 | Forum Reply | We could lose Zach Abbot in January at 12:24 12 Nov 2026
The first reports in the summer said we had an option to buy. The later reports said there was no option. Forest want to keep him and at the same time he signed the loan deal, he extended his contract at Forest to 2030. They have loaned him out for 1 season for development, which is why they won't let him stay here if he's not playing matches. |
 | Forum Reply | If Cameron Archer is the answer...... at 14:13 10 Nov 2026
Some fair points but, apart from anything else, he is very young and will learn and develop. If we had a 60 yr old coach who was making mistakes that's more of a problem because he's likely to have fixed ideas. Tonda is already good and is likely to develop and improve. As with Ross Stewart, what are the chances that we could easily find a like-for-like replacement? Not good. Sign him up before his agent starts getting ideas or some Moneybags FC decides to test the waters. |
 | Forum Reply | Southampton students killer gets sentence increased. at 12:48 9 Nov 2026
I used to think like you but I've changed my mind. We need harsher sentencing for everything, including a death penalty at the top end. You're right that mistakes can be made and we might execute someone who's innocent. But there are safeguards that could be applied and even if we did execute someone innocent, I'd be prepared to accept that if doing it saved many more innocent lives by making killers think twice. We convict when it is "beyond reasonable doubt". I think juries could also be asked if it is "beyond all doubt". When that applies, as I believe it would do in this case, then a death penalty seems both justified and fair to all involved. |
 | Forum Reply | If Cameron Archer is the answer...... at 12:35 9 Nov 2026
I agree with you, but it's not a fine detail, it's absolutely central and could well cost us promotion. It's also untrue to say that "we all said it". Most didn't. For example, Nick said we didn't need to sign a 3rd centre forward after we signed Mubama. I didn't see many on here disagreeing with him. You were one of the few who did. I've been banging on about this ever since we failed to take up our option to keep Ross Stewart. The only way out of it now is to spend way over the odds for a proper centre forward in January. I can't see them doing that, so unless by some miracle Larin plays 2 games a week, we're going to struggle. Btw, I can also see us repeating the Ross Stewart mistake with Tonda. We failed to extend Stewart's contract because we took the attitude that there was plenty of time, so we could wait. It sounds like that's what's happening with Tonda too. Unfortunately in life, circumstances can change suddenly and then you're out of time. By not tying him down we're just exposing ourselves to more risk. |
 | Forum Reply | Waterfront Expansion Plans at 18:38 7 Nov 2026
Bit late for today but if you have a good VPN then saintsplay is always an option. |
 | Forum Reply | Waterfront Expansion Plans at 14:44 7 Nov 2026
Let's see if there is any trouble when the Spurs legends event takes place. I doubt it. |
 | Forum Reply | Waterfront Expansion Plans at 14:26 7 Nov 2026
How do you know that Spurs wouldn't host a legends evening? Let's be real about this. Any legends evening is a few hundred people at most. The max attendance in the Mick Channon suite is 500. Hardly swarming the city. Neither would the skates be involved. Their fans wouldn't let them and even if they did, plod would veto it. |
 | Forum Reply | Waterfront Expansion Plans at 13:48 7 Nov 2026
So you'd be happy with Spurs playing another club in a game at St Mary's. So presumably you'd also be happy with Spurs playing another club in an FA Legends Cup game at St Mary's. So what would be the problem with the legends talking to the crowd instead of playing football for them? Same players, same fans, what's the problem? No it wouldn't make sense to "have a testimonial for a Southampton player in Manchester or an eveining with Saints legends in Newcastle" because they'd be poorly attended. But if someone wants to try it out I've got no problem with that. But I'd prefer in all cases that the events happened at St Mary's because then the ticket revenue would go to SFC instead of another club. |
 | Forum Reply | Waterfront Expansion Plans at 13:12 7 Nov 2026
So if we go back to having cup semi finals at neutral grounds (like we used to at Villa Park etc) then you would be against SFC hosting any semi final because that would mean having away fans in the stadium when Saints weren't playing ("I don't want them here when they arn't playing Southampton!") Don't you think that's a pretty extreme reaction? Why do you think the fans of Man U, Chelsea, Villa, Sheff Weds etc. were perfectly happy to have those games played on their grounds? |
 | Forum Reply | Waterfront Expansion Plans at 11:37 7 Nov 2026
"Spurs are a rival. Why do we want their fans using our stadium?" I want Spurs, Arsenal and Man Utd fans to use the stadium on a regular basis because that will mean that Saints are successful. I want them to show up every year when their teams play us in the PL. Do you want to ban away fans from matches? I also have no problem with them having legends evenings at St Marys. If they want to give money to our club instead of theirs, then go ahead. If we accept that we want away fans in the stadium for matches, then what's the problem with them showing up for a legends evening instead of a match? You don't have a problem with SFC hosting other matches, so how about a Spurs legends v Chelsea legends match? If that's ok, then what's wrong with the same fans showing up for an evening meeting those legends in person instead of watching a match? So long as they are paying SFC for the tickets I don't care. We're not going to see Spurs doing a bus top tour around the city, or anything like that. That's just not a real problem. Also the point about P&O and other sponsors not using the tickets we've sold them is a different issue. |
 | Forum Reply | Waterfront Expansion Plans at 19:33 6 Nov 2026
The city, like most of the country, badly needs new investment and growth so I'm not about to start complaining. Good luck to them and I hope they make a lot of money doing it, but the way they structure it will need careful thought. It needs to be done so that the football club gets revenue but is also shielded from the possibility of a huge project going wrong. It's a decade or so from happening, but if it eventually does happen, I couldn't care less if they have Barcelona v Madrid evenings and I'm not precious about the stadium and surroundings being used by other clubs and their supporters. What's the problem? Is this sacred ground or something? Chelsea currently let other clubs use Stamford Bridge for champions league games. Is that a problem? Villa used to let other clubs play a FA cup semi final at Villa Park pretty much every year. Was that a problem? It wouldn't be a problem for me. |
 | Forum Reply | Anyone remember the old baths in Southampton. at 19:18 28 Oct 2026
I think some of those bricks were mine because I was shitting bricks whenever I went up to the 3rd board. I only went up there because I was forced to by my older brothers. I never dived though, only jumped and tried not to die. I could just about manage the 2nd which was the springy one on the far side of this picture. I thought that was brave at the time but it looks like nothing in this picture. |
 | Forum Reply | Arteta what a prat at 14:04 28 Oct 2026
He got the ball, but not cleanly. He dived in aggressively, made contact and trapped Dowman's standing (right) leg in a scissor. That's a foul. Luckily it was only for a second. Dowman sort of buckled but his leg came free. If a scissor tackle traps a players leg and he goes over on it that can easily do ligaments. I'm not surprised Dowman reacted. The Fleetwood player could have seriously injured Dowman, but Dowman wouldn't have even bruised the other guy with his reaction. So it's nuts that it's Dowman who gets sent off. |
 | Forum Reply | Arteta what a prat at 11:26 28 Oct 2026
What I hated about this incident is the way it was refereed. If Dowman had rolled around on the ground, play acting, the Fleetwood guy would have been booked and Dowman would have been unpunished. Instead, Dowman stays on his feet, has a mild, honest reaction and gets sent off. The lesson: next time son, just roll around like a tvvat because that's what referees like to see. No one wants to see play acting but that's what referees reward. |
 | Forum Reply | Saints Players Falling Foul Of The Law at 11:20 28 Oct 2026
I remember the story (maybe made up for laughs) in Channon's autobiography, about some drink driving involving Osgood. The story goes that Osgood ran off but plod could see it was Osgood because his girlfriend was running faster than him. |
 | Forum Reply | Lewis Dobbin vs Ross Stewart at 13:31 26 Oct 2026
Stewart was fit before they were putting him in the squad. He hasn't been injured, just unused. They don't need him with Idah and Vipotnik. If he'd been with us, he'd have had a preseason as you say and been available from the beginning. No one knows if he'd have been injured since, but we know for sure that Larin has been. It seems it isn't going to happen but I would like to see Mubama given more of a chance. There have been glimpses of him doing all the things we need to do but he's not going to learn unless he plays real games. |
 | Forum Reply | Jason Wilcox at 13:10 26 Oct 2026
I doubt that Mr Martin takes any counselling from anyone. He's too arrogant. I also doubt that Wilcox would have helped him. He's had a similar situation at Man U with Ruben Amorim. Amorim faced constant criticism that his tactics weren't going to work with Man U's players. If Wilcox advised him to adapt then he was ignored. Wilcox left us before the sh1t hit the fan. But he can't escape responsibility for the squad and coaches he's put together at Man U, at great expense and with disastrous results. |
 | Forum Reply | Lewis Dobbin vs Ross Stewart at 12:07 26 Oct 2026
There's no way that Dobbin is a trade up on Stewart (who has been available for most of Swansea's games). I'm glad he played well on Saturday but that game suited him perfectly. He will struggle in other games. Dobbin needs space to play in, which he got on Saturday because WHU attacked us. When we play teams who want to defend more that space will disappear. Then the only space will be in the air, where Dobbin isn't much use. We might see that against QPR. They're in good form but even so will probably sit back. If Larin isn't fit we'll have a problem. You can see that Dobbin can play but he doesn't have the physicality to play as a centre forward. He needs someone to play off so he can play as a second striker. Hopefully we'll have enough regardless, but Saturday may be the type of game where we miss what Stewart can do and Dobbin can't. |
Please log in to use all the site's facilities |  | Ifonly
|
Site Scores| Prediction League: | 0 | | TOTAL: | 0 |
|