Please log in or register. Registered visitors get fewer ads.
Forum
Reply
Watson leaves. Who’s next?
at 17:48 22 Nov 2026

So we don’t need lots of players who are strapping and 6ft to compete in L2 then?

I didn’t need to visit AI to have that opinion, just forming it on what we’ve seen so far this season.

There’s enough in this squad, to stay up and compete however it will need some work doing to get the balance right. Two defenders, one who can play various roles and a centre forward would help.

There was no original discussion on EFL experience, so not sure why that’s the subject now. Oh, and Ollie Pearce hadn’t played one minute in the Football League before this season.
Forum
Reply
Watson leaves. Who’s next?
at 15:47 22 Nov 2026

So does that confirm we had players with a height advantage over York yet still lost?

Was just wondering which League 2 teams are “ awash with strapping, 6 foot tall lads”?

That’s yet to be established.

We’ve confirmed that York, in 5th place, aren’t. So why do we need to be to compete?
Forum
Reply
Watson leaves. Who’s next?
at 13:59 22 Nov 2026

Which teams are full of these strapping, 6ft tall 25-30 year old players who run, tackle and win headers?
The only one I’m aware of specifically are Oldham. Look how they’re doing. There may be others, so happy to be wrong, presumably there are other examples?

York certainly aren’t. They started last week with a smaller defender (Fallowfield) in the back three, two wing backs who aren’t that big, a centre forward in Pearce who is no bigger than our forwards. Boateng is more physical in midfield but he’s not featured much until recently. The only other starter they had who could partially fit the bill is Banks. He’s 34 and more of a creative player as well.

The York comparison being the obvious as they came up with us and would presumably recruit to fit the league. They are 5th and all the players mentioned were at the club last season.
[Post edited 22 Nov 14:01]
Forum
Reply
Watson leaves. Who’s next?
at 12:48 22 Nov 2026

McNulty left in early June, Watson was appointed on the 9th of that month. Maynard was still at York until the last week of July.
Forum
Reply
Watson leaves. Who’s next?
at 12:01 22 Nov 2026

Good post. Some of the stuff thrown his way has been very unfair. Also his last interview with the BBC saw him make a point around the fans continuing to back the players, even though he probably knew what was coming.
Forum
Reply
Watson leaves. Who’s next?
at 11:56 22 Nov 2026

Who said it was great?

People have admitted it hasn’t worked out and pointed out over time where he was falling short.

They were wrong if they thought it would be a success, as wrong as anyone was about thinking McNulty wouldn’t be. Life of a football fan, as long as it’s respectful there’s no harm in thinking differently.
Forum
Reply
What would you do
at 11:52 22 Nov 2026

The loan deals will hopefully have break clauses, plus some may finish in January - not checked.

Flint and Allen are easy savings when their deals end.

So no contracts to pay up and 6/7 squad spaces freed up.
Forum
Reply
Watson leaves. Who’s next?
at 11:21 22 Nov 2026

But he did have experience of coaching in the EFL.

It was a choice that made sense, not necessarily the right one. Not sure there’s any fan who was living on another planet for thinking that. Well, no more than anyone who said our previous manager would/would never take us up.
Forum
Reply
What would you do
at 11:17 22 Nov 2026

Posted elsewhere, send the loanees back (though rethinking that, Tasker offers so much across the whole back line that it would be silly not to keep him if fit soon)

But without them, those on short term contracts and long term injured:

Waller

Back three:Maguire-EEL-Beckwith. Sherring may be better in this formation too.

Wingback: TAR and Hannant. The wingers will have to be prepared to play there too (if Newby can do it, others can too.

Midfield three: East, Gilmour, Pettit. Adeeko and Francis as back up.

Two forwards: Dieseruvwe and Henderson. The likes of Hayes and Middleton could a secondary forward role if required too. Paterson too if he can show why he was brought here until the summer.

Proof there’s a starting point in the squad once we cut the numbers of unnecessary additions. A lot still depends on people getting and staying fit though. Two defenders and a centre forward need adding in January if we can enough players out.
Forum
Reply
Watson leaves. Who’s next?
at 09:09 22 Nov 2026

Watson deserves a lot of credit for how he handled his time at the club with professionalism and dignity. I’ve also got some admiration for how he stuck to his principles, even though the way he chooses to play wasn’t working.

Going forward, Maynard seems to be the obvious target but it’s whether he wants to wait for other options. If he thinks Oldham is the answer, he’d be better served coming to a more stable environment at Spotland.

Lowe doesn’t enthuse me, but he’s had some success in the past. His interviews aren’t great though…

Luke Williams would fit too, depending how he bounces back from his time at Peterborough.
Forum
Thread
Watson leaves. Who’s next?
at 09:03 22 Nov 2026

Forum
Reply
Refwatch - Northampton Town v Rochdale
at 08:42 22 Nov 2026

And yet some Stockport fans think it’s the best football they’ve seen in a long time, backed up by fans and managers of League 1 teams. The additions they’ve made there as well as quality like Norwood and Wootton have all seemingly fit into the structure McNulty/Taylor/Done employ too.

It’s all personal opinion at the end of the day. Supporters who watched Dale regularly over the last three seasons maybe didn’t like it every week but there was a clear, defined way of playing that won football matches. And there were even other ways to play when Plan A didn’t work - as seen towards the end of last season.

The facts are it was the most successful team we’ve had in terms of points and wins and it scored plenty of goals. Debates can rage about quality of opponents too, but it’s been noted plenty of times that the current division in which we play isn’t exactly awash with lots of really good sides.

If some fans choose not to enjoy the football a manager employs, that will only be a continuation of what’s gone on at more or less every club ever. Some Cambridge fans probably hated watching John Beck’s sides when they were challenging for promotion to the Premier League and in the quarter finals of the FA Cup.

As Dale supporters though, having a winning team playing half decent football, giving their all for a manager who has a clear plan and culture, it’s hard to want much more.

Then when you do, it’s a case of careful for what you wish for.
[Post edited 22 Nov 8:53]
Forum
Reply
Refwatch - Northampton Town v Rochdale
at 22:16 21 Nov 2026

No I don’t know, but Lillis has been involved in coaching teams for a while now and is visibly seen to contribute in the technical area. Therefore, it would be reasonable guess that he is capable and has coaching qualifications.

I don’t think Henderson mentioned having coaching qualifications in that website interview (he may have), so when it comes to setting up sessions etc it’s likely that, in house, Lillis would be better served. All hypothetical at this stage, but I’d expect the entire board/management team to have planned for whatever eventuality may occur and that they’d take all factors into account.

You’re right about how any organisation should be sounding out others they represent, acknowledging having such a process in place ensures the thoughts of a wider group are taken on board rather than prioritising individual opinion.
Forum
Reply
Refwatch - Northampton Town v Rochdale
at 20:54 21 Nov 2026

Manager aside, who should we look to move out in January?

For me, every loanee can go back, even Tasker now he’s injured. Not sure if that’s possible with the loan arrangements. Flint and Allen as well, we have to get pace it’s the back and we’ve more than enough options in midfield - hopefully they’ll all want to stay. Paterson has a deal until the end of the season it seems, if we play two up front he may have a part to play, but if not, hard to see him adding much than Henderson can’t.

Silcott-Duberry and Smith can go out on loan, if the latter can stay fit.

Fully aware that there are so many variables but the squad is far too messy, the potential quality within it needs clarity. Defence would remain the main area of concern though due to injuries. Two CH, one who could play full back, plus a CF to compete with a returning Dieseruvwe would probably be more beneficial than retaining what we have above.
Forum
Reply
Refwatch - Northampton Town v Rochdale
at 19:51 21 Nov 2026

As mentioned earlier, contracts usually have a termination clause. It would very surprising if all parties aren’t already aware of that. And again, Watson is not a “rookie manager”. He’s managed before and has EFL coaching experience. Much more than our previous manager had. The manager who oversaw the most successful season in the club’s history. Facts matter.

Why Henderson rather than Lillis who has been coaching for a while? Not sure why it’s on Gauge either. Would fully expect the management team put in place will make a collective decision. The joint chairman is only part of that.
Forum
Reply
Refwatch - Northampton Town v Rochdale
at 18:20 21 Nov 2026

Trying to analyse the game as far as decision making and how that’s reflected in the subs.

We are pegged back to 2-2 and despite the midfield being run through with ease for the equaliser, we swap a winger. Not Hannant who has done quite well recently and has proven defensive qualities, but Silcott-Duberry employed on the opposite side to where he normally plays.

Then they score again and the wholesale changes occur. Henderson finally on for Brown and Francis and Adeeko replaced by East and Paterson

Quite what Henderson thinks when he’s on the bench while we are leading and having someone of his ilk up front to hold it may assist.

Quite what East thinks when he’s brought on when we’re losing and expected to suddenly produce something from the previously anonymous middle of the park.

Quite what Pettit is thinking from the stand as he witnesses a player like Paterson come on to produce nothing of note, again, in a department he a) isn’t suited for and b) the players we know we can rely on aren’t getting similar opportunities.

Also feel sorry for Jamie Allen. Not his fault he was given the captaincy, which was rightly given straight to EEL after the break, but that role meant he almost had to see out the 90 minutes for it to make sense. Something he probably isn’t ready for yet, thus adding to the complete lack of protection our shaky defence get.

And what formation we were playing in the last few minutes is anyone’s guess, but seeing Taylor turn up on the right with TAR on the left sums up the cluttered approach to trying to get results without ever getting the structure right.

Make no mistake though, there’s enough in this squad (with a few needed departures to get the numbers down and the thinking clearer) to still be well away from trouble.

A massive week ahead before we get to next Saturday. Nothing will change whilst everything remains the same.
Forum
Reply
Refwatch - Northampton Town v Rochdale
at 16:32 21 Nov 2026

As seen yet again with the move leading to the penalty. Teams don’t have to work hard to get into our final third.

Feel a bit sorry for Taylor, not his fault he’s playing left back when there’s a left back on the bench.
Forum
Reply
Refwatch - Northampton Town v Rochdale
at 16:24 21 Nov 2026

Complete lack of midfield structure throughout with players interchanging positions. That they scored from someone running beyond the players we have in the middle of the park was no surprise, it’s happened all afternoon.
Forum
Reply
Refwatch - Northampton Town v Rochdale
at 16:11 21 Nov 2026

What do we all know…

Football, eh?
Forum
Reply
Refwatch - Northampton Town v Rochdale
at 16:03 21 Nov 2026

The terms of any management departure will almost certainly be included in a manager’s contract. Presumably it’s set at a figure a club would be prepared to pay if things go wrong.

You’re right about the fitness levels, it’s either that or we run really slowly to recover our ground.
Please log in to use all the site's facilities

442Dale


Site Scores

Prediction League: 0
TOTAL: 0
About Us Contact Us Terms & Conditions Privacy Cookies Online Safety Advertising
© FansNetwork 2026