Please log in or register. Registered visitors get fewer ads.
Forum index | Previous Thread | Next thread
Disallowed Goal v Charlton 16:09 - Oct 3 with 1968 viewsunion_jack

Haven’t seen it mentioned on here though I may have missed it.

Watching the game last night they said it was off-side. Having now seen the extended highlights the Swans TV comms said it was ball went out.

Anyone at the game get a proper view of this?

Are Sperm Whales the reason the sea is so salty?
Poll: Bony - Would You Want Him Back?

0

Disallowed Goal v Charlton on 16:14 - Oct 3 with 1935 viewsmonmouth

BBC said ball went out of play.

Poll: TRUST MEMBERS: What DID you vote in the, um, vote

0

Disallowed Goal v Charlton on 17:39 - Oct 3 with 1780 viewsMrSwerve

It was because the ball went out, but on SwansTV it did look like the ball had stayed in, albeit from a hard camera angle to tell from.

Poll: Decision day - who wins the PL title?

0

Disallowed Goal v Charlton on 17:57 - Oct 3 with 1728 viewsfelixstowe_jack

Was not disallowed for offside as the referee awarded a goal kick. The linesman was standing behind corner flag with his flag raised. He did not lower to the horizontal to indicate offside. From the stands was impossible to tell if it was out or not. Even the linesman view was blocked as Fulton was between him and the ball. Hard tell correct decision without sky's 12 cameras.

Poll: Who wants "valleyboy" banned from our forum so he can post on cardiff's forum ?

1
Disallowed Goal v Charlton on 17:58 - Oct 3 with 1725 viewskarnataka

Disallowed Goal v Charlton on 17:39 - Oct 3 by MrSwerve

It was because the ball went out, but on SwansTV it did look like the ball had stayed in, albeit from a hard camera angle to tell from.


One of the Charlton fans in their message board said he didn't think it went out and we were robbed. Don't know where he was in the ground of course but he may have had a better view than any of the cameras, who knows?
0
Disallowed Goal v Charlton on 18:11 - Oct 3 with 1677 viewsGlyn1

Disallowed Goal v Charlton on 17:58 - Oct 3 by karnataka

One of the Charlton fans in their message board said he didn't think it went out and we were robbed. Don't know where he was in the ground of course but he may have had a better view than any of the cameras, who knows?


But another one said that they should have had a penalty. No idea why. We got a deserved win anyway.

Poll: Who should be our next manager? Please name them.

0

Disallowed Goal v Charlton on 11:21 - Oct 4 with 1207 viewsSkipTheJack

Didn't look anywhere near out from the highlights, but the camera angle admittedly wasn't perfect.
0
Disallowed Goal v Charlton on 14:03 - Oct 4 with 1094 viewskarnataka

Disallowed Goal v Charlton on 11:21 - Oct 4 by SkipTheJack

Didn't look anywhere near out from the highlights, but the camera angle admittedly wasn't perfect.


That's exactly what I meant about the Charlton fan possibly having a better view than any of the cameras when he said it didn't go out. His seat may be inline with the goal line.
0

Disallowed Goal v Charlton on 14:20 - Oct 4 with 1065 viewssherpajacob

https://www.swanseacity.com/video/player/0_qcgx6wfi


slo mo replay at 15:50.

certainly not offside and doesn't look like the whole ball is out, robbed.

Poll: Your favourite ever Swans shirt sponsor?

0
Login to get fewer ads


Disallowed Goal v Charlton on 16:45 - Oct 4 with 950 viewsRiscaJack

Nowhere near out. Another shocker against us which is masked due to the final result.

JENKINS OUT

0
Disallowed Goal v Charlton on 16:48 - Oct 4 with 939 viewskarnataka

Disallowed Goal v Charlton on 14:20 - Oct 4 by sherpajacob

https://www.swanseacity.com/video/player/0_qcgx6wfi


slo mo replay at 15:50.

certainly not offside and doesn't look like the whole ball is out, robbed.


BTW, It's 5.50 not 15.50, it's only a 10 minute vid!

The ricochet off the post hits Fulton on the back of his left thigh when both his legs are clearly still on the pitch then drops down and lands well inside the line before Fulton plays it back to Ayew. Hard to tell whether or not the ball had travelled from more than a foot inside the line to a foot outside the line in such a short space of time but it seems unlikely and might be stretching the laws of physics a bit! Plus with Fulton standing on the line, there is no way the lino on the far side could have even seen enough of the ball to be 100% sure it had all completely crossed the line so he must have guessed.

Without a different camera angle, it's still inconclusive at best I guess.
1

Disallowed Goal v Charlton on 16:55 - Oct 4 with 917 viewsSwanseaman

Lots of people at the game thought the ball wasn't out, both Swansea amd Charlton fans.

Poll: Would you have Jenkins back if he found wealthy oil sheikhs to buy out the Yanks

0
Disallowed Goal v Charlton on 17:03 - Oct 4 with 907 viewsOldjack

Disallowed Goal v Charlton on 16:14 - Oct 3 by monmouth

BBC said ball went out of play.


Well they would .The ball was in ,even the Charlton fans agreed with that

Prosser the Tosser dwells on Phil's bum hole like a rusty old hemorrhoid ,fact You Greedy Bastards Get Out Of OUR Club!

0

Disallowed Goal v Charlton on 17:07 - Oct 4 with 898 viewsFireboy2

We won FFS so this 'goal' didnt matter.

Poll: Who is brexithomas17?

-1
Disallowed Goal v Charlton on 20:49 - Oct 4 with 755 viewskarnataka

Disallowed Goal v Charlton on 17:07 - Oct 4 by Fireboy2

We won FFS so this 'goal' didnt matter.


You saw the title of this thread, it's not ambiguous, so why read any of it and even bother to post on the thread ffs?? That reminds me of a time I put a question on Amazon to see if anyone knew if my old Bosch lawnmower batteries were compatible with the new model and 2 people replied, "Sorry, I have no idea" Why?
2
Disallowed Goal v Charlton on 21:35 - Oct 4 with 721 viewsFlashberryjack

Disallowed Goal v Charlton on 17:07 - Oct 4 by Fireboy2

We won FFS so this 'goal' didnt matter.


An extra 1 goal difference at the end of the season could crucial ... just saying.

Hello

1
Disallowed Goal v Charlton on 11:12 - Oct 5 with 544 viewsMrSwerve

Disallowed Goal v Charlton on 21:35 - Oct 4 by Flashberryjack

An extra 1 goal difference at the end of the season could crucial ... just saying.


Indeed.

Poll: Decision day - who wins the PL title?

0
Disallowed Goal v Charlton on 11:21 - Oct 5 with 524 viewsFireboy2

Disallowed Goal v Charlton on 21:35 - Oct 4 by Flashberryjack

An extra 1 goal difference at the end of the season could crucial ... just saying.


Fair enough

Poll: Who is brexithomas17?

0
Disallowed Goal v Charlton on 11:53 - Oct 5 with 488 viewsmonmouth

Disallowed Goal v Charlton on 21:35 - Oct 4 by Flashberryjack

An extra 1 goal difference at the end of the season could crucial ... just saying.


But if we’d scored then none of the rest would have existed. We might even have not won.

Poll: TRUST MEMBERS: What DID you vote in the, um, vote

0
Disallowed Goal v Charlton on 11:58 - Oct 5 with 481 viewsunion_jack

Disallowed Goal v Charlton on 11:53 - Oct 5 by monmouth

But if we’d scored then none of the rest would have existed. We might even have not won.


Yes indeed. It may have been a blessing in disguise.

On the other hand...

Who knows?

It looked ok from the camera angle but that may have been a touch deceiving.

Are Sperm Whales the reason the sea is so salty?
Poll: Bony - Would You Want Him Back?

0

Disallowed Goal v Charlton on 13:34 - Oct 5 with 428 viewsFireboy2

Interesting to see that charlton are leading free scoring fulham at craven cottage.

Poll: Who is brexithomas17?

0
Disallowed Goal v Charlton on 14:32 - Oct 5 with 377 viewsFireboy2

Disallowed Goal v Charlton on 13:34 - Oct 5 by Fireboy2

Interesting to see that charlton are leading free scoring fulham at craven cottage.


Draw good for us.

Poll: Who is brexithomas17?

1
About Us Contact Us Terms & Conditions Privacy Cookies Advertising
© FansNetwork 2020