| Walta has the final word 21:57 - Nov 15 with 3560 views | KeithHaynes | Against anyone this is class. |  |
| |  |
| Walta has the final word on 12:26 - Nov 16 | Whiterockin |
So we are outperforming our xG. |  | |  |
| Walta has the final word on 12:35 - Nov 16 | MumsArmy |
| Walta has the final word on 12:24 - Nov 16 by Dr_Winston | Something else worth noting is that our results under Matos last season were impressive enough even though we weren't as single minded about the press as we seem to have become. Both Vipi and Idah scored plenty of goals playing that way. Maybe we didn't need to reinvent the wheel. Adding more squad depth/quality to what we were already doing could have been just as good, maybe even better. |
I tend to agree. Our record after 15 games under Matos last season is pretty much the same as after 15 games this season, 8 wins a piece and a point separating the two spells. Given the spend this summer I would have much preferred to have invested in players that can play a varied game and elevated what we had (Eustaquio is the sort who can do both) rather than those who have just supercharged the press. Our DNA is being slowly changed because with all these players coming in that are just suited to the press, we are boxing ourselves in for the next manager. Dare I say it, Alan Sheehan is a lesser version of the same principles. Maybe I’m being spoilt but I just always valued a front footed possession first attitude like a Rodgers or a Laudrup, where as we are now an out of possession first type side. Possibly the two most technically gifted players at the club in Galbraith and Walta have found themselves pushed out of our midfield in favour of runners. |  | |  |
| Walta has the final word on 12:37 - Nov 16 | MumsArmy |
| Walta has the final word on 12:26 - Nov 16 by Whiterockin | So we are outperforming our xG. |
Slightly but not to any significant level, we are 13th in goals scored and 15th in xG so it’s about where we expect to be when it comes to the scoring/creating side of things. [Post edited 16 Nov 12:40]
|  | |  |
| Walta has the final word on 12:41 - Nov 16 | jack247 |
And sixth in the actual table, three points off the top, where we’ve been for most of the season and very likely still would be were it not for two missed open (ish) goals in our last few games. West Brom will be a good barometer. |  | |  |
| Walta has the final word on 12:49 - Nov 16 | MumsArmy |
| Walta has the final word on 12:41 - Nov 16 by jack247 | And sixth in the actual table, three points off the top, where we’ve been for most of the season and very likely still would be were it not for two missed open (ish) goals in our last few games. West Brom will be a good barometer. |
Yes but that is built on defensive solidity and off ball work rather than the creative side that we are talking about. In terms of goals scored, our output is roughly what our xG tells us it should be. If we slightly outperform it, it means our finishing has been slightly above the level of chances we have created. Defensively we have been excellent, but that’s a different discussion altogether to what we may be missing on the offensive side with Walta not being included, which is why I compared Walta’s off ball stats to Just, having Walta instead means we wouldn’t be losing anything (slightly gaining) with regards to the defensive side but offensively we will be more of a threat. |  | |  |
| Walta has the final word on 12:55 - Nov 16 | MumsArmy | This is what Christian on Twitter posted about the attacking/creative stats as a comparison: Leo Walta (23) 437 mins ⏱️ 1G+A⚽️ 2.27 shots 🥅 1.03 SOT 🎯 2.68 chances created 📦 0.62 big chances 🙌 Elijah Just (26) 649 mins⏱️ 1G+A⚽️ 1.80 shots 🥅 0.55 SOT 🎯 1.80 chances created 📦 0.14 big chances 🙌 |  | |  |
| Walta has the final word on 13:02 - Nov 16 | jack247 |
| Walta has the final word on 12:49 - Nov 16 by MumsArmy | Yes but that is built on defensive solidity and off ball work rather than the creative side that we are talking about. In terms of goals scored, our output is roughly what our xG tells us it should be. If we slightly outperform it, it means our finishing has been slightly above the level of chances we have created. Defensively we have been excellent, but that’s a different discussion altogether to what we may be missing on the offensive side with Walta not being included, which is why I compared Walta’s off ball stats to Just, having Walta instead means we wouldn’t be losing anything (slightly gaining) with regards to the defensive side but offensively we will be more of a threat. |
Well Just is by no means a nailed on starter. I think he will come good, but as frequently gets pointed out, he hasn’t hit the heights expected of him yet. If the XG is telling us our finishing is above the level of chances we’ve created, it must have missed the Ronald v West Ham and Stewart v Portsmouth late misses as well as Stewarts penalty at Birmingham. The three ‘creative’ goals I mentioned were all tap ins, where we played the ball through the opposition, leaving our players with easy finishes. If it’s factoring in two missed open goals, three tap ins and missed penalty and saying we’re still scoring more than we should be, I wouldn’t be inclined to trust it implicitly. |  | |  |
| Walta has the final word on 13:11 - Nov 16 | MumsArmy |
| Walta has the final word on 13:02 - Nov 16 by jack247 | Well Just is by no means a nailed on starter. I think he will come good, but as frequently gets pointed out, he hasn’t hit the heights expected of him yet. If the XG is telling us our finishing is above the level of chances we’ve created, it must have missed the Ronald v West Ham and Stewart v Portsmouth late misses as well as Stewarts penalty at Birmingham. The three ‘creative’ goals I mentioned were all tap ins, where we played the ball through the opposition, leaving our players with easy finishes. If it’s factoring in two missed open goals, three tap ins and missed penalty and saying we’re still scoring more than we should be, I wouldn’t be inclined to trust it implicitly. |
The misses are factored in, every shot we have taken is. While we have missed some sitters we have also scored some tough ones like Stewart’s 4th against Blackburn. So on the balance of all chances we have had, our finishing has slightly outperformed our chance creation. We have scored one of the lowest amounts in the top half, so there is no reason not to trust it. Having a low xG also doesn’t mean we can’t have creative moments, Stoke are in the bottom 3 for xG created but I’m certain they will have had some good creative moments too. But xG measures the whole 90, not just moments. |  | |  | Login to get fewer ads
| Walta has the final word on 13:25 - Nov 16 | jack247 |
| Walta has the final word on 13:11 - Nov 16 by MumsArmy | The misses are factored in, every shot we have taken is. While we have missed some sitters we have also scored some tough ones like Stewart’s 4th against Blackburn. So on the balance of all chances we have had, our finishing has slightly outperformed our chance creation. We have scored one of the lowest amounts in the top half, so there is no reason not to trust it. Having a low xG also doesn’t mean we can’t have creative moments, Stoke are in the bottom 3 for xG created but I’m certain they will have had some good creative moments too. But xG measures the whole 90, not just moments. |
And that is exactly what we need to do for Leo Walta if we are considering bringing him back. Not just the free kicks and the clever flicks people see on YouTube. If Matos thought he would do the whole job and produce moments of magic, he’d be here and starting every game. Gut feeling is that if Stamenić does go for big money, we’ll look to strengthen here and bring in competition/cover for Eustaquio. I’m not sure he sees Just as the answer either, he’s on the bench as often as he starts. |  | |  |
| Walta has the final word on 13:28 - Nov 16 | onehunglow |
| Walta has the final word on 11:23 - Nov 16 by wwcigne | These stats confuse me even more , just hasn’t done anything to impress me when I’ve watched him Maybe Matos just doesn’t like Walta , he’s only 22 and with the right coaching can improve his weaknesses ,the positives are there for all to see I hope we don’t lose a good player because of the managers stubbornness |
Walta seems to be a maverick Opposition hate these players |  |
|  |
| Walta has the final word on 13:35 - Nov 16 | jack247 |
| Walta has the final word on 13:28 - Nov 16 by onehunglow | Walta seems to be a maverick Opposition hate these players |
So do managers |  | |  |
| Walta has the final word on 13:35 - Nov 16 | MumsArmy |
| Walta has the final word on 13:25 - Nov 16 by jack247 | And that is exactly what we need to do for Leo Walta if we are considering bringing him back. Not just the free kicks and the clever flicks people see on YouTube. If Matos thought he would do the whole job and produce moments of magic, he’d be here and starting every game. Gut feeling is that if Stamenić does go for big money, we’ll look to strengthen here and bring in competition/cover for Eustaquio. I’m not sure he sees Just as the answer either, he’s on the bench as often as he starts. |
That’s the opposite of what we are doing there though with respect, we are looking at his rounded picture not just his free kicks or flicks. He is better defensively and offensively than the player presumably brought in to replace him, that’s aside from flicks or free kicks. I can see Matos doesn’t agree, but I suppose that’s the discussion right? Is Matos correct to think that? To assume a manager can’t make mistakes or have favourites would be a mistake in itself I suppose because we know that not to be true. |  | |  |
| Walta has the final word on 13:48 - Nov 16 | jack247 |
| Walta has the final word on 13:35 - Nov 16 by MumsArmy | That’s the opposite of what we are doing there though with respect, we are looking at his rounded picture not just his free kicks or flicks. He is better defensively and offensively than the player presumably brought in to replace him, that’s aside from flicks or free kicks. I can see Matos doesn’t agree, but I suppose that’s the discussion right? Is Matos correct to think that? To assume a manager can’t make mistakes or have favourites would be a mistake in itself I suppose because we know that not to be true. |
You are. You’re backing up your points with XG and stats from Twitter. Whilst I’m far from convinced on Walta, I can respect the points you are making. Many seem to be seduced by 10 second YouTube clips, they are seeing what he can bring us, but ignoring what his inclusion would take away. Whether people think we’re too heavily reliant on pressing, most would probably agree it’s been a big part of a successful season so far. As for Matos getting things wrong, any manager can and any fan can have opinions. The vast majority of the time though, the manager who has spent his whole adult life in and around football and sees the players every day, is far more likely to be right than the fan who watched them once a week and has a far more limited knowledge of the game. |  | |  |
| Walta has the final word on 13:53 - Nov 16 | MumsArmy |
| Walta has the final word on 13:48 - Nov 16 by jack247 | You are. You’re backing up your points with XG and stats from Twitter. Whilst I’m far from convinced on Walta, I can respect the points you are making. Many seem to be seduced by 10 second YouTube clips, they are seeing what he can bring us, but ignoring what his inclusion would take away. Whether people think we’re too heavily reliant on pressing, most would probably agree it’s been a big part of a successful season so far. As for Matos getting things wrong, any manager can and any fan can have opinions. The vast majority of the time though, the manager who has spent his whole adult life in and around football and sees the players every day, is far more likely to be right than the fan who watched them once a week and has a far more limited knowledge of the game. |
So that isn’t highlights of free kicks or flicks, I said the data takes into consideration the whole 90 not just highlights and that’s what we are talking about. I’m not talking about his YouTube clips or highlight reels, I’m talking about his production both offensive and defensive across the full 90’s. You say the press has been a big part of a successful season so far but the results mirror what we saw last season under Matos where the press wasn’t nearly as pronounced, 15 games, 8 wins, 1 point different between the two periods - but with 20m+ spent on top of what we had (minus Galbraith). It’s crazy to think your opinion changes the moment Matos changes his. |  | |  |
| Walta has the final word on 15:08 - Nov 16 | onehunglow |
| Walta has the final word on 13:53 - Nov 16 by MumsArmy | So that isn’t highlights of free kicks or flicks, I said the data takes into consideration the whole 90 not just highlights and that’s what we are talking about. I’m not talking about his YouTube clips or highlight reels, I’m talking about his production both offensive and defensive across the full 90’s. You say the press has been a big part of a successful season so far but the results mirror what we saw last season under Matos where the press wasn’t nearly as pronounced, 15 games, 8 wins, 1 point different between the two periods - but with 20m+ spent on top of what we had (minus Galbraith). It’s crazy to think your opinion changes the moment Matos changes his. |
I d say we have genuine cause for concern regarding Matos and his judgement We could easily lose the next three games and the talk of play offs will be just a memory It’s all about the now And right now, we have a talented player kicking his heels in MLS when he should be with us We brought in Parente to back up Tymon who’s defending has been dire He’s hardly had a.sniff but looked classy as n a short cameo role Vipotnik is being treated in a bizarre fashion and as each month / match goes by his value slips away Matos has been backed by the owners and he is under pressure , as he should be |  |
|  |
| Walta has the final word on 15:36 - Nov 16 | MumsArmy |
| Walta has the final word on 15:08 - Nov 16 by onehunglow | I d say we have genuine cause for concern regarding Matos and his judgement We could easily lose the next three games and the talk of play offs will be just a memory It’s all about the now And right now, we have a talented player kicking his heels in MLS when he should be with us We brought in Parente to back up Tymon who’s defending has been dire He’s hardly had a.sniff but looked classy as n a short cameo role Vipotnik is being treated in a bizarre fashion and as each month / match goes by his value slips away Matos has been backed by the owners and he is under pressure , as he should be |
I think we are missing strong direction at the club. There doesn’t seem to be a lot of forward thinking at the moment. Vipotnik being benched while rejecting offers of 8 figures, Walta being loaned out and bringing in Just for 6m, signing Stewart for 3 years at the age of 30 with an injury record like his, shaping the whole squad around the Matos style of play with no thought of what comes after, selling Congreve for 1m who has been phenomenal in Belgium and shown real output in Scotland last season, and then spending it all on loaning a 17 year old who doesn’t get a single minute while falling foul of the home grown rule. I think even Galbraith was undersold, if Stoke were to sell him in Jan you would be looking at closer to double what they paid. I like Matos, clearly a talented coach so I don’t want to be critical there as he has got us playing well, my concern is the strategy seems completely missing. Some of the decisions being made are very strange, hard to know who is making them. |  | |  |
| Walta has the final word on 15:53 - Nov 16 | onehunglow |
| Walta has the final word on 15:36 - Nov 16 by MumsArmy | I think we are missing strong direction at the club. There doesn’t seem to be a lot of forward thinking at the moment. Vipotnik being benched while rejecting offers of 8 figures, Walta being loaned out and bringing in Just for 6m, signing Stewart for 3 years at the age of 30 with an injury record like his, shaping the whole squad around the Matos style of play with no thought of what comes after, selling Congreve for 1m who has been phenomenal in Belgium and shown real output in Scotland last season, and then spending it all on loaning a 17 year old who doesn’t get a single minute while falling foul of the home grown rule. I think even Galbraith was undersold, if Stoke were to sell him in Jan you would be looking at closer to double what they paid. I like Matos, clearly a talented coach so I don’t want to be critical there as he has got us playing well, my concern is the strategy seems completely missing. Some of the decisions being made are very strange, hard to know who is making them. |
Some post that I like Matos as an individual but I’ve doubts about his coaching and strategy This is his squad and defines him You’re only as good as your last game : on any sport Anyway , welcome Fresh air |  |
|  |
| Walta has the final word on 16:21 - Nov 16 | jack247 |
| Walta has the final word on 13:53 - Nov 16 by MumsArmy | So that isn’t highlights of free kicks or flicks, I said the data takes into consideration the whole 90 not just highlights and that’s what we are talking about. I’m not talking about his YouTube clips or highlight reels, I’m talking about his production both offensive and defensive across the full 90’s. You say the press has been a big part of a successful season so far but the results mirror what we saw last season under Matos where the press wasn’t nearly as pronounced, 15 games, 8 wins, 1 point different between the two periods - but with 20m+ spent on top of what we had (minus Galbraith). It’s crazy to think your opinion changes the moment Matos changes his. |
That isn’t what I said, I acknowledged you were at least backing your opinions up. The majority of the people calling for Walta aren’t even considering (or at least not mentioning) the off the ball impact. They are generally the same people who think we should play two up front or a 10 in the current system and don’t realise we’d get overrun in the middle. Yes this seasons results are very similar to last seasons under Matos, but have been distorted by a disastrous five game period featuring missed open goals, missed penalties, a red card and an offside winner for West Ham. Five games ago we were easily outperforming that and I’m confident we will again soon. I’m not always going to agree with everything Matos does, I don’t think I agreed with Michael Duff on anything, but I’m sensible enough to understand they both have far more football knowledge and far more access to the players than I do. Probably more than Christian from Twitter does too. |  | |  |
| Walta has the final word on 16:25 - Nov 16 | jack247 |
| Walta has the final word on 15:36 - Nov 16 by MumsArmy | I think we are missing strong direction at the club. There doesn’t seem to be a lot of forward thinking at the moment. Vipotnik being benched while rejecting offers of 8 figures, Walta being loaned out and bringing in Just for 6m, signing Stewart for 3 years at the age of 30 with an injury record like his, shaping the whole squad around the Matos style of play with no thought of what comes after, selling Congreve for 1m who has been phenomenal in Belgium and shown real output in Scotland last season, and then spending it all on loaning a 17 year old who doesn’t get a single minute while falling foul of the home grown rule. I think even Galbraith was undersold, if Stoke were to sell him in Jan you would be looking at closer to double what they paid. I like Matos, clearly a talented coach so I don’t want to be critical there as he has got us playing well, my concern is the strategy seems completely missing. Some of the decisions being made are very strange, hard to know who is making them. |
In pretty sure the club expected £20m+ offers for Vipotnik. If we’d know he was staying, would we have signed Stewart, even on a free? Same sort of thing for Just really. He hasn’t hit the heights yet. Had we known that, we may well have looked elsewhere in the summer. Not every signing is going to hit the ground running. |  | |  |
| Walta has the final word on 16:45 - Nov 16 | MumsArmy |
| Walta has the final word on 16:21 - Nov 16 by jack247 | That isn’t what I said, I acknowledged you were at least backing your opinions up. The majority of the people calling for Walta aren’t even considering (or at least not mentioning) the off the ball impact. They are generally the same people who think we should play two up front or a 10 in the current system and don’t realise we’d get overrun in the middle. Yes this seasons results are very similar to last seasons under Matos, but have been distorted by a disastrous five game period featuring missed open goals, missed penalties, a red card and an offside winner for West Ham. Five games ago we were easily outperforming that and I’m confident we will again soon. I’m not always going to agree with everything Matos does, I don’t think I agreed with Michael Duff on anything, but I’m sensible enough to understand they both have far more football knowledge and far more access to the players than I do. Probably more than Christian from Twitter does too. |
Christian is just reporting the data that companies with dozens of experts employed by them compile, he’s not making the data himself. The same data companies that the top teams in Europe will all be paying to use, managers with far more behind them than Matos will be using the very same numbers. To say it’s Christian off twitter vs Matos is a misrepresentation of the issue. I don’t think the last 5 games were disastrous as such, they just happened to come in a batch vs tougher opponents (average opposition position was 8th), we had a very kind run of 10 games (average opposition position 15th) and the last 5 have been difficult as we have played a higher concentration of top 10 teams. If the fixtures had been spread more unevenly and the last 5 games were scattered in among the opening 10, I don’t think anybody would be calling it disastrous losing to those sides. To say it’s distorted suggests it’s not representation of reality which I would question, because we don’t have a right to play all our 46 games against the bottom half. I do accept that many people calling for Walta probably aren’t taking his off ball actions into account but my point is his off ball numbers are even better than the player who has played over 50% of minutes this year, so even if they aren’t using great logic they are still clumsily landing on the same conclusion as if they did take that into account. |  | |  |
| Walta has the final word on 16:58 - Nov 16 | jack247 |
| Walta has the final word on 16:45 - Nov 16 by MumsArmy | Christian is just reporting the data that companies with dozens of experts employed by them compile, he’s not making the data himself. The same data companies that the top teams in Europe will all be paying to use, managers with far more behind them than Matos will be using the very same numbers. To say it’s Christian off twitter vs Matos is a misrepresentation of the issue. I don’t think the last 5 games were disastrous as such, they just happened to come in a batch vs tougher opponents (average opposition position was 8th), we had a very kind run of 10 games (average opposition position 15th) and the last 5 have been difficult as we have played a higher concentration of top 10 teams. If the fixtures had been spread more unevenly and the last 5 games were scattered in among the opening 10, I don’t think anybody would be calling it disastrous losing to those sides. To say it’s distorted suggests it’s not representation of reality which I would question, because we don’t have a right to play all our 46 games against the bottom half. I do accept that many people calling for Walta probably aren’t taking his off ball actions into account but my point is his off ball numbers are even better than the player who has played over 50% of minutes this year, so even if they aren’t using great logic they are still clumsily landing on the same conclusion as if they did take that into account. |
Being sceptical about Walta doesn’t mean I think Elijah Just is the answer. I think he’s flattered to deceive. It’s an area for development no doubt and I really do think we need a player who combines creativity with the less glamorous stuff. Neither has done that in the fairly limited game time they’ve both had. I’m not convinced on the ‘better teams the last five games’ theory. We’ve been genuinely unlucky. Missed open goals against West Ham and Portsmouth cost us the four points that would see us top. We were doing well at Birmingham until the red card. The only teams that have really rinsed us are Southampton and QPR, one during our spectacular run and one during our disaster run. |  | |  |
| Walta has the final word on 17:08 - Nov 16 | MumsArmy |
| Walta has the final word on 16:58 - Nov 16 by jack247 | Being sceptical about Walta doesn’t mean I think Elijah Just is the answer. I think he’s flattered to deceive. It’s an area for development no doubt and I really do think we need a player who combines creativity with the less glamorous stuff. Neither has done that in the fairly limited game time they’ve both had. I’m not convinced on the ‘better teams the last five games’ theory. We’ve been genuinely unlucky. Missed open goals against West Ham and Portsmouth cost us the four points that would see us top. We were doing well at Birmingham until the red card. The only teams that have really rinsed us are Southampton and QPR, one during our spectacular run and one during our disaster run. |
Of course and that’s fine to be skeptical, but it’s only logical for people to prefer we brought a player back with better output than someone else we have playing in his spot. The better teams thing isn’t really a theory, it’s just a statement of truth. Our average opponent league position over the last 5 is significantly higher than the average opponent league position over the first 10 (8th vs 15th). Yes we missed some chances, but again those are moments and not representative of the full games. In the 4 games we lost, the opposition doubled our xG over each 90 mins combined so it doesn't point to a lack of luck. It’s also not taking into consideration the opposite, where the opposition have missed chances but we still won, Lincoln away comes to mind, we won 2-1 but they generated 3 big chances compared to our 1 (2.11 xG vs 0.92). [Post edited 16 Nov 17:20]
|  | |  |
| Walta has the final word on 17:20 - Nov 16 | jack247 |
| Walta has the final word on 17:08 - Nov 16 by MumsArmy | Of course and that’s fine to be skeptical, but it’s only logical for people to prefer we brought a player back with better output than someone else we have playing in his spot. The better teams thing isn’t really a theory, it’s just a statement of truth. Our average opponent league position over the last 5 is significantly higher than the average opponent league position over the first 10 (8th vs 15th). Yes we missed some chances, but again those are moments and not representative of the full games. In the 4 games we lost, the opposition doubled our xG over each 90 mins combined so it doesn't point to a lack of luck. It’s also not taking into consideration the opposite, where the opposition have missed chances but we still won, Lincoln away comes to mind, we won 2-1 but they generated 3 big chances compared to our 1 (2.11 xG vs 0.92). [Post edited 16 Nov 17:20]
|
That’s limiting us to Walta or Just (or someone like Widdell who has the aggression and industry but maybe not the guile of a traditional 10). I’d rather see a big improvement from one of the first two, or this part of the pitch be a priority, particularly if we sell Stamenić for decent money. The results themselves aren’t up for debate. If we’re looking at stats and XG, I’d imagine we weren’t far off equal with West Ham and Portsmouth in games we lost nor Stoke or Lincoln in games we won. Maybe it’s the optimist in me, but I think we’ll beat West Brom and have better stats on them on Saturday. |  | |  |
| Walta has the final word on 17:20 - Nov 16 | Whiterockin | Who was it who sourced Walta for the club. |  | |  |
| Walta has the final word on 17:30 - Nov 16 | MumsArmy |
| Walta has the final word on 17:20 - Nov 16 by jack247 | That’s limiting us to Walta or Just (or someone like Widdell who has the aggression and industry but maybe not the guile of a traditional 10). I’d rather see a big improvement from one of the first two, or this part of the pitch be a priority, particularly if we sell Stamenić for decent money. The results themselves aren’t up for debate. If we’re looking at stats and XG, I’d imagine we weren’t far off equal with West Ham and Portsmouth in games we lost nor Stoke or Lincoln in games we won. Maybe it’s the optimist in me, but I think we’ll beat West Brom and have better stats on them on Saturday. |
It’s just the reality of the situation, we can’t keep throwing money at a position and stockpiling those we don’t like, especially when they haven’t been given a real chance. It’s not realistic to think we have an option of keeping buying 10’s (not a cheap position) and letting ones we have already recently bought rot. Given the fact we likely can’t keep doing that then it comes down to who is more effective and the better asset, 26 year old Elijah Just or 23 year old Leo Walta. To me the answer is obvious. But I accept your point that in an ideal world you would want someone different again, I just question how realistic that is as a solution to the discussion. I think us and WBA are very similar levels, both top 8 sides battling for the spots 6th-8th - which we were last season too under Matos. |  | |  |
| |