Referee! (And assistant) - WBA 09:08 - Feb 20 with 2493 views | PinnerPaul | Disclaimer - based on watching live only - no replays 1) Mass pen claim 1st half - not for me 2) Our pen - didn't have a great view - but not a massive shout from crowd/players but then not a massive moan from WBA either 3) Lumley - That WAS handball outside the box in 2nd half wasn't it? Looked like it to me 4) Assistant ER - Now as I do that mostly all the time myself, I know its not easy but 1st half he missed two obvious ones and to me called 2 'technical ones (one on/one off) incorrectly as well. Missed an obvious foul right in front of him 2nd half as well. Thought he was poor. Ref pretty decent though - foul on Eze looked an orange in real time, so yellow not incorrect as such. | | | | |
Referee! (And assistant) - WBA on 09:24 - Feb 20 with 1946 views | 1MoreBrightonR | Even before they scored, i felt 5 mins added on was over the top. Lumley got warned on 89 mins about time wasting but hadnt until that point. their keeper barely had that half and the trainer was on once i think from memory. | | | |
Referee! (And assistant) - WBA on 09:26 - Feb 20 with 1935 views | TheChef |
Referee! (And assistant) - WBA on 09:24 - Feb 20 by 1MoreBrightonR | Even before they scored, i felt 5 mins added on was over the top. Lumley got warned on 89 mins about time wasting but hadnt until that point. their keeper barely had that half and the trainer was on once i think from memory. |
Full set of substitutions plus penalty decision/faffing plus Freeman injury, I think on the whole 5 minutes was probably about right in hindsight. | |
| |
Referee! (And assistant) - WBA on 09:37 - Feb 20 with 1900 views | stowmarketrange |
Referee! (And assistant) - WBA on 09:26 - Feb 20 by TheChef | Full set of substitutions plus penalty decision/faffing plus Freeman injury, I think on the whole 5 minutes was probably about right in hindsight. |
One of our subs was at ht,and the other 2 were made at the same time.5 mins was harsh.I hoped for 3 but expected 4. He only allowed 1 min in the 1st half for the same amount of injuries and goals. | | | |
Referee! (And assistant) - WBA on 10:20 - Feb 20 with 1819 views | daveB | Not sure how you can say ref was decent. Clear red for Livermore he only booked him. our penalty was never a penalty and Lumley should have been sent off for the handball | | | |
Referee! (And assistant) - WBA on 10:28 - Feb 20 with 1783 views | 1MoreBrightonR |
Referee! (And assistant) - WBA on 09:37 - Feb 20 by stowmarketrange | One of our subs was at ht,and the other 2 were made at the same time.5 mins was harsh.I hoped for 3 but expected 4. He only allowed 1 min in the 1st half for the same amount of injuries and goals. |
that was what got me....why only 1 min the first half then!? was expecting 3 in the 2nd. | | | |
Referee! (And assistant) - WBA on 10:45 - Feb 20 with 1733 views | smegma |
Referee! (And assistant) - WBA on 10:20 - Feb 20 by daveB | Not sure how you can say ref was decent. Clear red for Livermore he only booked him. our penalty was never a penalty and Lumley should have been sent off for the handball |
Lumley did not handle the ball, he chested it. I sat by press box and they show instant replays on TV. [Post edited 20 Feb 2019 10:47]
| | | |
Referee! (And assistant) - WBA on 11:00 - Feb 20 with 1688 views | toboboly | Thought our two other penalty shouts were more than the one he gave. Was strange that he started chastising Lumley for time wasting when he wasn't yet was more than happy to allow WBA to wander off to the side for drinks/tactics when it was a drop ball. If the extra time was 5 minutes then the Watford extra time should have been 25. | |
| Sexy Asian dwarves wanted. |
| |
Referee! (And assistant) - WBA on 11:22 - Feb 20 with 1655 views | robith | Some guy in the away end was going puce in the face screaming at the lino when Freeman was down injured? In the paddocks we shouted "You're doing great lino!" and he gave us a thumbs up behind his back. Quite tickled me | | | | Login to get fewer ads
Referee! (And assistant) - WBA on 11:23 - Feb 20 with 1653 views | quickpassrotter | Referee talking to Lumley about his time wasting when he had to climb into the School End Lower on three occasions to retrieve the ball himself in last few minutes because that was only way he could get the ball back. I thought 4 additional minutes. 5 was a bit harsh. We had the clock on and only 78 seconds left when they got their third. How many black cats have we run over in the last few weeks ? | | | |
Referee! (And assistant) - WBA on 11:31 - Feb 20 with 1624 views | superhoopdownunder |
Referee! (And assistant) - WBA on 11:23 - Feb 20 by quickpassrotter | Referee talking to Lumley about his time wasting when he had to climb into the School End Lower on three occasions to retrieve the ball himself in last few minutes because that was only way he could get the ball back. I thought 4 additional minutes. 5 was a bit harsh. We had the clock on and only 78 seconds left when they got their third. How many black cats have we run over in the last few weeks ? |
The commentators on the stream I watched were WBA fans and were amazed 5 minutes were added. They actually thought time was about up just before they scored (they had counted 4 additional minutes not 5 minutes) | | | |
Referee! (And assistant) - WBA on 11:49 - Feb 20 with 1594 views | PinnerPaul |
Referee! (And assistant) - WBA on 09:24 - Feb 20 by 1MoreBrightonR | Even before they scored, i felt 5 mins added on was over the top. Lumley got warned on 89 mins about time wasting but hadnt until that point. their keeper barely had that half and the trainer was on once i think from memory. |
I thought 4 mins - there were 3 subs from them, 1 double from us plus the Freeman injury and a little time wasting | | | |
Referee! (And assistant) - WBA on 11:51 - Feb 20 with 1579 views | PinnerPaul |
Referee! (And assistant) - WBA on 10:20 - Feb 20 by daveB | Not sure how you can say ref was decent. Clear red for Livermore he only booked him. our penalty was never a penalty and Lumley should have been sent off for the handball |
On the last point - common myth that GK handling outside the box is an automatic red card - has to be DOGSO. Our pen and 'red' card both debateable - which is what I said above! Don't suppose people will remember those last two when saying refs give everything against us though! | | | |
Referee! (And assistant) - WBA on 11:53 - Feb 20 with 1568 views | PinnerPaul |
Referee! (And assistant) - WBA on 11:31 - Feb 20 by superhoopdownunder | The commentators on the stream I watched were WBA fans and were amazed 5 minutes were added. They actually thought time was about up just before they scored (they had counted 4 additional minutes not 5 minutes) |
It was 3 mins 30 secs of added time when they scored. | | | |
Referee! (And assistant) - WBA on 11:56 - Feb 20 with 1552 views | smegma |
Referee! (And assistant) - WBA on 11:51 - Feb 20 by PinnerPaul | On the last point - common myth that GK handling outside the box is an automatic red card - has to be DOGSO. Our pen and 'red' card both debateable - which is what I said above! Don't suppose people will remember those last two when saying refs give everything against us though! |
DOGSO ???? | | | |
Referee! (And assistant) - WBA on 12:01 - Feb 20 with 1536 views | smegma |
Referee! (And assistant) - WBA on 11:00 - Feb 20 by toboboly | Thought our two other penalty shouts were more than the one he gave. Was strange that he started chastising Lumley for time wasting when he wasn't yet was more than happy to allow WBA to wander off to the side for drinks/tactics when it was a drop ball. If the extra time was 5 minutes then the Watford extra time should have been 25. |
The Luongo one at the school end I thought was a pen. I've only seen one replay and there was contact. The fact the away fans didn't abuse Luongo for diving told a story, neither did the defenders. I don't recall any other incident. The one we got was one that I thought could have been given but understand if it wasn't as it wasn't 100% conclusive either way. The ref only has one view . As for this thread discussing the officials, best ones we've had in weeks. | | | |
Referee! (And assistant) - WBA on 12:24 - Feb 20 with 1498 views | 81A | DOGSO = Denying Obvious Goal Scoring Opportunity. WOOF ! | | | |
Referee! (And assistant) - WBA on 12:41 - Feb 20 with 1468 views | HAYESBOY | Thought Luongo's was more of a pen than Hemed's. Both had there heels clipped. | |
| Smells like a trout farm in here |
| |
Referee! (And assistant) - WBA on 13:03 - Feb 20 with 1432 views | MrSheen | Freeman’s dive was laughable. Hard luck, great game from both sides, move on. | | | |
Referee! (And assistant) - WBA on 13:16 - Feb 20 with 1386 views | toboboly |
Referee! (And assistant) - WBA on 12:01 - Feb 20 by smegma | The Luongo one at the school end I thought was a pen. I've only seen one replay and there was contact. The fact the away fans didn't abuse Luongo for diving told a story, neither did the defenders. I don't recall any other incident. The one we got was one that I thought could have been given but understand if it wasn't as it wasn't 100% conclusive either way. The ref only has one view . As for this thread discussing the officials, best ones we've had in weeks. |
There was one in the first half with Luongo that you've mentioned, I can't seem to find it in the highlights but there was one 5 mins or so prior to the Hemed one that looked a better shout. | |
| Sexy Asian dwarves wanted. |
| |
Referee! (And assistant) - WBA on 13:23 - Feb 20 with 1370 views | superhoopdownunder |
Referee! (And assistant) - WBA on 11:53 - Feb 20 by PinnerPaul | It was 3 mins 30 secs of added time when they scored. |
Hi Paul, Yes - they said on coverage I watched times almost up - but there was around 1 minute 45 seconds to go and then they scored. I felt sick. | | | |
Referee! (And assistant) - WBA on 13:56 - Feb 20 with 1297 views | kensalriser | Only slightly related, ref in the Watford game seemed unaware of the handball rule - there were at least three by Watford that went unpunished, one of them blatant. | |
| |
Referee! (And assistant) - WBA on 16:57 - Feb 20 with 1205 views | derbyhoop | Luongo's fall was never a penalty. I thought the one that was given was very soft. If it had been against us we'd have been up in arms. Lumley looked like he'd handballed outside the area, but I only saw it once at full speed, so I'll bow to the knowledge of anyone who saw the replays. The tackle on Eze could have been red but I can see why it was only a yellow. Ultimately, Freeman's departure invited pressure onto us and the last 7-8 minutes was like the siege of the Alamo. I won't comment on time added on as it's so subjective. | |
| Travel is fatal to prejudice, bigotry and narrow-mindedness, and many of our people need it sorely on these accounts. Broad, wholesome, charitable views of men and things cannot be acquired by vegetating in one little corner of the Earth all one’s lifetime. (Mark Twain)
Find me on twitter @derbyhoop |
| |
Referee! (And assistant) - WBA on 18:39 - Feb 20 with 1106 views | PinnerPaul |
Referee! (And assistant) - WBA on 11:56 - Feb 20 by smegma | DOGSO ???? |
Denying Obvious Goal Scoring Opportunity | | | |
Referee! (And assistant) - WBA on 18:42 - Feb 20 with 1102 views | PinnerPaul |
Referee! (And assistant) - WBA on 13:56 - Feb 20 by kensalriser | Only slightly related, ref in the Watford game seemed unaware of the handball rule - there were at least three by Watford that went unpunished, one of them blatant. |
IF they change the law next season - being discussed soon - we wont' have anything to argue about - I can't wait! The proposal is to add 'or gains an advantage from the ball hitting hand/arm' to the deliberate criteria we have now. | | | |
Referee! (And assistant) - WBA on 18:44 - Feb 20 with 1098 views | PinnerPaul |
Referee! (And assistant) - WBA on 16:57 - Feb 20 by derbyhoop | Luongo's fall was never a penalty. I thought the one that was given was very soft. If it had been against us we'd have been up in arms. Lumley looked like he'd handballed outside the area, but I only saw it once at full speed, so I'll bow to the knowledge of anyone who saw the replays. The tackle on Eze could have been red but I can see why it was only a yellow. Ultimately, Freeman's departure invited pressure onto us and the last 7-8 minutes was like the siege of the Alamo. I won't comment on time added on as it's so subjective. |
Cheers Derby - that's how I saw it - as I say though, would have gone 4 mins added myself. | | | |
| |