| QPR being sued on 14:13 - Feb 12 with 4725 views | Northernr |
Oh good. |  | |  |
| QPR being sued on 14:22 - Feb 12 with 4640 views | Watford_Ranger |
I like the paragraph suggesting he was set for a comparable career to Eze or Chair which would explain being on loan at Crawley at 21. |  | | |
| QPR being sued on 14:25 - Feb 12 with 4616 views | KensalT |
He's basing his damages on text messages from Paul Hall comparing him favourably with Eberechi Eze and Ilias Chair!
Good luck making that stick:
"Bansal-McNulty’s case is based on his contention that QPR and Crawley failed to protect him from abuse by Yems, which he claims led to the end of his professional career and significant psychological damage. In documents submitted to the tribunal, seen by the Guardian, he is claiming for a net award of £6.1m, with the gross figure £11.1m before tax.
His legal team produced as part of their evidence text messages from QPR’s former professional development coach Paul Hall, in which he compared Bansal-McNulty favourably with two other players he worked with at Loftus Road, Eberechi Eze and Ilias Chair." | | | |
| QPR being sued on 14:26 - Feb 12 with 4605 views | 7374Ranger |
I don't subscribe to the Guardian so cannot read the article. What is the law suit about? | | | |
| QPR being sued on 14:26 - Feb 12 with 4595 views | Wilkinswatercarrier |
| QPR being sued on 14:26 - Feb 12 by 7374Ranger |
I don't subscribe to the Guardian so cannot read the article. What is the law suit about? |
You don't need to subscribe. It's free. | |
| |
| QPR being sued on 14:38 - Feb 12 with 4519 views | 7374Ranger |
It seems to be free only if I accept all their cookies., which according to advice I saw on a TV programme, is not good.
But as I was posting the article was also posted. | | | |
| QPR being sued on 14:49 - Feb 12 with 4408 views | KensalT |
| QPR being sued on 14:38 - Feb 12 by 7374Ranger |
It seems to be free only if I accept all their cookies., which according to advice I saw on a TV programme, is not good.
But as I was posting the article was also posted. |
Here's the whole article:
"Queens Park Rangers and Crawley Town are being sued for more than ÂŁ11m by a former player who is claiming they failed to protect him from alleged racist banter that he says destroyed his career.
The Championship club are joint defendants with Crawley in a claim currently being heard at the Central London Employment Tribunal, brought by the former Northern Ireland Under-21 international Amrit Bansal-McNulty, who is suing for ÂŁ11.1m for a loss of opportunity and personal injury. Both clubs have denied wrongdoing.
...
https://www.theguardian.com/fo
This post has been edited by an administrator | | | |
| QPR being sued on 15:10 - Feb 12 with 4269 views | nick_hammersmith |
| QPR being sued on 14:25 - Feb 12 by KensalT |
He's basing his damages on text messages from Paul Hall comparing him favourably with Eberechi Eze and Ilias Chair!
Good luck making that stick:
"Bansal-McNulty’s case is based on his contention that QPR and Crawley failed to protect him from abuse by Yems, which he claims led to the end of his professional career and significant psychological damage. In documents submitted to the tribunal, seen by the Guardian, he is claiming for a net award of £6.1m, with the gross figure £11.1m before tax.
His legal team produced as part of their evidence text messages from QPR’s former professional development coach Paul Hall, in which he compared Bansal-McNulty favourably with two other players he worked with at Loftus Road, Eberechi Eze and Ilias Chair." |
It's a tricky one, as he's suing for loss of potential future earnings.
I had a friend who was playing in L1 football and had a nasty leg break in a cup game. He got a letter from David Pleat saying Spurs were interested and based the case off hi moving there at some point.
They settled for somewhere no party was happy, as I'm sure will be the case here.
I'm not sure how I feel about this to be honest.
We send these boys out to be exposed to "Men's" football and it sounds like thats what they got in this situation, with a bit more to boot!
I've had some arsehole bosses in my time, but I'm not sure they stopped me from winning the metaphorical world cup... |  | | |
Login to get fewer ads
| QPR being sued on 15:18 - Feb 12 with 4218 views | Hoopstar |
I was at a Crawley game when he was on loan there (nearest league side) and remember how amazed I was at the size of him. Not sure he'd have made the flyweight class at the time and looked completely unsuited to League Two football.
He didn't get on the pitch so can't comment if he was any good, but he was Chair sized minus the heft that Chair possesses in abundance for one his size.
That Crawley side was awful however, and if you couldn't get a game there... |  | | |
| QPR being sued on 15:25 - Feb 12 with 4163 views | Northernr |
| QPR being sued on 15:10 - Feb 12 by nick_hammersmith |
It's a tricky one, as he's suing for loss of potential future earnings.
I had a friend who was playing in L1 football and had a nasty leg break in a cup game. He got a letter from David Pleat saying Spurs were interested and based the case off hi moving there at some point.
They settled for somewhere no party was happy, as I'm sure will be the case here.
I'm not sure how I feel about this to be honest.
We send these boys out to be exposed to "Men's" football and it sounds like thats what they got in this situation, with a bit more to boot!
I've had some arsehole bosses in my time, but I'm not sure they stopped me from winning the metaphorical world cup... |
It'll hinge on this conversation with Ramsey.
If ABM has gone to his 'line manager' (Ramsey) and explicitly told him what Yems was saying, doing etc and Ramsey has said "that's life kid, get yourself back there" then we'll have a problem.
If he's vaguely said that Yems is a bit of a cnt and he hates him but not mentioned the racism specifically and Ramsey has said "that's football kid, get used to it" then there's less of a case.
According to that piece ABM says it's the former and Ramsey says it's the latter. Hopefully Ramsey's record in this regard will stand us in good stead. | | | |
| QPR being sued on 15:28 - Feb 12 with 4124 views | colinallcars |
“Both have denied any wrongdoing” Since the Epstein file release we hear that on the news incessantly. |  | | |
| QPR being sued on 15:36 - Feb 12 with 4084 views | Lblock |
Ahhhhhhhh... the golden ticket being played.
I seem to recall this being spoken about some time ago. |  |
| Cherish and enjoy life.... this ain't no dress rehearsal |
| |
| QPR being sued on 15:38 - Feb 12 with 4070 views | TomS |
I feel sorry for Paul Hall. All he was clearly trying to do was boost a young player's confidence.
If Harry Redknapp told a reporter that a young player in the reserves, with no first team appearances, could be as good as Luka Modric, would you rely on that as evidence in Court for a multi million pound claim? |  | | |
| QPR being sued on 15:41 - Feb 12 with 4028 views | Northernr |
| QPR being sued on 15:38 - Feb 12 by TomS |
I feel sorry for Paul Hall. All he was clearly trying to do was boost a young player's confidence.
If Harry Redknapp told a reporter that a young player in the reserves, with no first team appearances, could be as good as Luka Modric, would you rely on that as evidence in Court for a multi million pound claim? |
There'd be a lot of claims! | | | |
| QPR being sued on 15:45 - Feb 12 with 3996 views | NW5Hoop |
| QPR being sued on 14:49 - Feb 12 by KensalT |
Here's the whole article:
"Queens Park Rangers and Crawley Town are being sued for more than ÂŁ11m by a former player who is claiming they failed to protect him from alleged racist banter that he says destroyed his career.
The Championship club are joint defendants with Crawley in a claim currently being heard at the Central London Employment Tribunal, brought by the former Northern Ireland Under-21 international Amrit Bansal-McNulty, who is suing for ÂŁ11.1m for a loss of opportunity and personal injury. Both clubs have denied wrongdoing.
...
https://www.theguardian.com/fo
This post has been edited by an administrator |
I have said this before, but please don’t copy and paste whole pieces of journalism. That is someone’s work, and reposting it a) steals that work and b) puts Clive in breach of copyright. The link is free. You can refuse cookies. Just click the bloody link. | | | |
| QPR being sued on 15:49 - Feb 12 with 3970 views | Superhoop83 |
| QPR being sued on 15:38 - Feb 12 by TomS |
I feel sorry for Paul Hall. All he was clearly trying to do was boost a young player's confidence.
If Harry Redknapp told a reporter that a young player in the reserves, with no first team appearances, could be as good as Luka Modric, would you rely on that as evidence in Court for a multi million pound claim? |
I wouldn't rely on Redknapp to tell me the time.
As for the case, and as I work in this field, I reckon he'll be awarded something but (hopefully) only against Crawley, probably a five figure sum, based mainly on what he was subjected to and not on his dream of being a megastar, which was never going to happen. |  |
| |
| QPR being sued on 15:50 - Feb 12 with 3962 views | Northernr |
| QPR being sued on 15:45 - Feb 12 by NW5Hoop |
I have said this before, but please don’t copy and paste whole pieces of journalism. That is someone’s work, and reposting it a) steals that work and b) puts Clive in breach of copyright. The link is free. You can refuse cookies. Just click the bloody link. |
He is right, sorry. | | | |
| QPR being sued on 16:25 - Feb 12 with 3717 views | E17hoop |
The club will have insurance to pay any claim, but a condition will have been that we defend; I'd guess a before-action offer might have been made accepting no liability beforehand, which has been rejected. |  |
| |
| QPR being sued on 16:33 - Feb 12 with 3664 views | KensalT |
| QPR being sued on 15:45 - Feb 12 by NW5Hoop |
I have said this before, but please don’t copy and paste whole pieces of journalism. That is someone’s work, and reposting it a) steals that work and b) puts Clive in breach of copyright. The link is free. You can refuse cookies. Just click the bloody link. |
Fair point and duly noted. | | | |
| QPR being sued on 16:37 - Feb 12 with 3622 views | bosh67 |
Would be potentially be cheaper to resign him and see if he actually is that good. |  |
| |
| QPR being sued on 16:43 - Feb 12 with 3576 views | KensalT |
| QPR being sued on 15:25 - Feb 12 by Northernr |
It'll hinge on this conversation with Ramsey.
If ABM has gone to his 'line manager' (Ramsey) and explicitly told him what Yems was saying, doing etc and Ramsey has said "that's life kid, get yourself back there" then we'll have a problem.
If he's vaguely said that Yems is a bit of a cnt and he hates him but not mentioned the racism specifically and Ramsey has said "that's football kid, get used to it" then there's less of a case.
According to that piece ABM says it's the former and Ramsey says it's the latter. Hopefully Ramsey's record in this regard will stand us in good stead. |
ABM won't get very far unless he can corroborate what he says he said to Ramsey.
He won't win if it's just his word v Ramsey! | | | |
| QPR being sued on 16:46 - Feb 12 with 3539 views | dmm |
| QPR being sued on 16:37 - Feb 12 by bosh67 |
Would be potentially be cheaper to resign him and see if he actually is that good. |
He really wasn't that good. While with us he went on loan to Torquay (National League), Dartford (National League South), Como (Serie C) and Crawley (League 2) and racked up a total of 13 appearances during those 4 loans. That, I think, tells us all we need to know about his footballing ability. |  | | |
| QPR being sued on 16:51 - Feb 12 with 3491 views | 1JD |
| QPR being sued on 16:37 - Feb 12 by bosh67 |
Would be potentially be cheaper to resign him and see if he actually is that good. |
He was one of those many players who look good at five a side but all at sea in the men’s game. At the post above says, featherweight. Was never ever going to make it as a professional footballer. | | | |
| QPR being sued on 17:02 - Feb 12 with 3427 views | nick_hammersmith |
| QPR being sued on 15:38 - Feb 12 by TomS |
I feel sorry for Paul Hall. All he was clearly trying to do was boost a young player's confidence.
If Harry Redknapp told a reporter that a young player in the reserves, with no first team appearances, could be as good as Luka Modric, would you rely on that as evidence in Court for a multi million pound claim? |
Is the player in question 'Arry's nephew though? | | | |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
