| Technical ability vs the press 17:57 - Nov 21 with 1571 views | MumsArmy | Today was the difference between technical players and pure press machines. Our press was nowhere near as pronounced today, as a result we were completely outshone technically by WBA. They played in tight spaces, sharp with their passes, played out and through us very quickly and skilfully and for a lot of the game we were chasing shadows. The underlying data on that game was shocking, 6 big chances vs our 1, WBA nearly 4 xG vs our 1. Bright spots were that Elijah Just had his best game and Lissah was very good, other than that it was all a bit of a mess. Need a manager in quickly. |  | | |  |
| Technical ability vs the press on 18:38 - Nov 21 | onehunglow | I thought it was encouraging actually We went behind twice We came back twice We could have won Matos and his tactics now being unravelled |  |
|  |
| Technical ability vs the press on 18:51 - Nov 21 | jack_lord | I thought our press was very slow to read what was going on and allowed them to get away with their possession at the back |  |
|  |
| Technical ability vs the press on 19:04 - Nov 21 | MumsArmy |
| Technical ability vs the press on 18:51 - Nov 21 by jack_lord | I thought our press was very slow to read what was going on and allowed them to get away with their possession at the back |
Yes the press wasn't anywhere near as sweeping, only one or two would commit to it at any one time as opposed to 3 or 4 which is what we had been used to. I’m stunned we got out with a point. Tymon suspended for Middlesborough but will be fresh for Cardiff. The concern was for all the talk of the Swans DNA, we had 45% possession. |  | |  |
| Technical ability vs the press on 19:15 - Nov 21 | Whiterockin |
| Technical ability vs the press on 19:04 - Nov 21 by MumsArmy | Yes the press wasn't anywhere near as sweeping, only one or two would commit to it at any one time as opposed to 3 or 4 which is what we had been used to. I’m stunned we got out with a point. Tymon suspended for Middlesborough but will be fresh for Cardiff. The concern was for all the talk of the Swans DNA, we had 45% possession. |
Styles was the best player on the pitch for me. His movement and passing broke any press that we tried. |  | |  |
| Technical ability vs the press on 19:29 - Nov 21 | MumsArmy |
| Technical ability vs the press on 19:15 - Nov 21 by Whiterockin | Styles was the best player on the pitch for me. His movement and passing broke any press that we tried. |
He was fantastic, Isaac Price on the half turn kept taking multiple players out of the game each time too. WBA were excellent, they played today how we used to in our pomp. Inviting aggression knowing that they can ping the ball around you at will. It felt a little bit like an Alan Sheehan set up, in between a few styles and not committing to any. Trying to press but not committing many bodies to it, trying to control the ball but not being good enough with it. Don’t know if this was the result of having 4 individuals leading us with different ideas, or trying to revert to the traditional Swansea way of doing things but not having enough players in the side capable of playing intricate one touch football in tight spaces. A confused approach I would describe it as. |  | |  |
| Technical ability vs the press on 20:57 - Nov 21 | SullutaCreturned | I think, all things considered, that we did well against a very good side. We have played football like them this season and given the last weeks revelations and the behind the scenes stories we have heard, that performance and that result were very good. The players were bound to be pee'd off with what's happened, lifting them, getting them to focus and get a result against the team with the best away form was great. Hopefully it's onwards and upwards now. Not that I don't think we need a new manager but I think it's better to not rush. We have to get it right, there's too many greedy, 2 faced SOB's out there, if we rush and get it wrong it could ruin our season. We could end up with another Victor if we're not careful! |  | |  |
| Technical ability vs the press on 22:03 - Nov 21 | MumsArmy |
| Technical ability vs the press on 20:57 - Nov 21 by SullutaCreturned | I think, all things considered, that we did well against a very good side. We have played football like them this season and given the last weeks revelations and the behind the scenes stories we have heard, that performance and that result were very good. The players were bound to be pee'd off with what's happened, lifting them, getting them to focus and get a result against the team with the best away form was great. Hopefully it's onwards and upwards now. Not that I don't think we need a new manager but I think it's better to not rush. We have to get it right, there's too many greedy, 2 faced SOB's out there, if we rush and get it wrong it could ruin our season. We could end up with another Victor if we're not careful! |
For me that performance was really bad, it was a good result but the performance was not good. We haven’t given up that amount of chances quality all season. For weight of chances to the opposition it was similar to the 5-0 QPR game. QPR 6 big chances 3.90 xG Swansea 0 big chances 0.43 xG 3.47 xG difference Swansea 1 big chance 1.14 xG WBA 6 big chances 4.21 xG 3.07 xG difference Those are the only two games this season where there has been such a huge gulf in chance creation between us and the opposition. [Post edited 21 Nov 22:05]
|  | |  |
| Technical ability vs the press on 22:11 - Nov 21 | onehunglow |
| Technical ability vs the press on 22:03 - Nov 21 by MumsArmy | For me that performance was really bad, it was a good result but the performance was not good. We haven’t given up that amount of chances quality all season. For weight of chances to the opposition it was similar to the 5-0 QPR game. QPR 6 big chances 3.90 xG Swansea 0 big chances 0.43 xG 3.47 xG difference Swansea 1 big chance 1.14 xG WBA 6 big chances 4.21 xG 3.07 xG difference Those are the only two games this season where there has been such a huge gulf in chance creation between us and the opposition. [Post edited 21 Nov 22:05]
|
I hated Algebra |  |
|  | Login to get fewer ads
| Technical ability vs the press on 22:33 - Nov 21 | Dr_Winston | West Brom basically had the one tactic, but it worked against us very well. Every chance they had they played the ball forward early. Either via one of those curving passes in behind the fullbacks, or by playing an "around the corner" pass. The players making said passes didn't even bother looking. They just assumed that the forwards would be there to receive, and quite often they were. That's good coaching of a well drilled side. They found space every time by doing it, whilst we did our usual thing of passing it around hoping to find a gap. I don't think there's any reason why the players that we have couldn't play in a similar way. Indeed it'd probably suit them more. Certainly Vipotnik would be more effective given how often their wide players found themselves in a position to deliver the ball into the penalty area, and there's no reason to suggest that Idah or Stewart wouldn't also. Yeo, Eom, Opuku, Ronald, they could all shine playing like this. We really need to consider that when looking at the new coach. Moving the ball quickly with purpose is somewhere we've fallen down a bit too much recently. [Post edited 21 Nov 22:36]
|  |
| Pain or damage don't end the world. Or despair, or f*cking beatings. The world ends when you're dead. Until then, you got more punishment in store. Stand it like a man... and give some back. |
|  |
| Technical ability vs the press on 01:40 - Nov 22 | swan65split | all season our weakness has been our full backs as they tend to be attacking , leaving space ,as we tend to play a central 3 at the back, also our far post positions, as shown in the qpr game and again today. its been like that since the Rat was here. our stength is the passing, just look at our second goal, sadly we for some reason play in spurts , correction......first goal. [Post edited 22 Nov 10:10]
|  | |  |
| Technical ability vs the press on 06:55 - Nov 22 | jack247 |
| Technical ability vs the press on 19:04 - Nov 21 by MumsArmy | Yes the press wasn't anywhere near as sweeping, only one or two would commit to it at any one time as opposed to 3 or 4 which is what we had been used to. I’m stunned we got out with a point. Tymon suspended for Middlesborough but will be fresh for Cardiff. The concern was for all the talk of the Swans DNA, we had 45% possession. |
Worst thing you can do is half commit to a press. It’s either got to be aggressive and co-ordinated or just drop back and don’t do it. West Brom were the best team we’ve played at home. All of them confident passing and moving anywhere on the pitch, but any team would have easily passed around our disorganised press yesterday. Very lucky with the point, we competed to an extent in the first half, second half they battered us. We ran out of ideas and resorted to long balls which never stuck. A few of our big players having poor games didn’t help. They’ve only had a couple of days and we were up against a very good team. Big improvements needed though. |  | |  |
| Technical ability vs the press on 09:32 - Nov 22 | sons_of_omri |
| Technical ability vs the press on 22:33 - Nov 21 by Dr_Winston | West Brom basically had the one tactic, but it worked against us very well. Every chance they had they played the ball forward early. Either via one of those curving passes in behind the fullbacks, or by playing an "around the corner" pass. The players making said passes didn't even bother looking. They just assumed that the forwards would be there to receive, and quite often they were. That's good coaching of a well drilled side. They found space every time by doing it, whilst we did our usual thing of passing it around hoping to find a gap. I don't think there's any reason why the players that we have couldn't play in a similar way. Indeed it'd probably suit them more. Certainly Vipotnik would be more effective given how often their wide players found themselves in a position to deliver the ball into the penalty area, and there's no reason to suggest that Idah or Stewart wouldn't also. Yeo, Eom, Opuku, Ronald, they could all shine playing like this. We really need to consider that when looking at the new coach. Moving the ball quickly with purpose is somewhere we've fallen down a bit too much recently. [Post edited 21 Nov 22:36]
|
I keep hearing that West Brom were the best we’ve faced this season but not in my opinion. If we’d played Southampton or West Ham we would have lost 4 or 5 - 2. The press wasn’t good enough and second half we kept turning the ball over giving them the opportunity to counter attack us. Lissah was out of position a lot and their left winger exploited that with glee. We didn’t have any on field leadership second half and Ash and co didn’t really know what to do to counter it. I would have liked Monga to have come on at the hour mark as he would at least caused WBA some worry with his pace. Our goals (especially the first) highlighted just how good we can be so I’m not at all downhearted- we just need to exercise more control in midfield and not playing Eustaquio so far forward would have that effect I’m sure. Hopefully Corberan , Elphick or Pablo will be appointed over the weekend so they could really get some good training ground work done this week. As for Middlesbrough it’s a shame about Tymon’s suspension but Parente looks capable and might surprise us - also a game for Lissah and Welsh at CB with Key on the right. I’m not sure how tired Widdell and Just are but one of them would be my pick at 10 in front of Fulton and Eustaquio with Opoku and Yeo on flanks and start Vipotnik up front with Stewart to replace him. EOM to come on at some point probably at 10 |  | |  |
| Technical ability vs the press on 09:51 - Nov 22 | Whiterockin |
| Technical ability vs the press on 09:32 - Nov 22 by sons_of_omri | I keep hearing that West Brom were the best we’ve faced this season but not in my opinion. If we’d played Southampton or West Ham we would have lost 4 or 5 - 2. The press wasn’t good enough and second half we kept turning the ball over giving them the opportunity to counter attack us. Lissah was out of position a lot and their left winger exploited that with glee. We didn’t have any on field leadership second half and Ash and co didn’t really know what to do to counter it. I would have liked Monga to have come on at the hour mark as he would at least caused WBA some worry with his pace. Our goals (especially the first) highlighted just how good we can be so I’m not at all downhearted- we just need to exercise more control in midfield and not playing Eustaquio so far forward would have that effect I’m sure. Hopefully Corberan , Elphick or Pablo will be appointed over the weekend so they could really get some good training ground work done this week. As for Middlesbrough it’s a shame about Tymon’s suspension but Parente looks capable and might surprise us - also a game for Lissah and Welsh at CB with Key on the right. I’m not sure how tired Widdell and Just are but one of them would be my pick at 10 in front of Fulton and Eustaquio with Opoku and Yeo on flanks and start Vipotnik up front with Stewart to replace him. EOM to come on at some point probably at 10 |
With Tymon out don't be surprised to see Lissah there and Key on the right. Lissah has played there before. |  | |  |
| Technical ability vs the press on 10:09 - Nov 22 | wwcigne |
| Technical ability vs the press on 09:51 - Nov 22 by Whiterockin | With Tymon out don't be surprised to see Lissah there and Key on the right. Lissah has played there before. |
Parente looked decent enough when he came on the other day |  | |  |
| Technical ability vs the press on 10:15 - Nov 22 | Whiterockin |
| Technical ability vs the press on 10:09 - Nov 22 by wwcigne | Parente looked decent enough when he came on the other day |
I agree he played well but I think they might start with our best team available as there is an extra rest day as we are not playing until Sunday. |  | |  |
| Technical ability vs the press on 10:15 - Nov 22 | SullutaCreturned |
| Technical ability vs the press on 09:32 - Nov 22 by sons_of_omri | I keep hearing that West Brom were the best we’ve faced this season but not in my opinion. If we’d played Southampton or West Ham we would have lost 4 or 5 - 2. The press wasn’t good enough and second half we kept turning the ball over giving them the opportunity to counter attack us. Lissah was out of position a lot and their left winger exploited that with glee. We didn’t have any on field leadership second half and Ash and co didn’t really know what to do to counter it. I would have liked Monga to have come on at the hour mark as he would at least caused WBA some worry with his pace. Our goals (especially the first) highlighted just how good we can be so I’m not at all downhearted- we just need to exercise more control in midfield and not playing Eustaquio so far forward would have that effect I’m sure. Hopefully Corberan , Elphick or Pablo will be appointed over the weekend so they could really get some good training ground work done this week. As for Middlesbrough it’s a shame about Tymon’s suspension but Parente looks capable and might surprise us - also a game for Lissah and Welsh at CB with Key on the right. I’m not sure how tired Widdell and Just are but one of them would be my pick at 10 in front of Fulton and Eustaquio with Opoku and Yeo on flanks and start Vipotnik up front with Stewart to replace him. EOM to come on at some point probably at 10 |
Southampton I can give you but not West Ham, I didn't think they were up to much at all and we gifted them their goal. Of course what we know now helps to explain the last few weeks, the drop in standards. |  | |  |
| Technical ability vs the press on 10:22 - Nov 22 | Whiterockin |
| Technical ability vs the press on 10:15 - Nov 22 by SullutaCreturned | Southampton I can give you but not West Ham, I didn't think they were up to much at all and we gifted them their goal. Of course what we know now helps to explain the last few weeks, the drop in standards. |
Exactly if the manager drops off slightly so do the team. If he had been offered one the other jobs that he was linked with he would have gone. Possibly Matos hasn't given 100% for over a month. |  | |  |
| Technical ability vs the press on 10:24 - Nov 22 | Dr_Winston | TBH I think the way WBA were playing it wouldn't have mattered all that much how we pressed. They certainly didn't dither in possession for reasons I've already gone into. |  |
| Pain or damage don't end the world. Or despair, or f*cking beatings. The world ends when you're dead. Until then, you got more punishment in store. Stand it like a man... and give some back. |
|  |
| Technical ability vs the press on 10:39 - Nov 22 | vetchonian |
| Technical ability vs the press on 22:03 - Nov 21 by MumsArmy | For me that performance was really bad, it was a good result but the performance was not good. We haven’t given up that amount of chances quality all season. For weight of chances to the opposition it was similar to the 5-0 QPR game. QPR 6 big chances 3.90 xG Swansea 0 big chances 0.43 xG 3.47 xG difference Swansea 1 big chance 1.14 xG WBA 6 big chances 4.21 xG 3.07 xG difference Those are the only two games this season where there has been such a huge gulf in chance creation between us and the opposition. [Post edited 21 Nov 22:05]
|
Another who is obsessed with stays and not what thir eyes show. Yes in the second half West Brom looked the side most likely to score but as ever its fine margins West Brom score their pen its most ly game over at 1-3 Widdells free kick goes in its game on at 3-2 I dont think a greay critique should be offered on yesterday given the events of the week and how thebinterim team have had little time to work on things. Id have settled for a point even without the upheavals. |  |
|  |
| Technical ability vs the press on 10:44 - Nov 22 | RichardO |
| Technical ability vs the press on 10:09 - Nov 22 by wwcigne | Parente looked decent enough when he came on the other day |
I would agreed with that a like for like swap with a player who looks stronger defensively but without Tymon experience. I would say the same on the other side Parker looked better or stronger on the ball defensively than Key when asked to get tight to a winger but he has been plagued by injury. Would say both Key and Tymon have improved but the question of how much room do you give wingers is a point that teams are exploiting. Tymon having to far to intercept the passes ending getting to the player too fast and getting turned, when he has got tight he cuts the ball out well getting or keeping us on the front foot, when he does that the centrebacks and midfield need to sort their positions out to ensure gaps or long balls are closed down. |  | |  |
| Technical ability vs the press on 11:28 - Nov 22 | vetchonian | so given our starting 11 yesterday which players would you drop for their kack of techincal ability v being pure press machlnes? |  |
|  |
| Technical ability vs the press on 11:52 - Nov 22 | jack247 |
| Technical ability vs the press on 10:44 - Nov 22 by RichardO | I would agreed with that a like for like swap with a player who looks stronger defensively but without Tymon experience. I would say the same on the other side Parker looked better or stronger on the ball defensively than Key when asked to get tight to a winger but he has been plagued by injury. Would say both Key and Tymon have improved but the question of how much room do you give wingers is a point that teams are exploiting. Tymon having to far to intercept the passes ending getting to the player too fast and getting turned, when he has got tight he cuts the ball out well getting or keeping us on the front foot, when he does that the centrebacks and midfield need to sort their positions out to ensure gaps or long balls are closed down. |
I don’t think we need to over complicate this. Just give Parente a game. Given what’s gone on this week, the level of opposition and the SWD on the horizon, there’s a decision to be made on Fulton as well. He’s on four yellow cards and I’m never defeatist, but I think I’d rather have him fresh for Cardiff than play him 90 minutes after a tough slog yesterday and risk a suspension. |  | |  |
| Technical ability vs the press on 12:05 - Nov 22 | MumsArmy |
| Technical ability vs the press on 11:28 - Nov 22 by vetchonian | so given our starting 11 yesterday which players would you drop for their kack of techincal ability v being pure press machlnes? |
None, I don’t think we have very many pure technicians to step in and replace the ones we have. But I would rank every WBA midfielder and winger over ours in terms of pure technical ability, their ability to manipulate the ball and play in tight spaces is something we don’t have. Elijah Just and Melker are largely industry and have singular moments of technical quality, that needs to be far more balanced if we are to compete in possession rather than out of possession. |  | |  |
| Technical ability vs the press on 12:21 - Nov 22 | MumsArmy | Harsh on Eom there, he has similar technical qualities needed for that style of play. He could have slotted into the WBA team seamlessly. Even Eustaquio to me isn’t good enough with the ball and is more industrious, his passing and touch yesterday was awful. It can be good but nowhere near consistent enough. Yeo has a decent mix of both technical and athleticism but still heavily weighted on the athleticism side, Opoku and Ronald are extremely weighted towards the athleticism side. It’s a side built for an out of possession game, having possession is a byproduct of winning the ball high, but make no mistake our style under Matos and Sheehan was an out of possession game and the players we have brought in are in the main (barring a couple of exceptions) weighted towards that style. |  | |  |
| Technical ability vs the press on 12:36 - Nov 22 | vetchonian |
| Technical ability vs the press on 12:21 - Nov 22 by MumsArmy | Harsh on Eom there, he has similar technical qualities needed for that style of play. He could have slotted into the WBA team seamlessly. Even Eustaquio to me isn’t good enough with the ball and is more industrious, his passing and touch yesterday was awful. It can be good but nowhere near consistent enough. Yeo has a decent mix of both technical and athleticism but still heavily weighted on the athleticism side, Opoku and Ronald are extremely weighted towards the athleticism side. It’s a side built for an out of possession game, having possession is a byproduct of winning the ball high, but make no mistake our style under Matos and Sheehan was an out of possession game and the players we have brought in are in the main (barring a couple of exceptions) weighted towards that style. |
so its not just Matos to blame for our recruitment of late is fhat what you are saying? So where do the lukes of Walts,Iorpenda and Monga figure in your assesment? |  |
|  |
| |