| Tonight's referee on 09:34 - Feb 26 with 1845 views | WrightUp5hit___ |
He's not good on big decisions, so who's he going to upset tonight? |  | |  |
| Tonight's referee on 16:37 - Feb 26 with 1735 views | PinnerPaul |
| Tonight's referee on 09:34 - Feb 26 by WrightUp5hit___ |
He's not good on big decisions, so who's he going to upset tonight? |
Everyone, as per I expect! |  | | |
| Tonight's referee on 23:28 - Feb 26 with 1621 views | stowmarketrange |
| Tonight's referee on 16:37 - Feb 26 by PinnerPaul |
Everyone, as per I expect! |
Only us again.At one point in the 2nd half he had to stop play to tuck his Leeds shirt back into his shorts. |  | | |
| Tonight's referee on 23:42 - Feb 26 with 1566 views | QPR_John |
| Tonight's referee on 23:28 - Feb 26 by stowmarketrange |
Only us again.At one point in the 2nd half he had to stop play to tuck his Leeds shirt back into his shorts. |
I don't think referees are biased simply incompetent. I don't know what orders they get but I thought a deliberate foul like pulling a player back was a yellow card but no although kick the ball away at a free kick the card comes out immediately. Then there was the deliberate handball seconds before half time. | | | |
| Tonight's referee on 23:46 - Feb 26 with 1554 views | dachiltern |
One thing that can be said was that he was consistent at being inconsistent. Bizarre is just one word to describe his decision making. Hey ho, after some of the decision from the weekends Prem I make him bang on for promotion. |  | | |
| Tonight's referee on 23:56 - Feb 26 with 1537 views | Stanisgod |
Perhaps Pinner can help here but one of their players had no name or number on his shirt a lot of the game.
Is this OK, although to be fair I assumed the ref had it on his!
Absolutely bizarre performance, putting the ball on the exact blade of grass for free kicks, sometimes, and then letting them decide for him where our throw ons should be taken. |  |
| It's being so happy that keeps me going. |
| |
| Tonight's referee on 01:02 - Feb 27 with 1457 views | DavieQPR |
| Tonight's referee on 23:56 - Feb 26 by Stanisgod |
Perhaps Pinner can help here but one of their players had no name or number on his shirt a lot of the game.
Is this OK, although to be fair I assumed the ref had it on his!
Absolutely bizarre performance, putting the ball on the exact blade of grass for free kicks, sometimes, and then letting them decide for him where our throw ons should be taken. |
Replacement shirts for bloodied ones don't have numbers and are permissible. |  | | |
| Tonight's referee on 10:15 - Feb 27 with 1221 views | smegma |
I thought the ref had a good game last night. But not according to some comments in SAR. I think it was BOS who appeared to go down in the box second half, bloke behind screamed 'if it aint a penalty why not book him for diving then ?'. Err, because it wasn't a dive , he fell over due to his momentum . Again when Izzy Brown committed a foul just after getting booked. Same bloke screamed 'you bottled it ref'. Err no. Every foul is not necessary a yellow card irrespective if the player has already been booked. If that was the case both sides would have had 14 yellow cards each. The same when Brown got his yellow and Scowen got booked shortly after and opposition fans screaming for a red card ??? and as for him insisting free kicks being taken an extra yard away on quite a few occasions, it ate up time and frustrated Leeds to hell, so well done Andy Davies !! | | | |
Login to get fewer ads
| Tonight's referee on 14:14 - Feb 27 with 1082 views | PinnerPaul |
OK - tin hat on …..again
Shirts - Competition rules - numbers/names requirement not actually in the LOTG
Another orange card last night - Brown this time - added to the one v WBA and Scowen v Portsmouth. As I've said before at this level and above, these 'oranges' are more often called as yellow rather than red. The 2nd foul, soon after was never another yellow in a million years.
Bamford handball - I think the HT whistle saved him. Luongo foul (and correct yellow) took place with 10 seconds to go. Ref had made his mind up to blow for HT almost as soon as ball is kicked. Needed ARs help (via comms) to see the handball and as he was blowing for HT they clearly didn't have time to sort out the possible yellow.
Wells - that was delaying the restart all day long and tbf Cousins had been warned about it 1st half when he did the same.
Scowen's yellow - well even the most rabid ref hater couldn't disagree with that surely!
Added time - 1st half - 1min for the head injury.
2nd half - 3 subs, 1 goal, 2 'injuries' - Pav and Cousins - and a bit of timewasting - so 5 prob about right.
Foul on Cousins? - Not for me, his momentum caused him to fall over.
He did miss a fairly obvious handball by Pav 2nd half.
ARs good for me
Usual disclaimer - all of the above seen only once live from T block! | | | |
| Tonight's referee on 15:44 - Feb 27 with 1037 views | loftboy |
| Tonight's referee on 10:15 - Feb 27 by smegma |
I thought the ref had a good game last night. But not according to some comments in SAR. I think it was BOS who appeared to go down in the box second half, bloke behind screamed 'if it aint a penalty why not book him for diving then ?'. Err, because it wasn't a dive , he fell over due to his momentum . Again when Izzy Brown committed a foul just after getting booked. Same bloke screamed 'you bottled it ref'. Err no. Every foul is not necessary a yellow card irrespective if the player has already been booked. If that was the case both sides would have had 14 yellow cards each. The same when Brown got his yellow and Scowen got booked shortly after and opposition fans screaming for a red card ??? and as for him insisting free kicks being taken an extra yard away on quite a few occasions, it ate up time and frustrated Leeds to hell, so well done Andy Davies !! |
Izzy Browns first tackle was borderline red, the second he led with his elbow and was at least a yellow, he was a very lucky boy. |  |
| |
| Tonight's referee on 16:08 - Feb 27 with 981 views | QPR_John |
| Tonight's referee on 14:14 - Feb 27 by PinnerPaul |
OK - tin hat on …..again
Shirts - Competition rules - numbers/names requirement not actually in the LOTG
Another orange card last night - Brown this time - added to the one v WBA and Scowen v Portsmouth. As I've said before at this level and above, these 'oranges' are more often called as yellow rather than red. The 2nd foul, soon after was never another yellow in a million years.
Bamford handball - I think the HT whistle saved him. Luongo foul (and correct yellow) took place with 10 seconds to go. Ref had made his mind up to blow for HT almost as soon as ball is kicked. Needed ARs help (via comms) to see the handball and as he was blowing for HT they clearly didn't have time to sort out the possible yellow.
Wells - that was delaying the restart all day long and tbf Cousins had been warned about it 1st half when he did the same.
Scowen's yellow - well even the most rabid ref hater couldn't disagree with that surely!
Added time - 1st half - 1min for the head injury.
2nd half - 3 subs, 1 goal, 2 'injuries' - Pav and Cousins - and a bit of timewasting - so 5 prob about right.
Foul on Cousins? - Not for me, his momentum caused him to fall over.
He did miss a fairly obvious handball by Pav 2nd half.
ARs good for me
Usual disclaimer - all of the above seen only once live from T block! |
"Bamford handball - I think the HT whistle saved him."
Yes that's what I said at the time but why. He did not know the ref was about to end the half and he deliberately handle the ball with intent to gain an advantage. The fact that he did not is immaterial. | | | |
| Tonight's referee on 16:31 - Feb 27 with 922 views | Antti_Heinola |
| Tonight's referee on 10:15 - Feb 27 by smegma |
I thought the ref had a good game last night. But not according to some comments in SAR. I think it was BOS who appeared to go down in the box second half, bloke behind screamed 'if it aint a penalty why not book him for diving then ?'. Err, because it wasn't a dive , he fell over due to his momentum . Again when Izzy Brown committed a foul just after getting booked. Same bloke screamed 'you bottled it ref'. Err no. Every foul is not necessary a yellow card irrespective if the player has already been booked. If that was the case both sides would have had 14 yellow cards each. The same when Brown got his yellow and Scowen got booked shortly after and opposition fans screaming for a red card ??? and as for him insisting free kicks being taken an extra yard away on quite a few occasions, it ate up time and frustrated Leeds to hell, so well done Andy Davies !! |
you must sit near me, smegs.
Although I thought Brown was very, very lucky to stay on the pitch. The first one was pretty much a red, to foul so soon after - i felt he should've gone. |  |
| |
| Tonight's referee on 16:45 - Feb 27 with 906 views | DevonWhite |
Alioski was allowed to do pretty much anything he liked without even coming to close to a booking. A snide kick out at Wells after the ball had gone for a throw? Absolutely fine apparently.
5 bookings for us and just 1 for them (which arguably should've been a red). It definitely felt (watching on TV) that he was far more lenient with Leeds. | | | |
| Tonight's referee on 17:02 - Feb 27 with 870 views | BuckR |
| Tonight's referee on 14:14 - Feb 27 by PinnerPaul |
OK - tin hat on …..again
Shirts - Competition rules - numbers/names requirement not actually in the LOTG
Another orange card last night - Brown this time - added to the one v WBA and Scowen v Portsmouth. As I've said before at this level and above, these 'oranges' are more often called as yellow rather than red. The 2nd foul, soon after was never another yellow in a million years.
Bamford handball - I think the HT whistle saved him. Luongo foul (and correct yellow) took place with 10 seconds to go. Ref had made his mind up to blow for HT almost as soon as ball is kicked. Needed ARs help (via comms) to see the handball and as he was blowing for HT they clearly didn't have time to sort out the possible yellow.
Wells - that was delaying the restart all day long and tbf Cousins had been warned about it 1st half when he did the same.
Scowen's yellow - well even the most rabid ref hater couldn't disagree with that surely!
Added time - 1st half - 1min for the head injury.
2nd half - 3 subs, 1 goal, 2 'injuries' - Pav and Cousins - and a bit of timewasting - so 5 prob about right.
Foul on Cousins? - Not for me, his momentum caused him to fall over.
He did miss a fairly obvious handball by Pav 2nd half.
ARs good for me
Usual disclaimer - all of the above seen only once live from T block! |
Agree with most of that apart from the 1 minute stoppage time in the 1st half. Leeds were time wasting horrifically when they were down to 10 for about 10 minutes. We were on the up and they were trying to kill the game any way they could. Seems just the norm for 1 min to be added in the 1st half then 4/5 for the second half! | | | |
| Tonight's referee on 18:20 - Feb 27 with 788 views | DavieQPR |
If the ref makes a decision against us then he is wrong- but then I am completely biased. | | | |
| Tonight's referee on 13:25 - Feb 28 with 614 views | PinnerPaul |
| Tonight's referee on 16:08 - Feb 27 by QPR_John |
"Bamford handball - I think the HT whistle saved him."
Yes that's what I said at the time but why. He did not know the ref was about to end the half and he deliberately handle the ball with intent to gain an advantage. The fact that he did not is immaterial. |
I agree. Just trying to explain/guess why he didn't get a card.
Referee lost concentration/focus as it was literally 1 second before half time I think - as I said any other time in the game he asks AR on comms for confirmation and then gives the yellow. | | | |
| Tonight's referee on 13:28 - Feb 28 with 606 views | PinnerPaul |
| Tonight's referee on 16:31 - Feb 27 by Antti_Heinola |
you must sit near me, smegs.
Although I thought Brown was very, very lucky to stay on the pitch. The first one was pretty much a red, to foul so soon after - i felt he should've gone. |
OK, putting the first foul aside - I said it was an 'orange' so not arguing big if anyone thinks a red.
However the fact he then committed a 2nd foul so soon after is irrelevant to the 1st foul and whether he should get a 2nd yellow.
There are 7 yellow card offences and 'committing a foul 30 seconds after receiving a yellow' isn't one of them! | | | |
| Tonight's referee on 13:54 - Feb 28 with 583 views | Watford_Ranger |
| Tonight's referee on 13:28 - Feb 28 by PinnerPaul |
OK, putting the first foul aside - I said it was an 'orange' so not arguing big if anyone thinks a red.
However the fact he then committed a 2nd foul so soon after is irrelevant to the 1st foul and whether he should get a 2nd yellow.
There are 7 yellow card offences and 'committing a foul 30 seconds after receiving a yellow' isn't one of them! |
The severity of the second foul warranted a yellow though.
Out of interest, when you’ve given a yellow for an ‘orange’ foul, do you think refs are quicker to give the second yellow? If not, should they be? | | | |
| Tonight's referee on 17:56 - Feb 28 with 529 views | PinnerPaul |
| Tonight's referee on 13:54 - Feb 28 by Watford_Ranger |
The severity of the second foul warranted a yellow though.
Out of interest, when you’ve given a yellow for an ‘orange’ foul, do you think refs are quicker to give the second yellow? If not, should they be? |
Just watched it again in full and can't agree on the 2nd foul - nothing in that at all.
Re the 2nd point, no & no.
If anything some refs are actually more reluctant to give a 2nd yellow - shouldn't work like that, 2nd yellow should be on 'merit' and has nothing to do with the 1st. | | | |
| Tonight's referee on 18:56 - Feb 28 with 512 views | ozranger |
| Tonight's referee on 17:56 - Feb 28 by PinnerPaul |
Just watched it again in full and can't agree on the 2nd foul - nothing in that at all.
Re the 2nd point, no & no.
If anything some refs are actually more reluctant to give a 2nd yellow - shouldn't work like that, 2nd yellow should be on 'merit' and has nothing to do with the 1st. |
So, what you are saying is that there is a grey area where yellows are concerned when they are probably red, orange or brown. And yet, these grey areas appear to be black and white to others. Perhaps we really need to give the officials a green light to hand out a red when its brown and a yellow when its orange. Of course, if the ref is colour blind... |  | | |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
