As QPR head to Birmingham on Saturday, LFW looks back at the memorable League Cup semi final meeting between the two in 1967.
QPR 1 Birmingham City 0, Saturday September 16, 2013, Championship
Ultimately, QPR’s first meeting with Birmingham City since 2008 finished exactly as their last did — a 1-0 home win — but there was none of the drama and entertainment of the ‘blizzard’ match as the R’s struggled past Lee Clark’s side back in September. In the type of performance that became typical of the first half of QPR’s season Rangers never once clicked into gear, and relied on the defensive abilities of Richard Dunne and Nedum Onuoha to keep a Birmingham side that created, and missed, several decent chances at bay. Back in those days of course, one Charlie Austin led the attack and four minutes after half time he bundled in the only goal of the game from a yard out after a corner caused a goal mouth scramble. These days, without Austin, it’s not quite so simple.
QPR: Green 6; Simpson 6, Onuoha 7, Dunne 7, Hill 6; O’Neil 7, Barton 6, Carroll 6 (Jenas 82, -), Hoilett 5 (Phillips 39, 5); Zamora 5 (Wright-Phillips 46, 6), Austin 6
Subs: Murphy, Assou-Ekotto, Faurlin, Henry
Goals: Austin 49 (assisted Onuoha)
Bookings: Barton 43 (repetitive fouling)
Birmingham: Randolph 6; Burn 6, Bartley 6, Robinson 6; Elliott 7, Spector 6, Caddis 6, Adeyemi 6 (Lovenkrands 82, -); Burke 7, Novak 6, Shinnie 6 (Ferguson 55, 6)
Subs: Doyle, Ambrose, Reilly, Lee, Brown
Bookings: Shinnie 49 (foul), Spector 78 (diving), Robinson 86 (foul), Burn 90+1 (foul)
QPR 1 Birmingham City 0, Tuesday October 28, 2008, Championship
Birmingham City’s previous visit to Loftus Road has gone down as one of the modern day classics in W12 folklore. Prior to the match the two teams couldn't have been in more different form: City were looking good for promotion and had already beaten QPR in the league earlier in the month, while Rangers were coming apart at the seams with manager Iain Dowie paying the price for clashing with the club’s ambitious, fiery, unpredictable new chairman Flavio Briatore.
Rangers were a mess in truth. A mixture of Dowie signings, players brought in by previous regimes, and foreign kids and ageing stars added at the whim of Briatore from clubs belonging to his friends. Ludicrously that night, with Gareth Ainsworth in caretaker charge, Rangers used midfielders ranging from Martin Rowlands and Gavin Mahon to Emmanuel Ledesma and Italian veteran Damiano Tommasi. A home gate of just 13,594 spoke volumes.
Things didn’t look good for the R’s when referee Stuart Attwell strode over with a card in one hand and his cock in the other right on the stroke of half time to send off Mikele Leigertwood for a tackle that was late but far from malicious or dangerous. But Ainsworth always was a positive, upbeat character as a player and as a manager he decided to remain with two strikers in the second half, and demand more work of a three man midfield, rather than retreat into a shell.
The attacking outlook caught Birmingham cold on a night of heavy snow, and nine minutes after the break Italian loanee Sam Di Carmine rifled in an unstoppable drive from 20 yards out at the Loft End. Di Carmine, on loan from Fiorentina at the time, was a truly dreadful footballer of almost zero natural ability and his single season spell at QPR was enough to drive a man to drink — but he didn’t half get hold of that one.
Suddenly it felt like one of those nights under the lights at Loftus Road. There may have been plenty of empty seats but the snow, the scoreline and the numerical disadvantage all combined to create an electric atmosphere inside the ground. Birmingham threw on Marcus Bent to join Kevin Phillips and Cameron Jerome in their attack and then added former Arsenal trainee Quincy Owusu-Abeyie for good measure.
But Rangers stood firm. Tommasi and Rowlands were magnificent together in midfield, working like dogs to make up for the extra man.
It could have been in vain of course — Attwell tormented the home crowd further by adding an outrageous amount of stoppage time to the end of the game during which Kevin Phillips stole into the six yard box and tapped home an equaliser that deflated Loftus Road like few goals that have ever been scored there. Through the gloom, the sleet and the snow however a linesman’s flag saved the day, and the points, for QPR.
QPR: Cerny 8, Leigertwood 6, Stewart 8, Hall 8, Connolly 8, Ledesma 7, Rowlands 8, Tommasi 8, Cook 5 (Mahon 46, 7), Blackstock 6 (Buzsaky 68, 7), Di Carmine 7 (Ephraim 74, 7)
Subs Not Used: Cole, Parejo
Sent Off: Leigertwood 45 (serious foul play)
Booked: Tomassi (foul), Cerny (time wasting), Ledesma (diving)
Goals: Di Carmine 54 (assisted Tommasi)
Birmingham: Maik Taylor 7, Parnaby - (Wilson 12, 5), Martin Taylor 5, Ridgewell 5, Queudrue 6, McFadden 6, Carsley 5, Nafti 6 (64, 4), Agustien 6, Phillips 6, Jerome 5 (Bent 64, 6)
Subs Not Used: Doyle, Quashie
Booked: Wilson, Queudrue
Birmingham City 1 QPR 0, Saturday October 4, 2008, Championship
Dowie had still been in charge when the sides met at St Andrews’ earlier that month for an early Saturday match screened live by Sky. Fitz Hall and goalkeeper Radek Cerny shared the blame for a dreadfully soft winning goal, scored on the stroke of half time by Kevin Phillips, but in truth the R’s rarely threatened the goal at the other end and the home team deserved their win. The game is best known by R’s fans as the opening scene of the Four Year Plan documentary where Flavio Briatore is seen in the car after the game branding Dowie a "hooligan” with "no strategy”.
Birmingham: Taylor 7, Parnaby 7, Jaidi 8, Ridgewell 8, Murphy 7, Larsson 8, Carsley 7 (Nafti 50, 6), Agustien 6, Owusu-Abeyie 7 (McFadden 75, 6), Phillips 7 (Jerome 80, -), O'Connor 8
Subs Not Used: Doyle, Martin Taylor
Booked: Ridgewell (deliberate handball)
Goals: Phillips 45+1 (assisted O'Connor)
QPR: Cerny 6, Ramage 4 (Connolly 87, -), Hall 5, Stewart 6, Delaney 4, Rowlands 5 (Ledesma 80, -), Leigertwood 6, Mahon 6 (Buzsaky 68, 6), Cook 6, Blackstock 5, Agyemang 5
Subs Not Used: Camp, Parejo
Booked: Leigertwood (foul)
Head to Head >>> Birmingham wins 21 >>> Draws 13 >>> QPR wins 16
2013/14 http://www.fansnetwork.co.uk/football/queensparkrangers/news/32828/austin-keeps- 1 Birmingham 0 (Austin)
2008/09 http://www.fansnetwork.co.uk/football/queensparkrangers/news/4226/ainsworths-ran 1 Birmingham 0 (Di Carmine)
2008/09 http://www.fansnetwork.co.uk/football/queensparkrangers/news/4175/qprs-slide-con 1 QPR 0
2006/07 Birmingham 2 QPR 1 (Cook)
2006/07 QPR 0 Birmingham 2
2000/01 Birmingham 0 QPR 0
2000/01 QPR 0 Birmingham 0
1999/00 QPR 2 Birmingham 2 (Steiner, Kiwomya)
1999/00 Birmingham 2 QPR 0
1998/99 Birmingham 1 QPR 0
1998/99 QPR 0 Birmingham 1
1997/98 Birmingham 1 QPR 0
1997/98 QPR 1 Birmingham 1 (Barker)
1996/97 QPR 1 Birmingham 1 (Spencer)
1996/97 Birmingham 0 QPR 0
1985/86 Birmingham 2 QPR 0
1985/86 QPR 3 Birmingham 1 (Bannister, Rosenior, Dawes)
1983/84 Birmingham 0 QPR 2 (Gregory, Fenwick)
1983/84 QPR 2 Birmingham 1 (Stainrod, Fenwick)
1979/80 QPR 1 Birmingham 1 (Burke)
1979/80 Birmingham 2 QPR 1 (Allen)
1978/79 QPR 1 Birmingham 3 (Roeder)
1978/79 Birmingham 3 QPR 1 (Busby)
1977/78 QPR 0 Birmingham 0
1977/78 Birmingham 2 QPR 1 (Masson)
1976/77 QPR 2 Birmingham 2 (Masson, Webb)
1976/77 Birmingham 2 QPR 1 (Eastoe)
1975/76 QPR 2 Birmingham 1 (Masson 2)
1975/76 Birmingham 1 QPR 1 (Thomas)
1974/75 Birmingham 4 QPR 1 (Thomas)
1974/75 QPR 0 Birmingham 1
1973/74 Birmingham 4 QPR 0
1973/74 QPR 2 Birmingham 0* (Leach, Givens)
1973/74 QPR 2 Birmingham 2 (Bowles, Hynd og)
1971/72 Birmingham 0 QPR 0
1971/72 QPR 2 Birmingham 0** (Francis, Marsh)
1971/72 QPR 1 Birmingham 0 (Marsh)
1970/71 QPR 5 Birmingham 2 (Marsh 3, Venables, McCulloch)
1970/71 Birmingham 2 QPR 1 (Bridges)
1969/70 QPR 2 Birmingham 1 (Bridges 2)
1969/70 Birmingham 3 QPR 0
1967/68 QPR 2 Birmingham 0 (Leach, I Morgan)
1967/68 Birmingham 2 QPR 0
1966/67 QPR 3 Birmingham 1** (Marsh 2, Keen)
1966/67 Birmingham 1 QPR 4** (Marsh, R Morgan, Lazarus, Allen)
1951/52 Birmingham 1 QPR 0
1951/52 QPR 0 Birmingham 2
1950/51 QPR 2 Birmingham 0 (Farrow, Shepherd)
1950/51 Birmingham 1 QPR 1 (Addinall)
1913/14 Birmingham 1 QPR 2*(Gregory, Miller)
* - FA Cup
** - League Cup
Birmingham City 1 Queens Park Rangers 4, Tuesday January 17, 1967, League Cup Semi Final
There are certainly greater football coincidences than QPR meeting Birmingham City this Saturday, 47 years to the week since the R’s lifted the only major trophy in the club’s history, but there is a nice symmetry to the date of the game. Third Division Rangers, of course, beat First Division West Bromwich Albion in the final at Wembley, recovering from two goals down at half time to win 3-2. But the scorer of the winning goal in the final, Mark Lazarus, always rated the rampant 7-2 aggregate win against Birmingham in the semi-final as the better achievement.
QPR started the 1966/67 Third Division season with a draw against Shrewsbury in the first match and a defeat to Watford in the second. It gave little indication of what was to follow as Alec Stock’s team went onto secure a historic league and cup double, winning promotion into the Second Division and claiming the League Cup at Wembley into the bargain.
The run to a two legged semi-final with Birmingham City had been long and arduous. A famous 4-2 giant killing against Leicester City with goals from Rodney Marsh, Les Allen and Mark Lazarus had been the highlight but Rangers had also ploughed through Colchester who’d been vanquished 5-0 with four goals from Marsh; Aldershot where a replay at Loftus Road was required after a 1-1 draw away from home; Swansea Town who were beaten by goals from defenders Mike Keen and Tony Hazell; and Carlisle United.
Birmingham were a Second Division side themselves, managed by Stan Cullis and backed by millionaire owner Clifford Coombs. They’d spent big on Bert Murray and Barry Bridges from Chelsea and Nottingham Forest winger Trevor Hockey among others and were therefore heavy favourites in the semi-final and in fact led 1-0 at half time in the first leg up at St Andrews. But QPR cut loose in the second half, with Allen, Marsh and Lazarus on the scoresheet again along with Roger Morgan in a 4-1 win. That set up a second leg at Loftus Road where QPR simply had to see the job through.
Initially there were nerves, with Birmingham throwing caution to the wind. But ten minutes after half time Rodney Marsh turned and hit an instinctive snap shot that caught goalkeeper Jim Herriot badly positioned and flat footed. Now 5-1 on aggregate there really was no way back for the visitors. Inside right Eric Barber did find an equaliser for them but gaps started to appear as they chased the impossible creating space for Mike Keen to head home Roger Morgan’s cross and Marsh to stride onto Hazell’s pass and smash in a third.
Rangers had destroyed Birmingham all over again, winning 3-1 to seal a 7-2 aggregate success. Manager Alec Stock said: "I’m as bucked as hell. This is a great thing for the club and could be a great thing for football.” His opposite number Stan Cullis added: "We didn’t lose it tonight, we lost it at St Andrews. Rangers deserved to win both matches and they go to Wembley with our best wishes.”
QPR went on to play First Division West Brom in the final at Wembley — the Baggies had beaten West Ham in the other semi-final — and despite trailing 2-0 the R’s fought back to win 3-2 for what remains their only major trophy success to this day.
QPR: Springett, Hazell, Langley, Keen, Hunt, Sibley, Lazarus, Sanderson, Allen, Marsh, R Morgan
Birmingham: Herriot, Murray, Green, Thomson, Sharples, Beard, Hockey, Barber, Bullock, Vowden, Bridges
Tweet @loftforwords
Pictures — Action Images