Please log in or register. Registered visitors get fewer ads.
Forum index | Previous Thread | Next thread
The great Brexit reset 08:45 - Nov 16 with 2342 viewsSullutaCreturned

Andy Burnham has a whole lot of stuff to say about this but one thing in particular I agree withwhich is...it's not that Brexit was wrong, but the way it happened was.

Well now he's trying to fix that and I really hope he can get it right.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/art
0
The great Brexit reset on 20:36 - Nov 17SullutaCreturned

The great Brexit reset on 20:33 - Nov 17 by Boundy

Do you honestly think Burnham won't sell the country out , he's already broken a public statement that he had no intention of revisiting the EU arguement and yet here we are already having chats and rumours of a binding agreement which would cost the country millions more shoud we in future decide to leave ,


Well I did ask that question!
0
The great Brexit reset on 10:16 - Nov 18union_jack

Interesting article.

Are we safer in these fraught days as a union of European states especially with the three threats to our well being getting together as we speak?

Or does an independent UK have potentially more influence in the world stage?

For me the stronger together from a security perspective holds true but probably not economically. If Europe wants to be a respected and influential state it really needs to go the whole hog and that means a United Staes of Europe. It needs proper leadership, not this unelected bunch of bureaucrats playing games at the moment. It needs nationalities and therefore cultures to come together as one.

Would the UK ever want to be part of this? Giving up our sovereignty would be a step too far for most Brits I’d wager. Does that mean we are going to be a bitter, disrespected, forgotten about island off the next potential world superpower?

We won’t ever be able to have that influence alone ever again I believe.

https://www.theguardian.com/co
[Post edited 18 Nov 13:42]

Are Sperm Whales the reason the sea is so salty?
Poll: Bony - Would You Want Him Back?

0
The great Brexit reset on 13:38 - Nov 18SullutaCreturned

The great Brexit reset on 10:16 - Nov 18 by union_jack

Interesting article.

Are we safer in these fraught days as a union of European states especially with the three threats to our well being getting together as we speak?

Or does an independent UK have potentially more influence in the world stage?

For me the stronger together from a security perspective holds true but probably not economically. If Europe wants to be a respected and influential state it really needs to go the whole hog and that means a United Staes of Europe. It needs proper leadership, not this unelected bunch of bureaucrats playing games at the moment. It needs nationalities and therefore cultures to come together as one.

Would the UK ever want to be part of this? Giving up our sovereignty would be a step too far for most Brits I’d wager. Does that mean we are going to be a bitter, disrespected, forgotten about island off the next potential world superpower?

We won’t ever be able to have that influence alone ever again I believe.

https://www.theguardian.com/co
[Post edited 18 Nov 13:42]


Britain as a superpower will never happen again in my opinion, so I agree with you.

Unless of course some British scientist invents some new super weapon that we can use to dominate the world stage, not likely!

I think we need to be together with |Europe on defence and have strong trading agreements but not political integration.
0
The great Brexit reset on 13:47 - Nov 18union_jack

The great Brexit reset on 13:38 - Nov 18 by SullutaCreturned

Britain as a superpower will never happen again in my opinion, so I agree with you.

Unless of course some British scientist invents some new super weapon that we can use to dominate the world stage, not likely!

I think we need to be together with |Europe on defence and have strong trading agreements but not political integration.


The defence issue I agree BUT as it is now with so many of the member states vying to be the Biggest Billy Bollox then there’ll be too much in-fighting before we could properly defend ourselves. That’s why I said it needs to be a USofE but any hope of that happening in the short or even medium term is almost impossible. And the more the EU expands, if it does will only make that task harder.

Are Sperm Whales the reason the sea is so salty?
Poll: Bony - Would You Want Him Back?

0
The great Brexit reset on 14:17 - Nov 18SullutaCreturned

The great Brexit reset on 13:47 - Nov 18 by union_jack

The defence issue I agree BUT as it is now with so many of the member states vying to be the Biggest Billy Bollox then there’ll be too much in-fighting before we could properly defend ourselves. That’s why I said it needs to be a USofE but any hope of that happening in the short or even medium term is almost impossible. And the more the EU expands, if it does will only make that task harder.


NATO still has cards to play until the powers that be get their collective heads out of their derriere's.

A US of E? I don't mind the idea but as I said above...

We can only make progress if people stop trying to be Billy and do what's in the greater interest of all of us. We cannot trust the USA under Trump/Vanceand Russia are pushing, by the sound of it, to rebuild the USSR, at least partially. They also wnat NATO to make certain concessions that I am sure they know will never happen. It's not really a negotiating position, more a set of demands. There is more to this I am sure.
0
The great Brexit reset on 15:14 - Nov 18union_jack

The great Brexit reset on 14:17 - Nov 18 by SullutaCreturned

NATO still has cards to play until the powers that be get their collective heads out of their derriere's.

A US of E? I don't mind the idea but as I said above...

We can only make progress if people stop trying to be Billy and do what's in the greater interest of all of us. We cannot trust the USA under Trump/Vanceand Russia are pushing, by the sound of it, to rebuild the USSR, at least partially. They also wnat NATO to make certain concessions that I am sure they know will never happen. It's not really a negotiating position, more a set of demands. There is more to this I am sure.


And we are all putting differing % of GDP into the NATO bucket. It’s the only thing I really support Trump on and that’s that other NATO members are not putting in enough.

But you’re right, Trump et al are nit to be trusted. My fear is though that even if a Democrat leader gets in in 28, their foreign policy maybe quite similar because Trump has done the hard work for them. The new administration will undoubtedly see that as looking after the good ol’ US of A.

Are Sperm Whales the reason the sea is so salty?
Poll: Bony - Would You Want Him Back?

0
The great Brexit reset on 17:44 - Nov 18max936

The great Brexit reset on 15:14 - Nov 18 by union_jack

And we are all putting differing % of GDP into the NATO bucket. It’s the only thing I really support Trump on and that’s that other NATO members are not putting in enough.

But you’re right, Trump et al are nit to be trusted. My fear is though that even if a Democrat leader gets in in 28, their foreign policy maybe quite similar because Trump has done the hard work for them. The new administration will undoubtedly see that as looking after the good ol’ US of A.


Anyway, popped bto Pilot lunchtime Uni, enjoyo much [lgrin]

Mrs in Cardiff Saturday to watch ABBA thingy, so may use my bus pass and go down there, or Fishing at Hereford.
0
The great Brexit reset on 18:20 - Nov 18union_jack

The great Brexit reset on 17:44 - Nov 18 by max936

Anyway, popped bto Pilot lunchtime Uni, enjoyo much [lgrin]

Mrs in Cardiff Saturday to watch ABBA thingy, so may use my bus pass and go down there, or Fishing at Hereford.


Love The Pilot.

I’m not a big drinker, probably won’t have anything until I go out with some friends just before Christmas. But they were serving Aspalls Cider last time I was in there which is the most refreshing tipple I know.

So are you going to miss the Swans and the rugby? They don’t have a TV do they?

Are Sperm Whales the reason the sea is so salty?
Poll: Bony - Would You Want Him Back?

0
Login to get fewer ads

The great Brexit reset on 21:13 - Nov 18Boundy

Burnham just can' t help lying , with the announcement that the UK sold £190billion more to the world in 2025 than in 2019, its last full year in the eu .Now how does he explain that " mistake "

"In a free society, the State is the servant of the people—not the master."

0
The great Brexit reset on 22:56 - Nov 18max936

The great Brexit reset on 18:20 - Nov 18 by union_jack

Love The Pilot.

I’m not a big drinker, probably won’t have anything until I go out with some friends just before Christmas. But they were serving Aspalls Cider last time I was in there which is the most refreshing tipple I know.

So are you going to miss the Swans and the rugby? They don’t have a TV do they?


Two small tv's one above bar in left hand corner when you walk through the door and one on the right of door in corner by bay window. They'll put the rugby on cause its on terrestrial Tv, they don't do sky etc, I'll be home for Wales game, Mrs is up in Cardiff for some ABBA tribute gig I think can't see it actually being ABBA.

Not sure what to do yet, may go back up to the Wye in Hereford after this rain has refreshed the river, didn't fish on weekend, back was still bad and after the 3 day fishing festival and a heavy frost, it wasn't worth it.
[Post edited 18 Nov 23:01]
1
The great Brexit reset on 23:03 - Nov 18max936

The great Brexit reset on 20:33 - Nov 17 by Boundy

Do you honestly think Burnham won't sell the country out , he's already broken a public statement that he had no intention of revisiting the EU arguement and yet here we are already having chats and rumours of a binding agreement which would cost the country millions more shoud we in future decide to leave ,


Trump getting cosy with Putin and China and maybe Kim jon, wouldn't trust Trump one little bit
0
The great Brexit reset on 07:37 - Nov 19Dr_Winston

The great Brexit reset on 21:13 - Nov 18 by Boundy

Burnham just can' t help lying , with the announcement that the UK sold £190billion more to the world in 2025 than in 2019, its last full year in the eu .Now how does he explain that " mistake "


Rejoining the EU has nothing to do with the Economy. Everyone knows that and people can barely be bothered to lie about it any more. The arguments for that side of it are rehashed, half hearted and thoroughly debunked.

It's about control, or more accurately, taking it out of the hands of the people and putting it back with the Globalists. Ever closer, seemingly unbreakable ties with the EU Parliament will, in their eyes, restrict any future "wrong" British Government from undoing them. That's why they're signing up to stuff that can potentially see us financially penalised for not doing it.

Of course, any future Govt worth its salt could just ignore it and jail (or maybe even worse) the traitors who signed up in the first place, but it's still a powerful deterrent to change for the general standard of politician that we have now.

Pain or damage don't end the world. Or despair, or f*cking beatings. The world ends when you're dead. Until then, you got more punishment in store. Stand it like a man... and give some back.

0
The great Brexit reset on 08:13 - Nov 191983

The great Brexit reset on 21:13 - Nov 18 by Boundy

Burnham just can' t help lying , with the announcement that the UK sold £190billion more to the world in 2025 than in 2019, its last full year in the eu .Now how does he explain that " mistake "


The bloke is an idiot
Three of the most powerful men/countries in private talks and all he's been worrying about all week is silencing a nonce who's banged up 😑

Stop The Boats !
Poll: Do you support the arrival of illegal immigrants

0
The great Brexit reset on 09:55 - Nov 19max936

The great Brexit reset on 08:13 - Nov 19 by 1983

The bloke is an idiot
Three of the most powerful men/countries in private talks and all he's been worrying about all week is silencing a nonce who's banged up 😑


At one time Britain would have been involved in this meet, this Government is so weak that its still shitting yellow, Starmer didn't have a clue and this Burnham character is even worse.

Refusing to spend big on defence whilst giving billions away to Ukraine, I think he thinks that if the missiles start following we can just put our umbrellas up.

We got goons in Westminster and we got goons in the Senedd following the previous bunch of goons. Incredible
0
The great Brexit reset on 09:55 - Nov 19majorraglan

The great Brexit reset on 21:13 - Nov 18 by Boundy

Burnham just can' t help lying , with the announcement that the UK sold £190billion more to the world in 2025 than in 2019, its last full year in the eu .Now how does he explain that " mistake "


We’re back to the old saying of lies, damned lies, and statistics.

Burnham’s comments may well be correct or partially correct but the devil is in the detail and people will take what they want and counter with other figures that suit their position hence the pro Brexit movement questioning them and the pro EU group supporting them.

There has been an increase in the cash value business exports which is the £190bn figure being quoted and that does reflect a 26% increase compared to 2019, BUT when the figure is adjusted for inflation then the actual increase is much much lower and works out at 2% which is poor.

Looking at the picture in greater detail and breaking down services v goods it’s a mixed bag and people will take what they want to depending on goods and destinations.

The overall position is

• Global goods exports fell by 12% in real terms, while global services exports rose by 18%.

• Total exports specifically to the EU fell by 0.9% in real terms (driven by a 14% drop in goods exports to the EU, offset by a 16% rise in services.)

If Burnham was specifically talking about overall EU trade in real cash terms, he was actually right in what he said.
[Post edited 19 Nov 10:08]
0
The great Brexit reset on 11:42 - Nov 19Gwyn737

The great Brexit reset on 07:37 - Nov 19 by Dr_Winston

Rejoining the EU has nothing to do with the Economy. Everyone knows that and people can barely be bothered to lie about it any more. The arguments for that side of it are rehashed, half hearted and thoroughly debunked.

It's about control, or more accurately, taking it out of the hands of the people and putting it back with the Globalists. Ever closer, seemingly unbreakable ties with the EU Parliament will, in their eyes, restrict any future "wrong" British Government from undoing them. That's why they're signing up to stuff that can potentially see us financially penalised for not doing it.

Of course, any future Govt worth its salt could just ignore it and jail (or maybe even worse) the traitors who signed up in the first place, but it's still a powerful deterrent to change for the general standard of politician that we have now.


One of the reasons I think we should keep looking at closer ties with the EU is the Economy.

It's all very well people saying that this country has only grown x compared to us, or we've outperformed these countries. That doesn't matter. What matters is what would it look like if we had closer ties? Would all figures be better?

As you know, I'm not wanting blindly to rejoin. I'm concerned about how much poorer the deal would be than we had last time. We need to keep talking about it without any discussions being shouted down.

You said earlier we haven't had Brexit. Of course we have, we're literally no longer part of the EU. What we might not have had are the things you wanted. Which will be different form what other people wanted.

We beginning to learn what being outside actually means and where there are problems we need to work to improve them. This is being stymied by every time a discussion point is raised, somebody shouts 'traitors!'
0
The great Brexit reset on 11:45 - Nov 19union_jack

The great Brexit reset on 09:55 - Nov 19 by max936

At one time Britain would have been involved in this meet, this Government is so weak that its still shitting yellow, Starmer didn't have a clue and this Burnham character is even worse.

Refusing to spend big on defence whilst giving billions away to Ukraine, I think he thinks that if the missiles start following we can just put our umbrellas up.

We got goons in Westminster and we got goons in the Senedd following the previous bunch of goons. Incredible


If you mean back in the 1940s then yes and only then because China was not a superpower.

We are not at the table now and never will be again. The only way our voice can be heard would be as part of a properly unified Europe which by definition wouldn’t be British influence. That’s not going to happen in the short term but with this Tri-lateral conference going on it seems they are trying to carve the world up into a new world order. Where does that leave us and the rest of the European countries? I’m genuinely beginning to believe that a union of European states I.e. safety in numbers is the way to go and create a 3rd superpower. It will mean attitudes all over Europe change and may take over 50-100 years to achieve. Or not at all.

Are Sperm Whales the reason the sea is so salty?
Poll: Bony - Would You Want Him Back?

0
The great Brexit reset on 11:53 - Nov 19Dr_Winston

The great Brexit reset on 11:42 - Nov 19 by Gwyn737

One of the reasons I think we should keep looking at closer ties with the EU is the Economy.

It's all very well people saying that this country has only grown x compared to us, or we've outperformed these countries. That doesn't matter. What matters is what would it look like if we had closer ties? Would all figures be better?

As you know, I'm not wanting blindly to rejoin. I'm concerned about how much poorer the deal would be than we had last time. We need to keep talking about it without any discussions being shouted down.

You said earlier we haven't had Brexit. Of course we have, we're literally no longer part of the EU. What we might not have had are the things you wanted. Which will be different form what other people wanted.

We beginning to learn what being outside actually means and where there are problems we need to work to improve them. This is being stymied by every time a discussion point is raised, somebody shouts 'traitors!'


Europe's share of Global GDP has declined for decades. Whilst other countries get on with catching rockets or building them with AI, Europe concerns itself with bottle tops.

If there was the slightest possibility of the EU Bloc suddenly changing direction and going great guns towards economic growth instead of regulation and stagnation then perhaps there would be a benefit to closer ties with it. I suspect we'll be waiting a while for that.

Pain or damage don't end the world. Or despair, or f*cking beatings. The world ends when you're dead. Until then, you got more punishment in store. Stand it like a man... and give some back.

1
The great Brexit reset on 13:13 - Nov 19Gwyn737

The great Brexit reset on 11:53 - Nov 19 by Dr_Winston

Europe's share of Global GDP has declined for decades. Whilst other countries get on with catching rockets or building them with AI, Europe concerns itself with bottle tops.

If there was the slightest possibility of the EU Bloc suddenly changing direction and going great guns towards economic growth instead of regulation and stagnation then perhaps there would be a benefit to closer ties with it. I suspect we'll be waiting a while for that.


Wouldn't it be good to be part of it and drive for change....

As an aside one thing we do seem to be doing really well with is AI
0
The great Brexit reset on 14:18 - Nov 19Dr_Winston

The great Brexit reset on 13:13 - Nov 19 by Gwyn737

Wouldn't it be good to be part of it and drive for change....

As an aside one thing we do seem to be doing really well with is AI


Cameron tried for change before the referendum and basically got told to do one. The idea that we can change the monolith from within is for the birds.

Pain or damage don't end the world. Or despair, or f*cking beatings. The world ends when you're dead. Until then, you got more punishment in store. Stand it like a man... and give some back.

0
The great Brexit reset on 14:30 - Nov 19Whiterockin

The great Brexit reset on 14:18 - Nov 19 by Dr_Winston

Cameron tried for change before the referendum and basically got told to do one. The idea that we can change the monolith from within is for the birds.


People have to realise that the reason we haven't done better in recent years is not because of Brexit but because we elected shite politicians.
0
The great Brexit reset on 14:58 - Nov 19Gwyn737

The great Brexit reset on 14:30 - Nov 19 by Whiterockin

People have to realise that the reason we haven't done better in recent years is not because of Brexit but because we elected shite politicians.


Or both?
0
The great Brexit reset on 17:03 - Nov 19AnotherJohn

Going back to the fishing angle, representative bodies like the SSF, the SSA and the SWFPA are worried about what the deal may involve.

https://www.msn.com/en-gb/news
0
The great Brexit reset on 17:40 - Nov 19Dr_Winston

The great Brexit reset on 14:30 - Nov 19 by Whiterockin

People have to realise that the reason we haven't done better in recent years is not because of Brexit but because we elected shite politicians.


We have actually done quite well compared to the other major EU economies. Not nearly as well as we could have done had we properly seized the opportunities getting out of there presented, but better than those who have stuck around.

This is the thing. Despite Covid, despite a political hierarchy that has done it's level best since June 2016 to sabotage and undermine the whole concept of Brexit, we've still outperformed the French or Germans.

It'll be a massive backward step when Burnham gets his way, and he will.

Pain or damage don't end the world. Or despair, or f*cking beatings. The world ends when you're dead. Until then, you got more punishment in store. Stand it like a man... and give some back.

0
About Us Contact Us Terms & Conditions Privacy Cookies Online Safety Advertising
© FansNetwork 2026