x

Watt View - Can Home Form Concerns Be Put To Bed ?

In the latest "Watt View" Matt airs his concerns over the home form last season and whether these can now be put to bed after the end of season run or will the return of the fans at some point prove to have been part of a problem not resolved.

It was a pleasure to be back with The Ugly Inside last week and many thanks to those of you who commented or contacted me as a result.

One of the topics that consistently reared its head throughout the second half of the season and continues to is that of home form.

A question was also raised of whether or not Saints would have delivered their barnstorming three-goal second-half riposte against Sheffield United on the final day had St Mary's been packed with supporters disgruntled at the first half display.

My answer to that is unequivocal — they absolutely would. I have never been one to place too much weight on how that can affect results and performances, particularly among today's top-level professionals.

Ralph Hasenhüttl's men came back fitter, mentally stronger and with more bite both home and away and that is why they responded in the manner they did against The Blades.

Additionally, as has been analysed extensively, the squad went through a transformation after the 0-9 capitulation to Leicester in late October.

Some of the concern has no doubt been fuelled by the starkness of end-of-season home and away tables which show Saints sat second-bottom and, contrastingly, third respectively.

For me personally, I prefer to celebrate the remarkable achievement of nine wins and four draws on the road over the course of the season and take comfort in the knowledge many results at home could have gone either way.

I think when we look at results and performances at home, it is important to give some context and perspective and results away are intrinsically linked. Therefore, I tend to view the season as a whole.

If we go back to the start, a 1-2 defeat at home against would-be champions Liverpool was very nearly a superb point with Danny Ings inches away from snatching a draw at the death.

Either way, the result was a respectable one given the disappointment of the opening day performance at Burnley — 3-0 — which raised eyebrows though, in fact, the Clarets went on to have a very impressive campaign.

Two away victories followed before a point against Manchester United and, sandwiched between away wins against Sheffield United and the memorable Carabao Cup demolition of Portsmouth, was a 1-3 loss against a then-strong Bournemouth side.

A slim 2-1 defeat at Tottenham Hotspur was followed by a home humbling against a very clinical Chelsea — but tempered by an excellent point away against Wolves at Molineux afterwards.

We all know what followed, the freak disaster against Leicester which saw Hasenhüttl look to regroup in two consecutive away trips to Manchester City (3-1 and 2-1 defeats). Then came the first home game after the Foxes thrashing, a 1-2 loss against Everton on 9 November — always going to be a tricky occasion given what had preceded it.

However, a point away against Arsenal at the Emirates was followed by two home wins against Watford (2-1) and Norwich (2-1).

After taking the lead away at Newcastle, Saints suffered a 1-2 Toon turnaround in the last 20 minutes and the hangover lasted into the following week with a 0-1 loss at home to West Ham.

But what was to come was pure delight — and part of the rebuilding project coming to fruition.

A 1-3 win at Villa Park and a 0-2 victory against Chelsea at Stamford Bridge — avenging that home thumping — was complemented with a point at home against Crystal Palace in an entertaining 1-1 draw. This saw three wins, a draw and two defeats in December.

The resurgence continued in January with home wins against Tottenham and Huddersfield (in the FA Cup) before that all-important 1-2 win at Leicester.

Unfortunately, after taking a 2-0 lead against Wolves at St Mary's, the away side hit back to steal a 2-3 win in a thrilling encounter. If Saints had held on it would have made it five wins in the last six matches.

January was then rounded off with a comfortable 0-2 win at Crystal Palace immediately after and a 1-1 draw in the FA Cup against Spurs at St Mary's — this time Saints hitting back late through Sofiane Boufal on 87 minutes.

While a tough February saw three defeats on the road (Liverpool, Spurs and West Ham) and a loss at home against a well-drilled Burnley in difficult conditions, Saints bagged an important 2-0 home win against Aston Villa.

In the final game before lockdown, Saints fell to a 0-1 defeat at home against Newcastle but had to contend with Moussa Djenepo's sending off on 28 minutes.

When the Premier League returned to action, it is well-documented Saints hit the ground running and, barring a slip at home against Arsenal, recorded five wins and three draws.

So, what does this all tell us?

Well, had Saints earned an additional 10 points at home they would have found themselves bang-on mid-point in the end-of-season home form table with 31 points — the same tally they took away.

Realistically, that was easily within reach. Six of the 10 losses were by one goal — the majority of those being games Saints could — and often should — have taken points from.

By laying it out as I have above, I think it shows that, except a few disappointing home defeats, the season was very much a resounding success, with disappointments often swiftly rectified.

The fact the 0-2 defeat at home by Arsenal on 25 June, during which goalkeeper Alex McCarthy misjudged a ball from the back into the path of Eddie Nketiah, happened in an empty stadium says to me the suggestions of crowd negativity and fear of performing at home are tenuous.

Ultimately, I feel the concerns about Saints' results at home were the consequence of two significant factors: that Saints suffered a record-equalling 0-9 defeat and then didn't record a home win until 30 November.

Based on these two points, I can very much understand where fans' concerns and frustrations came from but they were overcome through wins on the road.

I have pondered the possibility that Saints' excellent away results potentially contributed to poorer home form given they so often responded to home defeats by gaining points on their travels — perhaps, as a consequence, reduced the need to rely on home victories.

I believe Hasenhüttl and his team turned a corner and the side we saw in the final nine games is how they will embark on the new season and continue — with or without fans present.

What to read next:

A Rough Guide To Leeds United
A big big game for just Leeds now, although by Saturday the odds on them going up automatically might have changed slightly so here is all the info for those travelling Saints fans who are still going,
Southampton Should Not Fear Anyone In The Play Offs.
The hope of getting back into the Premier League automatically has long gone, but the season is not yet over and we now have a good chance of getting to Wembley and going up through the play offs, here we look at who we could meet.
Southampton V Stoke City The Verdict
This should have been a celebratory day for Saints fans, there should have been a feeling of positivity, but the truth is that the fight has been knocked out of the supporter base and we go into the play offs with confidence both on and off the pitch at a low ebb.
Southampton 0 - 1 Stoke City - Player Ratings and Reports
If you saw the match, please give us your player ratings and a mini match report.
Saints V Stoke City A Look Back In Pictures 2
In the second part of our pictorial look back at some of our games against Stoke City from the past, here we look back at more recent games, so most of you would have been at them.
Saints V Stoke City A Look Back In Pictures
We have looked through our photo archives for a look back as some games against Stoke City over the years, what are your memories of these games ?
Southampton V Stoke City The Preview
Saints go into the last two games of the season with their hopes of automatic promotion ended, even the hope of finishing 3rd is only a point away from being ended, but they do have something to play for and that is getting back the togetherness, character & fight Russell Martin has recently be moaned.
No Togetherness No Character No Fight
Not my words, but those of Southampton manager Russell Martin, who should ask himself the question why two months ago we had all those attributes and now we don't !
Southampton At Leicester The Debacle
The big question is how can a side that was so tight at the back, so clinical up front and who could pass the ball around almost with their eyes closed, become the disorganised rabble that they were at the Leicester City this evening.
Southampton Side Announced For Leicester Game
Russell Martin has revealed his side for the game against Leicester City, find out what surprises he has for Saints supporters this time out.