If Dale do decide to replace Watson, who could come in? Monday, 16th Nov 2026 22:55 by Chris Fitzgerald (Fitzochris) Following days of speculation and with supporter frustration and pressure growing around Ian Watson's position as manager, Dale fan, author and journalist Chris Fitzgerald gives us his thoughts on the situation and who might be available should push come to shove. If the Rochdale AFC board of directors decide a change in first-team management is needed, the right appointment depends on what the club needs most. Nobody wants to be having this conversation 15 league games into a season, and it would be wrong to assert the case for a change in first-team manager is clear-cut and absolute without fully knowing the machinations behind the scenes. But the table is hard to argue with. After the defeat to York on Saturday, Dale are 22nd with 15 points from 15 matches, having won four, drawn three and lost eight, and conceded 27 goals along the way. Rotherham and Crawley, the two sides below us, have games in hand. Just as worrying is how the points have been lost. Too many of the goals conceded have been soft, the gaps between players too wide and the mistakes very avoidable. Ian Watson arrived in the summer promising energetic, attacking football built on possession and counter-pressing, and the idea is sound, having been adapted by many a side the world over. The skill is in the execution, and too often Watson’s players haven’t looked like a collective that knows how to carry it out. Some supporters feel in-game changes haven’t always come at the right moment, too, with substitutions arriving too late to alter a game. The lack of options at No.9 has limited what Watson can do when a game needs a different shape or a new focal point and, again, the one option he does have at the minute is underused. In addition, a big squad should mean strength in depth, but too many players have been only occasionally available, which raises the question of how well so many of them are being managed and kept onside. There are mitigating factors. There have been encouraging spells over those 15 plus games, including against York, and mass injuries have left the squad without the settled shape a system like Watson’s needs, so it would be unfair to lay everything at his door. But our board has to ask whether the problems so evident now can be fixed in time, with so little margin for error. If the directors decide it can’t, who might they turn to in an attempt to put things right? There is a strong case for putting Stuart Maynard on Rochdale’s shortlist. He has a promotion on his CV that we all saw secured firsthand, at Spotland in April, when an equaliser in the 13th minute of added time left us all needing therapy. He also knows League Two, having been here before with Notts County. But it isn’t as simple as looking at his record at York and declaring him the obvious choice. The question is what Dale need most. One option is a manager who can organise a struggling side and get results quickly. The other is someone who can build a team and an identity that lasts. They aren’t necessarily the same appointment. Maynard’s biggest selling point is what he did at York. He arrived after four games of the season, by which point York had taken six points. They finished with 108, which means he collected 102 points from his 42 league matches. He won the National League title and was named Manager of the Season. His side scored freely, pressed hard and took the game to opponents. As much as we Dale fans would be pained to admit it, York were outstanding, and Maynard deserves real credit for the way they played. The attractions for Rochdale are obvious. Watson’s ideas and Maynard’s aren’t far apart, but York carried theirs out far more convincingly than Dale have managed. Poor distribution has repeatedly invited pressure and let opponents create chances without working hard for them. Maynard’s approach could be a more coherent version of what Rochdale are meant to be doing. His York players seemed to understand their roles and how they fitted the wider plan. There was a recognisable structure to their play, with the ball and without it. He also knows the division. His time at Notts County was far from an unqualified success, but it wasn’t a disaster either. He won 28 of his 73 matches in charge, with 16 draws and 29 defeats. In his first full season, County finished sixth and reached the play-off semi-finals, and their defensive record improved considerably. A poor finish, with one win in their last eight including the play-offs, ultimately cost him his job. That experience still counts, of course. He has managed in League Two and knows that what works in the National League doesn’t automatically work in the EFL. His exit from York was also not the result of failure. He left on 26 July, three months after the title and with the new season only weeks away, and the club cited a difference in direction and vision. It surprised many observers, and only those involved know what that difference amounted to in practice. His stock could hardly have been higher. The obvious question is whether he could do it again at Rochdale, and Notts County is the reminder that he’s no guaranteed solution. Some sections of the Notts support were never convinced, and the owners felt performances had fallen below expectations at the crucial time. There is a risk, too, in assuming the York model can simply be lifted and dropped into Rochdale. Maynard’s approach needs players who are comfortable on the ball, can make decisions under pressure and can sustain the intensity of a high press. Dale have struggled with basic distribution and defensive organisation. Injuries have also left the squad without the consistency and familiarity a settled system needs. A new manager would inherit all of that. He would have to decide whether this squad can play the way he wants or whether big changes are needed. A new name on the manager’s door won’t solve that on its own. Maynard is available. He was linked with the Scunthorpe vacancy, but they appointed Andy Preece this week, so that door has closed. If he is interested, he has t be considered. But if Maynard is the more progressive appointment, Andy Woodman is something rather different. His record at Bromley is remarkable. Over five and a half years he won the FA Trophy, took the club from the National League into the Football League through the play-offs, and then won the League Two title in 2025-26. His sides were hard to play against, as we found out for ourselves. They were organised and competitive, and comfortable without dominating possession. That could be exactly what Rochdale need right now. Dale don’t have to win every battle for the ball. They do, however, have to stop making life so easy for the opposition by defending the box properly, protecting the space in front of the centre-backs, competing for second balls and making opponents work for their chances. Woodman has shown he can build teams with those qualities. There are caveats, as always. Bromley struggled badly after stepping up to League One, winning only twice in their first ten league games and conceding 25 goals. Woodman left by mutual agreement on 22 October. The club had a long injury list and heavy squad turnover, much like Watson has had to contend with here, so it would be unfair to pin every problem on the manager. Even so, it’s a reminder that success in one division doesn’t guarantee it in the next. He’s available now, and his achievements make him a serious candidate, if a move north appeals to him. Of the names being discussed, he may be the likeliest to fix Dale’s immediate defensive problems. Whether he could take the side beyond that is another matter. Ryan Lowe is a different proposition altogether. An almost forgotten free agent at the moment, he has managed Bury, Plymouth Argyle, Preston North End and Wigan Athletic, and has far more EFL experience than either Maynard or Woodman. He won promotion from League Two with Bury and with Plymouth, and had a respectable spell at Preston, finishing in the top half of the Championship twice. His last job, at Wigan, ended in February after only 12 wins in 49 matches. The club had slipped into the relegation zone, and he was sacked after a 6-1 defeat at Peterborough. There’s also the question of how realistic he is. Speaking on the Sky Sports Essential EFL podcast in early October, Lowe said he wanted a club with good ownership who shared his vision. We check that box. But then he added that he didn’t want to spend 10 or 15 games firefighting just to pick up a few wins and earn a contract. He did concede that sometimes you have to go in somewhere and keep a side in the division, but a project is clearly what he’s after. That doesn’t sound like a natural fit for a club sitting 22nd in League Two and needing an immediate improvement. He would be an ambitious appointment, but there’s little reason to think he’d see Rochdale as the right opportunity now. Whoever comes in would have to tackle the defensive problems quickly. The distances between the lines have to shrink. The team needs a more reliable defensive structure, better protection for the back four, and a clearer sense of when to play and when to keep it simple. On that basis, I’d put Maynard and Woodman ahead of Lowe as realistic candidates. Maynard has the greater potential to build something, and what he did at York is compelling. He has shown he can put together a side capable of winning a title, and Notts County taught him what League Two demands. There are risks, but the football case for him is strong. Woodman may be the safer choice if the priority is to stop the rot. He has a proven record of building competitive sides, knows how to get results at this level, and could bring organisation to a team that looks far too easy to play against. Lowe would be an impressive appointment on paper, but his own words suggest he’s looking for something quite different from what Rochdale can offer. Being out of the game can open one’s mind, however. And of course, these are only the names I can immediately think of, but there will be others, some of them far from obvious. Football club boardrooms have a habit of springing a surprise. But if it is decided that Watson must be replaced, the decision has to be made swiftly. There is already talk around the campfires of our dear neighbours Oldham considering a managerial change, and they will almost certainly be fishing in the same pool. Whoever does eventually replace Watson must be allowed to set a clear plan, with proper support in recruitment to do what is required in January. Changing the manager without fixing the problems around the squad size would only risk repeating the same mistakes with someone else in charge. Photo: Action Images via Reuters Please report offensive, libellous or inappropriate posts by using the links provided.
You need to login in order to post your comments |
Rochdale Polls[ Vote here ] |
