| Best / Worst loan signing you have seen at QPR 15:23 - Feb 15 with 2073 views | runningman75 |
Following on from the Scott Sinclair threat was thinking about loan players who have played for us.
Best loan player I saw was Mark Kennedy. Worst loan signing Macheda full of expectation about a player from Man Untd who looked clueless. |  | | |  |
| Best / Worst loan signing you have seen at QPR on 15:33 - Feb 15 with 1621 views | N12Hoop |
The worst: Gus Ceasar, I can't believe anyone has been worse than him.
The best: Adel !
|  |
| |
| Best / Worst loan signing you have seen at QPR on 15:38 - Feb 15 with 1603 views | PinnerPaul |
| Best / Worst loan signing you have seen at QPR on 15:33 - Feb 15 by N12Hoop |
The worst: Gus Ceasar, I can't believe anyone has been worse than him.
The best: Adel !
|
Agree with the best
I'm going for Bob Malcolm as the worse to play in the 1st team, but haven't there been a few that haven't actually played for the first team who we have signed? | | | |
| Best / Worst loan signing you have seen at QPR on 15:40 - Feb 15 with 1600 views | fakekerby |
Jerome Thomas looked insanely good for a few games. | | | |
| Best / Worst loan signing you have seen at QPR on 15:50 - Feb 15 with 1584 views | Bluce_Ree |
Mark Kennedy was absolute class.
Worst: so many. Probably Gavin Peacock. Not because he was a bad loan, he was ace on loan, but because it led to a permanent deal where he became our most overrated player ever. |  |
| ALL THINGS ARE POSSIBLE THROUGH MARTI THE REDEEMER WHO STRENGTHENS ME. |
| |
| Best / Worst loan signing you have seen at QPR on 15:50 - Feb 15 with 1584 views | Toast_R |
Worst = Callum (Pillock) Willock. Missed a glarer I recall.
Best = Lee Cook
|  | | |
| Best / Worst loan signing you have seen at QPR on 15:51 - Feb 15 with 1582 views | themodfather |
| Best / Worst loan signing you have seen at QPR on 15:50 - Feb 15 by Toast_R |
Worst = Callum (Pillock) Willock. Missed a glarer I recall.
Best = Lee Cook
|
worst..robert taylor
was brett angell a loan??
best...mickel beck? lee camp is in there | | | |
| Best / Worst loan signing you have seen at QPR on 15:52 - Feb 15 with 1582 views | loftboy |
Best Kyle Walker
Worst Gus Ceasar by a country mile |  |
| |
| Best / Worst loan signing you have seen at QPR on 15:55 - Feb 15 with 1576 views | PinnerPaul |
| Best / Worst loan signing you have seen at QPR on 15:38 - Feb 15 by PinnerPaul |
Agree with the best
I'm going for Bob Malcolm as the worse to play in the 1st team, but haven't there been a few that haven't actually played for the first team who we have signed? |
LOAN - just noticed that! 
| | | |
Login to get fewer ads
| Best / Worst loan signing you have seen at QPR on 15:56 - Feb 15 with 1573 views | Birchwood |
| Best / Worst loan signing you have seen at QPR on 15:52 - Feb 15 by loftboy |
Best Kyle Walker
Worst Gus Ceasar by a country mile |
+1 |  |
| Never trust a man who, when left alone in a room with a tea cozy, doesn't try it on. |
| |
| Best / Worst loan signing you have seen at QPR on 16:28 - Feb 15 with 1544 views | N12Hoop |
Adel was a loan player before we signed him was he not? Therefore surely he must be our best loan signing. | |
| |
| Best / Worst loan signing you have seen at QPR on 16:30 - Feb 15 with 1536 views | toboboly |
Worst;
Jason Jarrett, Gary Borrowdale, Bob Malcolm, Carl Ikeme, Matt Hill etc etc |  |
| Sexy Asian dwarves wanted. |
| |
| Best / Worst loan signing you have seen at QPR on 17:16 - Feb 15 with 1491 views | PhilmyRs |
Camp was one of the best simply because of how we got him, last minute job, ended up being fantastic for us. Adel is the best player of all of them. But his form really came to life once he was made permanent, on loan he wasn’t so impressive.
The best for me — Mark Kennedy or Kyle Walker (can’t separate) both were to performers whilst on loan. Would be tempted to go for Walker as he stood out in a good team, Kennedy looked class playing alongside a bunch of cr*p.
The worst — Scott Sinclair due to his fear of getting injured is a contender, but the winner for me would be Mikel Beck. If he wasn’t a loan I’d go Bob Malcolm.
| | | |
| Best / Worst loan signing you have seen at QPR on 17:16 - Feb 15 with 1490 views | hoops_legend |
| Best / Worst loan signing you have seen at QPR on 16:30 - Feb 15 by toboboly |
Worst;
Jason Jarrett, Gary Borrowdale, Bob Malcolm, Carl Ikeme, Matt Hill etc etc |
No-one has put Marcus Bent or Tamas Priskin
Priskin scored only ONE goal
Bent did Nada except warn Warnock if he played 6 loan players we would get docked points! So he didnt have to play! |  | | |
| Best / Worst loan signing you have seen at QPR on 17:24 - Feb 15 with 1474 views | FredManRave |
| Best / Worst loan signing you have seen at QPR on 15:50 - Feb 15 by Bluce_Ree |
Mark Kennedy was absolute class.
Worst: so many. Probably Gavin Peacock. Not because he was a bad loan, he was ace on loan, but because it led to a permanent deal where he became our most overrated player ever. |
Agree re Kennedy.
As for Peacock, depends how you've come to the conclusion of him being "our most overrated player ever". Personally, thought he was a good, reliable solid player who gave his all in all his near 200 game, 6 year second stint with us. Not a world beater but definitely added to the team at the time.
Back to Best Signing let's hope it turns out to be Andros Townsend who, thanks to his goals and assists, helps us snatch safety from the jaws of relegation. |  |
| |
| Best / Worst loan signing you have seen at QPR on 18:18 - Feb 15 with 1425 views | CamberleyR |
| Best / Worst loan signing you have seen at QPR on 17:16 - Feb 15 by PhilmyRs |
Camp was one of the best simply because of how we got him, last minute job, ended up being fantastic for us. Adel is the best player of all of them. But his form really came to life once he was made permanent, on loan he wasn’t so impressive.
The best for me — Mark Kennedy or Kyle Walker (can’t separate) both were to performers whilst on loan. Would be tempted to go for Walker as he stood out in a good team, Kennedy looked class playing alongside a bunch of cr*p.
The worst — Scott Sinclair due to his fear of getting injured is a contender, but the winner for me would be Mikel Beck. If he wasn’t a loan I’d go Bob Malcolm.
|
Agree with Camp being one of the best. Completely unknown kid when we signed him after Day (Culkin?) got injured who'd had one previous dodgy loan spell at Burton.
It would have been quite a daunting prospect for a youngster to come into a side chasing automatic promotion but he showed remarkable maturity. He had a particularly good game in the decider at Hillsborough.
Honourable mentions: Mark Kennedy (who did a Scott Sinclair and opted to go back to Liverpool and sit on the bench), Michael Mancienne, Lee Cook
Worst: Usual suspects: Caesar, Willock, Cornwall, Taylor, Malcolm, Jarrett, Czerkas, Sahar |  |
| |
| Best / Worst loan signing you have seen at QPR on 18:34 - Feb 15 with 1399 views | batmanhoop |
few contenders for the best, Walker and Kennedy are good shouts, but out on his own as the worst, still sends shivers down my spine, Gus Caesar and the then Arsenal manager wanted £200,000 for him  | | | |
| Best / Worst loan signing you have seen at QPR on 18:46 - Feb 15 with 1379 views | RamseyR |
| Best / Worst loan signing you have seen at QPR on 15:50 - Feb 15 by Toast_R |
Worst = Callum (Pillock) Willock. Missed a glarer I recall.
Best = Lee Cook
|
Callum Willock - his miss was away at Luton if I remember rightly |  | | |
| Best / Worst loan signing you have seen at QPR on 21:13 - Feb 15 with 1301 views | TGRRRSSS |
In fairness to Malcolm he improved under De Canio and got a lot fitter, terrible debut but unfair to say he was anywhere near the worst. |  | | |
| Best / Worst loan signing you have seen at QPR on 21:36 - Feb 15 with 1280 views | numptydumpty |
| Best / Worst loan signing you have seen at QPR on 21:13 - Feb 15 by TGRRRSSS |
In fairness to Malcolm he improved under De Canio and got a lot fitter, terrible debut but unfair to say he was anywhere near the worst. |
Kyle Walker really did show a great deal of potential. |  |
| |
| Best / Worst loan signing you have seen at QPR on 21:50 - Feb 15 with 1276 views | simmohoopster |
| Best / Worst loan signing you have seen at QPR on 21:36 - Feb 15 by numptydumpty |
Kyle Walker really did show a great deal of potential. |
Worst: Bob Malcolm
Best Adel Taarabt | | | |
| Best / Worst loan signing you have seen at QPR on 22:02 - Feb 15 with 1263 views | Jamie |
Leon Clarke. Even worse we then signed him permanently many years later on. | | | |
| Best / Worst loan signing you have seen at QPR on 22:07 - Feb 15 with 1259 views | NorthLondonR |
| Best / Worst loan signing you have seen at QPR on 21:50 - Feb 15 by simmohoopster |
Worst: Bob Malcolm
Best Adel Taarabt |
Tommy Smith (pre-January 2011) when everyone knew he was really our player
Given our situation and the fact we initially thought he was ours... Aziz Ben Askar |  | | |
| Best / Worst loan signing you have seen at QPR on 22:13 - Feb 15 with 1253 views | 0hwestlondon |
other good un's are i reckon, Andrew Davies, short stay(he got run over if i remember correctly) looked decent at the time, in our dark hour of need in league 1 days, ben askar was pretty good considering our situation at the time, Paul furlong was a cracking loan as it lead to him signing for us, stephen kelly was good for the short stay, steve lomas, jimmy smith, darren ward,tommy williams, all good loan signings
bad un's, marlon broomes, leon clarke, neil ruddock, rohan rickets, leon knight, leon best, and i think puncheon should go in the bad un's list not cause he was shit but cause he didnt play, so pointless bad signing for me, also this tells me if you add in leon jeanne our old youth player, we should avoid those with the name leon. | | | |
| Best / Worst loan signing you have seen at QPR on 23:48 - Feb 15 with 1220 views | paulparker |
Good = Kennedy, walker,camp,Kelly ,McLeod,Routledge,Darren ward &
The lad at Pompey we got who broke a leg can't remember his name
Worst= rob Taylor,Paul Walsh, peschsolido, ceaser,prisken,matt hill, willock,
Maceada,
|  |
| And Bowles is onside, Swinburne has come rushing out of his goal , what can Bowles do here , onto the left foot no, on to the right foot
That’s there that’s two, and that’s Bowles
Brian Moore
|
| |
| Best / Worst loan signing you have seen at QPR on 01:37 - Feb 16 with 1195 views | hamptonhillhoop |
| Best / Worst loan signing you have seen at QPR on 15:50 - Feb 15 by Bluce_Ree |
Mark Kennedy was absolute class.
Worst: so many. Probably Gavin Peacock. Not because he was a bad loan, he was ace on loan, but because it led to a permanent deal where he became our most overrated player ever. |
Gavin peacock scored you ten goals a season from midfield, year after year, so i think thats a bit unfair. Mark Kennedy played about four games. Although he did a nice somersault after he scored against Crewe that time |  | | |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
