Please log in or register. Registered visitors get fewer ads.
Forum index | Previous Thread | Next thread
Soton v Derby VAR decision 20:56 - Jan 16 with 391 viewsBrynCartwright

Goal disallowed for Derby against Southampton in the first half via VAR because of obvious off side. However, nearly all the pundits decry it as a travesty of a decision,and absolutely panning VAR. Anyone else see it? I thought it was clear cut, or am I half cut?

Poll: When u die do you want to be...

0

Soton v Derby VAR decision on 21:04 - Jan 16 with 367 viewsswan_si

Definite off side, if the derby player had touched the ball instead of letting it run through then the goal would of stood, he didn't so the decision was correct, isn't that why VAR was introduced?
3

Soton v Derby VAR decision on 21:14 - Jan 16 with 342 viewshobo

Get rid once and for all

TrophyManager - The free to play online community football manager game. http://trophymanager.com/?c=756236 (If joining make sure you select Wales as your country, as I think the default is England)

-1

Soton v Derby VAR decision on 21:16 - Jan 16 with 330 viewshobo

The fans can't celebrate goals as each one is automatically checked by VAR This isn't what football is about. It will kill the game

TrophyManager - The free to play online community football manager game. http://trophymanager.com/?c=756236 (If joining make sure you select Wales as your country, as I think the default is England)

-1
Soton v Derby VAR decision on 21:24 - Jan 16 with 313 viewsBrynCartwright

Soton v Derby VAR decision on 21:16 - Jan 16 by hobo

The fans can't celebrate goals as each one is automatically checked by VAR This isn't what football is about. It will kill the game


VAR should only be used if there is any doubt in the veracity of a goal, not for clear cut goals. It's use should be as fluid as it is in rugby, and cannot but be a great positive contribution in my opinion, considering how we all bemoan the quality of refereeing these days..

Poll: When u die do you want to be...

1

Soton v Derby VAR decision on 21:31 - Jan 16 with 288 viewsLibertarian

VAR proved he was offside, so the goal was disallowed. Good decision.
3
Soton v Derby VAR decision on 21:36 - Jan 16 with 277 viewshobo

Soton v Derby VAR decision on 21:24 - Jan 16 by BrynCartwright

VAR should only be used if there is any doubt in the veracity of a goal, not for clear cut goals. It's use should be as fluid as it is in rugby, and cannot but be a great positive contribution in my opinion, considering how we all bemoan the quality of refereeing these days..


I find it awful in rugby too. They review most of the tries even if they have no clear reason in doing so

TrophyManager - The free to play online community football manager game. http://trophymanager.com/?c=756236 (If joining make sure you select Wales as your country, as I think the default is England)

-2

Soton v Derby VAR decision on 21:41 - Jan 16 with 266 viewsswan_si

If only we could clone Sian Massey.
2
Soton v Derby VAR decision on 21:47 - Jan 16 with 246 viewslonglostjack

Soton v Derby VAR decision on 21:36 - Jan 16 by hobo

I find it awful in rugby too. They review most of the tries even if they have no clear reason in doing so


Football isn’t rugby though where you have players all piled up on the line as VAR looks at all different camera angles taking a lot of time up. In football the decisions are much easier to see with the help of cameras and VAR works well.

Poll: Who would you rather win? England or Sweden?

2
Login to get fewer ads

Soton v Derby VAR decision on 21:52 - Jan 16 with 237 viewsBrynCartwright

Soton v Derby VAR decision on 21:36 - Jan 16 by hobo

I find it awful in rugby too. They review most of the tries even if they have no clear reason in doing so


Sorry, but i cannot agree with you at all. VAR has been a massive asset to rugby, and once it is perfected, will be a massive asset to football as well.

Poll: When u die do you want to be...

2

Soton v Derby VAR decision on 21:54 - Jan 16 with 233 viewsBillyChong

Rubbish system that will kill the game. No one will celebrate a goal for fear of the VAR. There was no secondary celebration when the Derby goal was awarded either. Get rid now.
0

Soton v Derby VAR decision on 23:12 - Jan 16 with 142 viewsgrabsplatter

If VAR was in operation it would have disallowed a clearly offside goal that put Newcastle 3 - 2 up last night.
Ask Blackburn fans whether they're in favour of it.
0
Soton v Derby VAR decision on 01:13 - Jan 17 with 74 viewsWanderer

Soton v Derby VAR decision on 21:16 - Jan 16 by hobo

The fans can't celebrate goals as each one is automatically checked by VAR This isn't what football is about. It will kill the game


Agree with this, do not like VAR myself.
0
About Us Contact Us Terms & Conditions Privacy Cookies Advertising
© FansNetwork 2019