Please log in or register. Registered visitors get fewer ads.
Birmingham City 1 v 1 Southampton
EFL Championship
Tuesday, 1st September 2026 Kick-off 20:00
Southampton At Birmingham City The Verdict
Wednesday, 2nd Sep 2026 08:13

They say that the sign of a good team is that they can play badly and win, that wasn't quite the case here, but we came through a game riddled with individual errors and got a point, so not great but you can't win every game.

Saints stretched their unbeaten run to 3 games in the Championship and in doing so, although they only moved up to 17th place, their true position without the 4 points deduction would now be 3rd.

That being the case from a points total we have had a satisfactory start to the season, but this was not a good performance overall from Saints, the stats looked good, but didn't show the individual errors from our team that punctuated the game.

Biggest culprits were ironically the goal scorer Keven Schlotterbeck who got away with a couple that should have seen a goal scored.

He perhaps had an excuse in that this was only his 2nd game in what has been a hectic 5 day period that has seen him leave Augsburg and move to England, but Daniel Peretz had no such leeway, he came and flapped at a couple of crosses and his kicking was appalling, twice he sent a clearance straight to an opponent and also skewed a couple out for throw ins.

At the moment he is going through a bad patch, hopefully he will play his way through it and like this game will not see an error lead to a goal.

If not then Tonda Eckert has a difficult decision to make.

It was a scrappy end to end game, that saw chances squandered at both ends, Saints could easily have been a goal, even two down by the time that Keven Schlotterbeck headed home in first half injury time to give Saints the lead.

But if we thought that would settle the game and see us take command, then we were wrong, after the break the home side came at us like a train and within 10 minutes were back on level terms, it's hard to point a finger at an individual, but in simple terms we went to sleep at the back and gave the scorer a free header.

There is a lot for Tonda to ponder from this game, he will be pleased that his team got down in the mud and scrapped when they had to, but as mentioned he will not be happy with the individual performances.

For long periods we couldn't seem to keep the ball, we struggled to get it down and play and we struggled to pass it, Cyle Larin never really got going and the few chances he had he squandered.

Likewise Leo Scienza was awful and I was surprised that he stayed on the pitch and Tom Fellows was taken off.

In the midfield we rarely got going and it was only when James Ward Prowse came into the fray on the hour mark that we started to get on top in that department.

We struggled to cope with Birmingham's high tempo game pressing game and it showed.

But negatives out of the way, as I said at the start, we still got a point and we move forward.

However on the evidence of this game we are going to miss Taylor Harwood-Bellis big time, the central defensive pairing did not click in this game and I think our failure to land an experienced central defender in this window could cost us dearly.

Jo Tessem in his post match comments said as much, he said that promotion in the Championship is won by a core of experienced players with the youngsters coming in when necessary.

This is not going to be the case, if Nathan Wood & Keven Schlotterbeck don't form a solid partnership then what do we have to replace them, Jack Stephens & new signing Zach Abbott a 20 year old with 3 League games for Nottingham Forest to his name.

Perhaps he will be another Tino Livramento or Romeo Lavia, but if that is the case then why did Forest let him go?

But we march on, as I said without that 4 point deduction we would be 3rd and hovering behind the top two, that shows that we have had a good start to the season, but we do have that four point deduction and we have to overcome it.

However there was a good ending to the evening, the news that Portsmouth had lost at home to Derby and that even after giving them a four point start, we are now above them albeit on goal difference.

All Photos Via Reuters



Please report offensive, libellous or inappropriate posts by using the links provided.



A1079 added 09:31 - Sep 2
A fair assessment.

Overall a draw was probably about right as both sides had their chances that they didn't take and both sides had moments where they were making errors. Peretz had a poor game and has not looked assured thus far this season. Whether that is due to having an indifferent defence in front of him I am not sure, but he is not dealing with crosses well and as you say, his kicking was woeful last night. In midfield we look flaky and Scienza was out of sorts. All that said, we had chances and Larin could have had more but equally Birmingham should have been ahead a couple of times.

I wouldn't say it was a poor performance but rather an indifferent one and so far this season we have looked inconsistent. But a draw is not a disgrace and as you say it is 3 games unbeaten. I do worry that in the window we went for cheap options rather than quality options in defence and that could cost us dearly. That said I am often proved wrong and happy to be proved wrong again. Also, apart from Larin last night I could not see anyone else scoring.

I suppose, overall, if this was a school report, you might say: not bad but must do better.
1

davidargyll added 09:44 - Sep 2
I have said it before that good managers are lucky ones and TE seems loaded with it. Because arguably the success we have enjoyed in most of our games so far have depended on large slices of it, last night more than the others, so here’s hoping it continues. Because let’s be honest we could have been three down before HT if Brum had been on their game, but Lady Luck was with us and a point won was a real bonus whereas it was definitely two points lost for them.

You make a point about not being able to handle their press. But I would disagree, yes it wasn't pretty at times and we did make a mess of it on a couple of occasions but I didn't see much panicking as per the Russell Martin era, and no doubt about it, when we broke, which we did on several occasions, we did catch them napping, albeit our finished product was lacking. I see this improving with each game as the new arrivals start to gel.

And talking of new arrivals, to me the real surprise was JWP, cool, calm, nearly scored, looked as if he had hardly been away; I think he just might turn out to be the bargain of the year.
9

SalisburySaint added 10:19 - Sep 2
Failure to get an experienced central defender ?

We bought a 29 year old with 152 Bundesliga games behind him, what do you expect ?
7

saintoaks added 10:22 - Sep 2
Birminghams goal came from the another cross into the box which we dont defend, Also, massive gaps between our holding two and Azaz. Hopefully Jander will be fit soon. On the plus side Matsuki was very good again. I do think we are a couple of players short. Realistically we only have two strikers, both with totally different styles. If either gets injured will he bring Downs back into the equation or use the young lads or even Dobbin ?
3

ElSanto added 10:29 - Sep 2
I really worry about not getting a striker. Thought Mubama has looked very toothless and on top of that can't even hold up the ball.

And we must not play lightweight players. Azaz is phenomenal and is worthy of carrying in this team as a luxury player who can create chances and score. However, Bragg and Fellows are just so soft. Bragg can pass, there's no doubt about it, but he needs to be more aggressive mentally and physically when protecting and tackling. It's a mentality shift that JWP was able to develop. As for Fellows, he is just so shy and lacks confidence. If he had a different mentality he could be one of our best players, but I worry he can't be that player we know he could be.

Good point in the end from a mediocre performance.
4

halftimeorange added 10:55 - Sep 2
This was an awful performance in my opinion. Larin barely won a header all game and the ball never stuck when he received it. Mubama looked cocky as though he was better than all those around him, and is no replacement for Stewart. As has been stated above, both Peretz and Scienza had, possibly, their worst games for Saints.Birmingham attacked us in a similar style to Watford. We couldn't cope then and with Schlotterbeck mimicking Stephens in respect of schoolboy errors, we didn't cope last night. I'm not going to blame Wood who, along with Matsuki, Azaz and Downes, was one of our better performers. From what I've seen so far this season, Tonda has his work cut out, in whatever time he has left in the event the Sword of Damocles descends, to tidy our performances up and make us more robust as he did last season. I wish him luck. Saints support was, as ever, outstanding last night.
2

Staycalm added 10:56 - Sep 2
Lots of misses by both teams, so 1-1 was a fair result. As an observation I thought that both our wingers were poor. Fellows was mainly back to his 'pass it back at the first opportunity' worst! Numerous times we had made progress forward only for him to turn an put it back into our own half!! Frustrating to watch.

Controversial maybe but you can see why Premier League teams have not been beating the door down to sign Scienza. He has occasional moments of magic but other times merely runs down blind alleys, or straight into defenders, then immediately thinks he is due a free kick, so drops to the ground. Alternatively, he passes into nowhere or straight to an opponent!! Harsh maybe, as he can be magic at times but more often than not, he isn't! A strange contrast between the two, with Scienza possibly trying too hard at times and Fellows just desperate not to lose the ball!
1

onetowatch added 11:37 - Sep 2
several names highlighted after last night for particular criticism, and I wouldn't disagree with any of it, but I'm amazed that Manning wasn't mentioned. In the defensive side of his game, he is quicky becoming a liability, missing on so many occasions. I would really like t see Wellington given a run again - he did extremely well last season prior to getting injured.
3

Saidou added 13:59 - Sep 2
Good Analysis 👍🏼
0

Waylander added 15:37 - Sep 2
Decent result considering we could have been 0-2 down by 20 minutes in. A lot of teams will drop points at Birmingham this season.
2

highfield49 added 15:41 - Sep 2
Lot's of valid criticism but in respect of their goal the cross appeared to be undefendable. Credit to the scorer who got between the defenders and timed his movement perfectly?
Before pressing doom and gloom buttons let's not forget how we started last season. In my view that was worse than the four point deduction.
Also, in respect of the forward line, Stewart wasn't available until late in the campaign and there is the opportunity to bolster the the attack in January if required.
I agree with davidargyll that JWP looks like an absolute bargain, despite my initial misgivings.
Whilst we are not firing on all cylinders there is a long, long slog until the end of the season and no alarm bells need ringing just yet. That said I'm hoping Peretz isn't, understandably, distracted by Ramsdale's presence in the squad.

2

bartley41 added 16:47 - Sep 2
We sold two players, Charles and THB at about 25 Million each, a total of 50 Million, yet we were after an experienced Norwegian centre back and offered 9 million Euros 10 Million Pounds but failed to offer more, WHY?
Although Viking Stavanger were reluctant to sell with Champions League games likely to come, why did we not offer say 12 Million Pounds to clinch the deal?
Also knowing sone time ago that THB was likely to leave, why did we not react earlier to seek a replacement?
2

StAnt added 17:09 - Sep 2
I've read on several occasions that Brum could have been 3-0 up at half time but so could we. We scored one, Larin should have had another and Bragg was unlucky to see a goal bound shot deflected wide. It's swings and roundabouts at the end of the day.
0

YosemiteSaint added 17:57 - Sep 2
They pressed high and jammed the midfield, which amplified Transfer Deadline Day jitters (as I think they were more settled than we were—and of course had the benefit of playing at home). This one could have gone either way, and ended about right. I sometimes wonder, though, if games ought be played on deadline day, as there's just too much going on and squads need time to adjust. I'dve settled for a draw from the out; we'll get max points at Lincoln.
0

Colburn added 20:14 - Sep 2
Personally I thought Ward Prowse gave us less than Romeo, can’t believe he took the free kick when it was the perfect spot for Manning and JWP never scores from that side of the box.. ridiculous decision. We were pretty poor all game, first touch looked awful too often and some players wanted too much time on the ball and Leo narrowed our shape too much. Matsuki looked good when he came on and looked sharp but in the main, we lacked the aggression and speed of transition too often. The amount of times Birmingham won the first ball and then the second ball was incredibly frustrating. So a point was probably a great result away from home with a poor performance.
2

bryanK added 20:17 - Sep 2
I thought Saints were disjointed and it is clear our manager is a lucky boy. Which is no bad thing.
My worry is like many the owners seek players on the cheap and appear to be reluctant to pay strong money when necessary and this works sometimes but as we all know the failures outnumber the successes if you pay poor money.
It is a well known that you play your strongest team so ignoring Ramsdale because you made a commitment to another goalkeeper who is currently out of form is total nonsense.
TE you have a 25 million goalkeeper in the wings so get real.
1

Kingsland34 added 21:06 - Sep 2
Watching some of the other Championship clubs this week makes both Tuesday's match and our performance look pretty good in comparison. Cause for confidence but we must not slip into complacency, which we sometimes do.
1

SaintDJ added 08:40 - Sep 3
Yet again the goal came from Mannings side. Take away his free kicks what you got? JWP in the side now solves that so start Wellington.
1


You need to login in order to post your comments

Blogs 31 bloggers

Southampton Polls

About Us Contact Us Terms & Conditions Privacy Cookies Online Safety Advertising
© FansNetwork 2026