x

Whats The Problem With Pulis

What have Saints fans got against Tony Pulis Jr, before he has even joined the club.

Saints fans have been known to take a dislike to a player at the Club, usually its been for good reason, but in all my years of supporting Saints, never have i come across vitriol to a player before he has even joined the club.

The truth is that signing this player could be the last straw for many supporters, and to be blunt I can see their point, in a time when we are trying to save wages, just what is the point in getting a player on the books in a position where we are well served, ie in midfield, when the supporters can clearly see that the problem lies in other areas.

But in runs deeper than that, the fans could accept a player with experience, they know thats whats needed, but the truth is that Pulis Jr has no experience whatsoever, at the age of 24 his career, spread across six clubs consists of 10 league starts, 9 of these at Grimsby two years ago, 2 league cup starts, plus 13 appearances as a sub, one of which against Newcastle in last seasons FA Cup was in the 91st minute and consisted of exactly two minutes.

So the fact is Tony Pulis Jr offers nothing to Saints that they havent already got, indeed their is the very definate suggestion that if he wasnt playing for his Dad's team, he would be out of football altogether, as it seems no other team is interested in signing him, except of course Saints.

Even Bristol Rovers didnt rate him, his month on loan there in March consisted of one appearance as sub. 

So why are we considering buying him and who is making the decision, Poortvliet most certainly wouldnt have heard of him and you would have thought that one glance at his playing record would tell the Dutchman all he needed to know about the player, if you havent found your level and are making regular appearances at the age of 24, there is something drastically wrong.

If as rumour has it, it is Lowe making the decision, that also strikes me as slightly strange, frankly he doesnt fit Lowe's well publicised blueprint for this seasons squad, where he is trying to get rid of journeyman players and replace them with youth, Pulis has neither youth nor experience on his side.

But the person to feel sorry for is Pulis Jr himslef, the man must have the thickest skin in history to be able to firstly turn up for training at Stoke and secondly to read what everyone is saying about him.

Certainly its hard to see who he might replace in our midfield, certainly the centre three are playing well and on the  right wing we have plenty of options, yes we are short on the left, but that can be covered, this is a baffling situation, Pulis just doesnt have a track record and if he had had any hidden talent then surely a club would have picked up on it by now.

Of course if he arrives i would like him to succeed, but I fel the pressure would be on him so much that it would make it very improbable and therefore its hard to see what anyone has to gain from signing him, certainly not Poortvliet whose reputation with the supporters will suffer, certainly not Lowe who will come under more fire from the fans and certainly not the player who will immediately be in the spotlight and bear the brunt of the fans frustrations.              

What to read next:

Swansea City : The real value will be the players who stay at the club
With the Swans retained list about to be named, generally around the 18th of the month, we take a look at those who stay, and their value to the club. The players who have the determination to turn next season in to more than a passing parade and a dismal home loss record.
Swansea City : The confusing decision making for a whole season
It was a pretty poor end to what can only be described as a disappointing football season for Swansea City. The defeat to Millwall yesterday was a display that has frustrated Swansea City supporters all season. A lack of effort, intensity and desire rewarding the home support with yet another home loss.
Swansea City 0 - 1 Millwall - Player Ratings and Reports
If you saw the match, please give us your player ratings and a mini match report.
Swansea City : Grimes misses a penalty in a return to bad old ways
An error strewn and tepid Swansea display ensured thousands left the stadium before the staff and players did their usual walk around at this end of season game. It wasn’t a good look as two players received red cards and any effort by the home side was lost in a static and frustrating display.
Swansea City : Last game of the season, latest injury news and the full low down on the big game
Today brings the Championship season to a close for the majority of the clubs involved, and the Swans face Millwall at 12.30pm today at the Swansea.com stadium. Just over 1,100 visiting supporters have made the journey in what we hope is a celebration of the end of the season for both clubs.
Swansea City : What needs to happen now ?
The Indy’s lead football writer, Andrew Winfield goes in deep on this weeks issues and the real problems in store for the Swans.
Swansea City : The facts on players in and out and the strategy behind it
This week has seen some bad financial news for the Swans, and of course more questions than answers yet again. That aside there is some great news from the age grade side at U21 as once again we see a player knocking on the door of the first team squad.
Swansea City : Has Andrew Coleman been in the shower for three months with Bobby Ewing ?
The changing timeline of when Andrew Coleman became Chairmen of Swansea City caused a stir yesterday, our twitter account getting well over eleven thousand views and increasing, which sent website views here in to their many thousands as well.
Swans supporters consult Kieran Maguire and when did Andy start as Chairman ?
News of Swansea City’s financial position hit home yesterday as the club announced further losses. The profit and sustainability rules are forever hanging over a club, and in Swansea City’s case like everyone else it’s a rolling three year issue.
Gwyn’s Eye View : Swansea City v Millwall
Glyn is back with his favourite stats as we build up to the last game of the season. That comes in the form of Millwall who it seems are close to selling their requested 1,148 allocation, so its down to the Jack Army to do their bit this bank holiday weekend.