x

If Southampton Appoint Eckert Backroom Recruitment Will Be Essential

After the win at Charlton Athletic on Saturday, Tonda Eckert taking the Saints manager's job on a full time basis suddenly looked a viable option, however after the departure of Paul Trollope, the coaching staff looks rather thin on the ground and will need revamping.

This weekend saw two key events in what will lead up to the appointment of will Still's successor on a permanent basis.

The first was not the win at Charlton, but the news on Friday that Assistant manager Paul Trollope had left the club to join Rob Edwards at Wolverhampton Wanderers, the two had worked together before at Luton Town.

But this was not the only changes in the Saints backroom staff, Adam Lallana will move into the U21 managers seat on an interim basis, that leaves Eckert with Jeremy Newton, Ben Reeves, Ryan Flood and analyst Albert Jones to assist him.

Those that point to a lack of experience of Eckert himself as a coach at this level as a stumbling block to his appointment will point to this as another reason why he should not be appointed.

Jeremy Newton is a name that few will know, he has worked under Eckert in the U21's as Player Transition Coach, whatever that means, the 47 year old has worked his way up the ranks at St Mary's from U16 coach over the past few years, he seems to have worked at Swindon Town as academy manager for a number of years and also a player for Aylesbury United in non league football, Albert Jones has also worked with Eckert as his analyst at U21 level. level.

Ben Reeves will be remembered by older Saints supporters, he made a few appearances for the club in 2011-12, including a sub appearance at Everton in the Premier League, being a left back his career at St Mary's was effectively ended in that Luke Shaw was breathing down his neck and was a first team regular early in the 2012/13 season.

He has had a long career in the lower leagues and retired from playing at the end of 2023/24 season at Eastleigh to join the Southampton coaching set up, again he has limited coaching experience, just a year in the U21 set up.

Ryan Flood was the U21 goalkeeping coach and he has a bit more experience, he has been at St Mary's for a while and was loaned out to Dundee United 3 years ago to gain him more experience at professional level.

So overall this week we have seen the only two coaches who have real playing experience leave the first team bench and replaced by those with limited playing and coaching experience.

These are all being cited as interim appointments, so there is no need to press the panic button just yet.

However most would feel that it would be folly to let Tonda Eckert have the job without at least one experienced man beside him, certainly this was the club's view back in the summer when Will Still was appointed, Paul Trollope was brought in alongside Adam Lallana.

But it appears that for one reason or another Still did not gel with his two senior coaches, he did not seem to seek their opinions or use them as a sounding board during games, he was a lone figure and it has to be said, this must have been a big factor in our loss of form and a lack of ideas from the manager.

Did Still see these two as men who wanted the job themselves and therefore kept them at arms length, again a lack of confidence in Still to back himself.

The same mistake must not be made, we need to appoint someone with experience to work with Tonda Eckert. perhaps even two men, but they need to be chosen carefully.

The problem though is that Eckert I would imagine does not know too many people at this level, like Still he would have to accept someone the club has chosen, rather than one of his own men.

Most football clubs when they appoint a manager allow him to bring in those he has worked with in the past, they recognise that his previous success would have been a team effort from the coaching staff and not just one man.

It could be said that Eckert's success has been achieved with his own men, those that he has worked with in the U21 set up, that does have some milage, but the fact is that none of them have any experience above academy level.

So who could Saints appoint as Eckert's assistant, it would need to be someone who has no ambition's to be a manager himself and is happy to be assistant, but how do you know whether he is on the same wavelength as Eckert both in football philosophy and more importantly on a personal level.

Nothing at Southampton Football Club is ever a simple decision !

What to read next:

Swans v U’s : Latest news, injuries, facts and Vitor on solidarity
This evening we look to on the pitch matters leading up to tomorrow afternoons big game against Oxford United (3pm) at the swansea.com. Vitor Matos has already stated that he has a full squad to choose from, and all that comes with our match day morning focus tomorrow plus team news.
Swansea City : Is there any good news ahead ? One last effort with the Home Office
Swans head coach, Vitor Matos had an interesting pre match gathering this week and possibly put paid to Malick Yalcouyé’s immediate involvement this weekend. Of course that would depend on how you view the words of the Portuguese who is already seeing more and more about his task ahead.
Swans fans fears could become reality this December
The month of December comes around with a few extra fixtures and the end of those six fixtures is a catalyst for some teams. The Swans have issues on the pitch and some are stating off it as well.
Swansea City : Jack Butty sails again with his cannons primed
The vultures were circling overhead. The bleached bones of the dead lay all around. Wait…a movement…a moving hand. A hen peckered face turns to the light and screams out, ‘Jack Butty here. I’m back with my latest missive from the defiles of dreadful duplicity.’ The cheers of voices were raised. Jack Butty looked around, ‘You lot can pipe down. You’re all gonners and gooners.’ And so, it came to pass…
New coaches in at the Swans ? Work permits examined & current issues
The Swansea City coaching mystery took another weird step yesterday when we received some information on Tozé Mendes, the new assistant manager to Vitor Matos. Well, in certain quarters he is Vitor’s assistant.
Why is Vitor still on his own ? Defensive insights in Swans collapse at West Brom
It all was going so nicely, well for fifteen minutes of the game yesterday at The Hawthorns. The script unfolded as soon as West Bromwich Albion got ahold of the game. A game which ended just the way most expected.
Swans collapse in a disastrous seventy five minutes of football
A brilliant start from Swansea City this afternoon dived into another order from the menu of disastrous football. Starters of no idea after fifteen minutes, with a main course of incompetence and a big desert of stupidity. They are now equal third bottom with Portsmouth who the Swans play at home on Tuesday 9th December (7:45pm) after a home game next Saturday against Oxford United (3pm)
West Bromwich Albion 3 - 2 Swansea City - Player Ratings and Reports
If you saw the match, please give us your player ratings and a mini match report.
West Bromwich Albion v Swansea City : Match Build Up & Team News
The Swans are at the Hawthorns this afternoon for their Championship fixture against West Bromwich Albion. We will carry some team news later and then will have the official announcement after that.
Big game weekend : Players, Focus, Mason v Matos & a reality check
Swansea City travel to the midlands today with one focus, do not lose the game and begin to rebuild the fans confidence in the team. By all accounts Vitor Matos has identified two glaring errors in the Swans training processes prior to his arrival, the more astute will have picked them up in this weeks public conversations.