By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions. We in turn value your personal details in accordance with our Privacy Policy.
Please log in or register. Registered visitors get fewer ads.
His first goal for the U21s for a year. Lee Carsley's certainly persevering with him. I think that's what we'll get with him: 1 or 2 goals a year, which isn't good enough for a No.9, especially as he doesn't do much else on the pitch, except stand in offside positions, stopping our attacks.
But, as I said, Lee Carsley's persevering with him for some reason. 3 years ago, he was seen as a brilliant teenage prospect, who scored a hat-trick to knock Saints U18s out in the semi-finals of the FA Youth Cup.
Pat's right though: very few of these brilliant teenage prospects ever make the grade at first team level.
We saw it when we beat France 6-4 in the World Cup and when we won 7-0 in Croatia. In fact, it was remarkably similar to the France game, which was our best result in a World Cup since 1966.
He didn't win any trophies at all, let alone titles.
The original post says that only managers who won titles were considered successful. McMenemy won our only major trophy, but even he didn't win any league titles.
"There’s a bit on Sky about Manchester United: Busby and Ferguson account for 18 of United’s 20 league titles, with Mangnall (don’t know him either) being the third to have won a title. Comparatively Liverpool’s 20 titles are shared between 10 managers.
The question and headline was why has Manchester United only had 2 “successful” managers in their 148 years."
The media and the Met are the arbiters of their fate. I wonder if they'll give this one another go: "On 2 January 2013, as Jim Davidson was set to become a housemate in the 11th series of Celebrity Big Brother, he was arrested at Heathrow Airport by police officers working on Operation Yewtree. .On 20 March 2013, he was arrested again over new allegations of sexual offences; however, on 21 August 2013, it was announced that no further action would be taken in relation to the allegations of historic sex abuse, due to insufficient evidence."
They may not be the answer, but Princewill Ehibhatiomhan and Sillah Dibaga are such prolific goal scorers for the U21s that they deserve a chance to show what they can do at first team level. It's not as if we'll be missing much if Mubama and Dobbin are replaced for 20 minutes or so from the subs bench.
We're creating more chances than ever. The problem is we're not finishing enough of them. Cyle Larin is injured and we've got no other goalscoring striker to replace him.
We're not alone. Middlesbrough have struggled to score without Lankshear.
As Bridders has said, Mubama and Dobbin are not the answer. Until the January transfer window, we should give Princewill and Sillah Dibaga a chance as subs at least. They can't do any worse. Princewill is only 21, but he's 6'3" and built like Larin, while Dibaga has already shown as a sub in the FA Cup that he can cope with first team football.
We seem to prefer Man City academy players to our own, but even though City have a better first team, their academy is not as good as ours. Our U21 team is currently the best in the country and City's is only 21st:
I'd still prefer to see them given a chance rather than Mubama. I know they need time to develop, but there are players their age playing top flight football. Mubama is 22, Ehibhatiomhan is 21. I think the best of the bunch is Sillah Dibaga and although he's only 19, he looked very good when he came on as a sub against Leicester in the FA Cup earlier this year..
(Princewill Ehibhatiomhan 2, Sillah Dibaga 2, Aston Daley 1)
Those 3 deserve a chance in the 1st team, more than Divin Mubama does. They have scored 10 goals between them this week, after also winning 5-2 at Crystal Palace on Monday. I'd even prefer Dibaga to Dobbin.