Please log in or register
Forum index | Previous Thread | Next thread
Retain / Sell / Loan Out 15:02 - May 19 with 1207 viewsWandererJack

Fabianski - Retain
Nordfeldt - Retain

Bartley - Sell
Amat - Sell
van der Hoorn - Retain
Mawson - Retain
Olsson - Retain
Rangel - Retain
Naughton - Retain
Fernandez - Retain
Kingsley - Loan Out

Ki - Sell
Britton - Retain
Fer - Retain
Dyer - Sell
Routledge - Retain
Montero - Sell
Sigurdsson - Retain
Cork - Retain
Narsingh - Retain
Carroll - Retain
Fulton - Loan Out
Barrow - Sell
Emnes - Sell

Ayew - Retain
Llorente - Retain
Baston - Sell
McBurnie - Loan Out

So that means, if I were PC I would want;

1x CB
1x LB (happy with SK as back up but a loan would be good for his development)
2x CM (1 creative and a younger Leon)
1x LW
1x CF

6 players, 2/3 of which would need to be first team quality.
[Post edited 19 May 15:03]
0

Retain / Sell / Loan Out on 15:09 - May 19 with 1188 viewsherefordjack

Couldn't argue with any of that.

Even if Llorente stays, I think our priority is to sign an effective striker who can bag 15 goals a season in the Premier League, and a decent, versatile, box to box midfielder like Pratley used to be.
1

Retain / Sell / Loan Out on 15:22 - May 19 with 1138 viewsyogibear_412

Fabianski - Retain - AGREE
Nordfeldt - Retain - AGREE

Bartley - Sell - DISAGREE
Amat - Sell - AGREE
van der Hoorn - Retain - DISAGREE
Mawson - Retain - AGREE
Olsson - Retain - AGREE
Rangel - Retain - AGREE
Naughton - Retain - AGREE
Fernandez - Retain - AGREE
Kingsley - Loan Out - AGREE

Ki - Sell - DISAGREE
Britton - Retain - AGREE
Fer - Retain - AGREE
Dyer - Sell - AGREE
Routledge - Retain - DISAGREE
Montero - Sell - AGREE
Sigurdsson - Retain - AGREE
Cork - Retain - AGREE
Narsingh - Retain - AGREE
Carroll - Retain - AGREE
Fulton - Loan Out - AGREE
Barrow - Sell - AGREE
Emnes - Sell - AGREE

Ayew - Retain - AGREE
Llorente - Retain - AGREE
Baston - Sell - AGREE
McBurnie - Loan Out - AGREE

VDH is gash - I struggle to see what he can do well. Ki - confidence player, under PC he will be important as Monk's first season. Routledge - best days are done for me.
0

Retain / Sell / Loan Out on 15:24 - May 19 with 1124 viewsTummer_from_Texas

OP - also back are Gomis, Tabanou, and Grimes.

Planet Swans 2015 Poster of the Year
Poll: Arias, Bony, Chadli, Clucas: how many are Swans on September 1?

0

Retain / Sell / Loan Out on 15:32 - May 19 with 1098 viewsEasternJack

We should have one of these threads for the posters on here...

Poll: Hull vs Middlesborough - What do we want?

0
Retain / Sell / Loan Out on 15:39 - May 19 with 1064 viewsDarran

Retain / Sell / Loan Out on 15:32 - May 19 by EasternJack

We should have one of these threads for the posters on here...


I'm not being an awkward twát here but what is the Nordfeldt - Retain decision based on?

The first ever recipient of a Planet Swans Lifetime Achievement Award.
Poll: Who do you prefer as a poster Bluey or Ebo?

0

Retain / Sell / Loan Out on 16:46 - May 19 with 939 viewsMartyrman57

Given our step up at u23 level next season then Kingsley, Fulton, Grimes (if sill here) and McBurnie can develop in house rather than loan options.
0
Retain / Sell / Loan Out on 16:52 - May 19 with 917 viewsWandererJack

Retain / Sell / Loan Out on 15:39 - May 19 by Darran

I'm not being an awkward twát here but what is the Nordfeldt - Retain decision based on?


Seen him play 2 or 3 games and he's been fine. What is the reason for selling him?
[Post edited 19 May 16:53]
0
Retain / Sell / Loan Out on 16:54 - May 19 with 912 viewsWandererJack

Retain / Sell / Loan Out on 16:46 - May 19 by Martyrman57

Given our step up at u23 level next season then Kingsley, Fulton, Grimes (if sill here) and McBurnie can develop in house rather than loan options.


Perhaps, it's the whole youth system vs lower leagues argument I guess.
0
Retain / Sell / Loan Out on 16:54 - May 19 with 909 viewsWandererJack

Retain / Sell / Loan Out on 15:24 - May 19 by Tummer_from_Texas

OP - also back are Gomis, Tabanou, and Grimes.


Oh yeah.. I'd sell all three.
0
Retain / Sell / Loan Out on 17:07 - May 19 with 879 viewsDarran

Retain / Sell / Loan Out on 16:52 - May 19 by WandererJack

Seen him play 2 or 3 games and he's been fine. What is the reason for selling him?
[Post edited 19 May 16:53]


Ok.

The first ever recipient of a Planet Swans Lifetime Achievement Award.
Poll: Who do you prefer as a poster Bluey or Ebo?

0

Retain / Sell / Loan Out on 17:09 - May 19 with 869 viewsJFSwan

I think we need a new right back. Naughton would be excellent on the bench as he can play on both sides but I feel we need an improvement in the first team, Rangel can stay for the odd game and he's one of the boys in it.
0

Retain / Sell / Loan Out on 17:09 - May 19 with 864 viewsAl_Bundy

With respect, what is the thinking if retaining Rangel and Routledge ??
0
Retain / Sell / Loan Out on 17:11 - May 19 with 858 viewsjasper_T

Retain / Sell / Loan Out on 16:46 - May 19 by Martyrman57

Given our step up at u23 level next season then Kingsley, Fulton, Grimes (if sill here) and McBurnie can develop in house rather than loan options.


None of them should be playing u23s level any longer.

And none of them are good enough for the first team here.
0
Retain / Sell / Loan Out on 17:14 - May 19 with 849 viewsAl_Bundy

Retain / Sell / Loan Out on 17:11 - May 19 by jasper_T

None of them should be playing u23s level any longer.

And none of them are good enough for the first team here.


The likes of Bournemouth, Everton, Southampton and Spurs play their youngsters and see if they sink of swim initially. We at the moment seem not confident in any of them !
0
Retain / Sell / Loan Out on 17:15 - May 19 with 844 viewsCooperman

Retain / Sell / Loan Out on 15:39 - May 19 by Darran

I'm not being an awkward twát here but what is the Nordfeldt - Retain decision based on?


I would have to know his wages before calling that one.

He's a steady keeper but hardly value for money if he's on £30k p/w.
0
Retain / Sell / Loan Out on 17:18 - May 19 with 837 viewsAl_Bundy

Retain / Sell / Loan Out on 17:15 - May 19 by Cooperman

I would have to know his wages before calling that one.

He's a steady keeper but hardly value for money if he's on £30k p/w.


Well he's our insurance policy... decent enough and appears happy to sit it out for Fabianski. Every club needs two decent keepers in the Prem and he had done well what limited games he's played.

Now if we want to upgrade on Fabianski then that's another story.
0

Retain / Sell / Loan Out on 17:19 - May 19 with 833 viewsA_Fans_Dad

Kingsley already has lots of experience, what he needs is Prem or Championship game time to get to the next step, anything less and he will not necessarily improve on where he is already.
The same can be said for Fulton.
0

Retain / Sell / Loan Out on 17:36 - May 19 with 782 viewsMartyrman57

Kingsley, Fulton and McBurnie can all be named in the PL 25 senior squad but also play in the u23 league which will include the top 6 teams.
They would develop with PC and the coaching team on a daily basis rather than be loaned out.
0

Retain / Sell / Loan Out on 17:57 - May 19 with 715 viewsWarwickHunt

You lost me at

Amat - Sell
van der Hoorn - Retain
0
Retain / Sell / Loan Out on 18:11 - May 19 with 674 viewsWandererJack

Retain / Sell / Loan Out on 17:57 - May 19 by WarwickHunt

You lost me at

Amat - Sell
van der Hoorn - Retain


Fair enough. I had high hopes for Amat this season but he's fallen short and he's not managed to hold a place down for the years he's been here so I would sell at this point.

We won't be buying more than one centre half so on that basis I would retain VDH as fourth choice for next season.
0
Retain / Sell / Loan Out on 18:18 - May 19 with 651 viewsWandererJack

Retain / Sell / Loan Out on 17:09 - May 19 by Al_Bundy

With respect, what is the thinking if retaining Rangel and Routledge ??


Routledge - it would be for his experience and I do rate him as defensive wideman. If there's a game against a strong team where we don't employ the diamond then I would play Routledge before any other winger because he is defensively responsible and does his bit in that regard. Secondary reasons would be that he is senior member of the squad, seems very popular with the other players and I personally think team morale is important. Thirdly he signed a new contract in January so is unlikely to move anyway.

Rangel I would keep for similar reasons as above. I do agree with the poster above that we need a new first choice right back and I'm not sure why I didn't include that in the OP. There's probably a bit of sentimentality going with this one too if I'm honest.
0

Retain / Sell / Loan Out on 18:36 - May 19 with 605 viewsmajorraglan

Can't sell Emnes, he's out of contract at the end of the season. Will no doubt be off.
0
Retain / Sell / Loan Out on 21:51 - May 19 with 423 viewsnantywatcher

Retain / Sell / Loan Out on 18:36 - May 19 by majorraglan

Can't sell Emnes, he's out of contract at the end of the season. Will no doubt be off.


McBurnie will be Premier standard next season. Narsingh might be a good fit for the Forest Green squad. Amat can cover several positions and so on....
0
About Us Contact Us Terms & Conditions Privacy Cookies Advertising
© FansNetwork 2017 hosted by FastHosts