| Andy Fisher& Jay Fulton rewarded with new contracts 16:45 - Feb 12 with 2880 views | KeithHaynes |
Solid Jay.
This post has been edited by an administrator |  |
| |  |
| Andy Fisher& Jay Fulton rewarded with new contracts on 10:52 - Feb 13 with 963 views | KeithHaynes |
| Andy Fisher& Jay Fulton rewarded with new contracts on 20:14 - Feb 12 by wwcigne |
I think Fisher is a good keeper ,his awareness to come off his line is very good and he has good shot stopping ability,I think the tactics of Martin and Williams didn’t suit his game .because he looks a lot better since they’ve gone |
Too many mistakes in him for me. His poor decision making and goalkeeping cost us in the FA Cup.
And cost the club. | |
| |
| Andy Fisher& Jay Fulton rewarded with new contracts on 10:58 - Feb 13 with 945 views | onehunglow |
| Andy Fisher& Jay Fulton rewarded with new contracts on 10:52 - Feb 13 by KeithHaynes |
Too many mistakes in him for me. His poor decision making and goalkeeping cost us in the FA Cup.
And cost the club. |
If he is that good then why do many fans have hearts in mouths when he is between the sticks
In four years , he has been mostly flaky yet given to more years
Sorry but it’s madness
If we are not ambitious then we will never progress
Sentiment is toxic
Imagine Vig busting an ACL
Opinion |  |
| |
| Andy Fisher& Jay Fulton rewarded with new contracts on 12:15 - Feb 13 with 888 views | streetlyjack |
| Andy Fisher& Jay Fulton rewarded with new contracts on 10:58 - Feb 13 by onehunglow |
If he is that good then why do many fans have hearts in mouths when he is between the sticks
In four years , he has been mostly flaky yet given to more years
Sorry but it’s madness
If we are not ambitious then we will never progress
Sentiment is toxic
Imagine Vig busting an ACL
Opinion |
With respect - any keeper that is good enough to replace Vig will not settle for being second choice so is unlikely to join the Swans. Even the most ambitious clubs do not have 2 top quality keepers on their books, regardless of your opinion of Fisher you cant accuse the club of not being ambitious for giving him a new deal. | |
| |
| Andy Fisher& Jay Fulton rewarded with new contracts on 12:19 - Feb 13 with 881 views | union_jack |
| Andy Fisher& Jay Fulton rewarded with new contracts on 12:15 - Feb 13 by streetlyjack |
With respect - any keeper that is good enough to replace Vig will not settle for being second choice so is unlikely to join the Swans. Even the most ambitious clubs do not have 2 top quality keepers on their books, regardless of your opinion of Fisher you cant accuse the club of not being ambitious for giving him a new deal. |
I’m no fan of Fisher but as you say it’s just not feasible for a club like ours to have two first choice keepers.
Fisher isn’t great but he pleasantly surprised me last time I saw him play. That was measured against the very low quality of his craftsmanship in the Martin era so bear that in mind😒 |  |
| |
| Andy Fisher& Jay Fulton rewarded with new contracts on 13:04 - Feb 13 with 835 views | onehunglow |
| Andy Fisher& Jay Fulton rewarded with new contracts on 12:15 - Feb 13 by streetlyjack |
With respect - any keeper that is good enough to replace Vig will not settle for being second choice so is unlikely to join the Swans. Even the most ambitious clubs do not have 2 top quality keepers on their books, regardless of your opinion of Fisher you cant accuse the club of not being ambitious for giving him a new deal. |
That’s a decent riposte and I’ve uparrowed it
However , I don’t believe a further contract is merited
There are better around
Hes too often been a liability and Vigsroux has been a joy
At least we can exchange views on this
Thanks | |
| |
| Andy Fisher& Jay Fulton rewarded with new contracts on 15:30 - Feb 13 with 780 views | jack247 |
| Andy Fisher& Jay Fulton rewarded with new contracts on 12:15 - Feb 13 by streetlyjack |
With respect - any keeper that is good enough to replace Vig will not settle for being second choice so is unlikely to join the Swans. Even the most ambitious clubs do not have 2 top quality keepers on their books, regardless of your opinion of Fisher you cant accuse the club of not being ambitious for giving him a new deal. |
I have to admit I was a bit surprised at the Fisher deal. He’s good enough to be first choice somewhere else.
There won’t be many better backup keepers in the championship | | | |
| Andy Fisher& Jay Fulton rewarded with new contracts on 16:51 - Feb 13 with 725 views | KeithHaynes |
Interesting going back some time ago when Jay seemed to be in limbo. With links.
| |
| |
| Andy Fisher& Jay Fulton rewarded with new contracts on 17:33 - Feb 13 with 659 views | Fireboy2 |
As ive previously, if the club who is managed by a bloke who is very positive and seems to know what hes doing wants to keep fisher and fulton then I am happy. |  | | |
Login to get fewer ads
| Andy Fisher& Jay Fulton rewarded with new contracts on 18:09 - Feb 13 with 628 views | Landore_Jack |
Fisher became number 1 after Rushworth left. Vigouroux was signed that summer but he was seen as backup. After a series of blunders and poor displays Vigouroux became number 1. [Post edited 13 Feb 22:45]
|  |
| |
| Andy Fisher& Jay Fulton rewarded with new contracts on 17:41 - Feb 14 with 465 views | ReslovenSwan1 |
If I was an US owner forking out cash for the academy I would be looking for explanations.
Goal keepers. Not one good enough to be back up even. Or even no 3.
No 9 strikers. Not one. Cullen is not a striker apparently as he does not have a full CF toolbox.
Cotterill and Congreve playing every week. Slow burners like Cullen.
Lissah and Wilson playing every week in Scotland, Lissah might be trusted next season,
Lloyd not cutting it at very poor Newport. |  |
| |
| Andy Fisher& Jay Fulton rewarded with new contracts on 17:43 - Feb 14 with 461 views | onehunglow |
| Andy Fisher& Jay Fulton rewarded with new contracts on 10:48 - Feb 13 by EagleEye |
And some people are so arrogant that they are unable to accept alternative viewpoints even in a football forum.
I don’t think Fisher or Fulton in any starting eleven would fill many with any confidence for a club with ambitions of challenging for promotion. You do. Get over yourself |
Fisher was replaced by Vig as he couldn’t be trusted as he was a liability
He’s never troubled Vig for number 1
A few half decent shows on the cup are him with another deal where he sits on the bench and counts the money
And fans accept this
Fulton , seen as a great servant is a nothing player , proven again today
Yet another laughing at our sentimental shite
We brought back a crocked Bony out of sentiment and we’ve learned nothing
We have given the unstartable Key with another deal
Meanwhile , we have one striker fit , one crocked yet we loan one young prospect out , one who’s not had a chance whilst eom and Ronald get away with ineffective murder
Apart from that , happy val day | |
| |
| Andy Fisher& Jay Fulton rewarded with new contracts on 17:45 - Feb 14 with 459 views | onehunglow |
| Andy Fisher& Jay Fulton rewarded with new contracts on 10:52 - Feb 13 by KeithHaynes |
Too many mistakes in him for me. His poor decision making and goalkeeping cost us in the FA Cup.
And cost the club. |
He’s a disaster
Yet we reward him
Another dumb decision
Meanwhile , another dumb decision , Joel Ward collects a top up pension top out | |
| |
| Andy Fisher& Jay Fulton rewarded with new contracts on 17:46 - Feb 14 with 458 views | onehunglow |
| Andy Fisher& Jay Fulton rewarded with new contracts on 18:18 - Feb 12 by Dr_Winston |
Solid both. Fisher was arguably our best player during the league cup run and kept us in several games, whilst Fulton's capability should be obvious to all by now.
The club can't have superstars in every position. Here and there it needs capable backup and deals like this secure it. |
Arguably is right
You love him
As you do Fisher
Both should not be at the club
There really is better out there | |
| |
| Andy Fisher& Jay Fulton rewarded with new contracts on 17:47 - Feb 14 with 460 views | jack247 |
| Andy Fisher& Jay Fulton rewarded with new contracts on 17:41 - Feb 14 by ReslovenSwan1 |
If I was an US owner forking out cash for the academy I would be looking for explanations.
Goal keepers. Not one good enough to be back up even. Or even no 3.
No 9 strikers. Not one. Cullen is not a striker apparently as he does not have a full CF toolbox.
Cotterill and Congreve playing every week. Slow burners like Cullen.
Lissah and Wilson playing every week in Scotland, Lissah might be trusted next season,
Lloyd not cutting it at very poor Newport. |
The more ambitious a club gets, the harder it is for young players to break through, particularly when the games they play don’t prepare them for the pace and aggression of league football.
Had the previous owners still been in situ, I’m sure some of them would have broken through by now, as we wouldn’t be spending significant money on improving our squad. | | | |
| Andy Fisher& Jay Fulton rewarded with new contracts on 17:47 - Feb 14 with 458 views | onehunglow |
| Andy Fisher& Jay Fulton rewarded with new contracts on 19:50 - Feb 12 by Fireboy2 |
We arent a big club so we need at least one old head to get the crew players to ger the club.
Some on here dont have a clue. |
Well you can’t see further than your saes hating ego [Post edited 14 Feb 19:12]
| |
| |
| Andy Fisher& Jay Fulton rewarded with new contracts on 18:48 - Feb 14 with 410 views | Fireboy2 |
| Andy Fisher& Jay Fulton rewarded with new contracts on 10:48 - Feb 13 by EagleEye |
And some people are so arrogant that they are unable to accept alternative viewpoints even in a football forum.
I don’t think Fisher or Fulton in any starting eleven would fill many with any confidence for a club with ambitions of challenging for promotion. You do. Get over yourself |
Your post being upparrowed by perch says alot, just saying 🤷 | | | |
| Andy Fisher& Jay Fulton rewarded with new contracts on 18:59 - Feb 14 with 400 views | Dr_Winston |
| Andy Fisher& Jay Fulton rewarded with new contracts on 17:46 - Feb 14 by onehunglow |
Arguably is right
You love him
As you do Fisher
Both should not be at the club
There really is better out there |
Less than 2 hours drive from Wallasey to Pride Park. Did you go? |  |
| Pain or damage don't end the world. Or despair, or f*cking beatings. The world ends when you're dead. Until then, you got more punishment in store. Stand it like a man... and give some back. |
| |
| Andy Fisher& Jay Fulton rewarded with new contracts on 19:18 - Feb 14 with 381 views | Fireboy2 |
| Andy Fisher& Jay Fulton rewarded with new contracts on 10:48 - Feb 13 by EagleEye |
And some people are so arrogant that they are unable to accept alternative viewpoints even in a football forum.
I don’t think Fisher or Fulton in any starting eleven would fill many with any confidence for a club with ambitions of challenging for promotion. You do. Get over yourself |
Is that a dig at me or you know who? | | | |
| Andy Fisher& Jay Fulton rewarded with new contracts on 20:06 - Feb 14 with 351 views | onehunglow |
| Andy Fisher& Jay Fulton rewarded with new contracts on 17:41 - Feb 14 by ReslovenSwan1 |
If I was an US owner forking out cash for the academy I would be looking for explanations.
Goal keepers. Not one good enough to be back up even. Or even no 3.
No 9 strikers. Not one. Cullen is not a striker apparently as he does not have a full CF toolbox.
Cotterill and Congreve playing every week. Slow burners like Cullen.
Lissah and Wilson playing every week in Scotland, Lissah might be trusted next season,
Lloyd not cutting it at very poor Newport. |
Yep
A back up keeper given another two years to sit on the bench and do farm all
And a midfielder who has been nothing less than average for at least six years
Loves the city
That’s enough
It’s crazy
It also can’t be said
But it the truth | |
| |
| Andy Fisher& Jay Fulton rewarded with new contracts on 21:37 - Feb 15 with 249 views | controversial_jack |
| Andy Fisher& Jay Fulton rewarded with new contracts on 20:06 - Feb 14 by onehunglow |
Yep
A back up keeper given another two years to sit on the bench and do farm all
And a midfielder who has been nothing less than average for at least six years
Loves the city
That’s enough
It’s crazy
It also can’t be said
But it the truth |
Fulton is a good professional player. He's never going to be a world beater, but we are a mediocre championship side. He knows his role, reads the game well and is strong. Glad we are giving him
An extension | | | |
| Andy Fisher& Jay Fulton rewarded with new contracts on 08:11 - Feb 18 with 121 views | GVJack |
| Andy Fisher& Jay Fulton rewarded with new contracts on 17:43 - Feb 14 by onehunglow |
Fisher was replaced by Vig as he couldn’t be trusted as he was a liability
He’s never troubled Vig for number 1
A few half decent shows on the cup are him with another deal where he sits on the bench and counts the money
And fans accept this
Fulton , seen as a great servant is a nothing player , proven again today
Yet another laughing at our sentimental shite
We brought back a crocked Bony out of sentiment and we’ve learned nothing
We have given the unstartable Key with another deal
Meanwhile , we have one striker fit , one crocked yet we loan one young prospect out , one who’s not had a chance whilst eom and Ronald get away with ineffective murder
Apart from that , happy val day |
Most number two goal keepers do sit on the bench and count the money. That's their job, to provide a back up option should the first choice keeper get injured or suspended. He would come in for a handful of games as cover, he's not going to oust Vig from the number 1 spot. No club (to my knowledge) use a weekly rotation system with their keepers, they have first choice who will play 90%+ matches and a backup.
It's not sentiment, it's good business all round that we have a keeper who's fit, has some experience at this level, happy to play understudy to Vig, is already settled into the area and squad, is not going to cost a transfer fee and is not going to be breaking the bank with his wage demands. It also offers us the opportunity to loan out some of our younger keepers over the next couple of seasons to gain competitive experience. I can't see any flaws in Fisher being given a new contract to be honest. [Post edited 18 Feb 8:14]
| | | |
| Andy Fisher& Jay Fulton rewarded with new contracts on 08:27 - Feb 18 with 108 views | Whiterockin |
| Andy Fisher& Jay Fulton rewarded with new contracts on 08:11 - Feb 18 by GVJack |
Most number two goal keepers do sit on the bench and count the money. That's their job, to provide a back up option should the first choice keeper get injured or suspended. He would come in for a handful of games as cover, he's not going to oust Vig from the number 1 spot. No club (to my knowledge) use a weekly rotation system with their keepers, they have first choice who will play 90%+ matches and a backup.
It's not sentiment, it's good business all round that we have a keeper who's fit, has some experience at this level, happy to play understudy to Vig, is already settled into the area and squad, is not going to cost a transfer fee and is not going to be breaking the bank with his wage demands. It also offers us the opportunity to loan out some of our younger keepers over the next couple of seasons to gain competitive experience. I can't see any flaws in Fisher being given a new contract to be honest. [Post edited 18 Feb 8:14]
|
With hindsight was it a mistake to sign Fisher for what we paid and the contract he was given, probably but that is not his fault or that of our current decision makers. Is it good business to extend his contract on fresh terms considering the current position of both Fisher and the club, I would say it is. Neither can be blamed for decisions in the past and to hold a grudge is foolish. |  | | |
| Andy Fisher& Jay Fulton rewarded with new contracts on 09:48 - Feb 18 with 78 views | KeithHaynes |
| Andy Fisher& Jay Fulton rewarded with new contracts on 08:27 - Feb 18 by Whiterockin |
With hindsight was it a mistake to sign Fisher for what we paid and the contract he was given, probably but that is not his fault or that of our current decision makers. Is it good business to extend his contract on fresh terms considering the current position of both Fisher and the club, I would say it is. Neither can be blamed for decisions in the past and to hold a grudge is foolish. |
For me the Swans would be right un the messy stuff if he was our number one this season. | |
| |
| Andy Fisher& Jay Fulton rewarded with new contracts on 09:59 - Feb 18 with 67 views | Whiterockin |
| Andy Fisher& Jay Fulton rewarded with new contracts on 09:48 - Feb 18 by KeithHaynes |
For me the Swans would be right un the messy stuff if he was our number one this season. |
Without a doubt, but at the right cost he is a good back up. | | | |
| Andy Fisher& Jay Fulton rewarded with new contracts on 10:02 - Feb 18 with 65 views | GVJack |
| Andy Fisher& Jay Fulton rewarded with new contracts on 09:48 - Feb 18 by KeithHaynes |
For me the Swans would be right un the messy stuff if he was our number one this season. |
I'd imagine most clubs would be saying the same about their backup keepers though unless there is some serious talent/potential sitting on the bench. | | | |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
