| Connor Roberts disallowed goal 19:19 - Feb 17 with 8630 views | Pacemaker |
What was the score with that? I didn’t see the flag up until after the goal had been given and the Lino and Attwell had a chat. |  |
| Life is an adventure or nothing at all. |
| |  |
| Connor Roberts disallowed goal on 19:19 - Feb 17 with 7056 views | Bloodyhills |
It certainly wasn't offside. |  |
| |
| Connor Roberts disallowed goal on 19:22 - Feb 17 with 7021 views | ploppy |
I don't think either was offside, but Celina was "more offside" than CR. It was CR that was given offside I assume. | | | |
| Connor Roberts disallowed goal on 19:23 - Feb 17 with 6998 views | JACKMANANDBOY |
Attwell! |  |
| |
| Connor Roberts disallowed goal on 19:24 - Feb 17 with 6982 views | Pegojack |
Don't understand it unless Celina was off, in which case why didn't the flag go up when he received the ball?
Roberts was two yards onside when the shot was made. Appalling officiating. [Post edited 17 Feb 2019 19:25]
|  | | |
| Connor Roberts disallowed goal on 19:24 - Feb 17 with 6977 views | LeonWasGod |
Well the ref explained his decision to Byers. I can only assume they thought he was offside or committed an infringement? Genuinely don’t know. Wasn’t Connor behind the ball so couldn’t be offside? Would need to see it all back. |  | | |
| Connor Roberts disallowed goal on 19:27 - Feb 17 with 6935 views | Chief |
What did the commentators make of it? Was it revisited after the game in the studio? Or am I overestimating BBC Wales? |  |
| |
| Connor Roberts disallowed goal on 19:28 - Feb 17 with 6913 views | ploppy |
| Connor Roberts disallowed goal on 19:23 - Feb 17 by JACKMANANDBOY |
Attwell! |
If it was Attwell's decision, then it's a shame (and completely wrong) because I thought otherwise he had a good game. His yellow/red cards were PL style, which makes a change this season. Too many fouls go unpunished in the Championship. And he dealt well the Dan James incident towards the end. Too many referees book the player committing the professional foul and the victim for his reaction. | | | |
Login to get fewer ads
| Connor Roberts disallowed goal on 19:29 - Feb 17 with 6888 views | Pacemaker |
I was more or less in line with it, the flag was held and the free kick taken at the point where Celina received the ball but I was sure Celina was on side.
I didn’t see anyone arguing with the ref so presumably they agreed/accepted the decision. | |
| Life is an adventure or nothing at all. |
| |
| Connor Roberts disallowed goal on 19:31 - Feb 17 with 6874 views | LeonWasGod |
| Connor Roberts disallowed goal on 19:29 - Feb 17 by Pacemaker |
I was more or less in line with it, the flag was held and the free kick taken at the point where Celina received the ball but I was sure Celina was on side.
I didn’t see anyone arguing with the ref so presumably they agreed/accepted the decision. |
Or just completely confused! Potter took it well, so it must have made sense to him. | | | |
| Connor Roberts disallowed goal on 19:48 - Feb 17 with 6742 views | Badlands |
From where I was sat I thought Celina was offside but that wasn't flagged.
Roberts was definitely onside by a couple of yards,
Why did Atwell spend a gas talking to Byers after the decision, did he get the Wong player? |  |
| |
| Connor Roberts disallowed goal on 19:54 - Feb 17 with 6707 views | oldcob |
| Connor Roberts disallowed goal on 19:48 - Feb 17 by Badlands |
From where I was sat I thought Celina was offside but that wasn't flagged.
Roberts was definitely onside by a couple of yards,
Why did Atwell spend a gas talking to Byers after the decision, did he get the Wong player? |
Yeah, and two Wongs don't make a white. | | | |
| Connor Roberts disallowed goal on 20:07 - Feb 17 with 6628 views | BLAZE |
| Connor Roberts disallowed goal on 19:54 - Feb 17 by oldcob |
Yeah, and two Wongs don't make a white. |
They make a cracking crispy beef though |  | | |
| Connor Roberts disallowed goal on 23:23 - Feb 17 with 6268 views | karnataka |
Disappointed MOTD didn't clear it up because I'm still baffled. If the programme had been done from a studio, I'm sure they'd have taken another look at it. |  | | |
| Connor Roberts disallowed goal on 23:26 - Feb 17 with 6249 views | jasper_T |
Both Bersant and Connor clearly onside. | | | |
| Connor Roberts disallowed goal on 23:30 - Feb 17 with 6228 views | LeonWasGod |
| Connor Roberts disallowed goal on 23:26 - Feb 17 by jasper_T |
Both Bersant and Connor clearly onside. |
Jackmanandboy nailed it. The reason was just Attwell. It was a perfectly good goal. | | | |
| Connor Roberts disallowed goal on 23:31 - Feb 17 with 6225 views | lifelong |
| Connor Roberts disallowed goal on 23:26 - Feb 17 by jasper_T |
Both Bersant and Connor clearly onside. |
I watched the game on Bein 1, they highlighted the incident, Celina was offside. |  | | |
| Connor Roberts disallowed goal on 23:31 - Feb 17 with 6222 views | jasper_T |
| Connor Roberts disallowed goal on 23:31 - Feb 17 by lifelong |
I watched the game on Bein 1, they highlighted the incident, Celina was offside. |
He was level by the lines on the pitch on the replays I've seen. | | | |
| Connor Roberts disallowed goal on 23:37 - Feb 17 with 6196 views | lifelong |
| Connor Roberts disallowed goal on 23:31 - Feb 17 by jasper_T |
He was level by the lines on the pitch on the replays I've seen. |
I thought he just looked off when he received the ball. | | | |
| Connor Roberts disallowed goal on 01:20 - Feb 18 with 6094 views | Joe_bradshaw |
| Connor Roberts disallowed goal on 23:37 - Feb 17 by lifelong |
I thought he just looked off when he received the ball. |
Aye, Lifey but as you know, it’s not when he received it, it when it was passed to him. |  |
| |
| Connor Roberts disallowed goal on 11:16 - Feb 18 with 5870 views | jasper_T |
 | | | |
| Connor Roberts disallowed goal on 11:26 - Feb 18 with 5832 views | andyofsa6 |
| Connor Roberts disallowed goal on 19:27 - Feb 17 by Chief |
What did the commentators make of it? Was it revisited after the game in the studio? Or am I overestimating BBC Wales? |
I watched the game on BBC and after the game the Women in the studio actually said " the disallowed goal we will not mention that" typical of BBCardiff and both the guests were more happy talking about Brentford than the Swans. | | | |
| Connor Roberts disallowed goal on 11:46 - Feb 18 with 5789 views | Jonathans_coat |
| Connor Roberts disallowed goal on 11:16 - Feb 18 by jasper_T |
|
Both players onside, dreadful desision, massive and confusing cock up afterwards!
Terrible officiating all round! |  | | |
| Connor Roberts disallowed goal on 12:31 - Feb 18 with 5709 views | SWANSEYE |
Thought it was an extremely late flag from an inept linesman who flagged for Roberts when it was Celina Offside but the passage of play had evolved so far forward that it was a mile late !!! |  | | |
| Connor Roberts disallowed goal on 12:55 - Feb 18 with 5652 views | The_E20 |
| Connor Roberts disallowed goal on 12:31 - Feb 18 by SWANSEYE |
Thought it was an extremely late flag from an inept linesman who flagged for Roberts when it was Celina Offside but the passage of play had evolved so far forward that it was a mile late !!! |
Celina wasn’t offside either. Horrendously odd decision. [Post edited 18 Feb 2019 12:55]
|  | | |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
