Please log in or register. Registered visitors get fewer ads.
Forum index | Previous Thread | Next thread
Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread 23:18 - Nov 3 with 26405 viewsModeratorC








Blues v Swans : The very latest as a huge sigh of relief is heard over South Wales 5th Nov 2026 19:00
All the latest Swans news as they prepare for the trip to St Andrews. Blues have their injury concerns, but Swansea face a side in form as our stats will reveal. 0




Swansea City : History is against the Swans. Friday night briefing 6th Nov 2026 17:33
Our Swansea City team played a significant role in the evolution of British football." 0



Swansea City: Lawrence Vigouroux; Filip Lissah, Ben Cabango (captain), Jenson Seelt, Josh Tymon; Jay Fulton, Marko Stamenic, Goncalo Franco; Moussa Yeo, Jisung Eom, Ross Stewart.

Substitutes: Andy Fisher, Josh Key, Melker Widell, Elijah Just, Zan Vipotnik, Tom Iorpenda, Joseph Opoku, Adam Idah, Carter Heywood


Blues 2 Swans 1 : Nearly men again but an encouraging performance against the odds 7th Nov 2026 17:52
You just knew that when Marko Stamenić was sent off for a clumsy challenge on BAFTA award-winning Ethan Laird, today was going to become even harder than it already was. Despite that, the Swans could have been a few goals up before the incident. The bad luck, frustration and overall despondency may well have returned, but that was only part of the story. 1






This post has been edited by an administrator
0
Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 17:15 - Nov 7 with 0 viewsunion_jack

Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 17:05 - Nov 7 by max936

"More disappointed when Ospreys win."

WHAT!!


Just what it says. I’m not a huge Wales fan or of any country really. I like them to win but don’t lose sleep when they lose. That would mean I’d be constantly tired.

I’m feeling a bit like that about the Swans but that may just be knee-jerk reaction to the last two games. Unfortunately, the next three don’t look to be any easier.

And we can’t even have a good laugh at Cardiff which was nailed on at one point😡
[Post edited 7 Nov 17:17]

Are Sperm Whales the reason the sea is so salty?
Poll: Bony - Would You Want Him Back?

0
Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 17:18 - Nov 7 with 0 viewsonehunglow

Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 17:15 - Nov 7 by union_jack

Just what it says. I’m not a huge Wales fan or of any country really. I like them to win but don’t lose sleep when they lose. That would mean I’d be constantly tired.

I’m feeling a bit like that about the Swans but that may just be knee-jerk reaction to the last two games. Unfortunately, the next three don’t look to be any easier.

And we can’t even have a good laugh at Cardiff which was nailed on at one point😡
[Post edited 7 Nov 17:17]


This time an international break might help
Though Widdell was injured

Its defensive boys


We’re not being coached right

Poll: Christmas. Enjoyable or not

-2
Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 17:18 - Nov 7 with 0 viewsswan65split

Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 17:11 - Nov 7 by onehunglow

Jesus H
Again
Basics
Vigaroux stays on his line for a corner
They have a player unmarked
This is awful
It’s cruel

Matos leaving doesn’t seem so bad a thought now

We’re not smart


ps Brum are shyte , like Pompey
Yard dogs


Vigs lookwed and acted as if he was pushed......my thought it was by one of our own!
0
Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 17:20 - Nov 7 with 0 viewsunion_jack

Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 17:14 - Nov 7 by max936

The sending off spoilt the plan for the game we had to re-adjust, we did well to hang in there and get the goal back.

Disappointing after the last few games, but surely some perspective is required


Indeed. But the manner of the defeats suggests we are not good enough to be in the current position and I’m disappointed that we’ve gone this way. Teams outplay, outmuscle and out-think us at the moment and we don’t have an answer.

Add in the stupidity of an individual today which basically scuppered our chances and yes, I’m p1ssed off.

Are Sperm Whales the reason the sea is so salty?
Poll: Bony - Would You Want Him Back?

2
Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 17:25 - Nov 7 with 0 viewsjohnlangy

Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 17:11 - Nov 7 by onehunglow

Jesus H
Again
Basics
Vigaroux stays on his line for a corner
They have a player unmarked
This is awful
It’s cruel

Matos leaving doesn’t seem so bad a thought now

We’re not smart


ps Brum are shyte , like Pompey
Yard dogs


'Matos leaving doesn’t seem so bad a thought now'

OHL - are you serious ?
0
Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 17:28 - Nov 7 with 0 viewsWhiterockin

Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 17:25 - Nov 7 by johnlangy

'Matos leaving doesn’t seem so bad a thought now'

OHL - are you serious ?


Yes and clueless.
0
Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 17:29 - Nov 7 with 0 viewsTreforys_Jack

Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 17:28 - Nov 7 by Whiterockin

Yes and clueless.


No change there
0
Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 17:30 - Nov 7 with 0 viewswwcigne

It galls me to say it but the Scummers seem to have spirit and a will to win by the cart full, I bet they’re chomping at the bit to play us
Oh for a bit of whatever they’re feeding them

If we keep defending corners and set pieces like we have recently we’ll keep getting beaten
Another long hard season ahead by the looks of it ,with no luck going our way

Matos needs to settle on a 1st eleven when we get everyone back fit and stick to it ,this constant tinkering is blowing any hope of consistency

Over to you,Vitor
3
Login to get fewer ads

Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 17:34 - Nov 7 with 0 viewsonehunglow

Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 17:25 - Nov 7 by johnlangy

'Matos leaving doesn’t seem so bad a thought now'

OHL - are you serious ?


OHL here
Yes
Serious
Let me elaborate before the Crew appear on here , as they do
I like Matos as a bloke but finding his interviews now rather management course speak
I don’t want him
To leave now
Got that?
Good

I am saying a month ago we were terrified of the reported interest in him
Now maybe , we (me) wouldn’t feel as heartbroken

Why? Well I’m
Not keen on selecting teams that do exactly the same mistakes at exactly the same time
That shows we’re not learning

Fact

We deserved something today but lack of basics again cost us

Now , debate it by all means but I’m
Not taking shite from anyone , even from lifelong uber fans

Watching wales rugby doesn’t help
They don’t do basics either


Enjoy the evening

Poll: Christmas. Enjoyable or not

0
Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 17:34 - Nov 7 with 0 viewsswan65split

Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 17:20 - Nov 7 by union_jack

Indeed. But the manner of the defeats suggests we are not good enough to be in the current position and I’m disappointed that we’ve gone this way. Teams outplay, outmuscle and out-think us at the moment and we don’t have an answer.

Add in the stupidity of an individual today which basically scuppered our chances and yes, I’m p1ssed off.


im sitting sat here,,,lol wondering how the heck have we gone from leaders and looking a top side to being a side that cant think and act like a pub side, as someone said look at that last throw in! caused me to throw my curry in the bin .
1
Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 17:35 - Nov 7 with 0 viewsunion_jack

Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 17:25 - Nov 7 by johnlangy

'Matos leaving doesn’t seem so bad a thought now'

OHL - are you serious ?


Like most managers he leaves me scratching my head at times but I have trust in him at the moment and any talk of him leaving bring a good thing is probably just the disappointment of the last 2 games. He's got a lot to do though.

I still think we need to be more on the front foot though. It’s been better at times this season but I’d like to see us getting forward, using overlaps and getting the best out of the pace we’ve now got. At the moment, this team / squad are not Play Off contenders imo.

Are Sperm Whales the reason the sea is so salty?
Poll: Bony - Would You Want Him Back?

1
Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 17:36 - Nov 7 with 0 viewsvetchonian

I will say my piece them switch off for the night as all the doom mongers and critics who never appear when we win are going to be out in force.
Again its all about fime lines.....the penalty is converted we go 1 up and it changes things, Frano's header goes in.
Stamenics sendimg off put us on the back foot.
Despite beimg 1 nil down we battled and for a period in the 2nd half we were the better team despite havimg a player less we battled and got the equaliser.
Yes we once a again gave away a sloppy goal..but the players didnt give up.

So already some are are having a real dig at Matos.....
How many of us in August would have been happy to see us sitting 6th in the table as we do tonight?
The Champuonship is a strange league look at this weekends results showimg anyone can beat anyone and leagie positin doesnt neccessarily guarantee thr highr team will win.

I wonder if we miss Margetson as we are concedimg far more goals from corners .
We beat top of the table Stoke away....and crap Blackburn beating West Ham,Watford holding Boro to a draw.
Still a long way to go........we arent going to win every game and I cant beleive folk are havimg a pop at Matos....they have short memories this time last year we were
sat in 18th place and were short on wins and looking shapeless .

Yes another bad day at the office but one which could have been so easliy different.

Poll: Should Coleman ask Curt for advice/help?

2
Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 17:39 - Nov 7 with 0 viewsonehunglow

Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 17:36 - Nov 7 by vetchonian

I will say my piece them switch off for the night as all the doom mongers and critics who never appear when we win are going to be out in force.
Again its all about fime lines.....the penalty is converted we go 1 up and it changes things, Frano's header goes in.
Stamenics sendimg off put us on the back foot.
Despite beimg 1 nil down we battled and for a period in the 2nd half we were the better team despite havimg a player less we battled and got the equaliser.
Yes we once a again gave away a sloppy goal..but the players didnt give up.

So already some are are having a real dig at Matos.....
How many of us in August would have been happy to see us sitting 6th in the table as we do tonight?
The Champuonship is a strange league look at this weekends results showimg anyone can beat anyone and leagie positin doesnt neccessarily guarantee thr highr team will win.

I wonder if we miss Margetson as we are concedimg far more goals from corners .
We beat top of the table Stoke away....and crap Blackburn beating West Ham,Watford holding Boro to a draw.
Still a long way to go........we arent going to win every game and I cant beleive folk are havimg a pop at Matos....they have short memories this time last year we were
sat in 18th place and were short on wins and looking shapeless .

Yes another bad day at the office but one which could have been so easliy different.


What about the naysayers

Today we saw a replication of the killer Pompey goal
Players should learn
Coaches organise
Why does Vigs stay on his line
He kept us on the game first half but he bakes basic errors
Basics

Poll: Christmas. Enjoyable or not

0
Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 17:40 - Nov 7 with 0 viewsDr_Winston

We need to get back to basics a bit.

Pick our strongest back four whenever possible. That's Tymon, Welsh Lissah and Key. Vipotnik needs to be given a run in the side again as the recent treatment of a proven 20+ goal a season striker has been bizarre.

Pain or damage don't end the world. Or despair, or f*cking beatings. The world ends when you're dead. Until then, you got more punishment in store. Stand it like a man... and give some back.

1
Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 17:43 - Nov 7 with 0 viewsonehunglow

Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 17:35 - Nov 7 by union_jack

Like most managers he leaves me scratching my head at times but I have trust in him at the moment and any talk of him leaving bring a good thing is probably just the disappointment of the last 2 games. He's got a lot to do though.

I still think we need to be more on the front foot though. It’s been better at times this season but I’d like to see us getting forward, using overlaps and getting the best out of the pace we’ve now got. At the moment, this team / squad are not Play Off contenders imo.


My point , again missed is this ;
He started the season well and his stock was raised accordingly
Now , something has gone badly wrong
I juries haven’t helped
Selections seem perverse
We have a.soft underbelly and this is what dog teams like Pompey and Brum smell
We can and should be beating both
It is entirely fair to ask questions

Fin

Poll: Christmas. Enjoyable or not

0
Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 17:45 - Nov 7 with 0 viewsunion_jack

Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 17:36 - Nov 7 by vetchonian

I will say my piece them switch off for the night as all the doom mongers and critics who never appear when we win are going to be out in force.
Again its all about fime lines.....the penalty is converted we go 1 up and it changes things, Frano's header goes in.
Stamenics sendimg off put us on the back foot.
Despite beimg 1 nil down we battled and for a period in the 2nd half we were the better team despite havimg a player less we battled and got the equaliser.
Yes we once a again gave away a sloppy goal..but the players didnt give up.

So already some are are having a real dig at Matos.....
How many of us in August would have been happy to see us sitting 6th in the table as we do tonight?
The Champuonship is a strange league look at this weekends results showimg anyone can beat anyone and leagie positin doesnt neccessarily guarantee thr highr team will win.

I wonder if we miss Margetson as we are concedimg far more goals from corners .
We beat top of the table Stoke away....and crap Blackburn beating West Ham,Watford holding Boro to a draw.
Still a long way to go........we arent going to win every game and I cant beleive folk are havimg a pop at Matos....they have short memories this time last year we were
sat in 18th place and were short on wins and looking shapeless .

Yes another bad day at the office but one which could have been so easliy different.


I don’t think anyone is having a pop at Matos but he shouldn’t be immune to criticism. Nor should the players of course. I don’t think anyone seriously believes he should go.

But, we are faltering and are recently masters of our own downfall. Not taking chances, gifting the opposition and today add a rush to the head by Stamenic.

We’ve got three killers ahead as well and yes, I do include Cardiff in that who clearly know how to score. Will we score more than them is the question.

Are Sperm Whales the reason the sea is so salty?
Poll: Bony - Would You Want Him Back?

0
Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 17:46 - Nov 7 with 0 viewsmax936

Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 17:15 - Nov 7 by union_jack

Just what it says. I’m not a huge Wales fan or of any country really. I like them to win but don’t lose sleep when they lose. That would mean I’d be constantly tired.

I’m feeling a bit like that about the Swans but that may just be knee-jerk reaction to the last two games. Unfortunately, the next three don’t look to be any easier.

And we can’t even have a good laugh at Cardiff which was nailed on at one point😡
[Post edited 7 Nov 17:17]


Go and have a few beers for gawds sake mun.

Its only football.
0
Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 17:48 - Nov 7 with 0 viewsmax936

Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 17:45 - Nov 7 by union_jack

I don’t think anyone is having a pop at Matos but he shouldn’t be immune to criticism. Nor should the players of course. I don’t think anyone seriously believes he should go.

But, we are faltering and are recently masters of our own downfall. Not taking chances, gifting the opposition and today add a rush to the head by Stamenic.

We’ve got three killers ahead as well and yes, I do include Cardiff in that who clearly know how to score. Will we score more than them is the question.


I'll be down Pilot one afternoon next week, if you need cheering up
0
Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 17:51 - Nov 7 with 0 viewsDr_Winston

We're faltering because the fixture list has got harder. Most of our wins when we were top of the table came against teams in and around the relegation zone. We had a kind start which got overlooked a bit.

I do believe that we've got the ability to do better than we have done in recent games, but we really need to work on our consistency. Injuries haven't helped, but they're only part of the story. Certain players are too sure of a place in the team when they're fit and perhaps they shouldn't be, even with the level of tinkering that goes on.

Getting that right is Matos's job, and his ultimate reputation will rest on how well he does it.

Pain or damage don't end the world. Or despair, or f*cking beatings. The world ends when you're dead. Until then, you got more punishment in store. Stand it like a man... and give some back.

1
Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 17:54 - Nov 7 with 0 viewsSgorioFruit

I’m not in the Matos leaving camp.
But what has gone wrong is a manager thinking he will put Idah, Viptonik and Opoku on the bench. Even after a defeat in the last game.

Anymore complete brain farts like that from our manager and then suspicions will deservedly arise.

Lose to Cardiff because he has left his best players on the bench and he’s toast.
[Post edited 7 Nov 17:55]

My methods are not favoured by some but by god i speak the truth. The caller out of bullshit since that letter to Paul Clement made planetswans famous. For a while.
Poll: Cardiff Are Relegated

-1
Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 18:03 - Nov 7 with 0 viewsonehunglow

Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 17:54 - Nov 7 by SgorioFruit

I’m not in the Matos leaving camp.
But what has gone wrong is a manager thinking he will put Idah, Viptonik and Opoku on the bench. Even after a defeat in the last game.

Anymore complete brain farts like that from our manager and then suspicions will deservedly arise.

Lose to Cardiff because he has left his best players on the bench and he’s toast.
[Post edited 7 Nov 17:55]


What camp
Posters should read what it actually in front of them and not assume

Meanwhile …. Basics ? Have a look at our rugby boys, not doing basics

Poll: Christmas. Enjoyable or not

0
Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 18:03 - Nov 7 with 0 viewsunion_jack

Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 17:48 - Nov 7 by max936

I'll be down Pilot one afternoon next week, if you need cheering up


Let me know and if I can, I will. 👍

Are Sperm Whales the reason the sea is so salty?
Poll: Bony - Would You Want Him Back?

0
Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 18:05 - Nov 7 with 0 viewsunion_jack

Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 17:54 - Nov 7 by SgorioFruit

I’m not in the Matos leaving camp.
But what has gone wrong is a manager thinking he will put Idah, Viptonik and Opoku on the bench. Even after a defeat in the last game.

Anymore complete brain farts like that from our manager and then suspicions will deservedly arise.

Lose to Cardiff because he has left his best players on the bench and he’s toast.
[Post edited 7 Nov 17:55]


Idah and Vipotnik made way for Stewart, a fair decision in my book.

Are Sperm Whales the reason the sea is so salty?
Poll: Bony - Would You Want Him Back?

0
Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 18:05 - Nov 7 with 0 viewsSgorioFruit

Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 18:03 - Nov 7 by onehunglow

What camp
Posters should read what it actually in front of them and not assume

Meanwhile …. Basics ? Have a look at our rugby boys, not doing basics


Basics is leaving Vipotnik, Idah and Opoku on the bench.

There is your Matos leaving camp

My methods are not favoured by some but by god i speak the truth. The caller out of bullshit since that letter to Paul Clement made planetswans famous. For a while.
Poll: Cardiff Are Relegated

0
Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 18:05 - Nov 7 with 0 viewsKeithHaynes


Blues 2 Swans 1 : Nearly men again but an encouraging performance against the odds 7th Nov 2026 17:52
You just knew that when Marko Stamenić was sent off for a clumsy challenge on BAFTA award-winning Ethan Laird, today was going to become even harder than it already was. Despite that, the Swans could have been a few goals up before the incident. The bad luck, frustration and overall despondency may well have returned, but that was only part of the story. 1


A great believer in taking anything you like to wherever you want to.
Blog: Would you like to appear here as a Welsh football writer?

1
About Us Contact Us Terms & Conditions Privacy Cookies Online Safety Advertising
© FansNetwork 2026