| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread 23:18 - Nov 3 with 26448 views | ModeratorC | Swansea City: Lawrence Vigouroux; Filip Lissah, Ben Cabango (captain), Jenson Seelt, Josh Tymon; Jay Fulton, Marko Stamenic, Goncalo Franco; Moussa Yeo, Jisung Eom, Ross Stewart. Substitutes: Andy Fisher, Josh Key, Melker Widell, Elijah Just, Zan Vipotnik, Tom Iorpenda, Joseph Opoku, Adam Idah, Carter Heywood Blues 2 Swans 1 : Nearly men again but an encouraging performance against the odds 7th Nov 2026 17:52You just knew that when Marko Stamenić was sent off for a clumsy challenge on BAFTA award-winning Ethan Laird, today was going to become even harder than it already was. Despite that, the Swans could have been a few goals up before the incident. The bad luck, frustration and overall despondency may well have returned, but that was only part of the story. 1
This post has been edited by an administrator |  | | |  |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 22:25 - Nov 7 with 0 views | union_jack |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 22:12 - Nov 7 by johnlangy | I believe we would have beaten them if Marco hadn't been sent off. In the circumstances (64 mins with ten men) I thought they were very good. And that against the most in form team in the league (I believe). |
We’ll never know John but we were looking better than the previous game for sure. Whether we would have had the required luck, something that is deserting us presently I don’t know. |  |
|  |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 22:30 - Nov 7 with 0 views | JJBomber |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 22:08 - Nov 7 by Whiterockin | If anyone was offered 6th place abd 3 points off the top going into the November International break I would have bitten their arm off. Yes we could have got a couple of better results but we have also got some excellent ones. |
If we'd been offered 3 points above West ham after 15 games, we'd have bitten their hands off. Top team in Wales by 8 points? More hands bitten off. That's with 8 away games and 7 at home. Start of the season we were optimistic for top 8 and the play-offs. That hasn't changed. Yes, it's frustrating because we could be so much higher. We are still looking for a signature win, but at the moment, we are on target. |  | |  |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 23:06 - Nov 7 with 0 views | wwcigne |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 22:17 - Nov 7 by Dr_Winston | Problem is that offer keeps changing. Three weeks ago we'd have bitten someones arm off to be top. Now it's sixth. Where will it be come early December? We desperately need to stop the rot. Our next three games are against WBA, Middlesbrough and Cardiff. All of them losable unless we pull our fingers out. |
We’ve conceded quite a few late goals because Some of our defending at the end of games has been lazy ,wingers getting past our FB’s too easily and getting the ball in the box,not marking properly at corners ,not sharp enough to get to loose balls and losing concentration and leaving players unmarked around the goal area and midfield and not covering late runners into the box to get on the end of pull backs ,all this has to change if we want to get anything from games We don’t seem to be able to to see games out like other sides do ,which is worrying ,maybe all the chopping and changing of the team isn’t helping We are too inconsistent to be considered promotion contenders at the moment but if we can find a settled team, tactics and performances ,maybe we can turn it around |  | |  |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 23:10 - Nov 7 with 0 views | swan65split |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 18:21 - Nov 7 by KeithHaynes |
This post has been edited by an administrator |
looks like we gotta show some consistency and concentrate more. |  | |  |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 23:10 - Nov 7 with 0 views | SgorioFruit | Idah... on the bench Vipotnik.... on the bench Opoku... on the bench have a great weekend all |  |
| My methods are not favoured by some but by god i speak the truth. The caller out of bullshit since that letter to Paul Clement made planetswans famous. For a while. | | Poll: | Cardiff Are Relegated |
|  |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 02:34 - Nov 8 with 0 views | joserobertorene | Several times this season we could have had different results early on in matches. Between hitting the post and individual mistakes, we keep seeing the same old story: 'the chances you don't take, you'll end up conceding.' Even so, with just a bit of luck, the outcome of several of those games would have been completely different. Now, as fans, our criticism is always harsh, but let's be honest—who realistically expected us to be sitting in a good league position at this stage of the year, with such encouraging signs that this could finally be our season to get promoted? Of course there are things to improve. I've said it in every match thread this season: we are simply dreadful at set-pieces, both when attacking and defending. As for the constant changes to the starting XI, I'm not sure if it's down to Matos' tactical tinkering or just how brutal and congested the fixture list is, but the manager certainly carries a lot of responsibility here. Personally, I’d love to see Lissah and Welsh as our centre-back pairing, I want to see Monga get a proper run, more of Vipotnik up top, and we need to push hard to help this team regain the belief that we can compete at a high level. Step by step, we can prove what we're capable of. Today's opponents are on a run that has them sitting at the top of the table. Put together a run like that ourselves, and we'll stop putting out bad vibes and start talking about achieving something special. We have to keep the faith—let's not turn on each other in the community we love. We're all behind this club, and we have to trust Swansea City. Up the Swans! |  |
| The proudest Mexican to love Swansea City |
|  |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 07:43 - Nov 8 with 0 views | EagleEye |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 22:08 - Nov 7 by Whiterockin | If anyone was offered 6th place abd 3 points off the top going into the November International break I would have bitten their arm off. Yes we could have got a couple of better results but we have also got some excellent ones. |
Most would have been happy to be where we are right now if asked at the start of the season. We were clear at the top of the league going in to the last international break. We have conceded a lot of late goals recently but we have also had our fair share of luck in some of our wins. Rotating players due to workload is one thing but Matos needs to stop tinkering for tinkering sake. The loss of Estaquio has exposed the lack of attacking intent, goal threat & creativity in central midfield. We have a decent squad but Matos needs to be more positive. We are too inconsistent at the moment and he needs to learn quickly how to close games out. The better sides in this division are punishing us too easily |  | |  |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 08:53 - Nov 8 with 0 views | vetchonian |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 07:43 - Nov 8 by EagleEye | Most would have been happy to be where we are right now if asked at the start of the season. We were clear at the top of the league going in to the last international break. We have conceded a lot of late goals recently but we have also had our fair share of luck in some of our wins. Rotating players due to workload is one thing but Matos needs to stop tinkering for tinkering sake. The loss of Estaquio has exposed the lack of attacking intent, goal threat & creativity in central midfield. We have a decent squad but Matos needs to be more positive. We are too inconsistent at the moment and he needs to learn quickly how to close games out. The better sides in this division are punishing us too easily |
Some good points raised there,but was Matos reponsible for Stamenic getting sent off? Before the sending off we were the better side and ahould have been 1 if jot 2 goals up before the sending off. It could be argied had Vip started instead of Stewart the pen might well have been convertee but we looked the team more likely to score up to thenpoint of the dismissal. Yes we have had some losses and apart from the debacle at QPR we have been in all the games. and even early in the QPR match we had chances to equalise at 1 nil down bit "luck" desertrd us as it did against West Ham Cabangos shot hittimg the bar ,Cabango balsting wide just two examples but we were mostly in thr game unril it was like the Alamo were we did defend well when under pressure in the closing minutes and dont forget due to injurries and suspension we hadthe "useless" Ronalf at full back yet were not hammered and only conceded the one goal Even at Portsmouth we could/should have gone 1-2 up and that would have changed rhe way the game went. Many have said it fime margims in football and especially in the Championship....look at yesterdays results.... Several have pointed out when we were top of rhe league perhaps it is becaise of rhe qulaity of opposition we had played rather than our actual ability and quality that had putbus there....but stillnyou have to beat what is in front of you. Mayne some have expected us to win every game. Yes we lost yesterdayy but we had a player less than them and durimg thr second half those 10 men were bustimg a gut. I do worry about us at set pieces and as I said in an earlier post I wonder how much we miss the input of Margetson. I guess many are cincerned about the upcoming derby given Cardiffs last two results but if we turn up as we fid against Blackburn it could be an interestimg scoreline even though I knowderbies are never "normal" games. |  |
|  | Login to get fewer ads
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 08:57 - Nov 8 with 0 views | onehunglow | We are where we are We weren’t really expecting to have reached the top Consequently , hopes are raised and people get a skip on their step We had every right to get expectant Recently , we’ve buggered it up and whether we did or didn’t expect to be top eight is not the point We should not have lost at Pompey nor yesterday We look for the complicated too often when the simple is required Brum were horrifically shithouses as we’re Pompey and if nothing else it should motivate us for their return fixture And Cardiff come back to win with four goals on the spin |  |
|  |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 09:38 - Nov 8 with 0 views | johnlangy |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 23:10 - Nov 7 by SgorioFruit | Idah... on the bench Vipotnik.... on the bench Opoku... on the bench have a great weekend all |
Yes. On the other hand, if he had started Opoku many would be saying why was Yeo not started who was our most dangerous player before his injury. Also Idah and Vip. If one of those had started and it didn't go well some would be arguing that the extremely experienced Stewart would have been the right choice. |  | |  |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 09:42 - Nov 8 with 0 views | onehunglow |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 08:53 - Nov 8 by vetchonian | Some good points raised there,but was Matos reponsible for Stamenic getting sent off? Before the sending off we were the better side and ahould have been 1 if jot 2 goals up before the sending off. It could be argied had Vip started instead of Stewart the pen might well have been convertee but we looked the team more likely to score up to thenpoint of the dismissal. Yes we have had some losses and apart from the debacle at QPR we have been in all the games. and even early in the QPR match we had chances to equalise at 1 nil down bit "luck" desertrd us as it did against West Ham Cabangos shot hittimg the bar ,Cabango balsting wide just two examples but we were mostly in thr game unril it was like the Alamo were we did defend well when under pressure in the closing minutes and dont forget due to injurries and suspension we hadthe "useless" Ronalf at full back yet were not hammered and only conceded the one goal Even at Portsmouth we could/should have gone 1-2 up and that would have changed rhe way the game went. Many have said it fime margims in football and especially in the Championship....look at yesterdays results.... Several have pointed out when we were top of rhe league perhaps it is becaise of rhe qulaity of opposition we had played rather than our actual ability and quality that had putbus there....but stillnyou have to beat what is in front of you. Mayne some have expected us to win every game. Yes we lost yesterdayy but we had a player less than them and durimg thr second half those 10 men were bustimg a gut. I do worry about us at set pieces and as I said in an earlier post I wonder how much we miss the input of Margetson. I guess many are cincerned about the upcoming derby given Cardiffs last two results but if we turn up as we fid against Blackburn it could be an interestimg scoreline even though I knowderbies are never "normal" games. |
Matos saying it wasn’t a red and obviously bitter about the Pompey game I get that It’s about intent and whilst high, player wasn’t touched really nor injured Intent , worth a court case in itself |  |
|  |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 09:45 - Nov 8 with 0 views | pencoedjack |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 17:40 - Nov 7 by Dr_Winston | We need to get back to basics a bit. Pick our strongest back four whenever possible. That's Tymon, Welsh Lissah and Key. Vipotnik needs to be given a run in the side again as the recent treatment of a proven 20+ goal a season striker has been bizarre. |
I find not starting Vip very strange I can’t think of any other team who would leave the previous seasons top scorer on the bench. Stewart looks like a carthorse waiting to go to the nackers yard. |  | |  |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 09:47 - Nov 8 with 0 views | KeithHaynes |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 09:42 - Nov 8 by onehunglow | Matos saying it wasn’t a red and obviously bitter about the Pompey game I get that It’s about intent and whilst high, player wasn’t touched really nor injured Intent , worth a court case in itself |
Stamenić intention was to get the ball. If we base this on intent he shouldn’t be sent off as the player wasn’t touched. |  |
|  |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 09:48 - Nov 8 with 0 views | onehunglow |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 09:45 - Nov 8 by pencoedjack | I find not starting Vip very strange I can’t think of any other team who would leave the previous seasons top scorer on the bench. Stewart looks like a carthorse waiting to go to the nackers yard. |
Can’t see why we can’t play Vipi in conjunction with another All we are doing is pissing him off We’ve done this before to our better players |  |
|  |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 09:55 - Nov 8 with 0 views | Dr_Winston |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 09:45 - Nov 8 by pencoedjack | I find not starting Vip very strange I can’t think of any other team who would leave the previous seasons top scorer on the bench. Stewart looks like a carthorse waiting to go to the nackers yard. |
It's obviously a tactical choice. Matos just thinks Stewart and Idah suit his pressing style more. "Perspiration over inspiration" as I've seen it labelled elsewhere. I'm just not sure that it works well enough often enough to justify our almost total reliance on it, especially when Idah had already proven himself capable of scoring goals in a system that suits Vipotnik. Many of our best passages of passing play have come when we're not pressing at all. |  |
| Pain or damage don't end the world. Or despair, or f*cking beatings. The world ends when you're dead. Until then, you got more punishment in store. Stand it like a man... and give some back. |
|  |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 10:01 - Nov 8 with 0 views | pete |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 08:53 - Nov 8 by vetchonian | Some good points raised there,but was Matos reponsible for Stamenic getting sent off? Before the sending off we were the better side and ahould have been 1 if jot 2 goals up before the sending off. It could be argied had Vip started instead of Stewart the pen might well have been convertee but we looked the team more likely to score up to thenpoint of the dismissal. Yes we have had some losses and apart from the debacle at QPR we have been in all the games. and even early in the QPR match we had chances to equalise at 1 nil down bit "luck" desertrd us as it did against West Ham Cabangos shot hittimg the bar ,Cabango balsting wide just two examples but we were mostly in thr game unril it was like the Alamo were we did defend well when under pressure in the closing minutes and dont forget due to injurries and suspension we hadthe "useless" Ronalf at full back yet were not hammered and only conceded the one goal Even at Portsmouth we could/should have gone 1-2 up and that would have changed rhe way the game went. Many have said it fime margims in football and especially in the Championship....look at yesterdays results.... Several have pointed out when we were top of rhe league perhaps it is becaise of rhe qulaity of opposition we had played rather than our actual ability and quality that had putbus there....but stillnyou have to beat what is in front of you. Mayne some have expected us to win every game. Yes we lost yesterdayy but we had a player less than them and durimg thr second half those 10 men were bustimg a gut. I do worry about us at set pieces and as I said in an earlier post I wonder how much we miss the input of Margetson. I guess many are cincerned about the upcoming derby given Cardiffs last two results but if we turn up as we fid against Blackburn it could be an interestimg scoreline even though I knowderbies are never "normal" games. |
i agree, the set peace in both boxes needs work on it as that is an area that is costing us goals defensively and when attacking from corners free kicks etc, but as disappointed as we all are yesterday up to the red card we were the better side and the work the lads put in after the red was really good so lets not be too down , this break hopefully will help to get our injured guys back to full fitness so we can go again, I think January may be interesting if we are still in the top 8 then |  | |  |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 10:58 - Nov 8 with 0 views | wwcigne |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 09:47 - Nov 8 by KeithHaynes | Stamenić intention was to get the ball. If we base this on intent he shouldn’t be sent off as the player wasn’t touched. |
Just watched Match of the day and witnessed a foul by Boyle of Leeds on. Spurs player ,catching him on the Achilles area , no where near the ball that could was quite easily have resulted in a very serious injury ,a red card all day long,VAR looked at it and Ref gave a yellow….abs ludicrous Stamenic did go in a bit enthusiastically but no contact was made …Red card The refereeing inconsistency is ruining the game On another point Killman of West Ham lost the ball and went down holding his head , but had a sneaky look at the Ref ,so obviously play acting , ref played on and Blackburn scored ,I wish that ref had been in charge when we played West Ham,they were embarrassing with their antics |  | |  |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 12:55 - Nov 8 with 0 views | swancity | Very harsh and an unfortunate red card for Stamenic But not the most sensible way to lunge into a tackle like that and he’s given the referee a decision to make. But overall, a good performance from us against a side unbeaten at home and are top ( for now ). Fine margins. Unlike QPR and Portsmouth we played well, individually and collectively and looked more like a team that can challenge for the top eight. Fine margins. It’s a fascinating league. I’m still unsure where our season will pan out. Anywhere from 1st to 21st is possible. A lot of clubs are in that situation. Anything is possible but so far there’s a lot to be positive about with a young manager who has done a superb job in his 12 months here. Certainly we are in a much better place. |  |
| Only an idiot would eat a turkey curry on Christmas day |
|  |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 13:14 - Nov 8 with 0 views | onehunglow | Knowing the perverse and often ludicrous decisions of referees , Stam was ill advised to go on both feet off ground Reg saw it as intent You can’t prove intent Davies is a shithouse as is his team of head workers who milked whatever they could That says , their winner,should not have happened Time to regroup |  |
|  |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 13:55 - Nov 8 with 0 views | AguycalledJack | Keep 11 on the pitch and we win. |  | |  |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 16:26 - Nov 8 with 0 views | max936 |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 23:06 - Nov 7 by wwcigne | We’ve conceded quite a few late goals because Some of our defending at the end of games has been lazy ,wingers getting past our FB’s too easily and getting the ball in the box,not marking properly at corners ,not sharp enough to get to loose balls and losing concentration and leaving players unmarked around the goal area and midfield and not covering late runners into the box to get on the end of pull backs ,all this has to change if we want to get anything from games We don’t seem to be able to to see games out like other sides do ,which is worrying ,maybe all the chopping and changing of the team isn’t helping We are too inconsistent to be considered promotion contenders at the moment but if we can find a settled team, tactics and performances ,maybe we can turn it around |
Injuries haven't helped, so a lot of the chopping and changing has happened because of that and Stamenic sending off yesterday will make yet another change although hopefully Eustáquio will be back after this International break, if not maybe Iorpenda will get his chance. |  | |  |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 17:18 - Nov 8 with 0 views | sons_of_omri |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 18:11 - Nov 7 by 3swan | Back home. Big battling performance after the sending off. Lots of maybe - the penalty and hitting the post. Started well and played some neat football. Shame the sending off changed the game. Can't fault any player for the effort today, a few wrong decisions but overall they did give thier all in awkward circumstances., Birmingham all about fast wingers and not much else. Voice nearly gone, haven't done so much shouiting for a long time |
On twitter some Birmingham fans saying we’re the best side that’s been there all season including the likes of Southampton, Middlesbrough, Wolves, Stoke and QPR. Let’s not be too downcast. We just have to keep all our players on the pitch in the next few games WBA, Boro and Cardiff. P.S. we have to play a less pressing and more precise passing game if we want to avoid the burn out especially with a depleted squad. We have some excellent technical players so why not let them get the opposition running around after us for a change. Some direct balls through the channels could lead to more chances in front of goal. The players are better than maybe they think they are and should have a bit more belief in themselves. [Post edited 8 Nov 17:22]
|  | |  |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 18:07 - Nov 8 with 0 views | Treforys_Jack |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 09:47 - Nov 8 by KeithHaynes | Stamenić intention was to get the ball. If we base this on intent he shouldn’t be sent off as the player wasn’t touched. |
Genuinely didn't think it was a red at the time and after seeing it numerous times I still don't. Embarrassing play acting by EL..Ref was conned, Stamanic going to ground didn't help. |  | |  |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 19:25 - Nov 8 with 0 views | onehunglow |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 18:07 - Nov 8 by Treforys_Jack | Genuinely didn't think it was a red at the time and after seeing it numerous times I still don't. Embarrassing play acting by EL..Ref was conned, Stamanic going to ground didn't help. |
I wish we were cuter We’re too honest for our own good |  |
|  |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 19:26 - Nov 8 with 0 views | jewsonjack |
| Birmingham City v Swansea City: : Match Thread on 18:07 - Nov 8 by Treforys_Jack | Genuinely didn't think it was a red at the time and after seeing it numerous times I still don't. Embarrassing play acting by EL..Ref was conned, Stamanic going to ground didn't help. |
The OTT reaction from the Birmingham players influenced the ref. Soccer Saturday's take on it was a yellow card, including Mike Dean who felt the Birmingham players put undue pressure on the ref. The CBS pundits on the stream I had also felt it was the wrong decision, and that included dyed in the wool blue Troy Deeney. The challenge unfortunately gave the ref a decision to make, but I'm not sure Stamenic deserves all the criticism and abuse he has had. |  | |  |
| |