| Guess the Ref 00:24 - Oct 8 with 3419 views | Lblock |
On 81 mins I reckon he was looking at a 3
On FT I’d say maybe, just maybe a 4 or 5, but come on… he was shockingly bad even by EFL standards
Such a shame that in the down part of my Friday blues this club featured so badly in the past |  |
| Cherish and enjoy life.... this ain't no dress rehearsal |
| |  |
| Guess the Ref on 00:26 - Oct 8 with 3382 views | aston_hoop |
Don't see him getting more than a 3 from Clive, and rightly so |  |
| |
| Guess the Ref on 00:28 - Oct 8 with 3356 views | WatfordR |
Really not sure in what universe Carroll's challenge wasn't a red. Thought it was a formality. |  | | |
| Guess the Ref on 01:54 - Oct 8 with 3235 views | QPerthR |
Add to that the booking for the unseen handball and Hutchinson would have had a second yellow for that challenge next challenge |  | | |
| Guess the Ref on 08:50 - Oct 8 with 2898 views | paulparker |
We were playing 12 men last night , another ref who seems to have a vendetta against us
The cherry on the cake for me was when chair was hacked not once but twice by reading players and he gave nothing , a second later the reading player falls to the floor and he blew instantly for a free kick to them
Also another word on Bum nose Hinchcliffe and his biased commentary, the bloke is a helmet of the highest order , the only man in the world who thought that was a clear penalty to Reading even when the replays showed he wasn’t touched at all
It really stuck in his claw when we got that second |  |
| And Bowles is onside, Swinburne has come rushing out of his goal , what can Bowles do here , onto the left foot no, on to the right foot
That’s there that’s two, and that’s Bowles
Brian Moore
|
| |
| Guess the Ref on 09:11 - Oct 8 with 2840 views | ozranger |
Strangely, Beale hit the nail right on the head with the non-given penalty in his internview posted through WLS. He stated that the referee was on the right not too far from his assistant. To my memory, the ball should be somewhat between the referee and the assistant so as to give the best angles for all key decisions. The positioning of the referee in this case was, from what I can see, down to laziness in not being more in the middle of the field or even a bit more off to the left. I will leave Pinner to comment more on this, but from what I can see, the positioning of the referee was purely what cost him the ability to view the incident properly. Be in the right position and you can make the right decision.
I have noticed this with a number of referees at the higher levels here in the UK. They are either too lazy or have been instructed not to run themselves out. That certainly compromises their decision making ability in these situations. |  | | |
| Guess the Ref on 10:52 - Oct 8 with 2723 views | LazyFan |
The ref was proper poor, the only decent decision he gave was for our pen which was a hard call, he managed to get that correct.
For their pen even though Readings player actually stamped on Tim not the other way around, you can forgive that as it was a tricky call too and no VAR. Sky kept showing that again and again.
But all the others were proper rubbish. Missing the handball, then the same player, later on, caused multiple fouls (as many Readings players did) and even he had to give a yellow, which if he gave the pen earlier with a yellow, would have meant sending off.
The obvious red card that should have been given to Carrol. Which he did see as he gave a free kick for it.
The best one I liked was against Kakay. Ozzie was shielding the ball out and Carrol came over and pushed him over onto the ball, which then came off the falling Ozzie and the ref not only does not give the free kick to us, but awards them a corner.
Multiple fouls all over the pitch, which resulted in our players in the last 20 mins starting to do the same as he wasn't giving them so okay new rules, game on.
Proper dreck that ref was. |  |
| |
| Guess the Ref on 12:39 - Oct 8 with 2633 views | paulhoop2 |
What makes me laugh Is this was a premiership ref !!! One thing I would like Pinner to discuss or indeed any of us is do you think that prem refs rely too much on VAR so when things happen like Hutchinson’s hand hall or Carroll’s Assault they are out of touch with those calls because they usually have someone in their ear telling them what to do ? | |
| |
| Guess the Ref on 12:46 - Oct 8 with 2611 views | QPR_Jim |
| Guess the Ref on 08:50 - Oct 8 by paulparker |
We were playing 12 men last night , another ref who seems to have a vendetta against us
The cherry on the cake for me was when chair was hacked not once but twice by reading players and he gave nothing , a second later the reading player falls to the floor and he blew instantly for a free kick to them
Also another word on Bum nose Hinchcliffe and his biased commentary, the bloke is a helmet of the highest order , the only man in the world who thought that was a clear penalty to Reading even when the replays showed he wasn’t touched at all
It really stuck in his claw when we got that second |
That incident summed it up for me. The difference in the challenges was that the player being fouled tried to play on, so it's therefore not a foul in the refs eyes. WHAT?
Reading we're quick to hit the deck as they wanted to pump the ball into the box and to be fair he played on for a couple of occasions but not often. |  | | |
Login to get fewer ads
| Guess the Ref on 13:17 - Oct 8 with 2545 views | E17hoop |
| Guess the Ref on 12:46 - Oct 8 by QPR_Jim |
That incident summed it up for me. The difference in the challenges was that the player being fouled tried to play on, so it's therefore not a foul in the refs eyes. WHAT?
Reading we're quick to hit the deck as they wanted to pump the ball into the box and to be fair he played on for a couple of occasions but not often. |
He waved both the incidents as advantages when Chair was double tagged. Poor decision to blow for the free kick and for a minute or so afterwards he looked out of control.
I don't want VAR in the Championship but we would have had a pen and they wouldn't if it had been in play. |  |
| |
| Guess the Ref on 13:55 - Oct 8 with 2497 views | CLAREMAN1995 |
| Guess the Ref on 09:11 - Oct 8 by ozranger |
Strangely, Beale hit the nail right on the head with the non-given penalty in his internview posted through WLS. He stated that the referee was on the right not too far from his assistant. To my memory, the ball should be somewhat between the referee and the assistant so as to give the best angles for all key decisions. The positioning of the referee in this case was, from what I can see, down to laziness in not being more in the middle of the field or even a bit more off to the left. I will leave Pinner to comment more on this, but from what I can see, the positioning of the referee was purely what cost him the ability to view the incident properly. Be in the right position and you can make the right decision.
I have noticed this with a number of referees at the higher levels here in the UK. They are either too lazy or have been instructed not to run themselves out. That certainly compromises their decision making ability in these situations. |
Mick Beale also said the Carroll yellow card was a proper tackle which I was a bit stunned by .I thought it was a straight red myself and no doubt with VAR it would be .
Beale was pictured laughing but only when Roberts got up so I guess its all good.
Paul Ince had the balls to say our penalty was never one but forgot to mention the handball in their box of course or the fact their player looked like he tripped over the ball for theirs .Another sore loser after match comments .
The Ref was just poor but as Clive said its the way it is .
We won , they lost brilliant week |  | | |
| Guess the Ref on 14:36 - Oct 8 with 2424 views | Benny_the_Ball |
A mixed evening for sure but he awarded the penalty that ultimately won us the game. He deserves a couple of brownie points for that. |  | | |
| Guess the Ref on 14:39 - Oct 8 with 2422 views | QPRSteve |
"The best one I liked was against Kakay. Ozzie was shielding the ball out and Carrol came over and pushed him over onto the ball, which then came off the falling Ozzie and the ref not only does not give the free kick to us, but awards them a corner."
That twunt Hinchcliffe actually praised Carroll for that. | | | |
| Guess the Ref on 14:42 - Oct 8 with 2412 views | DavieQPR |
He couldn't wait to give us that late penalty as he must have known he missed a blatant one. |  | | |
| Guess the Ref on 14:42 - Oct 8 with 2411 views | Stanisgod |
| Guess the Ref on 13:55 - Oct 8 by CLAREMAN1995 |
Mick Beale also said the Carroll yellow card was a proper tackle which I was a bit stunned by .I thought it was a straight red myself and no doubt with VAR it would be .
Beale was pictured laughing but only when Roberts got up so I guess its all good.
Paul Ince had the balls to say our penalty was never one but forgot to mention the handball in their box of course or the fact their player looked like he tripped over the ball for theirs .Another sore loser after match comments .
The Ref was just poor but as Clive said its the way it is .
We won , they lost brilliant week |
Ince was a wa#ker when he was playing, still is. |  |
| It's being so happy that keeps me going. |
| |
| Guess the Ref on 14:56 - Oct 8 with 2381 views | LazyFan |
| Guess the Ref on 14:42 - Oct 8 by DavieQPR |
He couldn't wait to give us that late penalty as he must have known he missed a blatant one. |
I suspect you are correct, the problem is that it actually makes it worse for him.
If the FA say that was not a pen and then the pen he never gave was obviously one, then he's getting all the decisions wrong.
This could be a problem for us, as now he probably will be reffing more in the Championship. Send him back to the prem, please! | |
| |
| Guess the Ref on 09:50 - Oct 9 with 2172 views | francisbowles |
Christ, I wonder what reaction he would have got if we had lost.
FWIW, IMHO, he missed the handball, their's was a penalty and so was ours and yellow was about right.
He let too much go, played advantage when he should have called it back on a couple of occasions. Otherwise ok. | | | |
| Guess the Ref on 10:00 - Oct 9 with 2139 views | distortR |
| Guess the Ref on 09:50 - Oct 9 by francisbowles |
Christ, I wonder what reaction he would have got if we had lost.
FWIW, IMHO, he missed the handball, their's was a penalty and so was ours and yellow was about right.
He let too much go, played advantage when he should have called it back on a couple of occasions. Otherwise ok. |
The only penalty decision I'm certain on, was the only one he didn't give. | | | |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
