| QPR vs Sunderland - Losing Match Thread 16:46 - Oct 26 with 25660 views | FredManRave |
Move along... Nothing to see here... |  |
| |  |
| QPR vs Sunderland - Losing Match Thread on 01:17 - Oct 27 with 2054 views | superhoopdownunder |
| QPR vs Sunderland - Losing Match Thread on 00:44 - Oct 27 by The_Beast1976 |
I did exactly the same. Saw the ref signal goal. I was astounded when the linesman then flagged for offside. WTF was he thinking. Unreal |
I'm fuming - the goal was onside - the Sunderland player handballed so should have been sent off and as the last player to touch it before Charlie scored it could not have been offside.
We need to take this up with the FA - it's not good enough.
We've missed out on our first quarter final in the last 26 years due to a dodgy referee and linesman.
We became deflated after this injustice and took the worst penalties since Kerry Dixon missed at the Loft End in 1990.
Feel sick. |  | | |
| QPR vs Sunderland - Losing Match Thread on 01:25 - Oct 27 with 2033 views | CLAREMAN1995 |
| QPR vs Sunderland - Losing Match Thread on 23:51 - Oct 26 by WatfordR |
Well they certainly made it up tonight because Austin was never offside, and it also looked to me that Albert's shot was deflected wide of the goal and towards Charlie by the defender's arm. It was really one of the worst decisions you'll ever see, whoever made it. |
This exactly .At worst its a penalty and straight red for the Sunderland defender , as the play continues Charlie heads in a sweet finish and we are all celebrating .The Ref called it correctly the linesman fcuked us all.
I was anti VAR all last year but have come around this year and Sunday in the Liverpool Utd game it showed its good and bad side.Pogba got sent off after a booking (he nearly killed the pool player dead )so that was the good .That tool Ronaldo kicked the Liverpool player at least 2 times but even with VAR got away with a yellow .
I think QPR should have been awarded at least 3 penalties those last 2 games and of course tonights dagger blow would have been rescued by VAR but no such luck | | | |
| QPR vs Sunderland - Losing Match Thread on 02:46 - Oct 27 with 1962 views | Match82 |
| QPR vs Sunderland - Losing Match Thread on 22:44 - Oct 26 by superhoopdownunder |
It was a legitimate goal and knocked the stuffing out of the team.
Disappointing to lose the way we did showing mental fragility in the penalties.
Also a real shame due to a poor decision our run of scoring in games has finished.
QPR it is the hope that kills you
U R's |
Harsh to say we showed mental fragility. Terrible penalties yes, but we were probably due after going 5 for 5 vs Orient and 8 for 8 vs Everton.
Also lost in all of this is that cracking save that Senny pulled off in the last minute, deserves a ton of credit in not just getting to it but pushing it away from the striker who looked set for the rebound. If that's a confidence booster and he can get back to the Senny of last year then that would be much welcomed |  | | |
| QPR vs Sunderland - Losing Match Thread on 03:54 - Oct 27 with 1937 views | superhoopdownunder |
Agree in relation to Dieng - great save at the end of the game.
With the penalties should we have taken them at the school end - less pressure perhaps?
(I presume Barbet won both coin tosses and chose the Loft End and to shoot first)
Also Charlie Austin was waiting for ages to take the first penalty and once he missed it went horribly downhill [Post edited 27 Oct 2021 3:58]
| | | |
| QPR vs Sunderland - Losing Match Thread on 07:50 - Oct 27 with 1824 views | HamptonR |
My take on it, at the time, was that the lino was told to signal offside, whether that was the fourth official, via Stroud or by Stroud himself, god only knows, but why else would he wait so long to put his flag up.
I don't believe the lino called it.
What feasible explanation can there be for such a delay,
Edited - However Stroud does appear to signal for a goal, perhaps he remembered that he had not been the center of attention for nearly 90 minutes. [Post edited 27 Oct 2021 8:03]
| | | |
| QPR vs Sunderland - Losing Match Thread on 08:14 - Oct 27 with 1768 views | superhoopdownunder |
| QPR vs Sunderland - Losing Match Thread on 07:50 - Oct 27 by HamptonR |
My take on it, at the time, was that the lino was told to signal offside, whether that was the fourth official, via Stroud or by Stroud himself, god only knows, but why else would he wait so long to put his flag up.
I don't believe the lino called it.
What feasible explanation can there be for such a delay,
Edited - However Stroud does appear to signal for a goal, perhaps he remembered that he had not been the center of attention for nearly 90 minutes. [Post edited 27 Oct 2021 8:03]
|
I think the fourth official got involved and communicated what he thought to Shroud and the linesmen | | | |
| QPR vs Sunderland - Losing Match Thread on 08:30 - Oct 27 with 1715 views | Mick_S |
| QPR vs Sunderland - Losing Match Thread on 08:14 - Oct 27 by superhoopdownunder |
I think the fourth official got involved and communicated what he thought to Shroud and the linesmen |
I’ve never heard of such a thing. Why would he do that unless he was asked to?
Has this happened before?
Man, we need Pinner on here double quick time. |  |
| Did I ever mention that I was in Minder? |
| |
| QPR vs Sunderland - Losing Match Thread on 08:38 - Oct 27 with 1671 views | traininvain |
Another moan. Why did the game last night go straight from 90 mins to penalties?
I understand the logic in the first 2/3 rounds of the competition but when we’re talking about places in the quarter finals, possible latter stages and the potential money involved. Surely it makes sense to have extra time after 90 mins. |  | | |
Login to get fewer ads
| QPR vs Sunderland - Losing Match Thread on 08:38 - Oct 27 with 1669 views | Ned_Kennedys |
| QPR vs Sunderland - Losing Match Thread on 08:14 - Oct 27 by superhoopdownunder |
I think the fourth official got involved and communicated what he thought to Shroud and the linesmen |
This HAS to be the linesman making a monumental feck up: anything else is going down a Stainrods Elbow mad conspiracy rabbit hole. |  | | |
| QPR vs Sunderland - Losing Match Thread on 08:40 - Oct 27 with 1659 views | superhoopdownunder |
| QPR vs Sunderland - Losing Match Thread on 08:30 - Oct 27 by Mick_S |
I’ve never heard of such a thing. Why would he do that unless he was asked to?
Has this happened before?
Man, we need Pinner on here double quick time. |
Me neither but I’m guessing based on what happened and what Warburton said after the game
https://www.qpr.co.uk/news/club-news/warburton-on-carabao-cup-exit-261021/
Charlie Austin’s offside goal
“I have just seen the incident again and it is quite staggering how clearly onside Charlie is.
“At this level a mistake like that is so costly for so many reasons. There was the opportunity to get into the quarter-finals of a major tournament, there are the financial implications for the club.
“The players’ reaction normally tells you if it might be offside - they turned to celebrate straight away. They knew it was onside.
“The fourth told me immediately that it was offside. From my viewpoint I couldn’t really argue against that. But when you see it back, well, my word.
“The image I have just seen of it — we aren’t talking about inches. It is very clear Charlie is onside and you have to get those calls right. When the officials look back at it I am sure they will be equally staggered.” [Post edited 27 Oct 2021 8:42]
| | | |
| QPR vs Sunderland - Losing Match Thread on 09:00 - Oct 27 with 1601 views | HamptonR |
| QPR vs Sunderland - Losing Match Thread on 08:30 - Oct 27 by Mick_S |
I’ve never heard of such a thing. Why would he do that unless he was asked to?
Has this happened before?
Man, we need Pinner on here double quick time. |
Wouldn't be the first time.
Wasn't Zidane's world cup head butt seen by the fourth official, who informed the ref?
Phil Dowd sent a player off, a few seasons ago, after consulting via the mic and earpiece with the fourth official, I can't remember the game, I think it involved Arsenal.
Either way, it is not a conspiracy, its a monumental cock up, somebody made a bad call but I don't think it was the lino.
In my line of work and my life in general, my feck ups occur instantly, I never wait a few seconds to balls it up, I do it straight away. | | | |
| QPR vs Sunderland - Losing Match Thread on 09:59 - Oct 27 with 1512 views | RangersDave |
The Lino's just turned up at his local Ferrari dealership this morning, with a wad of macken notes bulging out of his pockets.
And why oh why arent we demonstrative and get up in the officials grills as much as other teams?
It seems other teams do it a lot, we should to. |  |
| |
| QPR vs Sunderland - Losing Match Thread on 14:51 - Oct 27 with 1339 views | PinnerPaul |
| QPR vs Sunderland - Losing Match Thread on 22:34 - Oct 26 by traininvain |
That’s my understanding so it’s onside as a defender and keeper were both playing Austin on. |
Have to have two players or the ball between you and the goal line.
It wasn't obvious live, but as this level, that's often the case - its a poor decision. | | | |
| QPR vs Sunderland - Losing Match Thread on 15:07 - Oct 27 with 1322 views | WatfordR |
| QPR vs Sunderland - Losing Match Thread on 08:14 - Oct 27 by superhoopdownunder |
I think the fourth official got involved and communicated what he thought to Shroud and the linesmen |
My feeling was, reading Warb's comments about being told "immediately" by the fourth official that it was offside, that the fourth official's mic may have been on, and that both Stroud and the linesman heard the "offside" comments made by him, which led to the lino and Stroud having a chat and the lino then putting his flag up.
This is based on nothing other than trying to work out why it took the lino so long to flag. He clearly didn't appear to think there was an offside, and Stroud was already pointing back to the centre circle, so who else could have made the call? |  | | |
| QPR vs Sunderland - Losing Match Thread on 15:27 - Oct 27 with 1304 views | PinnerPaul |
| QPR vs Sunderland - Losing Match Thread on 15:07 - Oct 27 by WatfordR |
My feeling was, reading Warb's comments about being told "immediately" by the fourth official that it was offside, that the fourth official's mic may have been on, and that both Stroud and the linesman heard the "offside" comments made by him, which led to the lino and Stroud having a chat and the lino then putting his flag up.
This is based on nothing other than trying to work out why it took the lino so long to flag. He clearly didn't appear to think there was an offside, and Stroud was already pointing back to the centre circle, so who else could have made the call? |
That's a sensible assumption, but two points
1) 4th official isn't supposed to use the monitor and
2) It looked on side on TV, less so live. | | | |
| QPR vs Sunderland - Losing Match Thread on 15:42 - Oct 27 with 1262 views | WatfordR |
| QPR vs Sunderland - Losing Match Thread on 15:27 - Oct 27 by PinnerPaul |
That's a sensible assumption, but two points
1) 4th official isn't supposed to use the monitor and
2) It looked on side on TV, less so live. |
I mean, something isn't right here is it though?
Stroud has given the goal and is heading back to the centre circle, the lino is standing there having not raised his flag, and the fourth official is telling Warbs "immediately" that the goal is offside.
If Stroud doesn't call it, and the fourth official doesn't call it, are we to assume the lino is telling the other two "ooh...hang on, it might have been offside, I'm not sure, what shall I do?" | | | |
| QPR vs Sunderland - Losing Match Thread on 21:08 - Oct 27 with 1123 views | stainrods_elbow |
| QPR vs Sunderland - Losing Match Thread on 08:38 - Oct 27 by Ned_Kennedys |
This HAS to be the linesman making a monumental feck up: anything else is going down a Stainrods Elbow mad conspiracy rabbit hole. |
Let's call it a conspiracy of incompetence if you prefer - happy now? Either way, negligence or corruption, the outcome's the same for f*cked-over QPR. If I were a Sunderland player and had even a sliver of integrity, I'd feel like shit going through in the way they did. |  |
| |
| QPR vs Sunderland - Losing Match Thread on 21:18 - Oct 27 with 1115 views | dachiltern |
On the night and sat in SA Rd as usual in normal time i could understand why the Lino thought it may have been offside. However, ref can overall, looked confident by awarding the goal and between them all they fooled up, que sera, disappointing but sh it happens.
My question is, Sunderland made seven changes from the team that played Saturday and to be fair looked decent, would we look as comfortable if we made seven changes? Our lads have in the last few games looked as if they are running on thin air, important players are either injured or carrying injuries and the squad looks thin. Just saying. |  | | |
| Keith Shroud on 07:55 - Dec 28 with 772 views | superhoopdownunder |
I tried to place a same game accumulator bet just on knowing what he would do - book a few of our players and send one off and help Bournemouth win - unfortunately I could not put them in an accumulator as that was a certainty.
He should never manage our games again as he is biased against QPR and towards Bournemouth.
We should make an official complaint against this clown.
He is not competent and stinks of corruption.
All we want is a level playing field. | | | |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
