x

Tonda Eckert Should Base Goalkeeping Choice On Ability And Form But Are His Hands Tied

At his pre match press conference Southampton manager Tonda Eckert gave some very definitive statements on the goalkeeping pecking order at St Mary's, but this has raised some eyebrows and it could be more about transfer clauses than ability.

In his pre match press conference ahead of Saints trip to Lincoln City, Tonda Eckert gave a very clear message of support to his current first choice goalkeeper Daniel Peretz, he also gave his commitment to 2nd choice George Long & 3rd choice Jamie Jones.

But he was not so complimentary about Aaron Ramsdale who now looks set to twiddle his thumbs for at least the next 4 months on the highest wages at the club.

Tonda had this to say when asked about where Aaron Ramsdale currently stood at the club:

"Maybe I need to go a little bit further back on Daniel. He came in in January and we as a club, myself personally, have made a clear commitment to him.

"He is number one, and that stands. He deserves that. He's had some brilliant performances in the last year and now towards the beginning of the season.

"My commitment to Long has a number two stance as well and I think that group has worked very, very well last year together with Jamie.

"It's not just for the goalkeepers. Jamie has experience and has such an important role for the dressing room in general.

"It's clear that he came in as a training goalkeeper and as someone who supports everywhere he can, and that is the way that we go forward."

When asked whether it was a waste of talent not to have Ramsdale involved he replied:

" I think that every constellation, not just for the goalkeepers, has its own story and history. Rambo's started at this club before myself.

"With Rambo, we've had honest conversations from the first day of pre-season until the very last day of the transfer window.

"He's a part of the group, just like everyone else. Everyone is playing his role, the expectations for him are clear: to support the team in the best way.

"He's been very professional in doing that. That's all there is to say."

Personally I was a little concerned to hear him say that, I fully expected to hear him back Daniel Peretz, as quite rightly as he said he had some brilliant performances last season, he deserves to be number one at the start of this season.

But no player whatever his position should be in the starting order on anything other than merit, Peretz holds the number 1 shirt and it is his to lose, if he puts in good performances week in week out he should hold his place end of, if he doesn't play well then the manager has a decision to make.

But conversely no player should be ruled out of consideration either.

For obvious reasons Aaron Ramsdale wanted to leave the club in the summer, indeed the club wanted him to leave, for no other reason than they cannot afford to pay his Premier League level wages in the Championship.

But it looks like he is here till January at least and that means that he like any other player should be in contention for a place.

Indeed there is a precedent set by Tonda Eckert himself, Sam Edozie put in a transfer request and put out quite a negative message about the club on social media, yet Tonda remains loyal to him and used him as a sub at Lincoln on Saturday, if we talk about commitment then the likes of Tom Fellows who played no part at Lincoln other than sitting on the bench for the entire game, must feel a little miffed, likewise Lewis Dobbin who got on for just 12 mins.

I don't think anyone would deny that Ramsdale is a better keeper than Peretz, in that he has a lot more experience at the highest level and his transfer value is probably three times more than Peretz's.

But that should not mean that he is put straight into the first team now, as I have said Daniel Peretz is holding the jersey, if he plays well then it is his to keep.

But if Peretz's form does drop and there has been evidence that he is not performed at the standards that he set last year, then it has to be the best man for the job and to be blunt here there is not a Southampton supporter who would claim that George Long & Jamie Jones are better than Aaron Ramsdale.

It is a strange statement and it leads me to believe that there is something more behind this statement than just the fact that Tonda Eckert is standing behind his man.

I am starting to think that there is money involved, it is possible that the fee we paid Arsenal for Ramsdale has a clause in it where we have to pay more money if Ramsdale plays a certain number of games for the club.

If Ramsdale comes in, then he could activate that clause at some point in the coming season, the fact that we can't shift him on a permanent basis due to his wages (Not his fault) and that we are likely to make a loss on him, probably means that we don't want to increase that loss by having to pay Arsenal a few more million.

To be honest this is the only reason that I can plausibly think of for his continued isolation from first team contention.

What to read next:

CEO Phil Parsons Praises Loyalty Of Southampton Supporters.
Phil Parson's has been on the charm offensive ahead of this week which by the end of it will probably see the end of the Spygate saga, whether that verdict will be good or bad for the club.
Could Southampton Look To Repeat Managerial Solution Of January 2000
Back in January 2000, with the new century barely 4 weeks old, Saints had a problem, manager Dave Jones was embroiled in a Court case that had seen serious charges levelled against him, could Southampton repeat their almost 27 years later.
The Saints Adam Wrexham Not Going To The Match Day Vlog
While the Mighty Saints (the team not the mildly successful live podcast only available on this channel), travel to Wrexham to attempt to go into the international break with some more points on the board, Debbie and I head out to Freshwater to photograph a wedding.
Southampton V Wrexham The Verdict
The difference between our last visit to Wales back in April and Saturday's defeat was shocking, perhaps the upcoming Spygate verdict had a lot to do with this, but we once again failed to keep a clean sheet and up front couldn't hit a barn door.
Tonda Eckert Asks For Forgiveness As Final Judgement On Spygate Looms
Tonda Eckert & Southampton CEO Phil Parsons have spoken to the BBC ahead of an International break, when the verdict on the incident dubbed Spygate is expected to finally be decided.
Wrexham 2 - 1 Southampton - Player Ratings and Reports
If you saw the match, please give us your player ratings and a mini match report.
The Mighty Saints Podcast Live Thursday Night 9pm • Southampton At Wrexham Preview and Prediction Show
After another convincing home victory against Bristol City on Saturday, we digest the weekend's performance, name the elephant in the room (no spoilers its Tonda) and chat about football in general.
Southampton At Wrexham The Preview
Just 5 months ago Saints went to North Wales to take on a Wrexham side who had promotion hopes of their own and emerged from what was seen as a difficult game as 5-1 winners, however a lot of water has gone under the bridge since then.
Southampton Programme And Memorabilia Fair 26th September
A must for those Saints fans who like to collect programmes & are interested in the history of the club and memorabilia, will take place on Saturday 26th September at St Mark's Church Hall.
Inter Milan Interested In Southampton Youngster
Reports in Italy are suggesting that the Italian giants are taking a big interest in only of the club's up and coming players, have Saints missed a trick here.