Please log in or register. Registered visitors get fewer ads.
Forum index | Previous Thread | Next thread
Goldilocks syndrome and Swansea city 13:49 - Nov 19 with 1952 viewsReslovenSwan1

Swansea managers never last long. They last in the range 1-2 years For longevity Swansea need a specific type of manager A "Goldilocks manager". Not too good not too bad.

There are three classes of manager. Good, Average and Poor.

Good managers last a while and leave with compensation.

Brendan, Martinez, Matos and Cooper marginal.


Average Goldilocks managers

Stay for a while but are encouraged to leave or sacked

Sousa, Martin Giudolin, Cooper ( marginal).

Bad Managers are sacked

Sheehan Duff Williams Bradley.

For longevity Swansea need to keep the Goldie lock managers not push them to the door. Mowbrey is the classical "Goldilocks manager ".

Both Martin and Cooper felt let down by the board who were happy to take the compensation payment for both.

Probably the purest Goldilocks manager that should have gen kept subject to his health was Guidolin. He had a long carer of developing players in Italy love d Swansea and r too old to be tapped up. He was probably already very wealthy.

Brendan left in the Premier league so it is not simply a.matrefof promotion.

Would Steve Cooper and Russel Martin have stayed had they been given the transfer budget Matos was given ? Roberto might have stayed if given a transfer budget .

Laudrup Swansea most successful manager does not fit in my classification as he had exceptional features.

Who will be the first man anger to break the two season barrier ?
.
[Post edited 19 Nov 15:09]

Wise sage since Toshack era
Poll: Do Swansea city have enough centre backs?

0
Goldilocks syndrome and Swansea city on 14:05 - Nov 19jack247

Depends on the ambition. If we want to settle for being a lower mid table championship club, then yes, we appoint a steady Eddie who won’t do too well or too badly.

If we do want to challenge, which our owners evidently do, then we have to be prepared for bigger clubs coming in for successful managers and also prepared to press the button on managers like Sheehan and Williams who aren’t going to get there.

It’s not really a Swansea thing, it’s very common with clubs trying to better themselves.

What I am surprised by, is how we’ve reacted to it. This may have come as a shock, but it was always a possibility and I’d have expected us to have a short list ready to move quickly on. We’re not in the Levein and Kaplan era any more.
1
Goldilocks syndrome and Swansea city on 14:23 - Nov 19Whiterockin

Goldilocks syndrome and Swansea city on 14:05 - Nov 19 by jack247

Depends on the ambition. If we want to settle for being a lower mid table championship club, then yes, we appoint a steady Eddie who won’t do too well or too badly.

If we do want to challenge, which our owners evidently do, then we have to be prepared for bigger clubs coming in for successful managers and also prepared to press the button on managers like Sheehan and Williams who aren’t going to get there.

It’s not really a Swansea thing, it’s very common with clubs trying to better themselves.

What I am surprised by, is how we’ve reacted to it. This may have come as a shock, but it was always a possibility and I’d have expected us to have a short list ready to move quickly on. We’re not in the Levein and Kaplan era any more.


We must have been expecting it otherwise why give a new contract with an improved buy out. This is the 3rd club to be interested in Matos if reports are true. Are we delaying the departure statement from the club to announce a replacement at the same time.
0
Goldilocks syndrome and Swansea city on 14:26 - Nov 19RichardO

Goldilocks syndrome and Swansea city on 14:05 - Nov 19 by jack247

Depends on the ambition. If we want to settle for being a lower mid table championship club, then yes, we appoint a steady Eddie who won’t do too well or too badly.

If we do want to challenge, which our owners evidently do, then we have to be prepared for bigger clubs coming in for successful managers and also prepared to press the button on managers like Sheehan and Williams who aren’t going to get there.

It’s not really a Swansea thing, it’s very common with clubs trying to better themselves.

What I am surprised by, is how we’ve reacted to it. This may have come as a shock, but it was always a possibility and I’d have expected us to have a short list ready to move quickly on. We’re not in the Levein and Kaplan era any more.


Did Williams and Sheehan become the Claudio Ranieri of the Championship having a problem they tinkered too much to try and solve, did Matos go down the same rabbit hole or can we point to injuries to key players in his last few games in charge.
0
Goldilocks syndrome and Swansea city on 14:27 - Nov 19onehunglow

Goldilocks syndrome and Swansea city on 14:05 - Nov 19 by jack247

Depends on the ambition. If we want to settle for being a lower mid table championship club, then yes, we appoint a steady Eddie who won’t do too well or too badly.

If we do want to challenge, which our owners evidently do, then we have to be prepared for bigger clubs coming in for successful managers and also prepared to press the button on managers like Sheehan and Williams who aren’t going to get there.

It’s not really a Swansea thing, it’s very common with clubs trying to better themselves.

What I am surprised by, is how we’ve reacted to it. This may have come as a shock, but it was always a possibility and I’d have expected us to have a short list ready to move quickly on. We’re not in the Levein and Kaplan era any more.


Final paragraph is a mute point
I was reading this wasn’t the surprise it’s been to fans
We do need to replace promptly to obviate any tailing off
I think we feel rather wounded as a fan base and Matos name will stink for years to come
He’s been underhand IMO

We have to get back on the horse straight away though

Crowd will help Saturday and the Cardiff game has gone up a notch higher

Their cretinous tankers will be looking forward to heaping more hurt upon us

What a game in prospect


Do it lads

Poll: Christmas. Enjoyable or not

0
Goldilocks syndrome and Swansea city on 14:33 - Nov 19jack247

Goldilocks syndrome and Swansea city on 14:27 - Nov 19 by onehunglow

Final paragraph is a mute point
I was reading this wasn’t the surprise it’s been to fans
We do need to replace promptly to obviate any tailing off
I think we feel rather wounded as a fan base and Matos name will stink for years to come
He’s been underhand IMO

We have to get back on the horse straight away though

Crowd will help Saturday and the Cardiff game has gone up a notch higher

Their cretinous tankers will be looking forward to heaping more hurt upon us

What a game in prospect


Do it lads


I’m not sure how it’s a moot point. We should always be prepared for bigger clubs coming in for our manager or any of our players and should have a plan A,B and C.

Yes that plan will be fluid, but I would expect us to have a shortlist of the next Matos’ at clubs we can reasonably expect to poach them from.
1
Goldilocks syndrome and Swansea city on 14:40 - Nov 193swan

Goldilocks syndrome and Swansea city on 14:33 - Nov 19 by jack247

I’m not sure how it’s a moot point. We should always be prepared for bigger clubs coming in for our manager or any of our players and should have a plan A,B and C.

Yes that plan will be fluid, but I would expect us to have a shortlist of the next Matos’ at clubs we can reasonably expect to poach them from.


You would expect the club to have had a provisional list of coaches they would be interested in if it came to this point
Of course having a list and given permission to talk to them and them also showing interest can take time.
If as posted the 4 are in charge for the next 3 games then hopefully the process is being done fully before an appointment
2
Goldilocks syndrome and Swansea city on 14:43 - Nov 19Whiterockin

Goldilocks syndrome and Swansea city on 14:33 - Nov 19 by jack247

I’m not sure how it’s a moot point. We should always be prepared for bigger clubs coming in for our manager or any of our players and should have a plan A,B and C.

Yes that plan will be fluid, but I would expect us to have a shortlist of the next Matos’ at clubs we can reasonably expect to poach them from.


That is exactly the reality of football life, to think otherwise is nieve. If nobody wants them its because they are not very good.
0
Goldilocks syndrome and Swansea city on 15:48 - Nov 19Whiterockin

Goldilocks syndrome and Swansea city on 14:05 - Nov 19 by jack247

Depends on the ambition. If we want to settle for being a lower mid table championship club, then yes, we appoint a steady Eddie who won’t do too well or too badly.

If we do want to challenge, which our owners evidently do, then we have to be prepared for bigger clubs coming in for successful managers and also prepared to press the button on managers like Sheehan and Williams who aren’t going to get there.

It’s not really a Swansea thing, it’s very common with clubs trying to better themselves.

What I am surprised by, is how we’ve reacted to it. This may have come as a shock, but it was always a possibility and I’d have expected us to have a short list ready to move quickly on. We’re not in the Levein and Kaplan era any more.


There is no room for a steady Eddie in the championship the stakes are just to high. That is why the average life of a championship manager is only 9 months.
0
Login to get fewer ads

Goldilocks syndrome and Swansea city on 16:28 - Nov 19onehunglow

Goldilocks syndrome and Swansea city on 14:33 - Nov 19 by jack247

I’m not sure how it’s a moot point. We should always be prepared for bigger clubs coming in for our manager or any of our players and should have a plan A,B and C.

Yes that plan will be fluid, but I would expect us to have a shortlist of the next Matos’ at clubs we can reasonably expect to poach them from.


I’ve not expressed myself well enough
I do think we should always have interest in those who are available as coaches
It’s like any business
Don’t fire unless someone else lined up for example

Anyway , I think we are pretty united , more than wexwete and it might actually be beneficial

Poll: Christmas. Enjoyable or not

0
Goldilocks syndrome and Swansea city on 18:06 - Nov 19max936

"Probably the purest Goldilocks manager that should have gen kept subject to his health was Guidolin. He had a long carer of developing players in Italy love d Swansea and r too old to be tapped up. He was probably already very wealthy."

He was treated shockingly by your mate.
[Post edited 19 Nov 18:17]
0
Goldilocks syndrome and Swansea city on 18:14 - Nov 19max936

Goldilocks syndrome and Swansea city on 14:26 - Nov 19 by RichardO

Did Williams and Sheehan become the Claudio Ranieri of the Championship having a problem they tinkered too much to try and solve, did Matos go down the same rabbit hole or can we point to injuries to key players in his last few games in charge.


Injuries played a part without doubt, but what we then found out was that perhaps some of the players outside our "solid" first eleven weren't up to replacing those out, then maybe the argument could be made that they weren't given chances in first team often enough.

It's a vicious circle, well maybe not a vicious one
0
Goldilocks syndrome and Swansea city on 17:15 - Nov 20ReslovenSwan1

Goldilocks syndrome and Swansea city on 18:06 - Nov 19 by max936

"Probably the purest Goldilocks manager that should have gen kept subject to his health was Guidolin. He had a long carer of developing players in Italy love d Swansea and r too old to be tapped up. He was probably already very wealthy."

He was treated shockingly by your mate.
[Post edited 19 Nov 18:17]


No he was not. He was paid handsomely and given a chance I the biggest league in the world by HJ

At that age you do not worry about awkward moments and a missed birthdays. It was Kaplan and Levien which wanted Bob Bradley.

Wise sage since Toshack era
Poll: Do Swansea city have enough centre backs?

0
Goldilocks syndrome and Swansea city on 18:53 - Nov 20max936

Goldilocks syndrome and Swansea city on 17:15 - Nov 20 by ReslovenSwan1

No he was not. He was paid handsomely and given a chance I the biggest league in the world by HJ

At that age you do not worry about awkward moments and a missed birthdays. It was Kaplan and Levien which wanted Bob Bradley.


You posted at the time that he had been treated badly, you either don't remember or more than likely don't want to remember, because it doesn't suit your agenda, as per

Who mentioned Bradley
0
Goldilocks syndrome and Swansea city on 22:17 - Nov 20GVJack

Goldilocks syndrome and Swansea city on 14:40 - Nov 19 by 3swan

You would expect the club to have had a provisional list of coaches they would be interested in if it came to this point
Of course having a list and given permission to talk to them and them also showing interest can take time.
If as posted the 4 are in charge for the next 3 games then hopefully the process is being done fully before an appointment


I tend to agree, although having not even being here for one year, having recently signed a new contract, and going on record to say "I'm very happy at Swansea" when linked to other jobs and may have caused some complacency in the need to scout potential new managers for the short/medium turn.

Of course if his performances dived, he informed the chairman he was unhappy/unsettled or a little further into nearing the end of his contract would make sense to be thinking of the natural succession plan. But I sense this has caught the board as much as off guard as the fans.
0
Goldilocks syndrome and Swansea city on 22:22 - Nov 20Whiterockin

Goldilocks syndrome and Swansea city on 22:17 - Nov 20 by GVJack

I tend to agree, although having not even being here for one year, having recently signed a new contract, and going on record to say "I'm very happy at Swansea" when linked to other jobs and may have caused some complacency in the need to scout potential new managers for the short/medium turn.

Of course if his performances dived, he informed the chairman he was unhappy/unsettled or a little further into nearing the end of his contract would make sense to be thinking of the natural succession plan. But I sense this has caught the board as much as off guard as the fans.


I begrudge nobody for moving on and trying to improve but there is a way to do it, Matos has showed no class in that area and failed miserably. In life you reap what you sow.
1
Goldilocks syndrome and Swansea city on 08:49 - Nov 21Swans9

What I find mad is how quick matos went. I haven't seen that at another club. Surely it takes longer to leave than that. Strange one.In the past in the main we did well when a manager moved on.
1
Goldilocks syndrome and Swansea city on 11:04 - Nov 21max936

Goldilocks syndrome and Swansea city on 08:49 - Nov 21 by Swans9

What I find mad is how quick matos went. I haven't seen that at another club. Surely it takes longer to leave than that. Strange one.In the past in the main we did well when a manager moved on.


We probably had to sanction it otherwise he probably would have walked out going by the attitude he showed. F'him anyway!
0
Goldilocks syndrome and Swansea city on 11:18 - Nov 21KeithHaynes

Goldilocks syndrome and Swansea city on 08:49 - Nov 21 by Swans9

What I find mad is how quick matos went. I haven't seen that at another club. Surely it takes longer to leave than that. Strange one.In the past in the main we did well when a manager moved on.


🤷🏻‍♂️


Swansea City : Matos in negotiations with Strasbourg 2 weeks before Swans CEO knew 20th Nov 2026 15:55
Swansea City fans are asking questions regards how the situation with Vitor Matos materialised so quickly on Monday afternoon after an approach by Strasbourg the day before. Well, we can exclusively reveal without any caution that Matos was in discussions up to two weeks before he approached CEO Tom Gorringe on Monday which set the Swans into a real spin. 1


A great believer in taking anything you like to wherever you want to.
Blog: Would you like to appear here as a Welsh football writer?

0
Goldilocks syndrome and Swansea city on 11:45 - Nov 21majorraglan

Goldilocks syndrome and Swansea city on 17:15 - Nov 20 by ReslovenSwan1

No he was not. He was paid handsomely and given a chance I the biggest league in the world by HJ

At that age you do not worry about awkward moments and a missed birthdays. It was Kaplan and Levien which wanted Bob Bradley.


Whether Guidolin was paid handsomely or not isn’t the issue, it’s the way he was treated that counts and my take on it is that Guidolin was treated poorly.
2
Goldilocks syndrome and Swansea city on 12:38 - Nov 21pencoedjack

I stopped reading when Martin was rated as an average manager
0
Goldilocks syndrome and Swansea city on 12:40 - Nov 21ReslovenSwan1

Goldilocks syndrome and Swansea city on 12:38 - Nov 21 by pencoedjack

I stopped reading when Martin was rated as an average manager


What is your assessment.? Be brave

Wise sage since Toshack era
Poll: Do Swansea city have enough centre backs?

0
About Us Contact Us Terms & Conditions Privacy Cookies Online Safety Advertising
© FansNetwork 2026