| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread 23:18 - Nov 3 with 26450 views | ModeratorC | Swansea City: Lawrence Vigouroux; Filip Lissah, Ben Cabango (captain), Jenson Seelt, Josh Tymon; Jay Fulton, Marko Stamenic, Goncalo Franco; Moussa Yeo, Jisung Eom, Ross Stewart. Substitutes: Andy Fisher, Josh Key, Melker Widell, Elijah Just, Zan Vipotnik, Tom Iorpenda, Joseph Opoku, Adam Idah, Carter Heywood Blues 2 Swans 1 : Nearly men again but an encouraging performance against the odds 7th Nov 2026 17:52You just knew that when Marko Stamenić was sent off for a clumsy challenge on BAFTA award-winning Ethan Laird, today was going to become even harder than it already was. Despite that, the Swans could have been a few goals up before the incident. The bad luck, frustration and overall despondency may well have returned, but that was only part of the story. 1
This post has been edited by an administrator |  | | |  |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 19:57 - Nov 9 with 0 views | KeithHaynes |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 19:42 - Nov 9 by JJBomber | Can we appeal the red card? |
Yes certainly. |  |
|  |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 20:00 - Nov 9 with 0 views | KeithHaynes |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 14:01 - Nov 9 by pencoedjack | I'm pretty sure no other club will pay Fisher the wages he's on here so he will just see out his contract. Another Russy masterclass. |
I find it extremely strange that the club couldn’t find another far more experienced and better keeper as back up when Fishers contract ran out. |  |
|  |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 20:03 - Nov 9 with 0 views | Whiterockin |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 19:42 - Nov 9 by JJBomber | Can we appeal the red card? |
We have until 1pm on Wednesday. |  | |  |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 21:40 - Nov 9 with 0 views | union_jack |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 20:03 - Nov 9 by Whiterockin | We have until 1pm on Wednesday. |
The question is will we? It’s a fact that Stamenic got the ball. It’s also a fact he didn’t touch Laird to the extent he made out. However, his two feet left the ground and he went in in what will be deemed as ‘not in control’. It’s nothing to do with contact. It’s nothing to do with intent. But he wasn’t in control is what they will say. The club will know this and I doubt they’ll appeal in case it’s classed as frivolous (if that risk still exists?). We may not like it but those are the facts. It was a stupid thing to do. |  |
|  |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 21:42 - Nov 9 with 0 views | KeithHaynes |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 21:40 - Nov 9 by union_jack | The question is will we? It’s a fact that Stamenic got the ball. It’s also a fact he didn’t touch Laird to the extent he made out. However, his two feet left the ground and he went in in what will be deemed as ‘not in control’. It’s nothing to do with contact. It’s nothing to do with intent. But he wasn’t in control is what they will say. The club will know this and I doubt they’ll appeal in case it’s classed as frivolous (if that risk still exists?). We may not like it but those are the facts. It was a stupid thing to do. |
The slow motion reel shows that both feet didn’t leave the ground. |  |
|  |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 21:44 - Nov 9 with 0 views | union_jack |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 21:42 - Nov 9 by KeithHaynes | The slow motion reel shows that both feet didn’t leave the ground. |
I’ll look at it again but when I saw it it looked as if they did. Not when contact with the ball was made admittedly but just before. |  |
|  |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 21:48 - Nov 9 with 0 views | Whiterockin | It will come down to if we appeal or not. Appeal and we think Stamenic was harshly treated, don't and its because we don't think there is a good chance if winning. |  | |  |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 21:51 - Nov 9 with 0 views | KeithHaynes |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 21:44 - Nov 9 by union_jack | I’ll look at it again but when I saw it it looked as if they did. Not when contact with the ball was made admittedly but just before. |
Right leg never keft the ground once - it’s on the previous page. |  |
|  | Login to get fewer ads
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 21:52 - Nov 9 with 0 views | Fireboy2 |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 21:51 - Nov 9 by KeithHaynes | Right leg never keft the ground once - it’s on the previous page. |
Its an effing disgrace keef 😤 |  | |  |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 21:55 - Nov 9 with 0 views | union_jack |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 21:51 - Nov 9 by KeithHaynes | Right leg never keft the ground once - it’s on the previous page. |
Yes I’ve seen it but it’s not that clear. But it won’t matter because they’ll apply the excessive force rule. Rightly or wrongly you just can’t do that these days. Back in the 80s it would be tackle of the month. I give you Tommy Smith. I think VAR would have supported the on field decision. The question I’d like answered is would it have been given if the on field decision was a yellow? |  |
|  |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 22:05 - Nov 9 with 0 views | KeithHaynes |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 21:55 - Nov 9 by union_jack | Yes I’ve seen it but it’s not that clear. But it won’t matter because they’ll apply the excessive force rule. Rightly or wrongly you just can’t do that these days. Back in the 80s it would be tackle of the month. I give you Tommy Smith. I think VAR would have supported the on field decision. The question I’d like answered is would it have been given if the on field decision was a yellow? |
I didn’t see excessive force, that’s the judgement. Was it or not. |  |
|  |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 22:21 - Nov 9 with 0 views | union_jack |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 22:05 - Nov 9 by KeithHaynes | I didn’t see excessive force, that’s the judgement. Was it or not. |
In today’s game I’d have to say yes. |  |
|  |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 23:00 - Nov 9 with 0 views | onehunglow |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 20:00 - Nov 9 by KeithHaynes | I find it extremely strange that the club couldn’t find another far more experienced and better keeper as back up when Fishers contract ran out. |
Fisher should have been replaced less than 12 months into his initial contract To have been given extension is not only madness but lazy There is better around in lower leagues We should not even be mentioning him at all Vig needs a kick up the arse and all we have is Fisher as a back up, who is equally effete at crosses but without shot saving ability Vig has We’re not really that well run IMO as we have made dumb decision for over ten years and learned nothing |  |
|  |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 06:40 - Nov 10 with 0 views | jack247 |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 23:00 - Nov 9 by onehunglow | Fisher should have been replaced less than 12 months into his initial contract To have been given extension is not only madness but lazy There is better around in lower leagues We should not even be mentioning him at all Vig needs a kick up the arse and all we have is Fisher as a back up, who is equally effete at crosses but without shot saving ability Vig has We’re not really that well run IMO as we have made dumb decision for over ten years and learned nothing |
‘We should not even be mentioning him at all’ You’re the only person who ever brings him up |  | |  |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 06:55 - Nov 10 with 0 views | ncswan |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 22:05 - Nov 9 by KeithHaynes | I didn’t see excessive force, that’s the judgement. Was it or not. |
I've run the replay a dozen times and don't see it as a red. Stamenic goes through with his tackle dragging his left foot on the ground, gets to the ball first, and Laird makes a meal of it. Even when I saw it live on TV, I didn't think Stamenic clipped Laird. If the ref had the angle that the slo-mo video shows (from the other side of the tackle), he would have yelled "play on", imo. Lots of Brum players influencing the ref after the play. Appeal warranted, imo. |  | |  |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 07:30 - Nov 10 with 0 views | sons_of_omri |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 19:52 - Nov 9 by Fireboy2 | Should do on that evidence, absolutely shocking by laird and his team mates. |
I suppose that’s how under the cosh we had them that they had to resort to gamesmanship to win. Because they didn’t look anywhere good enough to beat us prior to that. I say appeal having watched that back again. |  | |  |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 11:35 - Nov 10 with 0 views | RichardO | Given the previous soft penalty decision I wasn't surprised that the red card was given, the tackle didn't go through the player it came side on but stretching a bit and needed timing right, if it was out on the wing it would have been seen as a good defensive tackle, I wouldn't watch the game again a bit disappointed that after working so hard to get back in the game, we buckled under the pressure or more to the point didn't defend properly. Often pressure we have created on ourselves by being a bit uncontrolled or loose on the ball in areas of the pitch or not looking to get the ball down when we could, you could cite safety first but for me we became ragged . We have now seen three games in which we have been in the game and not able to turn things around like we did against Lincoln. Start with the West Ham game we got caught over playing instead of keeping things tight and simple. Goal conceded and yes we had chances that could have got us back in the game but so did West Ham. Portsmouth game from what little I saw only the second half, we again were in the game even getting back level but did by pressing for a second leave ourselves open to breakaways and corners. Fast forward to the Birmingham game we could have scored early after about ten minutes of pressure from Birmingham but weathered their storm and with the penalty and the other chance in which we could have been ahead, sending off changes things but we got back level and should have been happy with that instead we conceded the corner. For Me it was back to panic defending again too many players going for the same ball getting in each others way and losing our defensive shape to counter any loose balls but to be fair the cross in was a wicked one so much so their centre forward was the one who cleared the ball on the line instead of being able to put I ìthe back of the net. In the fourth game lost one against QPR game we push on and left gaps again we conceded as we tried to pressed, again we could have scored but again left ourselves open to conceded in open play and just compounded it in the panic that ensued. Three games that we could of got points and a fourth that was thrown away very early on. Matos really need to learn from them as do the players, it often felt similar to previous seasons players in crowded areas going for the same ball, we have seen it with Cabango with Darling and Burgess. A lack of leaving players do their job if you don't get that crowding in the six yard box does that give Vigouroux more room to make that area his own? Just hope that panic doesn't become the norm as it did with Cabango and Burgess. [Post edited 10 Nov 13:17]
|  | |  |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 12:08 - Nov 10 with 0 views | onehunglow |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 06:40 - Nov 10 by jack247 | ‘We should not even be mentioning him at all’ You’re the only person who ever brings him up |
Not quite true but we’re talking goalkeepers and their respective abilities Vig is terrible with crosses Ideally he could be rested to work on his game That would mean replacing him That means Fisher That’s why I mentioned Keep the personal snidely shite off this site Don’t perpetuate the hatred of others Thanks |  |
|  |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 12:19 - Nov 10 with 0 views | KeithHaynes |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 12:08 - Nov 10 by onehunglow | Not quite true but we’re talking goalkeepers and their respective abilities Vig is terrible with crosses Ideally he could be rested to work on his game That would mean replacing him That means Fisher That’s why I mentioned Keep the personal snidely shite off this site Don’t perpetuate the hatred of others Thanks |
I’m unsure if he’s terrible. One of the best keepers in the Championship. He takes crosses capably. Yes he was beaten on Saturday, and has on one occasion this season that i can recall. Are you really suggesting Fisher replaces him. Genuinely ?
This post has been edited by an administrator |  |
|  |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 12:38 - Nov 10 with 0 views | jack247 |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 12:08 - Nov 10 by onehunglow | Not quite true but we’re talking goalkeepers and their respective abilities Vig is terrible with crosses Ideally he could be rested to work on his game That would mean replacing him That means Fisher That’s why I mentioned Keep the personal snidely shite off this site Don’t perpetuate the hatred of others Thanks |
No, it is true. Nobody else mentions him, he’s a reserve keeper who doesn’t play. Don’t take it personally, if you stop mentioning him, I doubt anyone else will pick up the batton. He’s not there to provide competition for Vigaroux, he’s there for emergencies. If he was a similar level, he’d be first choice somewhere else. We would be mental to rest Vigaroux. |  | |  |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 12:44 - Nov 10 with 0 views | streetlyjack |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 11:35 - Nov 10 by RichardO | Given the previous soft penalty decision I wasn't surprised that the red card was given, the tackle didn't go through the player it came side on but stretching a bit and needed timing right, if it was out on the wing it would have been seen as a good defensive tackle, I wouldn't watch the game again a bit disappointed that after working so hard to get back in the game, we buckled under the pressure or more to the point didn't defend properly. Often pressure we have created on ourselves by being a bit uncontrolled or loose on the ball in areas of the pitch or not looking to get the ball down when we could, you could cite safety first but for me we became ragged . We have now seen three games in which we have been in the game and not able to turn things around like we did against Lincoln. Start with the West Ham game we got caught over playing instead of keeping things tight and simple. Goal conceded and yes we had chances that could have got us back in the game but so did West Ham. Portsmouth game from what little I saw only the second half, we again were in the game even getting back level but did by pressing for a second leave ourselves open to breakaways and corners. Fast forward to the Birmingham game we could have scored early after about ten minutes of pressure from Birmingham but weathered their storm and with the penalty and the other chance in which we could have been ahead, sending off changes things but we got back level and should have been happy with that instead we conceded the corner. For Me it was back to panic defending again too many players going for the same ball getting in each others way and losing our defensive shape to counter any loose balls but to be fair the cross in was a wicked one so much so their centre forward was the one who cleared the ball on the line instead of being able to put I ìthe back of the net. In the fourth game lost one against QPR game we push on and left gaps again we conceded as we tried to pressed, again we could have scored but again left ourselves open to conceded in open play and just compounded it in the panic that ensued. Three games that we could of got points and a fourth that was thrown away very early on. Matos really need to learn from them as do the players, it often felt similar to previous seasons players in crowded areas going for the same ball, we have seen it with Cabango with Darling and Burgess. A lack of leaving players do their job if you don't get that crowding in the six yard box does that give Vigouroux more room to make that area his own? Just hope that panic doesn't become the norm as it did with Cabango and Burgess. [Post edited 10 Nov 13:17]
|
I honestly think that the panic and chaos we see from defending corners or balls into the box is purely down to our defence not trusting Vig in those situations hence every man and his dog going for the same ball. I would like to assume defending set plays is practiced quite a lot in training with everyone having a specific role to play in these situations, on the other hand if we are zonal defending which it looked like we were on Saturday then we dont have the keeper or defence equipped for this style of defending. |  |
|  |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 13:30 - Nov 10 with 0 views | onehunglow |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 12:19 - Nov 10 by KeithHaynes | I’m unsure if he’s terrible. One of the best keepers in the Championship. He takes crosses capably. Yes he was beaten on Saturday, and has on one occasion this season that i can recall. Are you really suggesting Fisher replaces him. Genuinely ?
This post has been edited by an administrator |
He is not rxcellent at crosses He does not command his box He is one of the best keepers notwithstanding that as his shot stopping is outstanding And No Not suggesting for a moment he is replaced because that would see Fisher between the sticks My opinion |  |
|  |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 13:42 - Nov 10 with 0 views | RichardO |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 12:44 - Nov 10 by streetlyjack | I honestly think that the panic and chaos we see from defending corners or balls into the box is purely down to our defence not trusting Vig in those situations hence every man and his dog going for the same ball. I would like to assume defending set plays is practiced quite a lot in training with everyone having a specific role to play in these situations, on the other hand if we are zonal defending which it looked like we were on Saturday then we dont have the keeper or defence equipped for this style of defending. |
We saw Potter's Swansea concede so many late goals to lose points in by playing Zonal marking, add into the we have had Martyn Margetson who thinking seems to be the goal keeper stays on the line. In all fairness to Vigouroux he has seemingly come for more ball against Birmingham he missed it given the quality of the corner but we have been undone by teams having players in close attendance on the edge of the box for those messy clearances we have been done twice in the last two games. You have to consider that before this bad run of games we had done well at our defensive set pieces. Could that panic be more down to a lack of communication and understanding by the players involved. Needing or having to chop and change the team due to injuries has not helped. Three games we could or should have got more from, 3 points off the top time for the players to take responsibly for their action on the pitch to control games and keep us a constant threat while making sure our rearguard is in place. Can we compare this season to previous managers displays leaking goals, for the most part no, never as badly as William's and Martin. Time for the players to focus on all elements of the game, still think we have a lot of inexperienced players in the team and losing players like Eustaquio, Eom, Welsh, Key and Ronald has not helped, Matos team has had a rough time but really think if the team gets their heads straight there is a lot in this season we are capable of fighting for. [Post edited 10 Nov 14:08]
|  | |  |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 13:57 - Nov 10 with 0 views | RichardO |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 13:30 - Nov 10 by onehunglow | He is not rxcellent at crosses He does not command his box He is one of the best keepers notwithstanding that as his shot stopping is outstanding And No Not suggesting for a moment he is replaced because that would see Fisher between the sticks My opinion |
The last two games the crosses by the opposition were put in dangerous areas of the box, against Portsmouth we managed to get a head on a near post delivery which was nowhere near Vigouroux and the Birmingham goal was one that was an excellent delivery, did he miss it badly maybe but the attacker had also got in front of the ball and could only head it out, the problem in both games both teams had players on the edge of the box unmarked, no Vigouroux fault, if we are marking zonal then who was marking those zones if you are marking man for man where are the markers. These days the chaos of corners has been an area to exploit, do think a settle team helps in defense but do think it is up to both the players to communicate as to who is doing what are corners I do think panic to get results has effected our focus during the last number of games which needs to be reapplied. As for attacking set pieces there doesn't seem to be a lot of movement to get across defenders in the box before and during the deliveries into the box. |  | |  |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 15:42 - Nov 10 with 0 views | onehunglow |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 13:57 - Nov 10 by RichardO | The last two games the crosses by the opposition were put in dangerous areas of the box, against Portsmouth we managed to get a head on a near post delivery which was nowhere near Vigouroux and the Birmingham goal was one that was an excellent delivery, did he miss it badly maybe but the attacker had also got in front of the ball and could only head it out, the problem in both games both teams had players on the edge of the box unmarked, no Vigouroux fault, if we are marking zonal then who was marking those zones if you are marking man for man where are the markers. These days the chaos of corners has been an area to exploit, do think a settle team helps in defense but do think it is up to both the players to communicate as to who is doing what are corners I do think panic to get results has effected our focus during the last number of games which needs to be reapplied. As for attacking set pieces there doesn't seem to be a lot of movement to get across defenders in the box before and during the deliveries into the box. |
Yes but Goalkeepers should command That means they tell defenders sheet to be They are vocal Best I’ve seen was Peter Schmeichel as obnoxious an opponent as was possible and a glorious bully who took command |  |
|  |
| |