x

Andy Fisher v Freddie Woodman : The battle of the old and new

Tomorrow nights game at the Swansea.Com Stadium see’s two goalkeepers on either side on familiar ground. Freddie Woodman who played eighty eight matches for the Swans against the current incumbent for Swansea Andy Fisher. This season Fisher has met with some criticism, and Freddie has at last found a permanent home at Deepdale for a small fee in June 2022.

Freddie ( below ) has forty two games under his belt for the Lillywhites, plus three in the league and FA Cup. He set a club record of seven consecutive clean sheets at the start of the season, as it stands Andy Fisher is on three going in to this game.

Freddie’s stats though are impressive for this campaign.

His team are looking at the play offs and will see their game at Swansea City as very winnable.

Andy Fisher’s ( below ) stats show just how much of a fine margin there is in goalkeeping ratings.

As a Goalkeeper, Andy Fisher ( above ) has conceded twenty six goals and kept five clean sheets in twenty two matches in the Championship 2022/2023 season. That means when Fisher is in goal, his team conceded a goal every 74 minutes. Andy Fisher's per ninety minutes goals conceded stat is 1.22. In terms of raw goalkeeping, he's saved 46 of the 76 shots faced - meaning Andy Fisher's save percentage is 60.53%.

Freddie Woodman has played more games and has a better rating.

As a Goalkeeper, Freddie Woodman has conceded 44 goals and kept 17 clean sheets in 42 matches in the Championship 2022/2023 season. That means when Woodman is in goal, his team conceded a goal every 86 minutes. Freddie Woodman's per 90 minutes goals conceded stat is 1.05. In terms of raw goalkeeping, he's saved 108 of the 155 shots faced - meaning Freddie Woodman's save percentage is 69.68%.

Without stats we have a narrative which is very clear. Freddie has had a full season of goalkeeping for Preston, Andy Fisher only came in for Steven Benda in January when he was injured against Queens Park Rangers. Fisher is a number two for his club who has been forced in to the spotlight by injury. Freddie Woodman has stayed injury free and is a number one choice goalkeeper for his club. Andy Fisher up until the home game against Coventry City on Good Friday has had a pretty traumatic time with numerous errors leading to goals and a loss of points for the Swans. Freddie Woodman plays for a team who are one point from a play off place with a poor goal difference. The Lillywhites also concede goals. However narrative wise Freddie seems to have gotten away with blame. At Newcastle United he was hung out to dry at times and his goalkeeping was error strewn. He had numerous ‘pundits’ criticise him and his then manager Eddie Howe also stated he didn’t know if he was good enough.

Put aside the errors this season for Fisher and he has a very similar record to the one he had in League one for MK Dons. He is showing an improvement at a higher level, albeit that will be as a part of this very good recent Swansea run.

Freddie Woodman sits third in the table of best goalkeepers in the championship with seventeen clean sheets that’s a very good return indeed. Especially for a club who concede more goals at home than they score. That really confirms the fact that much of the goals conceded for Preston are not just down to Freddie Woodman.

As we said goalkeeping has so many fine margins, not least the bravery of a goalkeeper to make not only physical choices in the tackle but mentally as well to adapt to games as the opposition change formation and strategy. One mistake as a keeper and your dust, let the ball roll under your foot as an outfield player and you have a deep groan and a few shouts to deal with. That’s the difference and that’s the mental affect of being between the sticks.

Swansea City v a Preston North End kicks off at 7.45pm tomorrow night at Swansea.Com Stadium. Tickets are still available. It is available as well Sky Sports Red button 🔴

What to read next:

Swansea City : Top striker target in the Swans sights, the full lowdown
There’s a lot more to Notts County’s prolific goalscorer than meets the eye. Not least his excellent injury record and the fact at twenty seven he is now in his prime as a professional footballer.
Swansea City : Nathan Wood knows he is available for transfer
Swansea City centre back Nathan Wood is aware that the Swans will listen to offers for his transfer away from the club this summer. His contract was extended recently with the Swans triggering a one year option on the player.
Joe Allen to stay at Swansea as retained list is imminent. Ogbeta to leave ?
It seems Joe Allen’s immediate future will continue to be at Swansea City as an agreement in principle has been reached between the two parties.
Swansea City : The real value will be the players who stay at the club
With the Swans retained list about to be named, generally around the 18th of the month, we take a look at those who stay, and their value to the club. The players who have the determination to turn next season in to more than a passing parade and a dismal home loss record.
Swansea City : The confusing decision making for a whole season
It was a pretty poor end to what can only be described as a disappointing football season for Swansea City. The defeat to Millwall yesterday was a display that has frustrated Swansea City supporters all season. A lack of effort, intensity and desire rewarding the home support with yet another home loss.
Swansea City 0 - 1 Millwall - Player Ratings and Reports
If you saw the match, please give us your player ratings and a mini match report.
Swansea City : Grimes misses a penalty in a return to bad old ways
An error strewn and tepid Swansea display ensured thousands left the stadium before the staff and players did their usual walk around at this end of season game. It wasn’t a good look as two players received red cards and any effort by the home side was lost in a static and frustrating display.
Swansea City : Last game of the season, latest injury news and the full low down on the big game
Today brings the Championship season to a close for the majority of the clubs involved, and the Swans face Millwall at 12.30pm today at the Swansea.com stadium. Just over 1,100 visiting supporters have made the journey in what we hope is a celebration of the end of the season for both clubs.
Swansea City : What needs to happen now ?
The Indy’s lead football writer, Andrew Winfield goes in deep on this weeks issues and the real problems in store for the Swans.
Swansea City : The facts on players in and out and the strategy behind it
This week has seen some bad financial news for the Swans, and of course more questions than answers yet again. That aside there is some great news from the age grade side at U21 as once again we see a player knocking on the door of the first team squad.