Please log in or register. Registered visitors get fewer ads.
Forum index | Previous Thread | Next thread
Matos - The Good, The Bad and the Ugly? 22:48 - Nov 17 with 3866 viewsswansjack84

My Opinion - On His Reign

The Good: Pressing Football - Positivity Into The Club and Players - League
Position

The Bad: Tactically Predictable - Changing Strongest Lineup Too Much - Rarely
Got 90 Minutes of Good Football (Game of 2 Half's). Copy and Paste
every press conference with his emotions and rarely took
responsibility for bad performances

The Ugly: Not giving players opportunities. Walta, Monga, and any new
additions and sticking to players like Just etc. And not getting the
best out of possibly the best striking force in the division
[Post edited 17 Nov 22:49]
5
Matos - The Good, The Bad and the Ugly? on 22:56 - Nov 17Whiterockin

At times I have seen us play the best football for years, this season is the most I have been up out of my seat for a long time.
0
Matos - The Good, The Bad and the Ugly? on 00:00 - Nov 18MumsArmy

Talented manager but a limited manager. His identity is the extreme press and the club started to revolve around him and that identity which never makes me comfortable because there is no longer term strategy. Out of possession we were fantastic, wouldn’t let opponents breathe - but the trade off is the players capable of doing that are usually more limited on the technical side. This has meant that we dominate the weaker teams and get beaten by the teams technically capable of playing around the press. We have seen that in the recent run of form when we have played a high concentration of teams in the top 10. Our record against them this season is won 1 and lost 5, scored 5 and conceded 15. As a result, some real technical quality has been either prematurely pushed out or underutilised; Monga, Walta, Galbraith and Yalcouye are some prime examples. I have a suspicion the club are a bit shell shocked by Matos’ departure and are maybe now realising their mistake of giving Matos so much. They are now at a crossroads, stick with this extreme high press type of manager or go back to a more balanced approach more in line with how we played under Martinez, Laudrup and Rodgers. We will soon get the answer to that once the names inevitably start appearing in the media.
2
Matos - The Good, The Bad and the Ugly? on 00:20 - Nov 18Whiterockin

Matos - The Good, The Bad and the Ugly? on 00:00 - Nov 18 by MumsArmy

Talented manager but a limited manager. His identity is the extreme press and the club started to revolve around him and that identity which never makes me comfortable because there is no longer term strategy. Out of possession we were fantastic, wouldn’t let opponents breathe - but the trade off is the players capable of doing that are usually more limited on the technical side. This has meant that we dominate the weaker teams and get beaten by the teams technically capable of playing around the press. We have seen that in the recent run of form when we have played a high concentration of teams in the top 10. Our record against them this season is won 1 and lost 5, scored 5 and conceded 15. As a result, some real technical quality has been either prematurely pushed out or underutilised; Monga, Walta, Galbraith and Yalcouye are some prime examples. I have a suspicion the club are a bit shell shocked by Matos’ departure and are maybe now realising their mistake of giving Matos so much. They are now at a crossroads, stick with this extreme high press type of manager or go back to a more balanced approach more in line with how we played under Martinez, Laudrup and Rodgers. We will soon get the answer to that once the names inevitably start appearing in the media.


The crux of it all is have supporters enjoyed this season more than recent years, in my opinion yes. We are not really interested in stats and the such, football is all about going to a game and enjoying it, this season I have seen more smiles after a game and less moans on the way out, sometimes we try to read too much into football, it should all be about enjoyment and in my opinion we have had more than recent seasons. Matos is moving on thats life, good luck to him but let's not be bitter. Hopefully the next manager/coach will take us up, if not just enjoy the ride, we have been served dross for years and Matos has been a breath of fresh air. Yes we can moan about tactics and team selection, but can we really say we have not on the whole enjoyed it.
3
Matos - The Good, The Bad and the Ugly? on 00:54 - Nov 18MumsArmy

Matos - The Good, The Bad and the Ugly? on 00:20 - Nov 18 by Whiterockin

The crux of it all is have supporters enjoyed this season more than recent years, in my opinion yes. We are not really interested in stats and the such, football is all about going to a game and enjoying it, this season I have seen more smiles after a game and less moans on the way out, sometimes we try to read too much into football, it should all be about enjoyment and in my opinion we have had more than recent seasons. Matos is moving on thats life, good luck to him but let's not be bitter. Hopefully the next manager/coach will take us up, if not just enjoy the ride, we have been served dross for years and Matos has been a breath of fresh air. Yes we can moan about tactics and team selection, but can we really say we have not on the whole enjoyed it.


My view is he put a ceiling on what we could achieve, we are never going to go up automatically being a counter press machine - unless we spend tens and tens of millions on players who can do both equally as well, which is why Liverpool can do it and still be successful. Where as investing in technical ability is something that generally combats most styles put in front of you, (the top few teams in the league don’t rank highly in the press) and your ceiling becomes a lot higher. Yes I think it’s fair to say we had a good time as supporters with Vitor at the helm, especially given the recent managers (Sheehan aside) have been too far the opposite way - but on the other hand it depends how high your ambitions are, if we genuinely want to go up and relive the glory days of Laudrup etc then we need to become less extreme in how we approach games and shape the squad.
2
Matos - The Good, The Bad and the Ugly? on 07:48 - Nov 18vetchonian

Matos - The Good, The Bad and the Ugly? on 00:00 - Nov 18 by MumsArmy

Talented manager but a limited manager. His identity is the extreme press and the club started to revolve around him and that identity which never makes me comfortable because there is no longer term strategy. Out of possession we were fantastic, wouldn’t let opponents breathe - but the trade off is the players capable of doing that are usually more limited on the technical side. This has meant that we dominate the weaker teams and get beaten by the teams technically capable of playing around the press. We have seen that in the recent run of form when we have played a high concentration of teams in the top 10. Our record against them this season is won 1 and lost 5, scored 5 and conceded 15. As a result, some real technical quality has been either prematurely pushed out or underutilised; Monga, Walta, Galbraith and Yalcouye are some prime examples. I have a suspicion the club are a bit shell shocked by Matos’ departure and are maybe now realising their mistake of giving Matos so much. They are now at a crossroads, stick with this extreme high press type of manager or go back to a more balanced approach more in line with how we played under Martinez, Laudrup and Rodgers. We will soon get the answer to that once the names inevitably start appearing in the media.


I would disagree , out of those 5 games against sides in the top half we we only tryly beaten at Southampton and QPR and even at QPR we had chances to get back into the game when 1 and 2 nil down had those chances been comverted it may have been different

Against West Ham one goal seperate us and we had Ronald at full back we had several chances to equalise .
Portsmouth we almost went 2-1 up with a couple of miutes to go,then again gave away a goal at a corner...not through our style of play being beaten their third goal came from us throwing everything forward seeking an equaliser.
At Birmingham we were the better side before Stamenic was dismissed we could mayen should have even been at least one if not 2 goals up by then.
They scored a goal as we were tryimg to settle but after thay our 10 players kept them comtaimed we pressured an equaliser only to concede again from a corner.
Our weakmess has been set piece defending particulary corners whic cost us the games at Pompey and Brum.
All about opinions I know...but we didnt lise to West Ham,Pompey or Brum because teams played around the press.

Poll: Should Coleman ask Curt for advice/help?

3
Matos - The Good, The Bad and the Ugly? on 07:56 - Nov 18Whiterockin

Matos - The Good, The Bad and the Ugly? on 07:48 - Nov 18 by vetchonian

I would disagree , out of those 5 games against sides in the top half we we only tryly beaten at Southampton and QPR and even at QPR we had chances to get back into the game when 1 and 2 nil down had those chances been comverted it may have been different

Against West Ham one goal seperate us and we had Ronald at full back we had several chances to equalise .
Portsmouth we almost went 2-1 up with a couple of miutes to go,then again gave away a goal at a corner...not through our style of play being beaten their third goal came from us throwing everything forward seeking an equaliser.
At Birmingham we were the better side before Stamenic was dismissed we could mayen should have even been at least one if not 2 goals up by then.
They scored a goal as we were tryimg to settle but after thay our 10 players kept them comtaimed we pressured an equaliser only to concede again from a corner.
Our weakmess has been set piece defending particulary corners whic cost us the games at Pompey and Brum.
All about opinions I know...but we didnt lise to West Ham,Pompey or Brum because teams played around the press.


In my opinion spot on and how I saw the games.
0
Matos - The Good, The Bad and the Ugly? on 08:22 - Nov 18Demitrius

Matos - The Good, The Bad and the Ugly? on 07:56 - Nov 18 by Whiterockin

In my opinion spot on and how I saw the games.


I'd agree as well. Lads down the pub keep asking what's happened to the Swans but I say pretty much what vetchonian says here. We were definitely 2nd best to Southampton no argument and QPR is best forgotten as a terrible opening 15 minutes but the other games could have gone either way. I'm not going to start a Matos pile on now he's left but there are things he could have done /changed Vs Pompey, WHU and Brum that might have tipped the scales in our favour. It's always fine margins in the Championship.

“Cunnilingus and Psychiatry brought us to this …”

0
Matos - The Good, The Bad and the Ugly? on 08:36 - Nov 18Whiterockin

Matos - The Good, The Bad and the Ugly? on 08:22 - Nov 18 by Demitrius

I'd agree as well. Lads down the pub keep asking what's happened to the Swans but I say pretty much what vetchonian says here. We were definitely 2nd best to Southampton no argument and QPR is best forgotten as a terrible opening 15 minutes but the other games could have gone either way. I'm not going to start a Matos pile on now he's left but there are things he could have done /changed Vs Pompey, WHU and Brum that might have tipped the scales in our favour. It's always fine margins in the Championship.


I would like to throw in that in my opinion the first half v Blackburn is the best football I have seen us play since we were relegated. If you look for negativity you will find it, but some of our football has been a joy to watch.
1
Login to get fewer ads

Matos - The Good, The Bad and the Ugly? on 08:42 - Nov 18SullutaCreturned

I agree with elements of every post so far. Matos obvioulsy improved us and it has been a more exciting season (at times) than the lasy several.

I also agree though, that Matos put a ceiling on what we could achieve by being tactically fairly rigid. Right down to substitutions usually happening at roughly the same time (unless because of injury or cards) and I've never seen football as being rigid. Football is reactive, the starting tactics are sometimes obviously wrong in the first 10 and I think a good manager will make a change as soon as it's clearly needed. Matos is another who stuck to his way, when it worked it was good but sometimes it needed changing and he didn't.

I think Walta would be a good option of the bench because he's a willing shooter and clearly good at free kicks, that talent should be utilised.

I'm not piling on though because he clearly improved us, that shouldn't stop us saying where we think he went wrong though.
2
Matos - The Good, The Bad and the Ugly? on 09:05 - Nov 18onehunglow

Matos - The Good, The Bad and the Ugly? on 07:48 - Nov 18 by vetchonian

I would disagree , out of those 5 games against sides in the top half we we only tryly beaten at Southampton and QPR and even at QPR we had chances to get back into the game when 1 and 2 nil down had those chances been comverted it may have been different

Against West Ham one goal seperate us and we had Ronald at full back we had several chances to equalise .
Portsmouth we almost went 2-1 up with a couple of miutes to go,then again gave away a goal at a corner...not through our style of play being beaten their third goal came from us throwing everything forward seeking an equaliser.
At Birmingham we were the better side before Stamenic was dismissed we could mayen should have even been at least one if not 2 goals up by then.
They scored a goal as we were tryimg to settle but after thay our 10 players kept them comtaimed we pressured an equaliser only to concede again from a corner.
Our weakmess has been set piece defending particulary corners whic cost us the games at Pompey and Brum.
All about opinions I know...but we didnt lise to West Ham,Pompey or Brum because teams played around the press.


And by losing to preventable goals means you are truly and cruelly beaten but beaten all the same

Poll: Christmas. Enjoyable or not

0
Matos - The Good, The Bad and the Ugly? on 09:15 - Nov 18onehunglow

Matos - The Good, The Bad and the Ugly? on 00:00 - Nov 18 by MumsArmy

Talented manager but a limited manager. His identity is the extreme press and the club started to revolve around him and that identity which never makes me comfortable because there is no longer term strategy. Out of possession we were fantastic, wouldn’t let opponents breathe - but the trade off is the players capable of doing that are usually more limited on the technical side. This has meant that we dominate the weaker teams and get beaten by the teams technically capable of playing around the press. We have seen that in the recent run of form when we have played a high concentration of teams in the top 10. Our record against them this season is won 1 and lost 5, scored 5 and conceded 15. As a result, some real technical quality has been either prematurely pushed out or underutilised; Monga, Walta, Galbraith and Yalcouye are some prime examples. I have a suspicion the club are a bit shell shocked by Matos’ departure and are maybe now realising their mistake of giving Matos so much. They are now at a crossroads, stick with this extreme high press type of manager or go back to a more balanced approach more in line with how we played under Martinez, Laudrup and Rodgers. We will soon get the answer to that once the names inevitably start appearing in the media.


Matos was backed like few others before him
He assembled players he wanted
He accepted players like Walta who he might not have so he froze him out
We bring in a wonder boy on loan and freeze him him
Maybe there’s a pattern here that we don’t like but it’s there
I think behind the painted smile play issues as yet unknown and there they should stay because he’s fooked off , at a time facing two of the toughest teams then Cardiff
Orbrigado ? Nao
I think his departure WAS a shock and hope it hasn’t put the owners off backing the next manager , a point everyone’s missed

He wasn’t really special
He was not a chosen one
He loved us all; players, club, chef and the station cat
As others have done

He was given a long lucrative contract to serve a club he “ loved” in a city he loved” so why knob off

So , va se foder

Poll: Christmas. Enjoyable or not

3
Matos - The Good, The Bad and the Ugly? on 09:21 - Nov 18johnlangy

Matos - The Good, The Bad and the Ugly? on 00:00 - Nov 18 by MumsArmy

Talented manager but a limited manager. His identity is the extreme press and the club started to revolve around him and that identity which never makes me comfortable because there is no longer term strategy. Out of possession we were fantastic, wouldn’t let opponents breathe - but the trade off is the players capable of doing that are usually more limited on the technical side. This has meant that we dominate the weaker teams and get beaten by the teams technically capable of playing around the press. We have seen that in the recent run of form when we have played a high concentration of teams in the top 10. Our record against them this season is won 1 and lost 5, scored 5 and conceded 15. As a result, some real technical quality has been either prematurely pushed out or underutilised; Monga, Walta, Galbraith and Yalcouye are some prime examples. I have a suspicion the club are a bit shell shocked by Matos’ departure and are maybe now realising their mistake of giving Matos so much. They are now at a crossroads, stick with this extreme high press type of manager or go back to a more balanced approach more in line with how we played under Martinez, Laudrup and Rodgers. We will soon get the answer to that once the names inevitably start appearing in the media.


This suggests a manager with experience is the answer. Another foreign, left field manager will by definition not have any experience of the Championship. And therefore no real understanding of how to adapt.

So the only obvious way of them getting that understanding is coming up against the problems and working out how to address them. But that means us and the Club accepting things are going to go pear shaped now and then (like now).

Not enough of us will accept that because we want. hopefully, promotion. And when do we want it - NOW.
0
Matos - The Good, The Bad and the Ugly? on 09:22 - Nov 18union_jack

Matos - The Good, The Bad and the Ugly? on 07:48 - Nov 18 by vetchonian

I would disagree , out of those 5 games against sides in the top half we we only tryly beaten at Southampton and QPR and even at QPR we had chances to get back into the game when 1 and 2 nil down had those chances been comverted it may have been different

Against West Ham one goal seperate us and we had Ronald at full back we had several chances to equalise .
Portsmouth we almost went 2-1 up with a couple of miutes to go,then again gave away a goal at a corner...not through our style of play being beaten their third goal came from us throwing everything forward seeking an equaliser.
At Birmingham we were the better side before Stamenic was dismissed we could mayen should have even been at least one if not 2 goals up by then.
They scored a goal as we were tryimg to settle but after thay our 10 players kept them comtaimed we pressured an equaliser only to concede again from a corner.
Our weakmess has been set piece defending particulary corners whic cost us the games at Pompey and Brum.
All about opinions I know...but we didnt lise to West Ham,Pompey or Brum because teams played around the press.


Ok, that’s fair but only to a point. If we argue that we could have lost games that we could have drawn / won then we have to take into account those we’ve won when indeed we couid have dropped points. There have been several games this season where we’ve been lucky and the opposition fans would be saying the same as yourself and with some justification.

That’s football. It’s always going to be a game of ifs and buts. To be able to say we truly deserved to win a game we’ve got to put more performances in like Blackburn where there is no doubt in anyone’s mind that we deserved the 3 points.

Are Sperm Whales the reason the sea is so salty?
Poll: Bony - Would You Want Him Back?

1
Matos - The Good, The Bad and the Ugly? on 10:01 - Nov 18MumsArmy

Matos - The Good, The Bad and the Ugly? on 07:48 - Nov 18 by vetchonian

I would disagree , out of those 5 games against sides in the top half we we only tryly beaten at Southampton and QPR and even at QPR we had chances to get back into the game when 1 and 2 nil down had those chances been comverted it may have been different

Against West Ham one goal seperate us and we had Ronald at full back we had several chances to equalise .
Portsmouth we almost went 2-1 up with a couple of miutes to go,then again gave away a goal at a corner...not through our style of play being beaten their third goal came from us throwing everything forward seeking an equaliser.
At Birmingham we were the better side before Stamenic was dismissed we could mayen should have even been at least one if not 2 goals up by then.
They scored a goal as we were tryimg to settle but after thay our 10 players kept them comtaimed we pressured an equaliser only to concede again from a corner.
Our weakmess has been set piece defending particulary corners whic cost us the games at Pompey and Brum.
All about opinions I know...but we didnt lise to West Ham,Pompey or Brum because teams played around the press.


I never understand these views if I’m honest. If we lose a game that’s deemed competitive, we still lose. Every game should be competitive, doesn’t mean we should win every game. In the 4 games we lost the opposition doubled our xG.
0
Matos - The Good, The Bad and the Ugly? on 10:06 - Nov 18Whiterockin

Matos - The Good, The Bad and the Ugly? on 10:01 - Nov 18 by MumsArmy

I never understand these views if I’m honest. If we lose a game that’s deemed competitive, we still lose. Every game should be competitive, doesn’t mean we should win every game. In the 4 games we lost the opposition doubled our xG.


Do the majority of football supporters really care about things like xG, we go to matches for enjoyment. Possibly you don't understand that its fine.
0
Matos - The Good, The Bad and the Ugly? on 10:11 - Nov 18MumsArmy

Matos - The Good, The Bad and the Ugly? on 10:06 - Nov 18 by Whiterockin

Do the majority of football supporters really care about things like xG, we go to matches for enjoyment. Possibly you don't understand that its fine.


Well this isn’t a discussion about enjoyment, it’s about whether we deserved to win/lose. If you enjoyed a game, it doesn’t mean we should have won it. Your enjoyment has no effect on it. Lots of fans and clubs alike are very much into xG and the deeper stats behind a game, because it tells the story that the eyes often miss. Fans have a very warped view of a game because they watch it through the eyes of emotion and who they want to win, they often berate their own bad luck but ignore the bad luck of the opposition - xG has no bias.
0
Matos - The Good, The Bad and the Ugly? on 10:13 - Nov 18Whiterockin

Matos - The Good, The Bad and the Ugly? on 10:11 - Nov 18 by MumsArmy

Well this isn’t a discussion about enjoyment, it’s about whether we deserved to win/lose. If you enjoyed a game, it doesn’t mean we should have won it. Your enjoyment has no effect on it. Lots of fans and clubs alike are very much into xG and the deeper stats behind a game, because it tells the story that the eyes often miss. Fans have a very warped view of a game because they watch it through the eyes of emotion and who they want to win, they often berate their own bad luck but ignore the bad luck of the opposition - xG has no bias.


This has a very familiar ring about it.
0
Matos - The Good, The Bad and the Ugly? on 10:14 - Nov 18MumsArmy

Matos - The Good, The Bad and the Ugly? on 10:13 - Nov 18 by Whiterockin

This has a very familiar ring about it.


Because it’s true.
0
Matos - The Good, The Bad and the Ugly? on 10:17 - Nov 18Whiterockin

Matos - The Good, The Bad and the Ugly? on 10:14 - Nov 18 by MumsArmy

Because it’s true.


Im talking about the tone of posting, I'll leave it there.
0
Matos - The Good, The Bad and the Ugly? on 10:18 - Nov 18MumsArmy

Matos - The Good, The Bad and the Ugly? on 10:17 - Nov 18 by Whiterockin

Im talking about the tone of posting, I'll leave it there.


I think my tone is fine. I am explaining the difference between an emotional view and a factual one. Saying we deserved to win because I enjoyed the game doesn’t hold up if the opposition factually generated the better chances.
0
Matos - The Good, The Bad and the Ugly? on 10:19 - Nov 18Whiterockin

Matos - The Good, The Bad and the Ugly? on 10:18 - Nov 18 by MumsArmy

I think my tone is fine. I am explaining the difference between an emotional view and a factual one. Saying we deserved to win because I enjoyed the game doesn’t hold up if the opposition factually generated the better chances.


As I say I will leave it there.
0
Matos - The Good, The Bad and the Ugly? on 10:24 - Nov 18onehunglow

Matos - The Good, The Bad and the Ugly? on 10:11 - Nov 18 by MumsArmy

Well this isn’t a discussion about enjoyment, it’s about whether we deserved to win/lose. If you enjoyed a game, it doesn’t mean we should have won it. Your enjoyment has no effect on it. Lots of fans and clubs alike are very much into xG and the deeper stats behind a game, because it tells the story that the eyes often miss. Fans have a very warped view of a game because they watch it through the eyes of emotion and who they want to win, they often berate their own bad luck but ignore the bad luck of the opposition - xG has no bias.


Enjoyment often has little to do with it
We can be winning by two goals with five mins to go then lose in the 8 th min of time added on
Enjoyment my backside
Hanging on at 1-1 with ten men , going into extra time, then concede via pitiful defending isn’t enjoyment
It’s nowt to do with supporting either


Then to read , we should have won / played well : deserved to win … the script of a clown

Nobody should ever enjoy losing
A good loser is a loser

We’ve lost a lot of games recently and thst eclipses any improvement Matos might have done

It’s forum warlocks meant to impress the impressionable and egotists , the “ better” fans


We need honesty


Matos has dumped on us
He’s marginalised good players by his arrogance and stubbornness
He’s spouted the usual platitudes so one shouldn’t be truly surprised

Those on my ignore list, don’t bother replying


Next …

Poll: Christmas. Enjoyable or not

0
Matos - The Good, The Bad and the Ugly? on 10:31 - Nov 18BarrySwan

I don't think that the team improvements have been particularly solid or outstanding equal to the substancial backing and resources over the last two seasons.

Yes some very good football played in a number of matches and a cracking start this season which is now tailing off and in my opinion the side always looked fragile and susceptible to a comprehensive beating or two which has happened, the Wrexham game was an early indication of that I feel.

The centre of defence is still an inadequate shambles ready to concede at a moments notice which is always going to hamstring any realistic march up the table to promotion.

A couple of decent mobile centre backs would really provide a bit of steel and solidity to set up the number of talented flair players within the squad to hopefully complete a team ready to challenge.
1
Matos - The Good, The Bad and the Ugly? on 10:59 - Nov 18raynor94

I sincerely hope he doesn't have the audacity to come out with a leaving message we plucked him from obscurity and gave him his chance and this is how he repays us

The grass isn't always greener

You give it out, you take it back it`s all part of the game
Poll: Happy to see Martin go

2
Matos - The Good, The Bad and the Ugly? on 11:01 - Nov 18onehunglow

Matos - The Good, The Bad and the Ugly? on 10:59 - Nov 18 by raynor94

I sincerely hope he doesn't have the audacity to come out with a leaving message we plucked him from obscurity and gave him his chance and this is how he repays us

The grass isn't always greener


Well said
He has shat on us Martinez style but at least Bob had emotional pull to Wigan
Matos plain two faced
Painted smile
Va se foder

Poll: Christmas. Enjoyable or not

1
About Us Contact Us Terms & Conditions Privacy Cookies Online Safety Advertising
© FansNetwork 2026