| Formation Conundrum - Fans Choices? 16:37 - Aug 16 with 25647 views | beat_the_bishop | Interestingly, scanning across various teams set up, including Stockport, York, Oldham, Salford and Barnet (and many others) all have a back four. I know the general consensus is to revert to a 3 and wingbacks either side and I full understand why… it seems the trend at the moment is a 4 which if we pursue it, I do wonder how we would look along the lines of the below… Ramming Moss Ebanks Maguire Beckwith Petit Smith Gilmour Hayes East Mani Obviously the above is based on fitness and availability. With the squad as it as today and injuries and as others have mentioned just familiarity I would go... Ramming Moss Ebanks Wilson Tar Hannant Gilmour Duberry East Brown Mani D The above still doesn’t fill me with confidence but I think it’s more likely to sure us up a bit. Wilson hasn’t impressed me on his brief cameos but he needs a start and go from there. Hendo for brown if he isn’t happy in the 10 after 60 minutes. What would others do? [Post edited 16 Aug 16:38]
|  | | |  |
| Formation Conundrum - Fans Choices? on 11:57 - Aug 26 | dingdangblue |
| Formation Conundrum - Fans Choices? on 10:40 - Aug 26 by DaleiLama | He's not been able to finish for quite a while sadly. |
Or start. |  |
|  |
| Formation Conundrum - Fans Choices? on 08:53 - Nov 15 | beat_the_bishop | I’m revisiting this thread because it’s 3 months on and the same question is as relevant now as it was then. With 30 odd players, I have zero clue what our best team is. More importantly, how you utilise them. Kane Taylor at left back and Silcott in the centre or number 10 certainly isn’t that. Watson aside, I need a sensible debate based on what we know now. And what as fans would do to / believe would turn our fortunates? What is abundantly evident to me is we need more support around Brown. And more support in front of the back line. Do you sacrifice wingers to accommodate this? [Post edited 15 Nov 8:55]
|  | |  |
| Formation Conundrum - Fans Choices? on 09:16 - Nov 15 | 442Dale |
| Formation Conundrum - Fans Choices? on 08:53 - Nov 15 by beat_the_bishop | I’m revisiting this thread because it’s 3 months on and the same question is as relevant now as it was then. With 30 odd players, I have zero clue what our best team is. More importantly, how you utilise them. Kane Taylor at left back and Silcott in the centre or number 10 certainly isn’t that. Watson aside, I need a sensible debate based on what we know now. And what as fans would do to / believe would turn our fortunates? What is abundantly evident to me is we need more support around Brown. And more support in front of the back line. Do you sacrifice wingers to accommodate this? [Post edited 15 Nov 8:55]
|
Brown, for all his hard work, doesn’t contribute enough to our play when we have the ball or worry defenders enough. Sone of that isn’t his fault as he’s far too isolated in the formation we have. That same structure which lets down defenders on the ball, midfielders who get overran when we lose it. Possible solutions? From the other thread: We could switch to wing-backs (TAR and Hannant… or even play a winger on the left, Middleton has the capacity). 3 central defenders (Wilson, Flint/EEL, Bilongo). 3 in midfield (from the six we have). 2 up front (Henderson has to start) Or a proper 4-3-3 with proper midfielders closer together. Not career forwards who want to play no.10. If you think of the 10s we had last season, some could play in midfield too. The likes of Barlow and Burger actually did as one of the two to good effect. Silcott-Duberry, Paterson, Brown? If they’re expected to contribute defensively near our goal then we won’t ever sort out how open we are. Then when Dieseruvwe is fit (why no update?) get him back in to the 3-4-3 or 3-5-2 formations. It’s a personal opinion and one I can accept the reasons for not being shared, but I think Mani has been let down when he played because of how far away any support was (the same problem Broen has but he adds more with his running). It was assumed he’d love wingers getting crosses in. Maybe, but I reckon he’d love clever players around him who he can link with more. A good goalscorer will always be that. Finishing chances and being in the right place is something that sometimes comes naturally. Dieseruvwe started five league games. If we’re writing him off after that without trying to adapt to get more out of him, it’ll be another mistake in a long list of them. |  |
|  |
| Formation Conundrum - Fans Choices? on 09:17 - Nov 15 | D_Alien |
| Formation Conundrum - Fans Choices? on 08:53 - Nov 15 by beat_the_bishop | I’m revisiting this thread because it’s 3 months on and the same question is as relevant now as it was then. With 30 odd players, I have zero clue what our best team is. More importantly, how you utilise them. Kane Taylor at left back and Silcott in the centre or number 10 certainly isn’t that. Watson aside, I need a sensible debate based on what we know now. And what as fans would do to / believe would turn our fortunates? What is abundantly evident to me is we need more support around Brown. And more support in front of the back line. Do you sacrifice wingers to accommodate this? [Post edited 15 Nov 8:55]
|
Sorry btb, and even though i engage in them myself, but these tactics debates are useless until we have a more tactically astute manager EDIT: Let me update that, with an example. Pre-match yesterday, 442 and I (and others joined in) posted multiple times on how Jamie Allen might fit into the starting lineup. On being pushed, i suggested ZSD should be the one omitted. We needed a solid base: Allen, Gilmour, Adeeko When the starting line-up was announced, it was obvious there were flaws and that's exactly how it panned out. After a promising start, York gradually took hold of the game with ZSD missing in action (not really his fault) So, what's the point of these debates? As fans, of course we're interested in these things, but yesterday showed just how pointless it was (literally) [Post edited 15 Nov 11:29]
|  |
|  |
| Formation Conundrum - Fans Choices? on 11:59 - Nov 15 | 442Dale |
| Formation Conundrum - Fans Choices? on 09:17 - Nov 15 by D_Alien | Sorry btb, and even though i engage in them myself, but these tactics debates are useless until we have a more tactically astute manager EDIT: Let me update that, with an example. Pre-match yesterday, 442 and I (and others joined in) posted multiple times on how Jamie Allen might fit into the starting lineup. On being pushed, i suggested ZSD should be the one omitted. We needed a solid base: Allen, Gilmour, Adeeko When the starting line-up was announced, it was obvious there were flaws and that's exactly how it panned out. After a promising start, York gradually took hold of the game with ZSD missing in action (not really his fault) So, what's the point of these debates? As fans, of course we're interested in these things, but yesterday showed just how pointless it was (literally) [Post edited 15 Nov 11:29]
|
Except if ZSD was going to the only one left out from last week’s team, that would have meant Paterson joining Allen and Gilmour in midfield. Not Adeeko who would have been on the bench (as noted in the posts in the discussion pre-match). Paterson can only play the 10 and having spent his career in advanced positions, would not have helped solve the recognised issue around how open we are between defence and midfield when the other side get the ball. Paterson’s absence probably led to Silcott-Duberry starting. But that’s only a guess. Hearing the views of fans on here, like in the pub is always worthwhile. [Post edited 15 Nov 12:03]
|  |
|  |
| Formation Conundrum - Fans Choices? on 13:34 - Nov 15 | D_Alien |
| Formation Conundrum - Fans Choices? on 11:59 - Nov 15 by 442Dale | Except if ZSD was going to the only one left out from last week’s team, that would have meant Paterson joining Allen and Gilmour in midfield. Not Adeeko who would have been on the bench (as noted in the posts in the discussion pre-match). Paterson can only play the 10 and having spent his career in advanced positions, would not have helped solve the recognised issue around how open we are between defence and midfield when the other side get the ball. Paterson’s absence probably led to Silcott-Duberry starting. But that’s only a guess. Hearing the views of fans on here, like in the pub is always worthwhile. [Post edited 15 Nov 12:03]
|
Yes, and whilst i wasn't remotely suggesting debates shouldn't happen, or that "the views of fans" aren't valuable (i'd be a hypocrite to suggest that) but i was pointing out how very specific points come to naught in very short order Even so...a midfield of Adeeko and Gilmour with Allen given a free role (as required) would've been the much better option, despite what your interpretation of "structure" might be |  |
|  |
| Formation Conundrum - Fans Choices? on 14:01 - Nov 15 | 442Dale |
| Formation Conundrum - Fans Choices? on 13:34 - Nov 15 by D_Alien | Yes, and whilst i wasn't remotely suggesting debates shouldn't happen, or that "the views of fans" aren't valuable (i'd be a hypocrite to suggest that) but i was pointing out how very specific points come to naught in very short order Even so...a midfield of Adeeko and Gilmour with Allen given a free role (as required) would've been the much better option, despite what your interpretation of "structure" might be |
We are lacking in one that makes us hard to beat. That seems to be almost everyone’s interpretation. |  |
|  |
| Formation Conundrum - Fans Choices? on 14:11 - Nov 15 | Toffeemanc |
| Formation Conundrum - Fans Choices? on 14:01 - Nov 15 by 442Dale | We are lacking in one that makes us hard to beat. That seems to be almost everyone’s interpretation. |
We’re also lacking a manager who is able to identify this issue and correct it. Nothing will change until Watson and his team are relieved of their duties and it can’t happen soon enough. |  |
|  | Login to get fewer ads
| Formation Conundrum - Fans Choices? on 15:55 - Nov 15 | D_Alien |
| Formation Conundrum - Fans Choices? on 14:11 - Nov 15 by Toffeemanc | We’re also lacking a manager who is able to identify this issue and correct it. Nothing will change until Watson and his team are relieved of their duties and it can’t happen soon enough. |
That's why these debates around rearranging deckchairs on the Titanic are of little value Pointing this out isn't about closing down debate |  |
|  |
| Formation Conundrum - Fans Choices? on 16:25 - Nov 15 | 442Dale |
| Formation Conundrum - Fans Choices? on 14:11 - Nov 15 by Toffeemanc | We’re also lacking a manager who is able to identify this issue and correct it. Nothing will change until Watson and his team are relieved of their duties and it can’t happen soon enough. |
Though in fairness, beatthebishop did make a point of saying “Watson aside”. Hence the discussion around what we have in the squad, how they could be best utilised whoever the manager is. The extended highlights on York’s YouTube adds further weight to arguments around possible solutions to the recognisable problems. |  |
|  |
| Formation Conundrum - Fans Choices? on 17:06 - Nov 15 | D_Alien |
| Formation Conundrum - Fans Choices? on 16:25 - Nov 15 by 442Dale | Though in fairness, beatthebishop did make a point of saying “Watson aside”. Hence the discussion around what we have in the squad, how they could be best utilised whoever the manager is. The extended highlights on York’s YouTube adds further weight to arguments around possible solutions to the recognisable problems. |
Paterson, Taylor, Smith, not to mention McGuire and due to newness in L2, Pettit (and i'm sure there's others) but we haven't seen anywhere near enough of them at this level for sound judgements to be made They could all turn out to make a difference, and i hope they do |  |
|  |
| Formation Conundrum - Fans Choices? on 22:56 - Nov 16 | BlueWizard |
| Formation Conundrum - Fans Choices? on 17:06 - Nov 15 by D_Alien | Paterson, Taylor, Smith, not to mention McGuire and due to newness in L2, Pettit (and i'm sure there's others) but we haven't seen anywhere near enough of them at this level for sound judgements to be made They could all turn out to make a difference, and i hope they do |
As I said on another thread this will be interesting, I watched training for a short while last Thursday when I was going past in Manchester and made a point of having a watch, Smith, Paterson & Maguire were training so I do believe they must be knocking on the door now .. Fingers crossed I do believe they will make a big difference, I also think it's time to give Wilson a rest too many errors although he has gone a bit better but think he's still too far off for this league. |  | |  |
| Formation Conundrum - Fans Choices? on 14:33 - Nov 17 | 49thseason | On the basis that Maguire is training (again) and the assumption that Paterson can play a left wing role or drop into a midfield 4 were it neccessary ,this would be my starting 11, the subs would depend on the opposition, and the suspected fragility of Maguire and Beckwith on the same side of the pitch. A selection for an away game at a top 10 club should be different to the selection for a home game against near- table rivals..We are getting to the must win at home and try to nick points away from home situation. We have to assume that players with 100s of games behind them present a safer proposition than young players prone to rookie mistakes. Even then , at a more granular level, Tasker would get my vote where Wilson perhaps doesn't.. horses for courses...utilise the squad ...similarly using Henderson and Hayes later in the game when the opposition is tiring is an obvious move. Going into the next transfer window, there are players who are unlikely to feature and who may want a move away, I think Taylor's contract is up in January so that might create 1 space. The fitness problem Rodney has might be an opportunity to mutually cancell his contract in some way. I would also try to offload Dieseruvwe in exchange for a more, ahem, "ebullient" Centre Forward...equally there are a number of players who might want to look for pastures new and I wouldn't try to stop most of them.... According to Transfermarkt, 18 Rochdale AFC players have contracts listed as expiring on 30 June 2027 (note that loan players such as Nils Ramming, Dajaune Brown, Charlie Tasker, and Kaiden Wilson are listed as expiring 31 May 2027, and Kane Taylor on 2 January 2027). Jenkins, Maguire ,Smith and Francis' contracts run out in June 2028 https://www.transfermarkt.com/ Waller Tasker, Flint, Maguire Beckwith East Gilmour Allen Smith Brown Paterson Spaven plus 6 more from: TAR Hayes ZSD Middleton Dieseruvwe Henderson EEL Wilson Adeeko Pettit Rodney Francis Hannant Taylor Sherring Bilongo Jenkins( INJURED) Moss ( INJURED) Ramming (INJURED) |  | |  |
| |