| Harrison Ashby Has been class 15:40 - Oct 11 with 2381 views | RhonddaSwans |
https://www.nufcblog.co.uk/202
They are saying he has hit a bad patch.
The team is on a roll and I think Harrison has still got a big part to play
.
No one just walks into a winning team.
Do you agree with this Newcastle article? |  |
| |  |
| Harrison Ashby Has been class on 16:03 - Oct 11 with 2350 views | jasper_T |
Has looked way off it in all his appearances so far. Half the player Key is going forward, and certainly no better defensively. Useful for that period before we signed three left-sided players but otherwise a very poor loan for us and the player. | | | |
| Harrison Ashby Has been class on 16:32 - Oct 11 with 2315 views | Whiterockin |
Just a club bigging up their player. He has been average at best and doesn't deserve a start and won't unless Key gets injured. |  | | |
| Harrison Ashby Has been class on 18:24 - Oct 11 with 2212 views | KeithHaynes |
I’m pretty certain Duff won’t play him just to make sure he isn’t recalled in January. |  |
| |
| Harrison Ashby Has been class on 18:36 - Oct 11 with 2196 views | RichardO |
| Harrison Ashby Has been class on 18:24 - Oct 11 by KeithHaynes |
I’m pretty certain Duff won’t play him just to make sure he isn’t recalled in January. |
He is a developing young player who really should have been used sparingly to get him up to speed but he was shoved in at the deep end, 2 not bad performances one where he lost his confidence completely(home games) but then again the team shape had yet to come together, still think he should be used as appropriately ie when we have a number of games in quick succession using the squad wisely we're injury doubts occur. | | | |
| Harrison Ashby Has been class on 23:19 - Oct 11 with 2003 views | onehunglow |
Developing for whom?
He is a wasted loan
Key is miles ahead of him in that right back position
Ashby shukdnt be made to play left back either
He does not look PL quality at all | |
| |
| Harrison Ashby Has been class on 00:40 - Oct 12 with 1979 views | RhonddaSwans |
| Harrison Ashby Has been class on 16:03 - Oct 11 by jasper_T |
Has looked way off it in all his appearances so far. Half the player Key is going forward, and certainly no better defensively. Useful for that period before we signed three left-sided players but otherwise a very poor loan for us and the player. |
key hasn't just left youth football has he? | |
| |
| Harrison Ashby Has been class on 11:34 - Oct 12 with 1825 views | jasper_T |
| Harrison Ashby Has been class on 00:40 - Oct 12 by RhonddaSwans |
key hasn't just left youth football has he? |
Who cares? We have him for this season only. If he's not good enough he's not good enough. | | | |
| Harrison Ashby Has been class on 16:28 - Oct 12 with 1740 views | jack247 |
| Harrison Ashby Has been class on 23:19 - Oct 11 by onehunglow |
Developing for whom?
He is a wasted loan
Key is miles ahead of him in that right back position
Ashby shukdnt be made to play left back either
He does not look PL quality at all |
At the moment I’d agree with you, though he is highly rated, so I’m hoping there’s more to him than we’ve seen so far.
I’m all for loan players, but they have to come in and make an impact. If he’s not forcing his way into our starting eleven or at the very least coming off the bench most games, then he’s not developing for anyone and he’d be better off at another club or in Newcastles reserves. | | | |
Login to get fewer ads
| Harrison Ashby Has been class on 17:39 - Oct 12 with 1709 views | onehunglow |
| Harrison Ashby Has been class on 16:28 - Oct 12 by jack247 |
At the moment I’d agree with you, though he is highly rated, so I’m hoping there’s more to him than we’ve seen so far.
I’m all for loan players, but they have to come in and make an impact. If he’s not forcing his way into our starting eleven or at the very least coming off the bench most games, then he’s not developing for anyone and he’d be better off at another club or in Newcastles reserves. |
Nice response
Thanks
I'm not as keen on loans myself | |
| |
| Harrison Ashby Has been class on 18:01 - Oct 12 with 1691 views | jack247 |
| Harrison Ashby Has been class on 17:39 - Oct 12 by onehunglow |
Nice response
Thanks
I'm not as keen on loans myself |
Personal opinion is that if we go into a season with no realistic chance of promotion or relegation (which is very unlikely) then don’t bother with them. If we’ve got 6 games left and the season is dead, give the like of Congreve game time.
Any other time, the success of the club takes priority over individual players. Plus having the likes of Humphreys and Ashby, who aren’t ready for Chelsea and Newcastle yet, means we can loan out Brandon Cooper, who will develop further playing for Leyton Orient than being a backup for us. Not exactly like for like, but you get my point.
I know not everyone will agree. | | | |
| Harrison Ashby Has been class on 18:21 - Oct 12 with 1668 views | KeithHaynes |
| Harrison Ashby Has been class on 16:28 - Oct 12 by jack247 |
At the moment I’d agree with you, though he is highly rated, so I’m hoping there’s more to him than we’ve seen so far.
I’m all for loan players, but they have to come in and make an impact. If he’s not forcing his way into our starting eleven or at the very least coming off the bench most games, then he’s not developing for anyone and he’d be better off at another club or in Newcastles reserves. |
The last bit another club yes.
A lot of premier league clubs are happy to see their players in and around a match day squad, experiencing what goes on, learning new training techniques, seeing how players are at other clubs, interaction, fending for themselves away from home ( as much as a pampered footballer does ) Yes, getting games is important, but it’s not the be all.
There’s a huge difference between training in a first team squad and being a reserve at their clubs. | |
| |
| Harrison Ashby Has been class on 09:37 - Oct 13 with 1529 views | RichardO |
Don't really like developing players for teams from the higher divisions but if they serve a purpose as Ashby did at the start of the season then so be it, Guehi was dropped until he found his feet. In the early season we were playing Key out of position to accommodate Ashby while also playing the 3/5 at the back which didn't work in the previous two seasons and didn't in the early season friendlies or at the begin on the season, some would say it was the defence or style of play but you could say that the midfield wasn't functioning properly.
New players, new options look a different team, do we need Ashby in the squad to cover the right back position I think so, you could say we have Abdulai but I think he is a better option in attack rather than defence.
Long season ahead so we may still have a use for Ashby. [Post edited 13 Oct 2023 9:51]
| | | |
| Harrison Ashby Has been class on 09:42 - Oct 13 with 1528 views | onehunglow |
| Harrison Ashby Has been class on 18:01 - Oct 12 by jack247 |
Personal opinion is that if we go into a season with no realistic chance of promotion or relegation (which is very unlikely) then don’t bother with them. If we’ve got 6 games left and the season is dead, give the like of Congreve game time.
Any other time, the success of the club takes priority over individual players. Plus having the likes of Humphreys and Ashby, who aren’t ready for Chelsea and Newcastle yet, means we can loan out Brandon Cooper, who will develop further playing for Leyton Orient than being a backup for us. Not exactly like for like, but you get my point.
I know not everyone will agree. |
I do get your point
Good posting | |
| |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
