| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread 23:18 - Nov 3 with 26451 views | ModeratorC | Swansea City: Lawrence Vigouroux; Filip Lissah, Ben Cabango (captain), Jenson Seelt, Josh Tymon; Jay Fulton, Marko Stamenic, Goncalo Franco; Moussa Yeo, Jisung Eom, Ross Stewart. Substitutes: Andy Fisher, Josh Key, Melker Widell, Elijah Just, Zan Vipotnik, Tom Iorpenda, Joseph Opoku, Adam Idah, Carter Heywood Blues 2 Swans 1 : Nearly men again but an encouraging performance against the odds 7th Nov 2026 17:52You just knew that when Marko Stamenić was sent off for a clumsy challenge on BAFTA award-winning Ethan Laird, today was going to become even harder than it already was. Despite that, the Swans could have been a few goals up before the incident. The bad luck, frustration and overall despondency may well have returned, but that was only part of the story. 1
This post has been edited by an administrator |  | | |  |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 20:07 - Nov 8 with 0 views | onehunglow |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 19:26 - Nov 8 by jewsonjack | The OTT reaction from the Birmingham players influenced the ref. Soccer Saturday's take on it was a yellow card, including Mike Dean who felt the Birmingham players put undue pressure on the ref. The CBS pundits on the stream I had also felt it was the wrong decision, and that included dyed in the wool blue Troy Deeney. The challenge unfortunately gave the ref a decision to make, but I'm not sure Stamenic deserves all the criticism and abuse he has had. |
However , the reason we should feel raw is that we had more than compensated for the red card We dug in and showed real spirit BUT Again , gave away an unnecessary corner from which an unmarked player strokes the ball home Absolutely gutting We keep doing this We should avoid if at all possible giving away corners so bad are we sending them With Vigaroux stood on his line , he has no chance with snapshots from six yards out |  |
|  |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 22:31 - Nov 8 with 0 views | RevEliJenkins |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 20:07 - Nov 8 by onehunglow | However , the reason we should feel raw is that we had more than compensated for the red card We dug in and showed real spirit BUT Again , gave away an unnecessary corner from which an unmarked player strokes the ball home Absolutely gutting We keep doing this We should avoid if at all possible giving away corners so bad are we sending them With Vigaroux stood on his line , he has no chance with snapshots from six yards out |
I think your post helps me to clarify where my head is... IMO we definitely had plenty of luck in our early games, defensively, which gave the illusion of solidity and drove us to the top of the league. But we are still not street wise enough; just like recent seasons, we are susceptible to conceding soft goals (especially towards the end of each half), and we seem find a way to minimise our points when decisions go against us. But we do battle, even when making poor decisions with the ball. And Vigs is a great stopper, but doesn't command his 6 yard box in the air. That's why we've got him, and he's not playing Barca. Having said that, I'd haven take this start to the season, all day long, if given the option in Aug. |  | |  |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 23:04 - Nov 8 with 0 views | onehunglow |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 22:31 - Nov 8 by RevEliJenkins | I think your post helps me to clarify where my head is... IMO we definitely had plenty of luck in our early games, defensively, which gave the illusion of solidity and drove us to the top of the league. But we are still not street wise enough; just like recent seasons, we are susceptible to conceding soft goals (especially towards the end of each half), and we seem find a way to minimise our points when decisions go against us. But we do battle, even when making poor decisions with the ball. And Vigs is a great stopper, but doesn't command his 6 yard box in the air. That's why we've got him, and he's not playing Barca. Having said that, I'd haven take this start to the season, all day long, if given the option in Aug. |
Let us pray Lord , look after Snr Matos and guide him Look after our players as they are having the crap kicked out of them and make the opponent feel the wrath of the Almighty May God Almighty cut them down and boil their heads in their own urine May the Lord look after our boys as we face the unwashed ,uneducated Capital cocks and their very very close valley warrior fans as they seek to wave their genitalia Amen |  |
|  |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 00:04 - Nov 9 with 0 views | Fireboy2 | I missed yesterday's game as I was on a good mates retirement do, so I havent posted but i got regular updates from the eldest, who was there. Imo after his view and several others I know who went we played very well before and after the stamenic dismissal, probably deserved the draw after a plucky 74+ minutes. Its gone, we should take from the game that we were the best team until the sending off and dug in after. What i am 100% sure of as night follows day, the usual suspect is racking up his post count after another defeat, yet he was were nowhere to be seen after the blackburn game, isnt that strange 🤔 But I suspect his count will still tick over as its another international break, im quite lucky though as I will be away as usual watching us so I wont be reading any of it. |  | |  |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 00:14 - Nov 9 with 0 views | JJBomber |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 00:04 - Nov 9 by Fireboy2 | I missed yesterday's game as I was on a good mates retirement do, so I havent posted but i got regular updates from the eldest, who was there. Imo after his view and several others I know who went we played very well before and after the stamenic dismissal, probably deserved the draw after a plucky 74+ minutes. Its gone, we should take from the game that we were the best team until the sending off and dug in after. What i am 100% sure of as night follows day, the usual suspect is racking up his post count after another defeat, yet he was were nowhere to be seen after the blackburn game, isnt that strange 🤔 But I suspect his count will still tick over as its another international break, im quite lucky though as I will be away as usual watching us so I wont be reading any of it. |
Nowhere to be seen??? He's living in your head, rent free! |  | |  |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 09:27 - Nov 9 with 0 views | Fireboy2 |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 00:14 - Nov 9 by JJBomber | Nowhere to be seen??? He's living in your head, rent free! |
Yeah, corse he is 🤣 |  | |  |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 09:38 - Nov 9 with 0 views | onehunglow |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 00:14 - Nov 9 by JJBomber | Nowhere to be seen??? He's living in your head, rent free! |
Who? This Bluddy ignore button Thread is about last game not individual posters That said, anyone wanting to vent spleen , join me on rugby forum on BBC Not as OHL however but also BG remains the same Meanwhile back on topic , unnecessary red card, fought back , screwed up Again Meanwhile the sun rises again and we have a new day Fookn live it, because one day it will be your last Amor Fati |  |
|  |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 10:20 - Nov 9 with 0 views | KeithHaynes | |  |
|  | Login to get fewer ads
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 10:28 - Nov 9 with 0 views | streetlyjack | Dissapointed to lose another gme we should have got something out of but thats gone now so lets hope players can recover and be up for two important games vs WBA and Cardiff. The coaches really need to get a grip on defending set plays over the international break as other teams are actively targetting and profiting from our weakness here, a good ball into our box and we are simply stuffed - this has to be addressed as it cannot continue. Pompey - We had 3 marking the front post with 5 Swans players going to attack the near post vs 2 Pompey players, the guy that scored was never marked by anyone as we seemed to mark space rather than players. A great corner by Bham to the far post and we left Widell on his own whist Seelt and Cabango were in no man's land (no point counting Vig as a defender in this type of situation as it's a lost cause). Old school is the best school IMO when you have a keeper who has little presence in his 6 yard box...cover your posts and match up on marking the appropriate sized player rather than this zone marking rubbish we see nowadays which does not suit us at all. I do like the fighting spirit within this squad, if we could just add better game management to our game then we should finish top 8 as minimum. Our deficiencies I am certain can be improved through better coaching, leadership on the pitch and more focus during critical periods of the game. |  |
|  |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 11:26 - Nov 9 with 0 views | wwcigne |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 10:28 - Nov 9 by streetlyjack | Dissapointed to lose another gme we should have got something out of but thats gone now so lets hope players can recover and be up for two important games vs WBA and Cardiff. The coaches really need to get a grip on defending set plays over the international break as other teams are actively targetting and profiting from our weakness here, a good ball into our box and we are simply stuffed - this has to be addressed as it cannot continue. Pompey - We had 3 marking the front post with 5 Swans players going to attack the near post vs 2 Pompey players, the guy that scored was never marked by anyone as we seemed to mark space rather than players. A great corner by Bham to the far post and we left Widell on his own whist Seelt and Cabango were in no man's land (no point counting Vig as a defender in this type of situation as it's a lost cause). Old school is the best school IMO when you have a keeper who has little presence in his 6 yard box...cover your posts and match up on marking the appropriate sized player rather than this zone marking rubbish we see nowadays which does not suit us at all. I do like the fighting spirit within this squad, if we could just add better game management to our game then we should finish top 8 as minimum. Our deficiencies I am certain can be improved through better coaching, leadership on the pitch and more focus during critical periods of the game. |
We definitely need a specialist set piece coach, specifically for defending but attacking set pieces also We concede far too many ,and don’t score enough from set pieces I’ve said many times times that Vigaroux is a great reaction saver and shot stopper but doesn’t command his goal area at all, he has a real reluctance to come off his line, almost like he’s glued to it when the opposition has the ball. he’s a big lad but only seems to take high balls if he’s unchallenged ,it’s as if he’s afraid of contact and taking a knock which is a big reason opposing teams win so many balls and get so many chances when high balls are played into our box Something has to change |  | |  |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 11:29 - Nov 9 with 0 views | onehunglow |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 10:28 - Nov 9 by streetlyjack | Dissapointed to lose another gme we should have got something out of but thats gone now so lets hope players can recover and be up for two important games vs WBA and Cardiff. The coaches really need to get a grip on defending set plays over the international break as other teams are actively targetting and profiting from our weakness here, a good ball into our box and we are simply stuffed - this has to be addressed as it cannot continue. Pompey - We had 3 marking the front post with 5 Swans players going to attack the near post vs 2 Pompey players, the guy that scored was never marked by anyone as we seemed to mark space rather than players. A great corner by Bham to the far post and we left Widell on his own whist Seelt and Cabango were in no man's land (no point counting Vig as a defender in this type of situation as it's a lost cause). Old school is the best school IMO when you have a keeper who has little presence in his 6 yard box...cover your posts and match up on marking the appropriate sized player rather than this zone marking rubbish we see nowadays which does not suit us at all. I do like the fighting spirit within this squad, if we could just add better game management to our game then we should finish top 8 as minimum. Our deficiencies I am certain can be improved through better coaching, leadership on the pitch and more focus during critical periods of the game. |
It’s why Vitor puzzles me We are do close to being a force but utterly inept defnfobgbisvkollongbourvhood work Basics Keepers catch the ball Full backs take a post , maybe even stop the cross on the first place Basics Again |  |
|  |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 13:41 - Nov 9 with 0 views | JJBomber |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 11:26 - Nov 9 by wwcigne | We definitely need a specialist set piece coach, specifically for defending but attacking set pieces also We concede far too many ,and don’t score enough from set pieces I’ve said many times times that Vigaroux is a great reaction saver and shot stopper but doesn’t command his goal area at all, he has a real reluctance to come off his line, almost like he’s glued to it when the opposition has the ball. he’s a big lad but only seems to take high balls if he’s unchallenged ,it’s as if he’s afraid of contact and taking a knock which is a big reason opposing teams win so many balls and get so many chances when high balls are played into our box Something has to change |
I've been saying it as well. Best shot stopper in the league but more afraid of crosses than Dracula. He seems to be 6'5'' when stopping shots, but 5'6'' at handling crosses. The second goal at B'ham just sums up his defensive shortcomings. If he could command the box, he'd be in the Premier League, so we have to accept his faults. It's still very frustrating when we do see it, week after week! Free headers in the 6 yard box are a given for any opponent. |  | |  |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 13:51 - Nov 9 with 0 views | onehunglow |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 13:41 - Nov 9 by JJBomber | I've been saying it as well. Best shot stopper in the league but more afraid of crosses than Dracula. He seems to be 6'5'' when stopping shots, but 5'6'' at handling crosses. The second goal at B'ham just sums up his defensive shortcomings. If he could command the box, he'd be in the Premier League, so we have to accept his faults. It's still very frustrating when we do see it, week after week! Free headers in the 6 yard box are a given for any opponent. |
And it’s not naysaying or doom mongering or negative It’s fact It’s why we get upset It’s why we should do better Vigs brilliant shot saver but terrible commander of his box And same with the alternative Fisher , who should have been replaced Three years ago Poor strategic decisions have meant we’ve been unable to get back to Prem league Now, we lack belief as a fan base and spend more time bit hobg with fellow fans than trash like Cardiff city No happy clapping We need to front up and puff our chests out and not feel cowed by the likes of West Ham and Portsmouth ffs |  |
|  |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 14:01 - Nov 9 with 0 views | pencoedjack |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 13:51 - Nov 9 by onehunglow | And it’s not naysaying or doom mongering or negative It’s fact It’s why we get upset It’s why we should do better Vigs brilliant shot saver but terrible commander of his box And same with the alternative Fisher , who should have been replaced Three years ago Poor strategic decisions have meant we’ve been unable to get back to Prem league Now, we lack belief as a fan base and spend more time bit hobg with fellow fans than trash like Cardiff city No happy clapping We need to front up and puff our chests out and not feel cowed by the likes of West Ham and Portsmouth ffs |
I'm pretty sure no other club will pay Fisher the wages he's on here so he will just see out his contract. Another Russy masterclass. |  | |  |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 14:11 - Nov 9 with 0 views | jack247 |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 14:01 - Nov 9 by pencoedjack | I'm pretty sure no other club will pay Fisher the wages he's on here so he will just see out his contract. Another Russy masterclass. |
He signed an extension six months or so ago |  | |  |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 14:18 - Nov 9 with 0 views | Whiterockin |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 14:11 - Nov 9 by jack247 | He signed an extension six months or so ago |
Yes 2 year extension until June 28, I'm not sure if there is an option after that. |  | |  |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 15:07 - Nov 9 with 0 views | union_jack |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 14:18 - Nov 9 by Whiterockin | Yes 2 year extension until June 28, I'm not sure if there is an option after that. |
I’ve said before on this matter that under Russy I would have been a better keeper. But the games he’s played more recently given his lack of game time I think he’s done very well. Not many games to go on admittedly but from the few he’s played… |  |
|  |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 15:14 - Nov 9 with 0 views | jack247 |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 15:07 - Nov 9 by union_jack | I’ve said before on this matter that under Russy I would have been a better keeper. But the games he’s played more recently given his lack of game time I think he’s done very well. Not many games to go on admittedly but from the few he’s played… |
As a backup keeper, he’s probably among the best in the Championship. |  | |  |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 15:17 - Nov 9 with 0 views | vetchonian |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 13:41 - Nov 9 by JJBomber | I've been saying it as well. Best shot stopper in the league but more afraid of crosses than Dracula. He seems to be 6'5'' when stopping shots, but 5'6'' at handling crosses. The second goal at B'ham just sums up his defensive shortcomings. If he could command the box, he'd be in the Premier League, so we have to accept his faults. It's still very frustrating when we do see it, week after week! Free headers in the 6 yard box are a given for any opponent. |
I have said it several times we are missing Margetson |  |
|  |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 16:05 - Nov 9 with 0 views | pencoedjack |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 14:18 - Nov 9 by Whiterockin | Yes 2 year extension until June 28, I'm not sure if there is an option after that. |
Seriously Like to think that's on much lower wages. |  | |  |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 16:16 - Nov 9 with 0 views | Whiterockin |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 16:05 - Nov 9 by pencoedjack | Seriously Like to think that's on much lower wages. |
I heard £6.5k instead of £10k. |  | |  |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 16:59 - Nov 9 with 0 views | jack_lord |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 10:20 - Nov 9 by KeithHaynes | |
from that angle it looks like Laird is more studs up than Stam and Stam certainly doesn't appear to be two feet off the ground out of control. However ref out of sight and the theatrical lie that answers to the name Ethan and you put yourself at the red card party |  |
|  |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 19:01 - Nov 9 with 0 views | sons_of_omri |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 10:20 - Nov 9 by KeithHaynes | |
Laird is a cheating crunt. No contact made!!!! Clutched his thigh initially! |  | |  |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 19:42 - Nov 9 with 0 views | JJBomber |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 10:20 - Nov 9 by KeithHaynes | |
Can we appeal the red card? |  | |  |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 19:52 - Nov 9 with 0 views | Fireboy2 |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 19:42 - Nov 9 by JJBomber | Can we appeal the red card? |
Should do on that evidence, absolutely shocking by laird and his team mates. |  | |  |
| |