x

Exceeding Good Pies - Girly Footballers XI

EGP is back with a look back at some of the girliest footballers to have played for Dale over the years.

 

It was said many years ago by Vinny Jones that whilst Gary Lineker may well have been a better player than he was, if it came down to who you'd want stood next to you in the trenches, you'd take Jones every time over Lineker. Of course, if you wanted someone to come on for that England v Germany Paul McCartney thingy, then Leicester's favourite goal hanger would have been an ideal late introduction.

Anyways, with this mind, pre-match pub discussion over the weekend turned to some of our former players who perhaps would be deemed more Lineker than Jones. And not because they came close to equalling Bobby Charlton's England record, or spent three years with a poorly toe in Japan.

We're talking the sort of players who perhaps didn't like it when it started raining, or perhaps weren't ones to get stuck it when it mattered. The ones who could be scared into submission after getting a bit of mud on their socks in the opening five minutes of a game. The ones who "didn't like it up them". Not without an allegedly anyway.

These are what we have christened the girly Dale players.

1) Kevin Pilkington

When collating this list the initial thoughts were that we had three problem positions. The two centre backs and the keeper. Then someone mentioned this loaned in clown. He wasn’t girlie I hear you all cry. I disagree he has let more balls go between his legs than any woman I have ever met. Just for that reason he makes the eleven

2) Andy Thackeray
Now it would be fair to say that poor Andy's time at Dale has been harshly judged. He wasn't the worst right back we've ever had, and if you look at some of the dross that we've had in that position over the years, we were probably lucky to have him. But there was still something undeniably girly about him. He came across as quite an intelligent chap. Nothing wrong with that, but in footballing terms, it's a complete no go. Look at Le Saux. Quite a nasty and malicious footballer at times, but he admits that he reads a newspaper which doesn't feature women's breasts and it's assumed by one and all that he lives on Canal Street. Forget that, anyway Thackeray's in there for different reasons. He's in here for being the teacher's pet. He was Sutty's model footballer and the one always being held up as an example. No one likes a swot, so therefore he's got girly written all over him. Besides, we featured him in EGP wearing lingerie years before photoshop was invented. Our Andy was a centrefold back in October 1994.
3) Alan Goodall

Right here we go. Proof that girly doesn't mean that we're talking about bad players. Goodall was a fine left back who served us well. But you know what you got with him. The sleeves were religiously rolled down. The socks were at their regulation height and you can bet that he had the best sock ties in the entire club. He was squeaky clean. He never once had to wash his kit in all the time he was at Spotland. He never argued with anyone, would never give away a cynical yellow card. Without doubt, a 21st century version of Thackeray.

4) Simon Gibson

Back in the 1980's, centre halves were centre halves. Back then, every player in this position looked like either John Bramhall or Joe Cooke, and defenders described as being two footed were those who could kick you with both feet. Twice. But looking back, one particular defender didn't fit the mould. Simon Gibson was a bit part player who would no doubt have played more had he not been such a girl. Dyed hair? Check. Hair gelled to the side? Check. Suspenders under his Dale shorts? Most probably. The picture to your right is the only picture which exists of Gibson as he refused all other pictures unless he'd checked his make up and had his eye brows plucked. A great bit girl.

5) Adam Reed
In this day and age, players like Reed are probably the more common type of defender. The days of your Alan Johnson's seem a long time ago. But Reed no doubt saw himself as having more to his game. He even went around the pitch having the most ridiculous mullet this side of the Aussie Outback. But he would be definitely more Sheila than a Bruce if ever he was to venture Down Under.
6) Jason Peake

Our talented Jason was a maestro on the field. When on form he had the vision of a player who really should have made more of his career. Girlie? Definitely! Anyone with blonde flowing locks such as his definitely makes this eleven on that alone. He didn’t exude much machismo on the field in comparison to your Shaun Reid’s of the world. If there was a fifty fifty ball you could have pretty much guaranteed Peake wasn’t the Dale player challenging. He’d be on the half way line preening himself.

7) Sean McClare

This bloke personifies everything about a girlie player. Couldn’t tackle to save his life, ponced about midfield like Lilly Savage in a football kit and to top it all off had white boots to match. Even Gary Jones came round to our way of thinking on McClare’s last appearance for Dale when he openly laughed out loud at Shauny performing the worst backheel in the world, where the ball got stuck on one of his stiletto heels and went straight out of play. Never have I seen a player so obviously scared of the ball that he would mince away from it. And was genuinely seen wearing nail varnish on one Player of the Season evening.

8) Ian Bishop

Right we know what you're thinking on this one. But we've never been one to survive on bits of gossip regarding players. Well we have actually, but that's a different story. But Bishop's in there for so many other reasons. But above anything, you can't look beyond the hair. Here he is - a player approaching the latter stages of his 30's and he still sees himself as being some sort of glamour model. You can guarantee that he spends more time looking in the mirror than he did on the training ground. Oh if only someone could have come up behind him and point out the error of his ways.

9) Paul Connor

Connor's inclusion is for so many reasons. Far too much of a pretty boy for a start to play for Dale. And in true girly style, at the beginning everything was fantastic, but as time passed by, the true self started to reveal itself, and those good old times seemed just a distant memory. But it was the way he carried himself around the pitch. Always dropping to the floor, always complaining, and that look that he used to give out suggested that one game soon he would scream out "It's not fair" if he damaged a nail. I swear he was only ever five minutes from crying. Referees suffered plenty of nag pie when Connor was on the pitch. And let's not forget the way he was always ruled out once a month. What more proof is required? Girl girl girl girl girl.

10) Blair Sturrock

When looking for reasons for putting people in this girlie eleven, Sturrock has one of the best reasons of all. He scored a goal with his tits, I hear you cry. True but not the reason why in my mind he is making this particular role call! And contrary to popular opinion it is not due to the reason that many fans named him Lionel, after the tap dancing charade playing bell end. No because Sturrock had the unerring ability to make a shot so powder puff that you thought that he was wearing those comedy slippers that your ‘crazy’ relative bought you last Christmas, that look like jesters shoes. After a Sturrock shot you were confident that only way the ball would hit the back of the net was if the keeper died of old age waiting for the ball to arrive or was doubled over laughing.

11) Andy Milner (captain)

We had to put a ginger in, we don’t want the PC brigade on our backs do we. Milner was a good player firstly. But unfortunately Milner was an 8 or 9 on the girlie-ometer. Many times you saw the ginger winger pass one player and then slip and fall, like a teenager tart pissed up on bitch piss on the way to a prom. So much so that now many years later even now in the Sandy Lane you can often hear somebody say ‘He’s got Milner’s boots on’ when a current player slips and falls for no reason. Without doubt, Milner would be captain of this side. Which other Dale player was universally recognised as being called Mandy?

managed by Paul Simpson
All the female traits were with this one. Always someone else's fault and a desire to have his own way. "I'll take this corner", "I'm having this free kick", "I think you'll find I'm in charge so I'll take the penalty". If he was ever not involved for more than two minutes, he felt like he was being ignored and would sulk until he got his own way again. He would decide.

What to read next:

Swansea City : What needs to happen now ?
The Indy’s lead football writer, Andrew Winfield goes in deep on this weeks issues and the real problems in store for the Swans.
Swansea City : The facts on players in and out and the strategy behind it
This week has seen some bad financial news for the Swans, and of course more questions than answers yet again. That aside there is some great news from the age grade side at U21 as once again we see a player knocking on the door of the first team squad.
Swansea City : Has Andrew Coleman been in the shower for three months with Bobby Ewing ?
The changing timeline of when Andrew Coleman became Chairmen of Swansea City caused a stir yesterday, our twitter account getting well over eleven thousand views and increasing, which sent website views here in to their many thousands as well.
Swans supporters consult Kieran Maguire and when did Andy start as Chairman ?
News of Swansea City’s financial position hit home yesterday as the club announced further losses. The profit and sustainability rules are forever hanging over a club, and in Swansea City’s case like everyone else it’s a rolling three year issue.
Gwyn’s Eye View : Swansea City v Millwall
Glyn is back with his favourite stats as we build up to the last game of the season. That comes in the form of Millwall who it seems are close to selling their requested 1,148 allocation, so its down to the Jack Army to do their bit this bank holiday weekend.
The fate today’s Swansea footballers would never have to endure
Swansea City bring this season to a close on Saturday with a home game against Millwall. However, what about those bygone days when footballers had no choice but to go down the pit after their career ended, or open a toy shop, pub or retrain ? That thought would petrify todays modern footballer.
Jamal Lowe : Still to be contacted regards his future at Swansea, Langstaff update
We have been told by numerous Swansea fans of a chance meeting in a service station between Jamal Lowe and those returning from Norwich yesterday. Nothing in that or indeed the conversation they had yesterday. Indeed there has to be some interpretation from what we know already on Jamal Lowe.
Brave Swans in memorable game at Carrow Road
It was a pulsating game to watch and very much one of my favourite away games of the season. The Swans looked an entirely different side to that we saw at Middlesbrough when it is clear a catalyst for commitment was agreed behind the scenes at Swansea City. To a man every player grafted and wore the shirt with pride. To see the players really acknowledge the Swans support at Carrow Road this afternoon was emotional.
Norwich City 2 - 2 Swansea City - Player Ratings and Reports
If you saw the match, please give us your player ratings and a mini match report.
TEAM NEWS : Norwich City v Swansea City
The Swans are on the Norfolk Broads, punting and boating their way to the end of the season. Hopefully the city of Norwich is obliging.