Please log in or register. Registered visitors get fewer ads.
Forum index | Previous Thread | Next thread
VAR Controversy AGAIN 19:15 - Jun 23 with 3032 viewswestwalesed

I've seen some good decisions so far at the WC and some injustices righted.

But how the feck that wasn't a foul on the Swedish striker just now and why that wasn't checked I have no idea. How is it decided if something is reviewed or not?

Poll: Live in a country with no internet?

2
VAR Controversy AGAIN on 19:18 - Jun 23 with 2619 viewsAndyNak

Was just saying the same.

Also if the play is allowed to go on while they review it and Germany go up the other end and score is their goal then disallowed if they decide to give Sweden a penalty? Do they also add on the additional 4-5 mins lost while they review the incident/while Germany are playing?

VAR is pointless if it’s not used consistently, it’s also annoying

Bin

Poll: Joe or Wilf? If you could only have one

1
VAR Controversy AGAIN on 19:18 - Jun 23 with 2619 viewshobo

It depends if it's a big team or not, and who the top brass want to go through
1
VAR Controversy AGAIN on 19:19 - Jun 23 with 2610 viewswestwalesed

VAR Controversy AGAIN on 19:18 - Jun 23 by hobo

It depends if it's a big team or not, and who the top brass want to go through


I can't say I haven't thought that as well.

And another excellent point, what WOULD have happened had Germany scored there?

Poll: Live in a country with no internet?

0
VAR Controversy AGAIN on 19:24 - Jun 23 with 2584 viewsNeathJack

VAR Controversy AGAIN on 19:19 - Jun 23 by westwalesed

I can't say I haven't thought that as well.

And another excellent point, what WOULD have happened had Germany scored there?


If the VAR had found it to be a penalty for Sweden then the a German goal in the same passage of play would be disallowed and play brought back.
0
VAR Controversy AGAIN on 19:28 - Jun 23 with 2568 viewsAndyNak

VAR Controversy AGAIN on 19:24 - Jun 23 by NeathJack

If the VAR had found it to be a penalty for Sweden then the a German goal in the same passage of play would be disallowed and play brought back.


Would the time between the incident and the review be added back on?

Poll: Joe or Wilf? If you could only have one

0
VAR Controversy AGAIN on 19:35 - Jun 23 with 2552 viewslondonlisa2001

VAR Controversy AGAIN on 19:24 - Jun 23 by NeathJack

If the VAR had found it to be a penalty for Sweden then the a German goal in the same passage of play would be disallowed and play brought back.


In exactly the same way as has happened in the rugby for years now.

Why is everyone finding this so confusing?
0
VAR Controversy AGAIN on 20:00 - Jun 23 with 2494 viewsplasjack

It's VARY confusing, sorry about my spelling.
1
VAR Controversy AGAIN on 21:42 - Jun 23 with 2407 viewsBadlands

VAR has got a few wrong - but a hell of a lot right nah the ref would have got wrong.

Poll: Should the summer transfer window close before the season starts?

1
Login to get fewer ads

VAR Controversy AGAIN on 09:08 - Jun 24 with 2210 viewsoldcob

VAR Controversy AGAIN on 21:42 - Jun 23 by Badlands

VAR has got a few wrong - but a hell of a lot right nah the ref would have got wrong.


Agree. Just look at how many penalties we've had this year that referees wouldn't have had the bottle to give otherwise. Even if it's not 100% it's a great improvement in "getting it right"
1
VAR Controversy AGAIN on 12:21 - Jun 24 with 2112 viewsA_Fans_Dad

VAR Controversy AGAIN on 21:42 - Jun 23 by Badlands

VAR has got a few wrong - but a hell of a lot right nah the ref would have got wrong.


Except of course it has now "officialised" wrestling to the ground of an attacking player during set pieces as being OK.
Even by 2 defenders, let alone 1.
-1
VAR Controversy AGAIN on 12:28 - Jun 24 with 2106 viewsJango

VAR Controversy AGAIN on 12:21 - Jun 24 by A_Fans_Dad

Except of course it has now "officialised" wrestling to the ground of an attacking player during set pieces as being OK.
Even by 2 defenders, let alone 1.


VAR still comes down to the opinion of the officials. Not everyone will agree with every decision but it has proven to be immensely important already in the tournament. The amount of fouls in the box that go unpunished normally is criminal. Also in the Neymar situation the other day, pens can get overturned. We could have done with it a few times last season.
1
VAR Controversy AGAIN on 12:41 - Jun 24 with 2092 viewsBillyChong

There was a delay in a game a couple of nights ago whilst a ref went to review an incident on the screen. What’s the point when there’s a group of refs watching it off the pitch to advise? Not convinced by it.
1
VAR Controversy AGAIN on 13:30 - Jun 24 with 2076 viewsDafyddHuw

It's a work in progress.
Stop being such big girl's blouses and give then a chance to iron it all out.
0
VAR Controversy AGAIN on 23:06 - Jun 24 with 2000 viewsBadlands

What is becoming obvious is the VAR teams who are used to it in their own leagues are far more on he ball yet game sensible.

Poll: Should the summer transfer window close before the season starts?

0
VAR Controversy AGAIN on 20:11 - Jun 25 with 1920 viewshobo

Its a good thing we have VAR so that Spain don't get a red for a 2 footed challenge and Ronaldo can get a soft penalty
0
VAR Controversy AGAIN on 20:52 - Jun 25 with 1873 viewsMrSwerve

Some of this VAR stuff is a bit farcical.

Poll: Decision day - who wins the PL title?

0
VAR Controversy AGAIN on 20:59 - Jun 25 with 1848 viewsItchySphincter

Loving this VAR.

BBC commentators positively apoplectic. Shearer has now deemed that a handball has to be intentional for it to be a pen. Lawrenson nearly shat his pants.

Brilliant.

‘……. like a moth to Itchy’s flame ……’
Poll: Planet Swans or Planet Swans? Which one's you favourite.

0
VAR Controversy AGAIN on 20:59 - Jun 25 with 1846 viewstheloneranger

VAR Controversy AGAIN on 20:52 - Jun 25 by MrSwerve

Some of this VAR stuff is a bit farcical.


A bit like the penalties Anthony Taylor has given against the Swans

Everyday above ground ... Is a good day! 😎

1
VAR Controversy AGAIN on 21:01 - Jun 25 with 1827 viewsLord_Bony

VAR Controversy AGAIN on 20:59 - Jun 25 by theloneranger

A bit like the penalties Anthony Taylor has given against the Swans


To be used in future tournaments then there must be a much quicker response to any disputed incidents.

The players acting up and diving and crying to the ref for the most trivial of reasons certainly does not help the situation

PROUD RECIPIENT OF THE THIRD PLANET SWANS LIFETIME ACHIEVEMENT AWARD. "Per ardua ad astra"
Poll: iS tHERE lIFE aFTER dEATH

1
VAR Controversy AGAIN on 21:04 - Jun 25 with 1805 viewsShaky

Shit ref in Spain v Morocco.

And Swansea really dodged a bullet when Jenkins failed to sign Aspas!

Misology -- It's a bitch
Poll: Greatest PS Troll Hunter of all time

0
VAR Controversy AGAIN on 21:04 - Jun 25 with 1805 viewstheloneranger

VAR Controversy AGAIN on 21:01 - Jun 25 by Lord_Bony

To be used in future tournaments then there must be a much quicker response to any disputed incidents.

The players acting up and diving and crying to the ref for the most trivial of reasons certainly does not help the situation


Any player signalling to the ref for Var, or signalling for an opponent to be booked, should receive a yellow card.

No warnings, straight yellow!!

Everyday above ground ... Is a good day! 😎

1
VAR Controversy AGAIN on 21:06 - Jun 25 with 1800 viewsLandore_Jack

The Paraguayan referee was shocking along with VAR.

#backtojack

0
VAR Controversy AGAIN on 21:16 - Jun 25 with 1756 viewsLandore_Jack

VAR had undermined the referee by asking him to review both incidents. Both were never pens. An absolute joke.
[Post edited 25 Jun 2018 21:19]

#backtojack

0
VAR Controversy AGAIN on 21:26 - Jun 25 with 1722 viewsmajorraglan

I believe that VAR is a positive development, but it certainly has its teething issues at this moment in time. In addition to some of the calls, surely something has to be done about the diving and play acting we are regularly seeing. It's not just the World Cup, we are seeing it in the Champions League especially with some of the teams from the Iberian peninsular.
[Post edited 25 Jun 2018 21:27]
0
VAR Controversy AGAIN on 21:30 - Jun 25 with 1709 viewsphact0rri

Since its introduction I've been all in VAR. But the amount of penalties in WC has been atrocious. Some are blatantly incorrect, and others are quite soft indeed.

If this is what VAR turns the sport into, I'd rather not have it at all.

Poll: Should EPL Refrees hold Post-Match Interviews

0
About Us Contact Us Terms & Conditions Privacy Cookies Advertising
© FansNetwork 2024