Please log in or register. Registered visitors get fewer ads.
Forum index | Previous Thread | Next thread
Swansea City v Birmingham City : The Indy match thread 10:31 - Aug 3 with 45629 viewsModeratorC







Swansea City : Leganés, Blues build up & striker on his way to the Swans ? 3rd Aug 2026 12:30
The pre-season has come to an end. CD Leganés was our final test, and Matos now has less than a week before the stakes become real. Birmingham City awaits, but first let's take what we can from that friendly at the Swansea.com Stadium. Plus we have news of a striker signing by the Swans rumoured. 0




Swans v Blues , how medicals work, Seck transfer latest & focus on tomorrow 7th Aug 2026 14:10
Swansea City take on Birmingham City in their first competitive fixture of the new season tomorrow. It’s League Cup time and for the first time ever it’s the curtain raiser for the season. 0




Swans v Blues : Match Day Saturday plus Fall Seck in Swansea ‘Myths exploded’ 8th Aug 2026 08:44
It’s the first competitive game of the season with the first round of the League Cup taking place later today at the .com. (3pm) The Swans take on the Blues of Birmingham City in a competition both sides have won this century. 0






This post has been edited by an administrator
0
Swansea City v Birmingham City : The Indy match thread on 09:56 - Aug 9 with 3346 viewsunion_jack

Swansea City v Birmingham City : The Indy match thread on 01:17 - Aug 9 by AnotherJohn

Technology moves on, though cardless ATM withdrawals still haven't been implemented by all UK banks.

https://acemoneytransfer.com/b

Re the game, I am still worried about where our goals will come from.


Having slept on this I can’t believe how disappointed I am that we lost yesterday. Normally, I’d shrug a cup game iff and seek solace in the fact that we can concentrate on the league.

But I keep replaying a few things from yesterday which chimes with your point. Idah was through on goal in the first half and although it was a tight-ish angle, his shot was tame. He should have put his laces through it. And then Just’s shit where he had plenty of time and tried to be cute by bending it. There were a few others.

I’ve just seen some of the other Championship sides goals and although I’m sure there were similar incidents in those games it being the first competitive match of the season, they managed to finish better than we did.

I’d like us to be getting the ball at speed into the area with a target man or two arriving at the right time. Yesterday, it seemed too much of trying to thread needles and being snuffed out too easy.

We’ve got genuine pace now, let’s get them and the strikers in the same page.

Are Sperm Whales the reason the sea is so salty?
Poll: Bony - Would You Want Him Back?

2
Swansea City v Birmingham City : The Indy match thread on 10:01 - Aug 9 with 3316 viewssons_of_omri

Swansea City v Birmingham City : The Indy match thread on 19:32 - Aug 8 by Whiterockin

Decent attendance today 11,283, meanwhile those up the road who are obsessed with attendance figures 6,168.


1,394 away fans so less than 5000 cardiff fans there . Not so big anymore !
0
Swansea City v Birmingham City : The Indy match thread on 10:05 - Aug 9 with 3251 viewsonehunglow

Swansea City v Birmingham City : The Indy match thread on 09:56 - Aug 9 by union_jack

Having slept on this I can’t believe how disappointed I am that we lost yesterday. Normally, I’d shrug a cup game iff and seek solace in the fact that we can concentrate on the league.

But I keep replaying a few things from yesterday which chimes with your point. Idah was through on goal in the first half and although it was a tight-ish angle, his shot was tame. He should have put his laces through it. And then Just’s shit where he had plenty of time and tried to be cute by bending it. There were a few others.

I’ve just seen some of the other Championship sides goals and although I’m sure there were similar incidents in those games it being the first competitive match of the season, they managed to finish better than we did.

I’d like us to be getting the ball at speed into the area with a target man or two arriving at the right time. Yesterday, it seemed too much of trying to thread needles and being snuffed out too easy.

We’ve got genuine pace now, let’s get them and the strikers in the same page.


Morning
I will get this in quick
Let’s forget this “ it’s only the carabea cup” crap
It was the first “
“ meaningful game
No excuses that it was a pre season etc and is no guide
It was a guide , we still played it slow,still faffed about, still missed ll gifted n appalling goal to a big team that hadn’t had a shot at goal . They didn’t get any after either . That’s because they were well drilled , referee smart and basically head workers .We were bullied again .
Vig still kicks to touch ,our full backs look abysmal apart from Lissah who looks real class .
We showed little urgency ,again
The crowd silence said it all.
We are still seeing substandard performances defended by some as being ( negative)

Negativity it’s not but fact and the truth .


I would warn against watching the likes of West Ham and wolves as to how they deal with defensive errors.

Poll: Christmas. Enjoyable or not

0
Swansea City v Birmingham City : The Indy match thread on 10:43 - Aug 9 with 3178 viewswwcigne

Swansea City v Birmingham City : The Indy match thread on 09:56 - Aug 9 by union_jack

Having slept on this I can’t believe how disappointed I am that we lost yesterday. Normally, I’d shrug a cup game iff and seek solace in the fact that we can concentrate on the league.

But I keep replaying a few things from yesterday which chimes with your point. Idah was through on goal in the first half and although it was a tight-ish angle, his shot was tame. He should have put his laces through it. And then Just’s shit where he had plenty of time and tried to be cute by bending it. There were a few others.

I’ve just seen some of the other Championship sides goals and although I’m sure there were similar incidents in those games it being the first competitive match of the season, they managed to finish better than we did.

I’d like us to be getting the ball at speed into the area with a target man or two arriving at the right time. Yesterday, it seemed too much of trying to thread needles and being snuffed out too easy.

We’ve got genuine pace now, let’s get them and the strikers in the same page.


The shooting opportunity that Stamenic had in the second half a perfect example of your point,got the ball on the edge of the box,a big gap in front of him an he chipped it to the back post and out for a goal kick instead of putting his foot through it
It’s simple really , don’t shoot and you won’t score
It’s pointless trying to walk it into the net
5
Swansea City v Birmingham City : The Indy match thread on 11:05 - Aug 9 with 3120 viewssons_of_omri

Swansea City v Birmingham City : The Indy match thread on 10:43 - Aug 9 by wwcigne

The shooting opportunity that Stamenic had in the second half a perfect example of your point,got the ball on the edge of the box,a big gap in front of him an he chipped it to the back post and out for a goal kick instead of putting his foot through it
It’s simple really , don’t shoot and you won’t score
It’s pointless trying to walk it into the net


It’s only the first game. Just , Yeo and Opoku will very soon be hitting the back of the net. Our problem yesterday was we could play the ball out and through Birmingham in the first half but the pressed us well in the second half which squeezed us into making mistakes and long balls from Vig which always coughed up possession. A comfortable CD and a bonafide CDM in the Bodde mould would certainly ease that pressure.
I thought our passing and general forward play was a joy to watch in the first half. They weren’t even in the game until the mistake and subsequent goal.
1
Swansea City v Birmingham City : The Indy match thread on 11:15 - Aug 9 with 3089 viewswwcigne

Swansea City v Birmingham City : The Indy match thread on 11:05 - Aug 9 by sons_of_omri

It’s only the first game. Just , Yeo and Opoku will very soon be hitting the back of the net. Our problem yesterday was we could play the ball out and through Birmingham in the first half but the pressed us well in the second half which squeezed us into making mistakes and long balls from Vig which always coughed up possession. A comfortable CD and a bonafide CDM in the Bodde mould would certainly ease that pressure.
I thought our passing and general forward play was a joy to watch in the first half. They weren’t even in the game until the mistake and subsequent goal.


First half was a breath of fresh air
Second half we reverted to the sideways and back in our own half rubbish we’ve seen over the last few years,slow boring and easy to play against ,having Stamenic and Fulton in the midfield together compounded our problems and made us easy to play against
The few times we did get forward second half came when Eom ran with the ball through the middle and laid the ball out wide
We could all see what was happening so Matos must have
0
Swansea City v Birmingham City : The Indy match thread on 11:19 - Aug 9 with 3069 viewsGwyn737

We’ll have no idea what season we’re in for until we’re 10 games in.

Before the game I was cautiously optimistic for the year ahead. I still feel the same.
0
Swansea City v Birmingham City : The Indy match thread on 13:01 - Aug 9 with 2830 viewsonehunglow

Swansea City v Birmingham City : The Indy match thread on 11:19 - Aug 9 by Gwyn737

We’ll have no idea what season we’re in for until we’re 10 games in.

Before the game I was cautiously optimistic for the year ahead. I still feel the same.


One is either optimistic or not

Poll: Christmas. Enjoyable or not

0
Login to get fewer ads

Swansea City v Birmingham City : The Indy match thread on 13:13 - Aug 9 with 2827 viewsCyberswan

Extended highlights


Full match
[Post edited 9 Aug 13:56]
0
Swansea City v Birmingham City : The Indy match thread on 16:31 - Aug 9 with 2600 viewsGwyn737

Swansea City v Birmingham City : The Indy match thread on 13:01 - Aug 9 by onehunglow

One is either optimistic or not


Cautiously optimistic is optimistic.
0
Swansea City v Birmingham City : The Indy match thread on 17:07 - Aug 9 with 2514 viewsonehunglow

Swansea City v Birmingham City : The Indy match thread on 16:31 - Aug 9 by Gwyn737

Cautiously optimistic is optimistic.


Fair play
I’m a realist and a doom monger but Jesus wants me for a sunbeam
I’ll be a sunbeam for him
Good to have respectful e changes isn’t it

PS you can’t be a cautious optimist as it’s a contradiction in terms

Terms such as optimist pessimist negative and positive should be outlawed as they’re comfort labels
[Post edited 9 Aug 17:09]

Poll: Christmas. Enjoyable or not

0
Swansea City v Birmingham City : The Indy match thread on 17:38 - Aug 9 with 2484 viewsOptimisticJack

Swansea City v Birmingham City : The Indy match thread on 17:07 - Aug 9 by onehunglow

Fair play
I’m a realist and a doom monger but Jesus wants me for a sunbeam
I’ll be a sunbeam for him
Good to have respectful e changes isn’t it

PS you can’t be a cautious optimist as it’s a contradiction in terms

Terms such as optimist pessimist negative and positive should be outlawed as they’re comfort labels
[Post edited 9 Aug 17:09]


Have I got to change my username OH?

Optimisticjack

0
Swansea City v Birmingham City : The Indy match thread on 17:42 - Aug 9 with 2476 viewsGwyn737

Swansea City v Birmingham City : The Indy match thread on 17:07 - Aug 9 by onehunglow

Fair play
I’m a realist and a doom monger but Jesus wants me for a sunbeam
I’ll be a sunbeam for him
Good to have respectful e changes isn’t it

PS you can’t be a cautious optimist as it’s a contradiction in terms

Terms such as optimist pessimist negative and positive should be outlawed as they’re comfort labels
[Post edited 9 Aug 17:09]


Of course you can be cautiously optimistic.

It’s a common phrase.
1
Swansea City v Birmingham City : The Indy match thread on 18:00 - Aug 9 with 2414 viewsWhiterockin

Swansea City v Birmingham City : The Indy match thread on 17:42 - Aug 9 by Gwyn737

Of course you can be cautiously optimistic.

It’s a common phrase.


Quote.

Yes, cautiously optimistic is a very real and widely used phrase. It means you hope for a good result and see reasons to feel positive, but you also know that problems or setbacks could still happen.
1
Swansea City v Birmingham City : The Indy match thread on 18:06 - Aug 9 with 2405 viewsGwyn737

Swansea City v Birmingham City : The Indy match thread on 18:00 - Aug 9 by Whiterockin

Quote.

Yes, cautiously optimistic is a very real and widely used phrase. It means you hope for a good result and see reasons to feel positive, but you also know that problems or setbacks could still happen.


Yep.

What you can’t be is a realist AND a doom monger.
0
Swansea City v Birmingham City : The Indy match thread on 23:04 - Aug 9 with 2175 viewsRichardO

Lots of what if and buts, will Matos revert to the players with championship experience for the first league game, looks as if Burgess will be out so new pairing will be needed in the heart of the defence, good thing or bad thing?
should Lissah or Welsh start iwho is the most comfortable on the left.
Matos tried the same thing on Saturday as he did against Legane when bringing Fulton on pushing Stamenic onto the right side of the midfield did that benefit Just being pushed out wide?
Are we comfortable with Widell needing to come so deep in both games, as per lthe start of last season Matos will have to work out the best fits for the team just as Sheehan had to but struggled for any form of positive consistency.

We have to wait an see who will be relied on to get us off to a good start away from home.
0
Swansea City v Birmingham City : The Indy match thread on 23:11 - Aug 9 with 2165 viewsmax936

Swansea City v Birmingham City : The Indy match thread on 23:04 - Aug 9 by RichardO

Lots of what if and buts, will Matos revert to the players with championship experience for the first league game, looks as if Burgess will be out so new pairing will be needed in the heart of the defence, good thing or bad thing?
should Lissah or Welsh start iwho is the most comfortable on the left.
Matos tried the same thing on Saturday as he did against Legane when bringing Fulton on pushing Stamenic onto the right side of the midfield did that benefit Just being pushed out wide?
Are we comfortable with Widell needing to come so deep in both games, as per lthe start of last season Matos will have to work out the best fits for the team just as Sheehan had to but struggled for any form of positive consistency.

We have to wait an see who will be relied on to get us off to a good start away from home.


Last thing we want to be doing is forces square pegs into round holes and vice versa, we did it with Galbraith when it was clear that we were more effective with him in midfield No10 role.
0
Swansea City v Birmingham City : The Indy match thread on 23:28 - Aug 9 with 2136 viewswwcigne

Swansea City v Birmingham City : The Indy match thread on 23:11 - Aug 9 by max936

Last thing we want to be doing is forces square pegs into round holes and vice versa, we did it with Galbraith when it was clear that we were more effective with him in midfield No10 role.


And don’t forget Key was less than impressive against Sorba last season
Lissah at right back for me and Welsh in the middle
We have to be tight to their widemen and in midfield
We need to be aggressive or they will roll us over
2
Swansea City v Birmingham City : The Indy match thread on 23:29 - Aug 9 with 2136 viewsRichardO

Swansea City v Birmingham City : The Indy match thread on 23:11 - Aug 9 by max936

Last thing we want to be doing is forces square pegs into round holes and vice versa, we did it with Galbraith when it was clear that we were more effective with him in midfield No10 role.


Is it clear that Stamenic is the best option in the central midfield?
As for a No 10 role we haven't played with two up top wjich is the formation most associated with it, for a number of seasons .
We have lost Franco for the moment and Galbraith is gone who is going to grab the midfield positions Just seem full of vigour at the moment and Widell has stake a claim but as yet we are missing something there to be found, Lissah looks really assured on the ball with him driving forward from defends cam we then afford to have Stamenic in the centre of the midfield to cover those runs or just play Lissah there instead and would Lissah be happy there or would it be too much for the young player with little experience around him to help?
Happy days new season has started with a disappointing result but surely Matos will turn things around.
0
Swansea City v Birmingham City : The Indy match thread on 23:36 - Aug 9 with 2127 viewswwcigne

Swansea City v Birmingham City : The Indy match thread on 23:29 - Aug 9 by RichardO

Is it clear that Stamenic is the best option in the central midfield?
As for a No 10 role we haven't played with two up top wjich is the formation most associated with it, for a number of seasons .
We have lost Franco for the moment and Galbraith is gone who is going to grab the midfield positions Just seem full of vigour at the moment and Widell has stake a claim but as yet we are missing something there to be found, Lissah looks really assured on the ball with him driving forward from defends cam we then afford to have Stamenic in the centre of the midfield to cover those runs or just play Lissah there instead and would Lissah be happy there or would it be too much for the young player with little experience around him to help?
Happy days new season has started with a disappointing result but surely Matos will turn things around.


Lissah ,Cabango ,Welsh,Tymon
Stamenic (not too deep) Widell Walta
Yeo,Zan,Opoko
For me ,make them defend and cut out the slow stuff
0
Swansea City v Birmingham City : The Indy match thread on 08:40 - Aug 10 with 1902 viewssons_of_omri

Swansea City v Birmingham City : The Indy match thread on 23:29 - Aug 9 by RichardO

Is it clear that Stamenic is the best option in the central midfield?
As for a No 10 role we haven't played with two up top wjich is the formation most associated with it, for a number of seasons .
We have lost Franco for the moment and Galbraith is gone who is going to grab the midfield positions Just seem full of vigour at the moment and Widell has stake a claim but as yet we are missing something there to be found, Lissah looks really assured on the ball with him driving forward from defends cam we then afford to have Stamenic in the centre of the midfield to cover those runs or just play Lissah there instead and would Lissah be happy there or would it be too much for the young player with little experience around him to help?
Happy days new season has started with a disappointing result but surely Matos will turn things around.


We desperately need a proper CDM and not shoehorn Stamenic who is really an 8. His presence further forward would help nip some opposition moves in the budget if he and the team press correctly .

Plus - a proven right back so Lissah/Cabango/Welsh could rotate now Burgess is injured.
[Post edited 10 Aug 8:42]
0
Swansea City v Birmingham City : The Indy match thread on 09:17 - Aug 10 with 1867 viewsonehunglow

Swansea City v Birmingham City : The Indy match thread on 17:38 - Aug 9 by OptimisticJack

Have I got to change my username OH?


Don’t go changing
To try and please me


You sing it , I’ll play

Poll: Christmas. Enjoyable or not

0
Swansea City v Birmingham City : The Indy match thread on 09:18 - Aug 10 with 1864 viewsonehunglow

Swansea City v Birmingham City : The Indy match thread on 17:42 - Aug 9 by Gwyn737

Of course you can be cautiously optimistic.

It’s a common phrase.


As is “ me personally” but it’s wrong

Poll: Christmas. Enjoyable or not

0
Swansea City v Birmingham City : The Indy match thread on 09:20 - Aug 10 with 1862 viewsonehunglow

Swansea City v Birmingham City : The Indy match thread on 18:06 - Aug 9 by Gwyn737

Yep.

What you can’t be is a realist AND a doom monger.


Of course you can be

Better to be miserable in the real world
Than happy on a fantasy world


See, it’s only words

And words are all I have …

Poll: Christmas. Enjoyable or not

0
Swansea City v Birmingham City : The Indy match thread on 09:26 - Aug 10 with 1859 viewsWhiterockin

Swansea City v Birmingham City : The Indy match thread on 09:20 - Aug 10 by onehunglow

Of course you can be

Better to be miserable in the real world
Than happy on a fantasy world


See, it’s only words

And words are all I have …


I'll take happy any day of the week.
0
About Us Contact Us Terms & Conditions Privacy Cookies Online Safety Advertising
© FansNetwork 2026