Please log in or register
Would Wilshere Move Really Be A Bad One?
Monday, 24th Jul 2017 08:00 by Planet Swans (follow us on Twitter @swansnews)

It is fair to say that Arsenal midfielder Jack Wilshere being linked with a move to the Swans has not been met with resounding excitement from the fans but would a move for the player really be a bad one?


We all know that Wilshere has got potential but injuries and, at time, his attitude has let him down but if Paul Clement believes that he can realise his potential then it would certainly benefit the club if it was proved to be true.

I think it is fair to say that any move for Wilshere will only happen if Gylfi leaves the club (it seems as if we have many links at the moment that are dependent on that) but I certainly don't subscribe to the fact that it would be a bad one.

It should of course also be remembered that this could just be paper talk generated by the agent to engineer a move for his client. With West Ham and Newcastle also both being linked then that piece certainly seems to make sense.

He spent last season on loan at Bournemouth where he made 22 starts in the league with a further 5 substitute appearances on top of that.

When he first arrived on the scene, a 16-year-old kid coming through the ranks at Arsenal, he was seen as the player England had been waiting for: a technically gifted passing midfielder who had a little spark and toughness, the sort that could control a game.

Wilshere's career though has felt unfulfilled, to this point a disappointment. Partly that is down to the litany of injuries he has suffered, to the point that he only made his 100th Premier League start in November this season, eight years after making his debut.

It's also down to confusion, indecision and a lack of clarity about what sort of midfielder he is and what his best position is. For Arsenal, he would often play in a two or three-man midfield, occasionally out wide. England briefly tried to turn him into a deep-lying playmaker, a sort of imitation Andrea Pirlo. For Bournemouth, he's broadly been a No.10, playing ahead of two players who would do much of the grubby work and behind a centre-forward.

However, if we are interested in the player we should look beyond that and know better than anyone that sometimes a change in club is as much of a kick start than anything else. He has the attributes, the question is whether we could develop them and whether we are prepared to take an expensive gamble in trying to do so.

If the answer is yes then I'm in.

Get two free £10 bets on Swansea City v Leicester City (or other matches) by opening a new account at William Hill. Place an initial bet of a minimum of £10 and William Hill will give you two £10 bets. You must enter the promotional code ''F20'' when signing up as a new customer.

Action Images



Please report offensive, libellous or inappropriate posts by using the links provided.



johnjubal1958 added 11:12 - Jul 24
I believe Wilshere it's simply a motivation problem. As everyone knows Jack can produce the goods, but you have to ask yourself, why hasn't he do so! There has to be a reason right? I think Jack Wilshere would be a good asset for the Swans, because the club itself and the background staff have a knack in bringing out the best in players when it comes down to encouraging and motivation them. What Jack Wilshere had with regards to his skill level you just don't loss it like you would loss a set of car keys when you never find them again. He's lost the desire and commitment for whatever reason only he can pinpoint, but I believe in the right hands that can be turned around and Swansea City would be the ideal place for Jack to come. However, I'm not in favour or a fan of the reported buy back clause that is supposedly attacked to any selling agreement. I think that is unfair on any buying club and in many ways it can penalize the buyers under such conditions. They do the hard work then they have to hand it over? Hence unfair, but if they are willing to pay the required market transfer valuation along with other clubs want to buy then far enough!

The bottom line, I think Jack Wilshere would be a good risk to take if you remove the obligated buy back clause of course!
0


You need to login in order to post your comments

Swansea City Polls

About Us Contact Us Terms & Conditions Privacy Cookies Advertising
© FansNetwork 2017 hosted by FastHosts