Please log in or register. Registered visitors get fewer ads.
Prediction Logged by at 23:13:21
Sunderland v Queens Park Rangers prediction logged
Rednapp v Warnock
at 14:45 19 Sep 2013

With Harry suggesting Kranscar would play in behind Austin, we have the intriguing possibility of mapping Harry's team with the same 4-2-3-1 formation that Colin employed so successfully just 3 years ago. (Harry wouldn't play a clunky 4-4-1-1 would he?)

Assuming we are comparing like formations, we are far enough into the season to start making opinionated judgements!

Let's start with where we are after 7 games

P W D L F A Pts
Warnock 7 6 1 0 19 2 19
Rednapp 7 5 2 0 7 2 17

Player for Player mostly (compare Warnock's with how they were then) - based on Kranscar in place

Kenny v Green; Green shades it
Orr/Walker v Simpson; Simpson over Orr, Walker over Simpson
Connelly v Onuoha; Ned, I would have to say
Gorkks v Dunne; again, Dunne I would have to say
Hill10 v Hill13/BAE; Hill13 as good as Hill10 - but BAE probably better than Hill10 (Q. If he's also better than Hill13, what happens when Ned returns from injury?)
Faurlin10 v Barton; Hard to split them on a Then and Now basis; Faurlin13 sadly inferior to Faurlin10 at this time.
Derry v Henry; Derry - attitude, visibility, commitment, authenticity, leadership
Routledge v Hoilett; Still Routledge for me but close. Hoilett could readily change my mind
Tarrabt v Kranscar; Great reputation-and-achievement signing by Harry I'm sure - but it's hard to see him transcending the Championship player of the 2010/2011 season. Warnock built the entire team around Adel - as Stock did around Rodney - and it paid off big time.
Smith/Buszaky v perm 1 from Carroll, Jenas, Faurlin13, Phillips, SWP and several others. This all needs to settle down before we can compare. I just wonder id Franscar might be the new Buszaky rather than the new Tarrabt...
Helguson v Austin; call me unfair but the Iceman is on a far planet in a distant galaxy..
I wish he was still here.

Overall. Warnock's team gelled from Day 1, Harry is still Work In Progress so right now we are comparing a team with an XI if you get the distinction.

There's a famous TV series called 7 up which compares a bunch of kids, now pensioners every 7 years of their life. Might do the same here after 14, 21 games etc.

Now have your say..
Calm down! Sober Reflection In The Fullness Of Time
at 11:26 29 Jan 2013

Not often you can reference both the late Michael Winner and even later Sir Humphrey in the same review but it works here

After Sober Reflection In The Fullness Of Time, Saturday's debacle can be seen to be entirely predictable

Fringe players
Not match sharp
No team acquaintanceship with each other (is there such a word?)
No leadership on the field
No incentive from Harry - even match magazine FA Cup comments were lukewarm
No motivation or desire - they knew they wouldn't be back tonight
Utterly complacent - especially after netting within 2 minutes
Bad luck with first goal. "One of those days" as Smithy remarked several times in the first half as MK repeatedly cleared their panic lines

MK suffered from none of the above

Other posters have forensicly examined individual performance and - Park and Ferdinand aside - found difficulty in condemning individual performances outright

Easy to predict 9 or 10 changes tonight, but, more interestingly, who will fill the bench? Those least tainted by Saturday's debacle...

Bench prediction: Green, Ben Haim, Traore, Mackie, Bothroyd. Plus Young and Ephraim - who were relieved not to have been involved on Saturday.

Calm down! Until maybe 21.45hrs...
[Post edited 1 Jan 1970 1:00]
Please log in to use all the site's facilities


Site Scores

Forum Votes: 0
Comment Votes: -1
Prediction League: 3
About Us Contact Us Terms & Conditions Privacy Cookies Advertising
© FansNetwork 2022