to Daniel Farke’s team, which boasted nearly 70% of the possession and was anchored at the base of midfield by the game’s outstanding player Alex Tettey, but they’re not a quick side or particularly easy on the eye and had actually started wasting time at 0-0 before scoring the only goal of the game midway through the second half. With QPR offering absolutely nothing in attack themselves until the very final stages the whole thing quickly descended into a gruelling spectacle that seemed to go on for hours. If you thought our 0-0 draw at Birmingham City was dull, that was a night at Cirque du Soleil compared to this.

A big part of the success on Wednesday was the way QPR flew out of the traps, getting straight onto the front foot, involving their game changing players in the match immediately, winning a free kick on the edge of the Millwall box within 60 seconds to set the tone, pace and tempo of the game. They dictated things from there on, scoring twice before half time and coming close to several more. Here, against Norwich, they barely got out of the traps at all. In fact I think they’re still in there. Curled up, asleep.

That best performance of the season had come in a 4-2-3-1 system which saw Ebere Eze star at ten and Nahki Wells run the channels with smooth, attractive effectiveness as a lone striker. Tomer Hemed’s religious fast had seen him drop to the bench during the week allowing Steve McClaren to return to his favoured formation but with Hemed available to start again in this match he was faced with a straight choice of whether to stick to what had worked against the Lions or revert back to the 4-4-2 shape and team that had, in fairness to him, played well for an hour at Bolton the previous week and secured a first away win of 2018/19. He decided to twist, and it became clear pretty quickly that this had been a mistake.

Eze’s threat was reduced from perpetual to almost non-existent by moving him back to the wing. He’d been able to come inside and roam around behind Hemed and Wells at Bolton a week ago but there was none of that here, nor any of the brilliance we’d seen against Neil Harris’ side. Hemed did nowhere near enough to justify the immediate recall and Wells was starved of possession and chances.

Some of the problems were out of McClaren’s control. Angel Rangel has been quietly impressing on the right side of defence but had a groin strain so couldn’t play, Alex Baptiste was nowhere close to the Spaniard’s standards as an out of position replacement. I’m starting to wonder if Osman Kakay has been having it away with Mrs McClaren. Geoff Cameron, too, had been a big part of what went well during the week but didn’t have the match fitness to go again so soon – would Tettey have been able to dominate as he did had the Stoke loanee been in the team? And some of his players needed to do a lot more. Several of them – Luongo, Scowen and Hemed in particular – were so anonymous here I only know they played because they’re on the team sheet on the BBC website. Three games in a week, fair enough, but Scowen, Hemed and Baptiste should all have looked a lot fresher than this having not played the previous ones, and Norwich had a lot more energy and desire to affect the game about them having also played Saturday-Wednesday-Saturday.

But McClaren got this wrong, and then waited way, way too long to change it. Only after Rangers had fallen behind was Bright Osayi-Samuel introduced to add pace and purpose to the attack and get Eze playing more centrally. The decision to suddenly start with Baptiste who isn’t a right back and is clearly well short of match fitness necessitated a wasted straight swap substitution with Cousins when ideally we’d have been bolstering the attack. And it wasn’t until three minutes from time that Matt Smith was finally summoned and Rangers were able to create enough attacking threat to be denied an obvious penalty for a push on Luongo, and come close to a scrambled equaliser in stoppage time if only Luke Freeman had realised his proximity to a loose ball in the six yard box. The manager’s comments afterwards about this having 0-0 written all over it were true – the game was a tumour – but not for the first time this season a lot of the other things he said about QPR being the better side, creating more chances, being the only side likely to win, being harshly done to by the score and so on, bore very little relation to the game I suffered through on Saturday night. Norwich were the better side, and deserved to win.

I’ve written six things down about the first half, only one of which was a QPR shot on target – Wells dribbling a tame shot straight at Tim Krul five before half time. He had earlier pushed a loose ball past the Dutch keeper in the area but the angle was tight, the ball wouldn’t sit down for a shot, and he ended up conceding a foul. At the other end Stiepermann shot straight at Lumley off a nice move from a throw in after seven minutes, a low cross flashed right through the QPR box on 21 minutes, and Stiepermann again could only find Lumley’s gloves on the half hour when Teemu Pukki got in behind to the byline and cut a ball back for him. City quickly realised they could get joy by loading their left flank and trying to swamp Baptiste and Todd Cantwell, looking like he’d come straight from the set of Home and Away, had particular joy down there. But that was about it and referee Darren Bond could be done for cruel and unnecessary punishment for adding two minutes to an utterly turgid affair.

City started much the better of the second half, whatever the forecast on Steve McClaren’s hair island reckoned. Cantwell shot over, Baptiste produced a goal-saving block on Tettey, and although Aarons was shown a deserved yellow card for a deliberate foul on Luke Freeman it was actually Norwich who countered well off the resulting free kick and Joe Lumley did really well to emerge from his area and avert the danger with an improvised header. The Norwich penalty area was barely a rumour to QPR, and Jake Bidwell’s improvised deflection forcing Krul to catch the ball under his crossbar on the hour brought ironic cheers from the inmates. How you make a Championship team with Ebere Eze, Luke Freeman, Tomer Hemed and Nahki Wells as its front four look this devoid of ideas and toothless is beyond me, and so crushingly disappointing after the highs of four days ago.

It seemed very odd that Norwich would start time wasting with half an hour to go and the score at 0-0, the game looked there for the taking to me, but so they did and I resigned myself to the whole sordid little horror show petering out to a desperate 0-0. That actually proved to be rather optimistic as Stiepermann got in behind Baptiste and sent a cross via Toni Leistner’s outstretched boot into the path of the impressive Pukki who chested it home from close range. Four in four and seven in 11 now for the summer signing from Bronby – odd given he struggled to make an impact in the great fish-in-a-barrel shooting competition that is playing St Mirren 17 times a season for Celtic three years ago.

If you thought Norwich were clock running before, well then the remaining time in this game really wasn’t for you. It seems to be just generally accepted in the Championship this season that once a team is leading in the final third of the game they are allowed to take absolute liberties with what time remains. We’ve had it done to us by Sheffield United, Preston and Norwich now, while we’ve done it ourselves to Wigan, Bolton and Millwall. It is appalling to watch, reducing sporting fixtures people have forked over serious amounts of their hard earned cash to see into drawn out, boring farces. Players who are substituted deliberately going to the far side of the field and then walking off like a veteran member of the Cleethorpes and District Arthritis Care Association. Goalkeepers allowed to fuck about with the ball - cleaning it, placing it, replacing it, taking it to the other side of the six yard box, having a couple of false start run ups – for days and days at a time at every single goal kick. Play disrupted with one deliberate free kick after another, and every free kick immediately followed by the same niggly stuff where the ball gets poked away, and players refuse to retreat, and we have a big mother’s union with the referee about whether it was actually a free kick or not a free kick and whether it’s been placed in quite the correct position or not. Play repeatedly stopped to tend to one prostrate player after another when it is blatantly obvious to everybody in the ground that there is absolutely nothing wrong with them. And two physios now for every team - since when did that become necessary? One to make sure they are indeed pretending to be hurt and one to check for any signs of intelligent life? Then the whole palaver where said cheating footballer limps off to the side of the pitch the long way before immediately sprinting back on fit as a fiddle as soon as the game restarts.

And all the while all any of the referees at this level do is repeatedly point at their watch, book absolutely nobody, and then add four minutes at the end of the game regardless of anything that’s gone before. One or two minutes in the first half, four minutes in the second, thanks very much I’m off home now. What’s the point in them having a fucking watch at all really? I already know how much stoppage time there’s going to be at Swansea next week and the game’s six days away.

Now let’s be clear here. This is not the embittered, sour grapes ranting of the beaten football fan, though I appreciate it may come across as that in this context. As I say, we were doing exactly this to Bolton and Millwall earlier in the week. Joe Lumley is bloody awful for it. And let’s not forget that after Preston and Sheff Utd dark arted us to death in the opening week of the season, I said that QPR needed to learn from them and get some street smarts of their own, which in the last few games it seems we have. We were wasting time at 0-0 at Birmingham a fortnight ago.

This is a general point about how referees in the Championship are complicit in, and in the case of Darren Bond on Saturday actively encouraging through total indifference and inaction, this descent of second tier football in this country to the very worst tropes of the leagues in Spain, Italy and particularly Portugal – where the aim of the game is to make sure you’re not losing after an hour, and then piss the final 30 minutes up the wall in front of 12,000 people who’d paid north of £30 to get in. This will fester if there isn't a serious clampdown and make what is already a basic, attritional, mediocre and borderline unwatchable league less palatable still. There have been episodes of Celebrity Big Brother that had more about them than this latest dirge. Loftus Road, like many Championship grounds, littered with empty seats, and I doubt those that did bother will be keen to rush back for more.

McClaren slung on Samuel and Cousins, then later Smith. Since his barnstorming man of the match display against Bristol Rovers, Samuel has been rewarded with 13 minutes of playing time across four matches. Freeman could have scored in one scramble, and brought a good save from Krul by powering through two tackles and unleashing a powerful shot that burned with personal frustration. Luongo should have had a penalty, but even if the referee did have the balls to add on the amount of time he should have done I’m not sure a goal was ever really likely. Norwich rarely looked unduly troubled, and they saw out the win far more comfortably than the 1-0 scoreline suggested.

The whole thing was excruciatingly boring.

Match Gallery: 15 photos

And it pissed with rain all afternoon.

Links >>> Knee Jerks >>> Photo Gallery >>> Ratings and Reports >>> Message Board Match Thread

QPR: Lumley 6; Baptiste 5 (Cousins 77, 5), Leistner 6 (Smith 87, -), Lynch 6, Bidwell 5; Eze 5, Luongo 5, Scowen 5 (Osayi-Samuel 77, 6), Freeman 6; Hemed 5, Wells 6

Subs not used: Ingram, Cameron, Wszolek, Kakay

Norwich: Krul 6; Aarons 6, Zimmerman 6, Klose 6, Lewis 7; Leitner 6 (Trybull 90, -), Tettey 8; Buendia 6 (Vrancic 68, 6), Stiepermann 7, Cartwell 7; Pukki 7 (Rhodes 90+2, -)

Subs not used: Godfrey, Srbeny, McGovern, Thompson

Goals: Pukki 71 (assisted Stiepermann)

Yellows: Aarons 61 (foul), Lewis 67 (foul)

QPR Star Man – Luke Freeman 6 Best of a very mediocre bunch for my money. Kept going right to the end, desperately trying to make things happen for his team, came as close as anybody to scoring.

Referee – Darren Bond (Lancashire) 5 Missed a fairly blatant QPR penalty at the end of the game when Luongo was shoved to the ground as he was about to shoot. Was complicit in, and actively encouraged, the time wasting that went on in the second half.

Souls on Board 12,843 (1,800 Norwich approx) Ground looking pretty sad and empty so far this season. Those that braved this one won’t be in a rush to come back.

The Twitter/Instagram @loftforwords

Pictures – Action Images

Get two free £10 bets on Queens Park Rangers v Middlesbrough (or other matches) by opening a new account at William Hill. Place an initial bet of a minimum of £10 and William Hill will give you two £10 bets. You must enter the promotional code ''F20'' when signing up as a new customer.

Action Images



Please report offensive, libellous or inappropriate posts by using the links provided.



ozexile added 20:18 - Sep 23
Over from Oz for the game and very disappointed. My wife who I presumed knew nothing about Football but as it turns out knows more than Mclaren after 10 mins she said " Shouldn't your players push out and try and get the ball off of the other team?" Goodnight.
0

062259 added 21:14 - Sep 23
There’s a very winnable cup game away to Blackpool coming up. A win would result in a last 16 appearance with the likelihood of a much-needed infusion of cash, a chance of reaching the quarter finals, and some excitement and anticipation for the fanbase. Despite this, I’m almost certain McLaren will make 11 changes to the team that started against Norwich, citing the need for rest and rotation with another 3 league games in a week coming up. I would have some sympathy with 5 or 6 changes, but if they lose with 11 different players, I’ll be pissed.
0

tsbains64 added 21:34 - Sep 23
Missed out the midfield for long periods Had the opportunities to score but didn't NCFC had more fo the possession but didn't look much better than us in the pouring rain
0

Burnleyhoop added 22:42 - Sep 23
Tactically MaClaren got this completely wrong and his comments after the game were perplexing to say the least.
I’m a huge admirer of Eze, but he spent almost the entire game chasing,and failing, to catch their left back Lewis. He was also guilty of some sloppy passing which often failed to find a team mate. He clearly needs to sit in behind the striker(s) to be at his most effective.

As for Luongo,Scowen and Cousins, they all have similar attributes and weaknesses. There is only one place in the team for their type. Play one of them, but certainly not all of them.

The conundrum now is do we accommodate the two new strikers at the expense of an unbalanced midfield that puts our two most creative players in uncomfortable positions or change the system?

MaClaren now needs to be brave and make a decision that serves the balance of the team more than individuals. The Norwich game was crying out for Pav and BOS after 20 mins with Hemed and Scowen or Luongo giving way to provide us with some much needed width. A ball player in the centre of the park is much needed.
1

Phil_i_P_Daddy added 23:29 - Sep 23
With you all the way Clive.
As luck would have it (?) I turned up about half an hour before kick off, wondering why the TV vans were there at 2.30 but nobody else was.
Yup, I are a dick.
However, it meant I got to watch our dreary capitulation on Sky from the comfort of my girlfriend’s sofa. Maybe there is a god? (SPOILER - there isn’t!).
0

Myke added 00:10 - Sep 24
As you rightly pointed out in the preview, Clive, Norwich were a tougher proposition than Milwall, but my god it was difficult to imagine we were watching the same team 3 days apart. Hemed undoubtedly weakened the team, both directly by being completely ineffective and indirectly by forcing Eze out on the wing rendering him useless. Baptiste may be inferior to Rangel (although I was disappointed with him v Milwall) but still made a goal-saving block. Lewis' pace caused him problems all evening but would probably have done so to Rangel also, so McClaren should either have started started with Kakay or offered Babtiste more protection by playing Pav or Cousins in front of him.
Both of their full-backs were on yellow cards with plenty of time to go but McClaren never exploited this by getting Pav and BOS on (the latter in time) to really run at them and see if he could draw another yellow. A blatant penalty that should have been spotted by the lino not withstanding, we were shocking and fully deserved to lose. It's that bloody fickle nymph called Hope that has killed us again
0

DavieQPR added 01:19 - Sep 24
All lino's seem incapable of making any decision without looking at the Ref first.
0

californiahoop added 08:08 - Sep 24
Can’t play Mass or Scowen in the same midfield.
0

smegma added 08:39 - Sep 24
I have no idea what game Steve watched as there WAS only one team who were going to win and they weren't wearing hoops. As for him saying we created the most chances, Krul could have played 'Rush goalie' and we wouldn't have scored. It appears Steve had a policy of picking older more experienced players on Saturday as that's the only reason for not picking Kakay to start and not bringing him on as Baptiste was out of his depth in the shallow puddles on the pitch.
0

Marshy added 10:45 - Sep 24
From the very off Norwich pressed and pressed us to win the ball, but yet we didn't do the same to them. When they were in possession there were just far too many big gaps. Tactically we were way too disjointed. It's not surprising that our two strikers didn't achieve much, as for 90 minutes they got virtually no service. Steve has got to find a way of getting us more attacking width, whilst still accommodating Wells and Hemed (with Eze just behind), as I'm convinced these two have got plenty of goals in them. As many on here have alluded to, we have both Pav and BOS and even Symth who can run the wing with pace, and get crosses into the box. Therefore there needs to be a rebalance, with one of the regular midfield making way. In my opinion that would be Luongo who unfortunately hasn't continued his good form from the latter part of last season, and hasn't contributed very much so far this term.
0

Patrick added 11:09 - Sep 24
It was all a bit negative from McLaren, no subs until they score and can run the clock down. I fear that after our dire defensive opening to the season we may have to get used to it. McC will look at the goals against column in recent games and think that's enough. Both he and the team were scarred by the 7+3 goals and they'll probably take this. One lucky bobble or pen at the end and it would have been presented as "job done". Yet again we buy winger after winger but don't play them (or not as wingers). It's going to be a grind but as I say - get used to it! Certainly until (unless?) we're a lot safer than now. (Except in cups of course - two wingers Tuesday).
0

BlackCrowe added 12:42 - Sep 24
I'm not so bothered that McLaren got it tactically wrong - that happens to the best of managers. It's the fact that he didn't remedy it after about 25 minutes when i and everyone around me could see it wasn't working, players not comfortable, shape all wrong. That to me says he's either incompetent, stubborn or was targeting a draw. All three pretty unpalatable.
0

Paddyhoops added 14:00 - Sep 24
McLaren's line that " there was two very good teams out there today" was baffling unless he was watching a live feed of Brighton and Spurs in the dugout!!
By the way where has paul smyth disappeared to.
A positive player whos only thought is creating or scoring goals . Dispiriting isn't the word!!
1

extratimeR added 20:53 - Sep 24
Cheers Clive

Absolutely nailed on. Pretty much everyone around me in F Block picked up that Norwich would pile on Baptiste straight from the kick-off, they did. Then had the bizarre spectacle of Eze tracking back and marking the Norwich guy to cover Baptiste, Bonkers!

Surely he is our main threat, we want Norwich worried about him, not the other way round!

Yes, Norwich better side, I to watched BOS have a blinder against Bristol Rovers, never to be seen again, and Kakay with pace, must have been a better option than Baptiste?

Thanks Clive, great report.
0


You need to login in order to post your comments

Blogs 29 bloggers

Queens Park Rangers Polls

About Us Contact Us Terms & Conditions Privacy Cookies Advertising
© FansNetwork 2018