Please log in or register. Registered visitors get fewer ads.
Forum
Reply
TVOS Preview - Rochdale v York City
at 18:29 15 Nov 2026

Think it’s his win percentage stats aren’t that great apart from at York. But yeah he did get Notts in the playoffs and it was a harsh looking sacking.

It might have been to do with them having a poor run in when automatic promotion looked on the cards.

Seems to be the preferred choice of Oldham fans as they’re currently experiencing a ‘Mellon Out’ week.
[Post edited 15 Nov 18:29]
Forum
Reply
Formation Conundrum - Fans Choices?
at 16:25 15 Nov 2026

Though in fairness, beatthebishop did make a point of saying “Watson aside”. Hence the discussion around what we have in the squad, how they could be best utilised whoever the manager is.

The extended highlights on York’s YouTube adds further weight to arguments around possible solutions to the recognisable problems.
Forum
Reply
Formation Conundrum - Fans Choices?
at 14:01 15 Nov 2026

We are lacking in one that makes us hard to beat. That seems to be almost everyone’s interpretation.
Forum
Reply
Formation Conundrum - Fans Choices?
at 11:59 15 Nov 2026

Except if ZSD was going to the only one left out from last week’s team, that would have meant Paterson joining Allen and Gilmour in midfield. Not Adeeko who would have been on the bench (as noted in the posts in the discussion pre-match).

Paterson can only play the 10 and having spent his career in advanced positions, would not have helped solve the recognised issue around how open we are between defence and midfield when the other side get the ball.

Paterson’s absence probably led to Silcott-Duberry starting. But that’s only a guess.

Hearing the views of fans on here, like in the pub is always worthwhile.
[Post edited 15 Nov 12:03]
Forum
Reply
Formation Conundrum - Fans Choices?
at 09:16 15 Nov 2026

Brown, for all his hard work, doesn’t contribute enough to our play when we have the ball or worry defenders enough.

Sone of that isn’t his fault as he’s far too isolated in the formation we have. That same structure which lets down defenders on the ball, midfielders who get overran when we lose it.

Possible solutions? From the other thread:

We could switch to wing-backs (TAR and Hannant… or even play a winger on the left, Middleton has the capacity). 3 central defenders (Wilson, Flint/EEL, Bilongo). 3 in midfield (from the six we have). 2 up front (Henderson has to start)

Or a proper 4-3-3 with proper midfielders closer together. Not career forwards who want to play no.10. If you think of the 10s we had last season, some could play in midfield too. The likes of Barlow and Burger actually did as one of the two to good effect. Silcott-Duberry, Paterson, Brown? If they’re expected to contribute defensively near our goal then we won’t ever sort out how open we are.

Then when Dieseruvwe is fit (why no update?) get him back in to the 3-4-3 or 3-5-2 formations.

It’s a personal opinion and one I can accept the reasons for not being shared, but I think Mani has been let down when he played because of how far away any support was (the same problem Broen has but he adds more with his running). It was assumed he’d love wingers getting crosses in. Maybe, but I reckon he’d love clever players around him who he can link with more.

A good goalscorer will always be that. Finishing chances and being in the right place is something that sometimes comes naturally. Dieseruvwe started five league games. If we’re writing him off after that without trying to adapt to get more out of him, it’ll be another mistake in a long list of them.
Forum
Reply
TVOS Preview - Rochdale v York City
at 22:16 14 Nov 2026

Instead of throwing out random words about what a team would look like or stats that are not backed up by actual reality, it’s worth considering that this squad has enough to be competing in L2. That’s even only picking from the ones that are currently fit.

Sorting the keeper situation is obviously a priority, but we could easily line up in different ways that would make this team harder to beat and better going forward.

We could switch to wing-backs (TAR and Hannant… or even play a winger on the left, Middleton has the capacity). 3 central defenders (Wilson, Flint/EEL, Bilongo). 3 in midfield (from the six we have). 2 up front (Henderson has to start)

Or a proper 4-3-3 with proper midfielders closer together. Not career forwards who want to play no.10. If you think of the 10s we had last season, some could play in midfield too. The likes of Barlow and Burger actually did as one of the two to good effect. Silcott-Duberry, Paterson, Brown? If they’re expected to contribute defensively near our goal then we won’t ever sort out how open we are.

Then when Dieseruvwe is fit (why no update?) get him back in to the 3-4-3 or 3-5-2 formations.

That’s all before considering the likes of Maguire, Beckwith, Tasker.

The squad is lopsided in certain areas, but there are enough good footballers to ensure we finish mid-table. Injuries and tactics permitting.
Forum
Reply
TVOS Preview - Rochdale v York City
at 20:10 14 Nov 2026

That example and the goal (there’s only a short highlights, so their other first half opportunities aren’t shown) reflect perfectly how exposed we are with the current formation.

On that one, Allen has been the one sitting, he’d dropped into a left back position with Taylor moving infield (a tactic he’d done more than once throughout the half). So as soon as there was an error York were into our back four. Except it wasn’t, the centre halves are miles apart and Pearce has enough time to line up his shot.

For the goal, Gilmour makes an really poor attempt at stopping Kitching as he comes forward, and then there’s acres of space for Banks as the rest of the side are stretched across far too much of the pitch. Again, ages for Banks to shoot, Pearce turns his effort in.

We could play Keane, Butt and Scholes in there, but if they are all 20-30 yards away from each other as a starting point, it’s doomed to give up chances every week.
Forum
Reply
TVOS Preview - Rochdale v York City
at 18:21 14 Nov 2026

The Flint header led to many in the Sandy to immediately compare it to the Stones goal. The football gods were obviously having a laugh at us then.

Fair assessment by the York fans. You could sense they aren’t as confident in how they play under Lindsay, but it can be argued his tactics worked - wait, win it, break into the oceans of space.

First ten, last twenty, we were the better side. As we have been in parts of many games.
Forum
Reply
TVOS Preview - Rochdale v York City
at 18:04 14 Nov 2026

Yeah that was startling.

When Whatmuff did it last season it was with the clear knowledge that everyone watching knew we’d retain the ball and move up the field with it.

That structure ensured the players knew it too. Currently we look in a state of panic any time we go backwards.
Forum
Reply
TVOS Preview - Rochdale v York City
at 18:01 14 Nov 2026

While I’d agree about the statement that what we’ve added to the squad hasn’t been an improvement on what we had, as individuals they might still prove to be better in the long run.

It’s that failing to deal with the problems makes the collective seem worse, because we’d been accustomed to everyone knowing what their role was and what worked.

Would try and stress that sticking with the club is important for fans too, even though it’s a tough watch at the moment. Bad times won’t last, and we have to trust that something suddenly clicks, if not then you’d expect changes.
Forum
Reply
TVOS Preview - Rochdale v York City
at 17:50 14 Nov 2026

Aye, nonsense as we are walked through every week when we lose the ball because of how we set up. The structure.

Individual performances will always be a massive contributor. That those are directly impacted by the formation is something on the manager. Gilmour was poor today, not helped by being stranded so often. Similarly Allen’s contribution was limited by having so few options around him. No matter who plays in midfield, they’re on an immediate loser with the amount of space they have to cover because of how expansive we play. Everyone is miles away from everyone else.

This is then highlighted when the opposition win the ball. As seen all afternoon.

We are currently as far away from getting things right as we were at the start of the season. The five game unbeaten run, which saw an indication of how Watson wanted to play, was a false dawn it seems. The recognisable issues which were there during that run as well are still to be addressed. The answer has been to add player after player.

It hasn’t worked.
Forum
Reply
TVOS Preview - Rochdale v York City
at 17:05 14 Nov 2026

After the subs there was more energy and proof that a proper midfield three consisting of three midfielders makes us look a bit better.

Everything else? Just like this week, it’s chucking a whole load of stuff against the wall and hoping it sticks.

It was said a couple of posts back, such a shame we’ve lost so much of our identity to the point fans don’t even know what we are.

A mention for Tobi, people had concerns before the season about his suitability to play right back at this level. He’s been fine all season and today was a clear man of the match.
Forum
Reply
TVOS Preview - Rochdale v York City
at 16:04 14 Nov 2026

Started well, then pretty much all York once they worked out they just had to wait for us to give it away. Allen’s quality on the ball is obvious (his ball to Brown was brilliant) but he’s not improved our structure at all. If anything we’re even more open.
Ironically Middleton still had the best chance.
Forum
Reply
TVOS Preview - Rochdale v York City
at 13:52 14 Nov 2026

So a left back on the bench while a no.10 who’s been out for weeks come back in at left back.

Meanwhile a winger continues at no.10.
Forum
Reply
Jamie Allen
at 13:20 14 Nov 2026

Dunno. Don’t check or presume about everyone.
Forum
Reply
Jamie Allen
at 13:19 14 Nov 2026

It was a very valid criticism of McNulty the way he signed a multitude of players who could play no.10. The difference was each one knew where they fit in and all were utilised at any given moment to good effect. Well, except Mancini.

You don’t have to like something if you can understand it. But if it becomes difficult to work out why, faith is sometimes lost.
Forum
Reply
Jamie Allen
at 12:54 14 Nov 2026

Of course he will, Gilmour does similar. It’s what his actual role is within the structure that will relate to those around him in any given moment, whilst at the same way going some way to addressing the yet to be solved problems.

That will have been established in training. As Watson references a lot, it’s about processes. Was just wondering which position people see him start in.
Forum
Reply
Jamie Allen
at 12:50 14 Nov 2026

Didn’t say they did. Pointing out the issues that come with this signing are, as noted, understandable.
Forum
Reply
Jamie Allen
at 12:36 14 Nov 2026

The lack of structure, particularly in midfield with respect to the distances that leave us exposed is exactly why we need to ensure that Allen’s role alongside the two other players is clearly defined.
Forum
Reply
Jamie Allen
at 12:26 14 Nov 2026

Reiterating my concerns with the added note about relying on Henderson.

Why, if we were looking at players without a club, have we signed Paterson and Allen rather than a looking to bring in a centre forward?

Collecting players just because they’re good is fine if 1) the manager believes the squad is short in certain areas; 2) it’s within budget; 3) it doesn’t contradict previous concerns.

I’ve been supportive of Watson, he’s had so much bad luck, but pointing out obvious and avoidable errors and contradictions just because we’ve signed an excellent player isn’t unfair either.
Please log in to use all the site's facilities

442Dale


Site Scores

Prediction League: 0
TOTAL: 0
About Us Contact Us Terms & Conditions Privacy Cookies Online Safety Advertising
© FansNetwork 2026