Southampton FC 2020/21 Season Review - The Goalkeepers
Wednesday, 26th May 2021 10:01
We start the post mortem of Saints 2020/21 season with a look at the goalkeeping position, what were the good and bad points and what should Saints do next in a position where we have four on the books but none that have truly made the position their own.
We start the review with the forgotten man of the goalkeeping department, but who did make an appearance or two on the bench this season when Saints were so short of bodies they put two keepers on there.
Harry Lewis career seems to have stalled, four years ago he made three appearances in the FA Cup back in January 2017 and still aged only 19 he looked a potential prospect for the future.
The following season he went on loan to Dundee Utd in the Scottish Championship and played a big part as they reached the play offs , but they fell short at the final hurdle.
Since then he has just sat in the squad at St Mary's seemingly stagnating and it appears that he too is one who has been stuck on a well paid contract that has meant that he cannot afford financially to leave and has had to stick it out.
However he is out of contract this summer and highly unlikely to be offered an extension and at 23 will be able to seek a new club.
Good luck to Harry, he didn't let us down in the 3 FA Cup games he played for the club, he just hasn't been able to make the leap forward, I truly hope he finds a decent league club and has a successful career in football.
Next is another forgotten man Angus Gunn, when he arrived from Manchester City in the summer of 2018 for £10 million there was a real hope that we had found a talented player, the previous season he had played every game on loan at Norwich City and had been a real success, prompting Saints interest.
He started his first season as back up to Alex McCarthy and in the EFL he looked good against three Premier League teams and with McCarthy falling out of form he made his Premier League debut away to Chelsea on January 2nd 2019 in a 0-0 draw, McCarthy made a brief return but was still out of sorts Gunn then kept his place for the remainder of the season and looked the part.
But in 2019/20 he found himself playing behind a defence in disarray and after the 9-0 against Leicester he was dropped , he would play 3 more games in the FA Cup and looked ok but Ralph seemed to have lost faith in him.
This season he has been at Stoke where he has done well, but injury has limited his appearances, there seems to have been an agreement to loan him again to the Potters, but another rumour abounds that Norwich want him to return to Carrow Road on a permanent deal.
Still only 25 his problem at St Mary's has been he was thrown in to the deep end behind an erratic defence, I still think he could have a future in the game, perhaps a loan move to Norwich might enable him to get the experience he needs to play behind an erratic defence and pull it into shape.
Under contract until 2023 Saints may prefer to cut their losses and get him off the books for around £3-5 million.
So to the two keepers that have played in the first team this season.
Alex McCarthy has played the bulk of the games, but he has never truly been convincing, I think Alex's problem is that during a long career spanning 13 years and 10 clubs he has never truly made the number 1 position his own, the fact that in that time and now approaching 32 he has amassed just 245 League starts with around a quarter of those coming in this and last season tells a story of a keeper who is capable of some good displays, but lacks the concentration and application needed by a keeper to keep a high standard up week in week out
In the second half of the season he has not been good and would have played less than the 30 games he did manage but for Ralph Hasenhuttl's strange rotation policy, in the last three appearances of the season he has been poor, shipping 6 goals and on all of them he really should have done better, I think he only made a real attempt at 1 of them , not even throwing himself at the other 5, his reactions are shot, his decision making was shot and the rotation system did him no good at all.
His ratio of goals conceded per game was 1.9, an appalling , his save percentage of 61% of shots saved was the worst in the Premier League.
Fraser Forster looked to be just there to warm the bench, but with McCarthy far from convincing even when we were winning he came in for the game against Liverpool and although slightly shaky at first kept a clean sheet but seemed to bring a stability to the defence, they seemed to know what Forster would and wouldn't do in a situation, his shots saved percentage was 68% which was in line with most of the keepers in the Premier with 70% seemingly the benchmark.
So although he played only 8 Premier League games, Fraser Forster was clearly the better keeper and if he had played more games then we might have pulled off a few more results.
So what should Saints do, Ralph Hasenhuttl has said that both keepers are going to be here next season and vie for the number 1 spot, that does not completely fill me with confidence, although I would say Forster is proven and looks the better bet.
But I would also say that is what Ralph Hasenhuttl has to say now, you don't wipe out a goalkeepers confidence by saying you are going to get rid of them.
Both are out of contract next summer so the question is whether we deal with that problem now, Forster probably won't leave to take a cut in pay and go elsewhere permanently will cost him something like £2 million, he will see it out or perhaps have one last loan move.
Saints will probably be considering options, the first is getting rid of one of them permanently and from that point of view that means McCarthy, he will still have a small value and it would free up wages for a replacement.
There are rumours though Saints are looking to extend his contract, but surely that is going to be as the back up, I have no problem with that, it is the role he has performed all his career bar two seasons, only in 2009/10 on loan at Yeovil in League One and again in 2013/14 in the Championship for Reading has he ever held the position for a full season.
This tells you something.
Ideally we would be looking to bring in a first choice keeper now, then move on either Forster or McCarthy and leave one as back up.
This will depend on what we can do in the transfer market, there will be a lot of wheeler dealing going on and with little money flying around at all football clubs at present, Ralph may feel that his priorities lie in other positions when spending cash.
So the likelihood is that next season Fraser & Alex fight it out for the number one spot, this is not ideal because defenders like to know what the keeper behind them will do, good sides are based on solid stoppers who command their area and marshal their defence, we lack that ans chopping and changing does no good.
Photo: Action Images
Please report offensive, libellous or inappropriate posts by using the links provided.
You need to login in order to post your comments
Blogs 31 bloggers
Letters from Wiltshire #48 by wessex_exile
“And now the end is near, and so we face the final curtain…regrets, we’ve had a few, but then again, too few to mention”. Not quite right Paul Anka, probably more than a few, but otherwise a fair assessment of where the U’s are today. It’ll be interesting to see how we perform with the relegation monkey finally off their back – I’m not expecting miracles, particularly with Tranmere needing at least a point to guarantee making the play-offs, but they’ll certainly be more nervous than we will be, so can we make that count? This will be my last blog of the season, and not yet sure what I may or may not do for next season, but suggestions are always welcome.
Letters from Wiltshire #47 by wessex_exile
Here we are, at the penultimate game of the season, and our last game in front of the cardboard U’s faithful at the JobServe. It has been a long, difficult, and definitely strange season, which frankly I’ll be glad to see the back of. That’ll we’ll be here again in August is definitely going to be something to celebrate, but I suspect we’re facing a summer of significant rebuilding both on the pitch, and possibly off it too. I won’t be the only one, but the biggest oddity for me has been being able to watch every single game – not always easy viewing, but something I’ve never done before, and probably never will again. But it doesn’t really make up for not being there in person, the long train journey away-days, meeting fellow U’s and other supporters, and of course sharing a beer or three. Fingers-crossed we can return to the terraces in 2021/22.
Letters from Wiltshire #46 by wessex_exile
That was quite a week for us all then. In the space of four short but remarkably tense days we have gone from having to take shoes and socks off to check how many more points we need to guarantee survival, or whether we would even achieve it, to breathing a huge sigh of relief knowing we’re almost there. But close of play this afternoon, whether by our own actions or the failure of others, I am sure survival will be confirmed. Of course, Tuesday night not only all but guaranteed it, it also virtually condemned local rivals Southend United to non-league football for the foreseeable. Looking at the host of fully professional former football league sides currently battling it out for the two promotion slots out of the National league (including Hartlepool, Torquay, Stockport, Wrexham, Chesterfield and Notts County), it is not going to be a walk in the park for Southend to return any day soon.
Letters from Wiltshire #45 by wessex_exile
Tonight, Colchester United face Southend United in what may not necessarily be the most important game of our respective histories (though it’s certainly very close), but is almost certainly the most important Essex derby ever. However this season pans out, by the end of it there’ll either be only one team in Essex, or worst case scenario, none at all. If the U’s win, then Southend will be 9pts behind with just three games to go, and a minimum of a -12 goal difference to overturn if they want to overtake us. Certainly mathematically possible, but that would rely on a remarkable turnaround in their form, form that they’ve shown precious little sign of achieving so far this season. The stalking horse is Grimsby, with their game in hand, who have rather belatedly shown an improvement in form, so their match against automatic promotion chasing Morecambe tonight is equally important, particularly if we want to avoid the unthinkable, with both Essex clubs dropping out of the league.
Letters from Wiltshire #44 by wessex_exile
So here we are, as the nation mourns the passing of His Royal Highness, Duke of Edinburgh, the U’s face the first of two season-defining moments, with our late kick-off match at home to Walsall. Before then, no doubt many will have been focused on events elsewhere, not least the early kick-offs for Grimsby (at home to promotion-chasing Bolton Wanderers), and particularly Essex rivals Southend United, who faced a tricky visit to Exeter City – still very much in the hunt for at least a play-off spot. As I finalise this blog, I know that Grimsby have beaten Bolton 2-1, and Southend earned a credible 0-0 draw in the West Country. More to the point, the U’s will know this too. Whilst I can’t help but feel that will ought to be to our advantage, it surely must also put additional pressure on a squad whose confidence is paper-thin. We must hope that Hayden Mullins, assisted by Paul Tisdale, get their heads right, and send the lads out this evening fired up with self-belief.
[ Vote here ]