| Logan/Lillis 20:22 - Nov 19 with 4613 views | dingdangblue |
Both super keepers, both have their own attributes. I dont think Hill has anything against either and will chop and change it now while we have them both. If we lose a few with Logan in net Josh will come back in and vice versa. |  |
| |  |
| Logan/Lillis on 20:29 - Nov 19 with 3320 views | D_Alien |
Today demonstrated to me why Conrad should be no1
Due to misplaced passes in midfield before we'd scored, Swindon had a couple of fast breaks on goal which Conrad saw early, positioned himself precisely where it made it most difficult for them to score and saved the day. It could have been a different game, otherwise
His command of the area and defenders in front of him is also superior, instilling confidence, whilst his handling of balls into the area is never in doubt
That's not to say I don't rate Lillis - I do, but as I've said elsewhere, whilst Conrad is at the club (and failing any major loss of form) he should keep the jersey |  |
| |
| Logan/Lillis on 20:34 - Nov 19 with 3291 views | _dezzy |
Conrad was a lot more vocal today, and was even heard by many behind the goal in the 2nd half swearing at the defenders to get into position. |  |
| |
| Logan/Lillis on 20:55 - Nov 19 with 3194 views | nordenblue |
Logan is a FAR better keeper,there is no argument |  | | |
| Logan/Lillis on 21:09 - Nov 19 with 3131 views | 100notout |
| Logan/Lillis on 20:55 - Nov 19 by nordenblue |
Logan is a FAR better keeper,there is no argument |
he's eaten a few pies recently | |
| |
| Logan/Lillis on 21:16 - Nov 19 with 3108 views | rochedale |
Josh for me. Fitter, more agile, shot stopper. Conrad needs to lose 2 stone, he is very vocal and closes down fantastically, his distribution is also very good, but I'd have josh any day. |  |
| |
| Logan/Lillis on 21:29 - Nov 19 with 3057 views | nordenblue |
| Logan/Lillis on 21:09 - Nov 19 by 100notout |
he's eaten a few pies recently |
He's always been overweight,not had a bad career? | | | |
| Logan/Lillis on 21:33 - Nov 19 with 3040 views | fitzochris |
| Logan/Lillis on 21:09 - Nov 19 by 100notout |
he's eaten a few pies recently |
Keepers tend to benefit from a bit of extra natural padding. |  |
| |
| Logan/Lillis on 21:36 - Nov 19 with 3026 views | D_Alien |
| Logan/Lillis on 21:29 - Nov 19 by nordenblue |
He's always been overweight,not had a bad career? |
He doesn't even look overweight to me, it's just his natural physique. Are we really saying that Hilly would allow a player to overindulge with food then select him ahead of a keeper who hadn't made any errors recently? That's an insult to Hilly as much as anything (i don't mean you've said that)
If Conrad had a problem with mobility, he wouldn't be getting to the ball on the ground or in the air with such timing and facility. There's plenty of keepers down the ages who've had a similar physique, and it's just lazy thinking to accuse them of being overweight (again, i don't mean you)
[Post edited 19 Nov 2016 21:37]
| |
| |
Login to get fewer ads
| Logan/Lillis on 21:41 - Nov 19 with 2991 views | 100notout |
| Logan/Lillis on 21:29 - Nov 19 by nordenblue |
He's always been overweight,not had a bad career? |
Indeed he hasn't but to me he's piling on the pounds - got bitter tits than Linda Lusardi (Google it young 'uns).
I'd like to say it hasn't affected his game- maybe it hasn't but tbh I don't think he's been tested that much so I can't [Post edited 19 Nov 2016 21:54]
| |
| |
| Logan/Lillis on 21:45 - Nov 19 with 2968 views | Daley_Lama |
Made some very quick forward dashes and blocks today, aside from one moment in the FH where he dived to save, erm, nothing and we escaped a tap into an empty net with a last gasp defensive clearance for a corner.
He would have saved Davis penalty too |  |
| |
| Logan/Lillis on 21:46 - Nov 19 with 2962 views | D_Alien |
| Logan/Lillis on 21:41 - Nov 19 by 100notout |
Indeed he hasn't but to me he's piling on the pounds - got bitter tits than Linda Lusardi (Google it young 'uns).
I'd like to say it hasn't affected his game- maybe it hasn't but tbh I don't think he's been tested that much so I can't [Post edited 19 Nov 2016 21:54]
|
I think I know where you're coming from 100, and perhaps it's true that if he had a different natural physique, allied to his other skills, he'd have made a top class keeper - premier league standard. But for where he is right now, he's a class above with his physique taken into account.
PS: and don't mention Linda Lusardi, it gets R17 overexcited!
[Post edited 19 Nov 2016 21:48]
| |
| |
| Logan/Lillis on 21:58 - Nov 19 with 2913 views | dingdangblue |
He's always been a 'big lad'.
 | |
| |
| Logan/Lillis on 22:01 - Nov 19 with 2896 views | Daley_Lama |
He could weigh 500 pounds if he keeps the ball out.
Which he does blinking effectively. | |
| |
| Logan/Lillis on 22:02 - Nov 19 with 2892 views | D_Alien |
| Logan/Lillis on 21:58 - Nov 19 by dingdangblue |
He's always been a 'big lad'.
|
Compared with:
 | |
| |
| Logan/Lillis on 22:08 - Nov 19 with 2853 views | DaleiLama |
| Logan/Lillis on 22:02 - Nov 19 by D_Alien |
Compared with:
|
Looks fresh out of the shower but would have been better advised to use Swarfega to shift R17s pearl necklace?
PS I can't believe how huge Logan is. He's put on a hundredweight since I last saw him. Must have really missed the rag puddings in Wilbutt's chippy and making up for lost time now he's back "home". Not sure how you get a ball past him anymore  |  |
| |
| Logan/Lillis on 22:18 - Nov 19 with 2805 views | rochedale |
| Logan/Lillis on 21:36 - Nov 19 by D_Alien |
He doesn't even look overweight to me, it's just his natural physique. Are we really saying that Hilly would allow a player to overindulge with food then select him ahead of a keeper who hadn't made any errors recently? That's an insult to Hilly as much as anything (i don't mean you've said that)
If Conrad had a problem with mobility, he wouldn't be getting to the ball on the ground or in the air with such timing and facility. There's plenty of keepers down the ages who've had a similar physique, and it's just lazy thinking to accuse them of being overweight (again, i don't mean you)
[Post edited 19 Nov 2016 21:37]
|
He is overweight, no doubt about it. Doesn't stop him from being a good keeper, but losing a bit of Terry would make him better. | |
| |
| Logan/Lillis on 22:21 - Nov 19 with 2789 views | dalenumber2 |
Has anyone else noticed how much thinner his right calf is compared to his left? Something to do with that injury probably. |  | | |
| Logan/Lillis on 23:13 - Nov 19 with 2666 views | Yorkshire_Dale |
| Logan/Lillis on 21:58 - Nov 19 by dingdangblue |
He's always been a 'big lad'.
|
Looks like Joe Bugner? | | | |
| Logan/Lillis on 00:48 - Nov 20 with 2554 views | dingdangblue |
| Logan/Lillis on 23:13 - Nov 19 by Yorkshire_Dale |
Looks like Joe Bugner? |
Look's like he's eaten Joe Bugner! | |
| |
| Logan/Lillis on 03:19 - Nov 20 with 2511 views | olympicdale |
I always feel more confident with Logan, his positional play and distribution are streets ahead of Lillis. Both are good shot stoppers, but Logan commands his defence better, and reads danger better. |  |
| |
| Logan/Lillis on 09:53 - Nov 20 with 2354 views | electricblue |
| Logan/Lillis on 23:13 - Nov 19 by Yorkshire_Dale |
Looks like Joe Bugner? |
Looks like he is putting his gloves ready to step into the octagon...... |  |
| My all time favourite Dale player Mr Lyndon Symmonds |
| |
| Logan/Lillis on 10:15 - Nov 20 with 2308 views | aleanddale |
| Logan/Lillis on 03:19 - Nov 20 by olympicdale |
I always feel more confident with Logan, his positional play and distribution are streets ahead of Lillis. Both are good shot stoppers, but Logan commands his defence better, and reads danger better. |
I agree with OD.
Logan for me! Just. Both excellent keepers. | | | |
| Logan/Lillis on 16:15 - Nov 20 with 2119 views | 49thseason |
What makes the main difference between the two for me is the way that Logan always seems to have the next move figured out ahead of time once he has possession of the ball. whereas Lillis takes an age to suss out what to do next and nearly always ends up hoofing it out to the right-hand side of the pitch even when Vincenti isn't playing!
The speed and accuracy of distribution from Logan gives the forwards the confidence that if they make a move he will find them. |  | | |
| Logan/Lillis on 16:22 - Nov 20 with 2082 views | Daley_Lama |
When defending a corner in the second half, CL was pointing to NML where to run if there was a chance of a breakaway.
He duly caught the corner, two seconds later NML was haring down our right wing. | |
| |
| Logan/Lillis on 16:25 - Nov 20 with 2075 views | 100notout |
| Logan/Lillis on 22:02 - Nov 19 by D_Alien |
Compared with:
|
thanks D'Alien!!!!!!
Ahhh happy memories | |
| |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
